CS Paper Radar

Prophet Inequalities Beyond Utilitarian Social Welfare

Daniel Halpern, Abhiram Manohara, Alexandros Psomas

cs.GT ·submitted 2026-09-21 21:22 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

In the classical i.i.d. prophet-inequality problem, a single item is allocated to one of $n$ agents who arrive sequentially, with values drawn independently from a known distribution. When an agent arrives, their value is revealed, and the algorithm must immediately allocate the item or continue. The usual objective is utilitarian welfare: the expected value of the recipient. Guarantees for this objective extend to allocating $m$ indivisible items to sequentially arriving agents with i.i.d.\ additive values. Utilitarian welfare, however, ignores how expected utility is distributed across agents. Motivated by a rich literature in fair division, we instead evaluate an online rule by its generalized $p$-mean welfare, which includes utilitarian welfare at $p=1$, Nash welfare (the geometric mean of utilities) at $p=0$, and egalitarian welfare (the minimum utility) as $p\to-\infty$. When the number of items is large, we show that this many-item fair-division problem is captured exactly by a single-item prophet problem evaluated by the $p$-mean of agents' expected utilities. We characterize this single-item problem: every online rule is weakly Pareto dominated by a quantile-threshold rule, and an optimal egalitarian rule equalizes agents' expected utilities. We prove that for every $n$, the online optimum is at least $Γ\approx0.7059$ times the prophet's egalitarian welfare; by monotonicity of generalized means, the same guarantee holds for every $p\le1$. Further, for egalitarian welfare, the optimal ratio converges to $Γ$ as $n\to\infty$. Thus, asymptotically, optimizing egalitarian rather than utilitarian welfare costs only about four percentage points relative to the classical utilitarian ratio of $0.7451$. Finally, when $m=n$, the worst-case competitive ratio converges to zero as $n\to\infty$ for every $p\le0$, showing that the large-item assumption is necessary.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Fair Prophets

cs.GT cs.DS ·2026-09-18 ·Paul Duetting, Michal Feldman, Mathieu Molina
similarity 0.77
Abstract

We initiate the study of $α$-fair prophet inequalities. This interpolates between utilitarian welfare $(α=0)$, Nash welfare $(α=1)$, and Rawlsian max-min fairness $(α\to\infty)$. Given the non-linearity of the objective, it matters when the expectation is applied. For instance, for the Rawlsian objective, it matters whether we aim to maximize $\min \mathbb{E}[u_i]$ or $\mathbb{E}[\min u_i]$. We refer to the former as the ex-ante model, and the latter as the ex-post model. For ex-ante fairness, full distributional knowledge yields a tight competitive ratio of exactly $1/2$ for every $α\ge 0$. Under sample access, $O(n\log n)$ samples per distribution suffice for a constant competitive ratio when $α\in(0,1]$. In contrast, for every $α>1$, no finite number of samples improves upon the trivial $1/n$ guarantee. Thus, unlike in the utilitarian setting, full-information and sample-access prophet inequalities become fundamentally separated. For ex-post fairness, under full information, we obtain a uniform constant ratio for all $α\in(0,1)$, while for every $α>1$ the competitive ratio collapses to $1/n$. In the sample-access model, one sample per distribution suffices for each fixed $α<1$, but no sample budget depending only on $n$ yields a uniform constant guarantee as $α\to 1$. Beyond these phase transitions for $α$-fairness, our results open the door to a broader theory of prophet inequalities for non-linear welfare objectives.

0.25

Closing Gaps in Online Fair Division

cs.GT ·2026-09-04 ·Tzeh Yuan Neoh, Nicholas Teh
theoryhighly cited similarity 0.74
Abstract

We study the online fair division of indivisible items, where items arrive one at a time and must be allocated immediately and irrevocably. We address three central open questions in the literature. First, we show that for every $n\ge 2$ agents, every fixed $k\ge 1$, and every $α\in(0,1]$, no online algorithm can guarantee $α$-PROP$k$ against an adaptive adversary. This remains true even when the total number of goods is known in advance, all values lie in $[0,1]$, and every good is positively valued by at most two agents. The impossibility extends to a broad range of standard envy-based, proportionality-based, and share-based fairness notions. We also establish an analogous impossibility for chores. Second, in the setting with predictions, a lightweight form of future information, the maximum item value, was previously known to guarantee only $1/n$-PROP1, leaving open whether the dependence on $n$ is necessary. We give a deterministic $19/30$-PROP1 algorithm against adaptive adversaries that does not require knowing the total number of goods. Given an additional upper bound $κ\in[2,n]$ on the number of agents who value any good positively, the guarantee improves to $\max \{ 19/30, n/(n+κ) \}$. The guarantee remains a positive constant under any fixed one-sided prediction error below one. When predictions are exact and the total number of goods $m\ge n\log n$ is known in advance, a deterministic algorithm achieves the same $19/30$-PROP1 factor together with $O(\sqrt{m\log n/n})$ maximum additive envy after normalizing each agent's values by their maximum item value. Third, against a non-adaptive adversary, we determine the tight high-probability PROP1 guarantee of the classical Like rule, which assigns each good uniformly among the agents who value it positively. Its guarantee improves when fewer agents value the same good, unlike uniform random allocation.

