CS Paper Radar

From OA colors to observable access states: A commentary on the 2026 OpenAlex proposal

Abdelghani Maddi

cs.DB ·submitted 2026-09-21 15:05 UTC · v1

Abstract

The OpenAlex Colors Working Group proposes replacing the familiar Gold, Green, Hybrid, Bronze and Closed taxonomy with a work-level framework based on three dimensions: access, location and license. The proposal addresses genuine weaknesses in the legacy color system, particularly its dependence on journal-level characteristics, its difficulty in describing non-article outputs, and its conflation of access conditions with venue business models. This commentary supports that general direction but argues that the proposed labels should not become the primary data model. The central technical issue is that access, location and license are not best understood as three independent attributes of a work: scholarly works commonly have several versions or copies at different locations, and access status, license and version may differ from one location to another. The analysis therefore recommends treating the location/version observation as the atomic unit of OA metadata and deriving work-level labels, legacy colors and user-facing summaries from those observations. Particular attention is given to license semantics, version identification, the normative assumptions embedded in a ``best-available'' hierarchy, the coarse Publisher/Other Platform distinction, temporal change, provenance, compound works, and backward compatibility. Existing standards and infrastructure (including NISO/ALPSP Journal Article Versions, COAR controlled vocabularies, FAIR provenance principles, and OpenAlex's own current location objects) already provide many of the components needed for such an approach. The result would preserve the simplicity sought by the Working Group while making the underlying data model more extensible, auditable and suitable for funder compliance, bibliometric research and future changes in scholarly communication.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Beyond the Editing Canvas: Evidence Divergence in OOXML-to-LLM Ingestion

cs.SE cs.CR ·2026-08-26 ·Side Liu, Jiangpeng Liu, Jinwen Xin, Guojun Peng, Jiang Ming
surveycode/data similarity 0.58
Abstract

LLM pipelines increasingly ingest Office Open XML (OOXML) documents (Word, Excel, and PowerPoint files) as first-class evidence in financial, compliance, and retrieval-augmented workflows, implicitly assuming semantic integrity: that the evidence consumed by the model matches the content shown in the Microsoft Office suite editing canvas. We show that this assumption can fail in OOXML-to-LLM pipelines. The same specification-valid OOXML file can yield one evidentiary view in Microsoft Office and another when extracted for an LLM. Each view is treated as authoritative by its consumer, a condition we call plural ground truth. The ingestion contract rarely states which view and semantic roles become model evidence or preserves how that evidence was derived. We call the specification-grounded OOXML constructions that induce such divergence evidence forks. We systematically traverse and mine the OOXML specification and confirm 21 evidence forks across Excel, Word, and PowerPoint, spanning six dimensions of view construction. All 13 tools in our extraction panel emit evidence from at least one fork. We test four native-ingestion LLM APIs and seven web chatbots. Each test document carries a trap: a task-relevant fact exposed by extraction but not shown in Office. Across this 21-mechanism evaluation, the four APIs return the trap in 48--76% of trials. For 20 of 21 mechanisms, at least one of the eleven interfaces returns the trap. Our measurements further show that exposure is shaped upstream of the model by the ingestion path and extractor configuration. A source-level survey of sixteen popular open-source LLM projects further shows that default OOXML ingestion paths concentrate on affected extractor families.

0.51

Towards a Definition of the Computational Architecture of Open Scholarly Infrastructures

cs.DL ·2026-08-24 ·Ivan Heibi, Mario Petrella, Angelo Di Iorio, Silvio Peroni
similarity 0.55
Abstract

This paper proposes a layered framework for defining the architecture of the computational unit of an Open Scholarly Infrastructure (OSI) and presents a concrete implementation possibility through the introduction of OpenCitations, an OSI dedicated to publishing citation data and bibliographic metadata. Grounded in the Principles of Open Scholarly Infrastructure (POSI), the study focuses on the technical dimensions of openness, sustainability, interoperability, and reproducibility that are required for a robust OSI. The proposed approach first identifies the core principles and technical features that a computational block in an OSI should guarantee, including separation of operational domains, orchestration, scalability, observability, automation, and workflow portability. It then maps these requirements onto a layered architectural model composed of Hardware, Virtualization, Orchestration, and Application layers, complemented by a transversal Meta layer. The OpenCitations case study shows how this framework can be instantiated in practice through an on-premises infrastructure. The case is presented with details regarding the technicalities and actual implementations of the proposed methodology. By combining a conceptual definition with a real-world implementation, this work offers both a practical reference and a methodological basis for designing the computational block of an OSI.

