CS Paper Radar

Annie, Are You Okay? How Style- and Context-Based Personalization Shape AI-Assisted Decision-Making

Hasibur Rahman, Benjamin R. Cowan, Smit Desai

cs.HC cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-21 14:20 UTC · v1

Abstract

As people turn to generative AI for financial advice, these systems can personalize how they communicate and what they say. Whether these forms of personalization shape decisions differently remains unclear. We conducted a preregistered 2 x 2 between-subjects factorial experiment (N=240): participants ranked three comparably viable stocks, discussed them with an AI, and reranked them. Participants perceived both forms of personalization, but only context-based personalization reliably changed ranking behavior: it increased reconsideration and moved rankings toward the AI's assigned recommendation. Participants felt more influenced without judging the AI as more correct, trustworthy, intelligent, likeable, or high-quality. Those initially farther from its recommendation moved more toward it while judging its advice less correct; exploratory analyses suggest greater susceptibility among lower-expertise participants. These findings show how personalized AI can steer decisions among defensible options with only a minimal evaluative trace, raising concerns for the design and governance of personalized decision support.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

How People Evaluate AI-, Expert-, and Peer-Style Financial Advice

cs.HC cs.AIcs.CLcs.CY+1 ·2026-08-10 ·Aryan Ramchandra Kapadia, Eshwar Chandrasekharan, Koustuv Saha
similarity 0.70
Abstract

As generative AI increasingly becomes a common source of daily decision-making, including financial choices, it is critical to understand how people evaluate AI-generated financial advice. We conducted a preregistered vignette experiment (N = 285) in which substantive financial content---including facts, numerical values, recommendation direction, and core reasoning---was held constant while communication style varied across AI Financial Assistant (AI), Certified Financial Planner (Expert), and Online Community Forum (OC) advice. Displayed source attribution was independently manipulated through correctly labeled, unlabeled, and mislabeled conditions, allowing us to separate attribution effects from source-specific communication cues. Expert advice was rated more favorably than AI advice on 9 of 10 outcomes (|d|=0.20--0.47), and this advantage remained visible without source labels, where Expert advice outperformed AI advice on 8 of 10 outcomes (up to d=0.60). Correct labels added limited differentiation, whereas mislabeling increased ratings of AI advice for situational fit and overall quality (d=0.42 for each) and attenuated the Expert advantage in situational fit (d=-0.36). Descriptive analyses further showed that AI advice was most responsive to displayed attribution and, conversely, that advice-style differences were most visible under an AI label. These findings show that financial-advice evaluations are shaped jointly by displayed attribution and message-level communication cues. We position disclosure not as a neutral transparency mechanism, but as an interpretive frame whose accuracy and interaction with message cues can shape trust and reliance.

0.38

Trustworthy FinAInce: Unpacking How AI-Mediated Financial Advice is Judged

cs.HC cs.AIcs.CLcs.CY ·2026-09-17 ·Aryan Ramchandra Kapadia, Eshwar Chandrasekharan, Koustuv Saha
similarity 0.69
Abstract

As generative AI is increasingly used as a source of personal financial guidance, understanding how people appraise such advice is important for supporting appropriate reliance. We conducted a randomized vignette experiment with 285 U.S. adults across eight financial decisions, independently varying three advice styles---AI, expert, and online community---and displayed source labels while holding the underlying recommendation consistent. Advice style most strongly shaped message and safety appraisals, Expert labels selectively increased perceived source knowledge, and decision context primarily shaped risk and safety appraisals. These appraisals were associated with downstream judgments, with models explaining 69.2% of overall quality, 75.9% of trust, and 82.9% of intended reliance. Expert-style advice also remained most preferred when shown without source labels. Our findings have implications for understanding financial advice evaluation, distinguishing the roles of advice style and source labels, and designing financial AI that supports grounded evaluation rather than simply maximizing trust.

0.09

The Differential Effects of AI Abstention on Advice Acceptance

cs.HC ·2026-10-19 ·Nicholas Wolczynski, Yotam Liel, Maytal Saar-Tsechansky, Lior Zalmanson
similarity 0.64
Abstract

AI advising systems are typically designed to always provide a response. Recent work has focused on developing systems that withhold advice in some instances, such as when advice quality is questionable, to improve the overall quality of guidance when it is given; a design paradigm we refer to as AI abstention. While substantial work has focused on optimizing when models should abstain, little is known about how users respond to systems that abstain. In a preregistered experiment, participants made repeated financial decisions, assisted by one of two advising regimes: an AI that advises selectively or one that advises on every decision. We find that the same AI abstention regime produces differential effects depending on the user: it increases advice acceptance among users with high perceived expertise and tends to decrease it among users with low perceived expertise. This differential effect is accounted for by the cognitive burden users face when repeatedly reconciling AI recommendations with their own judgment; AI abstention appears to relieve this burden among users with high perceived expertise, and in doing so increases their receptivity to advice. Further, AI abstention mitigates the decline in advice acceptance observed among expert users over repeated interactions. Exploratory evidence also suggests it increases appropriate acceptance where advice would improve the decision, increasing the downstream accuracy of perceived experts. The AI abstention regime is thus a first-order design property of AI advisory systems, and one that must be calibrated to the users a system serves.