0.43

Randomized Online Fair Division: High-Probability and Expected Realized Fairness

cs.GT ·2026-09-20 ·Tianqi Chen, Jingxiao Long
similarity 0.70
Abstract · 22 pages. Improved high-probability and expected realized PROP1 guarantees; revised proofs and exposition

We study randomized algorithms for the fully online allocation of indivisible goods among $n\ge2$ agents with nonnegative additive valuations. Goods arrive sequentially and must be allocated immediately and irrevocably, with only $n$ known in advance. Since exact ex-ante envy freeness and proportionality are readily achievable, while no positive ex-post approximation is possible for the fairness notions considered here, we study the intermediate notions of high-probability fairness and expected realized fairness. Against a non-adaptive adversary, we give a randomized algorithm for proportionality up to one good (PROP1) whose parameter depends only on $n$ and that preserves exact ex-ante envy-freeness and proportionality. At confidence $1-δ$, its PROP1 guarantee improves on independent uniform allocation (Rand) by a factor of $Ω(\log n)$, uniformly over $δ\in(0,1/2]$. As $n\to\infty$, its expected realized PROP1 factor is at least $\frac{3-\sqrt5}{2}-o(1)$. We also show that the expected realized PROP1 factor of Rand is $(1+o(1))/\log n$, yielding an improvement of at least $\bigl(\frac{3-\sqrt5}{2}-o(1)\bigr)\log n$ for our algorithm. For every randomized online algorithm and every positive approximation factor, the success probability can be made arbitrarily small for envy freeness up to any good (EFX) and at most $\frac{n+1}{2n}$ for envy freeness up to one good (EF1). Consequently, every randomized fully online algorithm has an expected realized EFX guarantee of zero and an expected realized EF1 guarantee of at most $\frac{n+1}{2n}$.

0.43

Maximizing $p$-Mean Social Welfare in the High-Multiplicity Setting: Few Agent Types and Few Item Types

cs.GT cs.AI ·2026-10-03 ·Trung Thanh Nguyen, Khaled Elbassioni
similarity 0.70
Abstract

The $p$-mean welfare objective unifies several classical social welfare criteria for the allocation of indivisible goods. We study its maximization under additive nonnegative utilities when item and agent multiplicities are encoded in binary. For every fixed finite rational $p<1$, $p\neq0$, we show that the problem is $\mathsf{NP}$-hard with only two item types. Nash welfare ($p=0$) and egalitarian welfare ($p=-\infty$) are NP-hard with three item types. These results hold both for computing an optimal allocation and for rational-threshold decision, and the utilities and threshold can be required to be positive integers. We also show that maximizing $p$-mean social welfare is strongly NP-hard with one agent type and an unrestricted number of item types, for every fixed finite rational $p<1$ and for $p=-\infty$. A quantitative gap in this reduction rules out an FPTAS in the latter setting unless $\mathsf{P}=\mathsf{NP}$. On the positive side, for a fixed number of item types and an arbitrary number of agent types, we give an FPTAS for every fixed $p\in\mathbb Q\cup\{-\infty\}$. Its running time is polynomial in the compact input length and in $1/\varepsilon$, and it returns a compressed allocation. For a fixed number of agent types and an unrestricted number of item types, we give a PTAS for every fixed finite rational $p<1$, also in the fully compact model. We further give explicit compact-model proofs of the classical exact allocation algorithms for one item type, and for egalitarian welfare with two item types. These results essentially settle the complexity and approximability of $p$-mean welfare maximization with few item types and/or few agent types, leaving only the exact complexity of Nash welfare maximization with two item types unresolved in the small-item-type classification.

0.29

On best of both worlds allocations with subadditive valuations

cs.GT ·2026-09-27 ·Uriel Feige
theory similarity 0.69
Abstract

We consider allocation of indivisible goods to agents with equal entitlements and subadditive valuations. As an ex-post fairness notion we consider the maximin share (MMS), and as an ex-ante fairness notion we consider the maximum expectation share (MES), which is always at least as large as the MMS, and sometimes much larger. We present a simple transformation that for every $0 < ρ\le 1$, given any algorithm that produces $ρ$-MMS allocations, transforms it into a randomized allocation algorithm that offers $ρ$-MMS ex-post simultaneously with $η$-MES ex-ante. We prove several new properties of MES, and use them to show that $η\ge \min[\fracρ{2 + ρ}, \frac{1}{4}]$. We also present cases in which the transformation results in a higher value of $η$. Applying our transformation to currently known allocation algorithms shows for subadditive valuations the existence of randomized allocations that are simultaneously $Ω(\frac{1}{\log\log n})$-MES ex-ante and $Ω(\frac{1}{\log\log n})$-MMS ex-post, and for XOS valuations the existence of randomized allocations that are simultaneously $\frac{4}{27}$-MES ex-ante and $\frac{4}{17}$-MMS ex-post.