0.34

Visible but Not Yet Curatable: Characterizing the Curatability of Compact and Derived Open LLM Artifacts

cs.HC cs.DL ·2026-08-28 ·Yiyi Lu, Yilai Qian, Yucheng Jin
publishedcode/data similarity 0.51
Abstract · 11 pages, 5 figures. Accepted at the ACM/IEEE Joint Conference on Digital Libraries (JCDL 2026). Yiyi Lu and Yilai Qian contributed equally;…

Open Large Language Model (LLM) research increasingly produces compact and derived artifacts, such as adapters, quantized checkpoints, merged models, and distilled variants, that are distributed across papers, model hubs, model cards, code repositories, and release statements. Although these artifacts are publicly visible, digital libraries often lack sufficient evidence to identify, preserve, and cite them as coherent scholarly objects. We introduce a framework that conceptualizes curatability as a record-level property of distributed scholarly records and operationalizes it through four evidence dimensions: artifact identity, scholarly linkage, upstream evidence, and release assets. Guided by this framework, we conduct the first collection-scale characterization of open LLM curatability using a May 2026 snapshot of 191,375 public Hugging Face repositories and a core corpus of 2,214 scholarly papers. Our results reveal a pronounced visibility-to-curatability funnel. While 90.7% of paper records contain at least one useful curation signal, only 18.1% combine usable upstream evidence with concrete release evidence, and only 6.1% provide sufficiently coordinated evidence to support high-curatability records. Based on these findings, we derive a minimal seven-field curatable record and complementary responsibilities for model hubs, scholarly indexes, and digital libraries, providing practical guidance for improving the preservation and bibliographic control of open LLM artifacts.

0.48

A curated global dataset of open science initiatives and policies

cs.DB ·2026-10-26 ·Abdelghani Maddi, Marc-Andr{é} Simard, Isabelle Dorsch
similarity 0.51
Abstract

Inventories of open science initiatives differ in scope, geographic coverage and classification, making it difficult to compare infrastructures, services, networks and policies. We developed COSMI Hub within the OPENIT project to bring these sources together in a curated dataset. The release archived on 8 October 2026 contains 1,186 records and 71 variables covering initiative identity, source provenance, geography, record level, operational status, thematic activities, governance, funding and external identifiers. We identified candidates through structured directories, policy documents, official websites and suggestions from the open science community, then checked identities, reconciled duplicates and assessed supporting evidence. The dataset distinguishes standalone initiatives, services, deployments, umbrella organisations and policy instruments. Records can be assigned several thematic dimensions, with uncertainty retained where evidence is incomplete. We describe the collection and coding methods, the data structure and file-level checks, together with considerations for reuse. The Zenodo release is fixed, whereas the companion dashboard is updated separately. Because we assembled the collection purposively, it cannot be used to estimate the worldwide number of open science initiatives.

0.28

Extracting Value from Grey Literature: processes and technologies for aggregating and analyzing the hidden big data treasure of organizations

cs.DL ·2026-11-19 ·G. Motta, R. Puccinelli, L. Reggiani, Massimiliano Saccone
publishedhighly cited similarity 0.51
Abstract

Grey literature can be a valuable source of information about organizations activities and, to a certain extent, about their identity. Some of the major problems that hinder their full exploitation are the heterogeneity of formats, the lack of structure, the unpredictability of their content, the size of the document bases, which can quickly become huge. The collection and mining of grey literature can be applied to individual organizations or classes of organizations, thus enabling the analysis of the trends in particular fields. To this end, some techniques can be inherited from the best practices for the management of structured documents belonging to well identified categories, but something more is needed in our case. Obvious steps are: identifying sources, collecting items, cleansing and de-duplicating contents, assigning unique and persistent identifiers, adding metadata and augmenting the information using other sources. These phases are common to all digital libraries but further steps are required, in our opinion, in the case of grey literature in order to build document bases of value.