0.19

Et Tu, Brute? Economic Misalignment in Personal AI Agents

cs.AI ·2026-09-21 ·Aman Priyanshu, Supriti Vijay, Brian Jabarian, Niloofar Mireshghallah
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 20 pages, 10 tables, 4 figures

Personal AI agents make recommendations and take actions on people's behalf in high-stakes economic contexts, e.g., buying a flight, choosing health insurance, or selecting a graduate program. The agent is given access to the user's personal context, e.g., their email inbox and a structured profile of personal attributes, with the intention of making an optimal, personalized decision for the user. We show that by simply providing this personal context, the agent steers recommendations based on inferred wealth, without being explicitly instructed to do so. In a suite of 325K experiments on 13 agents across three types of economic decisions (flights, health insurance, and graduate programs), we find that 8 models systematically choose more expensive options for wealthier users when requests are identical. This steering continues even when it directly goes against the user's stated objective: when explicitly instructed to find the cheapest option, some agents still act on the wealth profile they have inferred. It also occurs when wealth is inferred from ambient data, such as emails unrelated to the task. And it persists under privacy controls that block specific attributes: blocking financial attributes largely removes the disparity, but blocking other attributes leaves it unchanged and can increase it by up to 40% for insurance, as agents rely on the remaining signals to infer wealth. Larger and more capable models are no better; Claude Opus 4.8 shows the largest effect. We term this misalignment "adversarial delegation", in which the very conditions that make a personal AI agent useful - access to personal information - enable it to act against the user's interests.

0.52

When More Data Is Not Enough: The Context-Sufficiency Frontier in Generative AI Personalization

cs.AI cs.LG ·2026-09-30 ·Merieme Askour, Ayoub Merimi
similarity 0.63
Abstract · PREPRINT - SUBMITTED TO JOURNAL OF SERVICE RESEARCH (JSR)

Personalization has long relied on customer data to infer what an individual is likely to value. We call this customer evidence: the customer's historical behavior and preferences. Generative AI extends personalization by allowing providers to supply changing situational information at the moment a response is produced, without encoding every condition in advance. We define this provider-side context as information about what is possible, permitted, or advisable now. This flexibility creates a new problem: once context becomes easy to supply, more is not necessarily better. We develop a theory of context sufficiency in which the relevance of context to the customer's current intent matters more than its volume. The theory identifies four states, insufficiency, sufficiency, saturation, and interference, and introduces the Context-Sufficiency Frontier to locate the minimal relevant set. In a full-factorial experiment with a generative recommender at a large home-furnishing retailer, relevant context improved appropriateness, while irrelevant context reduced it and destabilized retrieval. The framework shifts personalization from supplying more context toward identifying what the current interaction actually requires and enforcing constraints throughout the service process.

0.19

Enabling and Understanding Personalization in AI-Generated Advertising Imagery

cs.AI cs.HC ·2026-09-11 ·Victor Kolominsky-Rabas, Leopold Müller, Claudius Budcke, Claas Christian Germelmann, Niklas Kühl
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Personalized marketing traditionally matches static products to customers, while dynamic creative optimization focuses mainly on AI-driven text personalization or basic product image modifications. We address this gap by developing and implementing an AI-based framework that generates personalized advertising imagery directly from customer data. We evaluate this framework in a two-stage within-subject study with N=100 participants across four products and three levels of personalization, varied by the amount and specificity of customer data used. Participants rated each image on attitude toward the advertisement, attitude toward the product, and purchase intention. Results show that participants perceive differences across personalization levels and evaluate AI-generated advertising imagery most positively at a moderate level of personalization. High personalization increases perceived personalization, which is positively associated with all three outcome measures, but also increases perceived creepiness, which is negatively associated with the outcomes and dominates the total effect.

0.32

When the AI Leaves the Tailorshop: Measuring What an LLM Advisor Leaves Behind in Complex Problem Solving

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-09-14 ·Robin Welsch
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 40 pages, 14 figures, 6 tables, including appendices

Complex problem solving depends on acting effectively and understanding how a system works. AI advice may support these outcomes unequally. Two preregistered experiments compared participants managing a simulated clothing factory with and without an LLM advisor. Across studies, AI-supported participants reported greater confidence and understanding with less effort. In the first study (N=200), assistance increased company value but produced no detectable prediction-accuracy difference. After withdrawal, previously supported participants outperformed controls when decisions were scored against repeating previous choices, but not default settings. Within the AI-supported group, more frequent recommendation alterations predicted better unaided performance. In the second study (N=198), AI-supported participants went bankrupt less often and showed a small knowledge advantage in the registered analysis, largely associated with remaining solvent. More frequent recommendation alterations predicted higher knowledge within the AI-supported group. Applied HAI evaluation should assess users' understanding and independent capability alongside the performance achieved with AI support.

0.38

How Contextual Information in Physical Environments Shapes Decisions with AI

cs.HC ·2026-11-02 ·Omar Elgohary, Amanda Elvarsdottir, Vannessa Lee, Zhu-Tian Chen
similarity 0.58
Abstract

AI assistants in augmented reality may advise users about parts of the physical world they cannot directly observe. We ask whether contextual information from the situation helps users make better decisions with fallible AI. In an AR visual- search study (N = 32), we varied target prevalence and scene visibility while participants judged whether a key was present, with or without AI assistance. Lowering target prevalence and revealing part of the desk together improved observed AI-assisted accuracy, but our analysis did not demonstrate that this gain came from participants making better use of context. Context also changed which answers seemed plausible: when keys were rare, participants became more skeptical of Present suggestions, but this shift applied to both correct and incorrect suggestions rather than improving selective acceptance of correct advice. Revealing part of the desk also increased decision time, with little evidence of better AI use. Overall, contextual information can shape AI- assisted decisions and increase decision effort without necessarily helping users judge when the AI is correct.

0.13