0.26

Minimization Prophet Inequality with Bounded Costs

cs.DS ·2026-09-06 ·Haolong Li, Xiaowei Wu
similarity 0.68
Abstract

We study the cost-minimization prophet inequality problem, in which a decision-maker sequentially observes $n$ independent and identically distributed (IID) random variables. After each observation, the decision-maker must either accept the current realization and stop, or reject it and continue with the next variable. The goal is to minimize the selected value. Unlike the classical maximization setting, if none of the first $n-1$ values is accepted, the final realization must be selected. Esfandiari et al. (SIDMA 2017) showed that this problem does not admit constant-competitive online algorithms in general, which motivates subsequent work on restricted distribution classes, such as entire distributions (Livanos and Mehta, SODA 2024) and distributions with bounded extreme values (Livanos and Mehta, EC 2025). In this work, we focus on distributions with bounded support. For distributions supported on $[1,b]$, we characterize the competitive ratio of online algorithms as a function of both $b$ and $n$. We consider both distribution-aware and distribution-oblivious settings. In the distribution-aware case, we provide a nearly tight characterization of the optimal online algorithm, showing that its competitive ratio is at most $b^{(1-1/n)^n}$ for all $n\geq 2$. More significantly, we design a distribution-oblivious algorithm that achieves the same guarantee, with a sequence of predetermined thresholds that depend only on $b$ and $n$. Furthermore, we extend our analysis to the non-IID setting, where we show that a simple single-threshold algorithm attains an asymptotically optimal competitive ratio of $Θ(\sqrt{b})$.

0.27

Improved Combinatorial Auctions with and without Samples

cs.GT cs.DS ·2026-10-13 ·Aviad Rubinstein, Sahil Singla
similarity 0.68
Abstract · Abstract shortened to fit arXiv constraints

We give new mechanisms for combinatorial auctions in the offline, secretary, and prophet-with-samples models. Specifically, we obtain the following guarantees for social welfare maximization with $m$ items and $n$ XOS buyers: * In the prophet-with-samples version, buyers arrive in adversarial order and draw their values from independent distributions. We give a universally truthful, polynomial-time $(2+\eps)$-approximation mechanism using $O(\log\!\log m)$ samples from each distribution. The approximation factor is tight even for a single item and without the incentive constraints, due to the classic prophet inequality. Compared to the previous state-of-the-art with the same guarantees [Dütting--Kesselheim--Lucier--Reiffenhäuser--Singla (FOCS 2024)], our running time is exponentially faster, and our sample complexity is doubly-exponentially lower, resolving two explicit open problems by Dütting et al. * Using the same techniques, we also obtain improved mechanisms in the secretary and offline versions, where the values are worst-case, and buyers are processed in either random order (secretary) or without any timing restrictions (offline). After a long line of works, the state of the art in both models is an $O((\log\!\log m)^2)$-approximation due to [Assadi--Kesselheim--Singla (SODA 2021)], who explicitly ask whether it can be improved to $O(\log\!\log m)$. We indeed obtain an $O(\log\!\log m)$-approximate universally truthful mechanism for the secretary and offline models.

0.08

Temporal Fair Division: Simultaneous Guarantees for Goods and Chores

cs.GT ·2026-11-18 ·Tianqi Chen
similarity 0.68
Abstract

We study temporal fair division of indivisible items in both the goods and chores settings, with $n \ge 2$ agents and nonnegative additive values or costs. Items arrive one at a time and must be assigned immediately and irrevocably. The arrival order and all agents' values or costs are known in advance, and the cumulative allocation must satisfy the fairness requirements after each arrival. For goods, we give a polynomial-time algorithm that simultaneously achieves exact temporal proportionality up to one item (TPROP1), a $1/n$ approximation to temporal maximin share (TMMS), and a $1/(n-1)$ approximation to temporal envy-freeness up to one item (TEF1). The TMMS factor is optimal. For chores, we give a polynomial-time algorithm that simultaneously achieves exact TPROP1 and a $2-1/n$ approximation to TMMS. Classical scheduling lower bounds based on fixed sequences carry over to chores TMMS, establishing the optimality of this factor for $n=2,3$. For every $n \ge 2$, we further show that $2-1/n$ is the optimal TMMS factor subject to exact TPROP1. For every fixed $n \ge 3$ and every finite $β\ge 1$, we construct an instance of chores admitting no $β$-TEF1 allocation.

0.25