0.67

A Multi-Surface Consistency Audit of Software Citation Metadata

cs.SE cs.CRcs.DL ·2026-08-17 ·Pengyin Shan
code/data similarity 0.51
Abstract · 10 pages, 2 figures, 3 tables

Research software projects describe themselves in many places at once: citation files in the repository, archive deposits, DOI registry records, package registries, and README text. We treat the software as the underlying object and these machine-readable self-descriptions as its surfaces: the points where people and automated systems read what the project declares about the software. Citation guidance, indexing services, and automated agents may read a different subset of these surfaces, so disagreement between them can silently fragment credit and provenance. This paper asks a simple question that has not been measured directly: when a project's own metadata surfaces are compared with each other, how often do they agree? We audited 117 open-source research software projects, comprising an 87-project high-performance computing and quantum computing corpus and a 30-project registered baseline drawn from the JOSS and pyOpenSci accepted-package lists, across up to seven machine-readable surfaces per project. Using a four-level verdict rubric across six metadata fields, with 98.5\% hand-verified verdict precision on a 338-row stratified sample, we found that 52 of the 62 projects exposing at least two comparable surfaces (83.9\%) contain at least one core-field conflict, a result that is insensitive to the fuzzy-matching threshold. Half of hand-adjudicated cross-surface conflicts trace to a single mechanism: surfaces describing the software's paper rather than the software itself. Among projects whose CITATION.cff includes a preferred citation, 28 of 32 route citations to a record that disagrees with the software's own metadata. The author lists and titles disagree the most, and the registry surfaces are the least aligned. We release the audit pipeline as an importable library, the corpus, the registered sampling protocol, all raw snapshots, and the complete verification log.

0.64

Estimating global article processing charges paid to 14 publishers for open access between 2019 and 2025

cs.DL ·2026-08-17 ·Lisa Matthias, Eric Schares, Juan Pablo Alperin, Leigh-Ann Butler, Sherry Kuang +2 more
similarity 0.50
Abstract

This study presents estimates of the global expenditure on article processing charges (APCs) paid to 14 publishers for open access (OA) between 2019 and 2025. APCs are charged for publishing in fully OA journals (gold) and making individual articles OA in subscription journals (hybrid), but how much is paid, and for which articles, is not publicly known. We therefore curated an open dataset of publicly listed APC prices from 14 academic publishers (ACS, CUP, De Gruyter, EDP, Elsevier, Frontiers, IEEE, IOP, MDPI, OUP, PLOS, Sage, Springer Nature, and Wiley) and combined it with counts of OA articles from OpenAlex. We estimate that \$15.08 billion (in 2025 USD) was spent globally on APCs between 2019 and 2025. Adjusted for inflation, annual spending quadrupled from \$0.9 billion in 2019 to \$3.7 billion in 2025, with >85% concentrated among a few large publishers. Hybrid OA fees exceed gold fees, and the median fee paid is higher than the median price listed for both. Our approach addresses major limitations in previous efforts to estimate APC spending, offering much-needed insight into an opaque aspect of scholarly publishing, especially as transformative agreements make it more challenging to understand the costs of publishing OA.

0.10

Towards More Granular Reasoning: Mapping the DSA Transparency Database Taxonomy to Platform Terms and Conditions Using Large Language Models

cs.AI cs.CY ·2026-10-19 ·Alyson Ranucci, Eline Leijten, David Graus
publishedposition similarity 0.50
Abstract · Accepted to JURIX 2026

Article 24(5) of the Digital Services Act (DSA) requires providers of online platforms to submit every content moderation decision they make, with a corresponding Statement of Reasons (SoR), to the DSA Transparency Database (DSA-TDB). Such decisions are classified against seventeen high-level attribute categories that categorize the primary reason for the moderation decision. Because over 99.8% of statements cite a violation of the provider's own terms and conditions rather than a legal provision, the database is overwhelmingly a record of contractual enforcement using catch-all reporting; however, whether its categories actually describe those contractual rules well has not been examined. In this paper, we map the terms and conditions (T&C) of 31 designated online services against the DSA-TDB's high-level category taxonomy using a few-shot GPT-4.1 classifier over 447 policy documents. The analysis concerns how T&C rules are represented in the taxonomy, not how they are enforced. Two findings emerge. First, high-level category applicability varies sharply by service type: unsafe products account for 17.5% of e-commerce assignments and 0.2% of adult-platform assignments, and negative effects on civic discourse reaches 9.9% within the Meta family but is absent from adult platforms, Booking.com, and Wikipedia. Second, the categories have notable overlap among sub-category specifications, which makes assigning a single high-level category to a decision difficult. We argue that catch-all reporting is plausibly in part a consequence of the DSA-TDB's schema and attribute design, and recommend a schema that is differentiated by service type with more mandatory attributes derived inductively from platform governance language.

0.30