CS Paper Radar

When Concealed Links Cannot Be Recovered: A Structural Identifiability Bound and Evaluation Pitfalls in Offshore Leak Networks

Joseph Bingham

cs.IR math.PR ·submitted 2026-08-10 20:08 UTC · v1
position

Abstract

Leaks such as the Panama and Paradise Papers expose large networks of offshore entities, and they invite an obvious question for network learning. Can the relations these structures are built to hide---above all, who beneficially owns what---be recovered from the public part of the leak by link prediction? We argue that the answer is mostly no, and that the analyses which suggest otherwise are measuring the wrong thing. Our main result is a distribution-free identifiability bound. For any recovery rule that respects graph isomorphism, and that covers every topological link-prediction score together with every message-passing graph neural network, a concealed endpoint left isolated in the observed graph is interchangeable with its structural twins, so its hidden edge cannot be recovered above chance. Isolation is only the sharpest case. In general the ceiling on recovery is set by the size of a node's structural-indistinguishability class, for which the Weisfeiler--Leman colour class is a computable stand-in, and node degree is at best a loose proxy. On the full ICIJ Offshore Leaks graph (814K entities and 84K labelled beneficial-owner edges) a classifier-free, degree-controlled probe reproduces an exact $0.5$ floor for isolated owners, who make up $20.6\%$ of all owners, and a trained graph neural network lands on the same floor. Recovery climbs only as structural distinctiveness grows, and the floor reappears in every one of the five leaks. Along the way we document five evaluation traps. Each one makes a bound that cannot be beaten look beaten, and we give a short rule that avoids them. The practical upshot is to redirect effort from the hidden principal, which is close to unrecoverable, toward the machinery of concealment, and to spell out why fusing external data helps far less than one would hope.

Comment
9 pages, 7 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Link Inference Attack on Privacy-Preserving Knowledge Graphs

cs.CR ·2026-09-30 ·Emna Bouguerra, Ibtissam Harrouche, Ferran Alborch, Melek Önen
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Knowledge Graphs (KGs) are widely used to store and share structured information across sensitive domains such as healthcare, fi- nance, and social networks. A common privacy practice is to delete sen- sitive relations before publishing the graph, under the assumption that removing edges is sufficient to prevent their recovery. In this paper, we challenge this assumption and show that even when a relation is fully or partially hidden, its existence leaves structural traces in the public graph that can be exploited to recover it with high accuracy. To this end, we propose a link inference attack that operates on the topology of the public graph, and evaluate it under two privacy scenarios that differ in how the adversary exploits the knowledge available to him. In the first setting where the adversary exploits all topological information, the attack achieves near-perfect discrimination (AP = 0.949, ROC-AUC = 0.999), while in the more realistic one where the adversary makes use of some semantic information, it recovers up to 74% of hidden edges. Build- ing on these results, we further conduct a structural analysis to identify which topological properties of the graph drive the attack success, re- vealing that privacy risk is not uniform across entities and that certain structural patterns make specific relations significantly more vulnerable to inference than others.

0.15

Structural Negative Transfer in Federated Graph Neural Networks: Diagnosis, Causal Investigation, and the Limits of Divergence-Aware Mitigation

cs.LG cs.DC ·2026-09-15 ·Chethana Prasad Kabgere, Shylaja SS
similarity 0.60
Abstract · Working Paper Draft

Federated learning lets multiple participants train a shared model without pooling raw data, by exchanging locally trained model updates instead. Federated averaging assumes that averaging local models is a reasonable way to solve one shared problem when participants' data are broadly similar. Work on non-IID federated learning has shown that this assumption can withstand differences in label and feature distributions. We ask whether it survives a different strain specific to graph neural networks, where client graphs differ not in label or feature distribution but in structure itself, requiring the same shared weights to operate over fundamentally different topologies. We call the resulting harm structural negative transfer. In a federation of real citation networks and synthetic structural proxies, a structurally atypical client lost more than half its achievable accuracy simply by joining. In an initial six-client federation, two label-free structural statistics computable before training were strongly associated with this harm. Expanding to twenty clients showed that degree divergence remained associated with harm, although more weakly, and survived removal of domain contrast. Spectral divergence did not replicate, which we trace to a confound caused by the composition of the reference pool used for leave-one-out statistics. A causal intervention isolating topology found no significant effect. A degree-normalization mechanism held across twenty-four seeds but did not explain the harm when corrected. The best of five candidate fixes beat a tuned baseline only until a matched, structurally blind control was applied, after which the gain disappeared. What survives is a modest, partially replicated, degree-specific signal that is not yet a validated predictor at scale.

0.19

Does the Explanation Drift Before the Guarantee? Label-Free Early Warning on Evolving Graphs

cs.AI ·2026-10-12 ·Tomasz Szandała, Damian Raczkowski
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 9 pages + appendix for reproducibility

Deployed models can fail silently as the world they describe evolves. Attribution drift has served as an early warning in tabular data; we ask whether, in graph streams, a model's own explanations can forewarn the loss of nominal conformal coverage. Doing so requires repairing the naive drift statistic twice. A vanishing edge loses mask mass regardless of whether the model relied on it, so we condition the importance on edge presence. Evolving graphs also break edge identity: a relabelling that changes nothing shifts the identity-based statistic by 0.69 on synthetic graphs and 0.83 on real ego-networks, whereas aggregating over structural roles brings both to 0.0 and stays well-defined when the support changes. We test six pre-registered regimes on thirty seeds each. A two-channel monitor, tracking conditional mask mass and its distribution over roles, precedes coverage collapse by 8 to 14.5 steps across four gradual regimes (node addition, removal, replacement, and edge thinning), all surviving Holm correction. A sudden knockout yields the expected zero lead, and a harmless change triggers no alarm. Leads track the length of the transitional phase (Spearman 0.79 over 150 runs). On real transaction ego-networks, the untuned mass channel forewarns staged drift by 27 steps and is the only channel, attributional or structural, that never alarms on a stationary stream. The main limitation is that the mass channel is blind to covariate drift, which breaks the guarantee in every run; the distributional channel detects it and also rescues the rewiring regime, so we report the two channels separately rather than as a union.

0.25

Empirical Auditing of Edge-Private Graph Generators

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-09-21 ·Anum Fatima, Stratis Limnios, James Adams, Lukasz Szpruch, Carsten Maple +2 more
similarity 0.59
Abstract

We empirically audit privacy leakage by testing whether outputs from edge-neighbouring inputs remain distinguishable, using statistically valid lower bounds on the privacy loss witnessed by our attacks. Our framework compares direct-edge, local-structural, and GNN-based attacks through the geometry surrounding a target edge. Experiments across two generators and two networks show that privacy leakage is both mechanism- and network-dependent, with learned representations revealing information not captured by conventional local statistics.

0.10

Operationalising Weaker Faithfulness: Recovery, Ambiguity and Computational Limits

cs.LG stat.MEstat.ML ·2026-10-22 ·Cillian Hourican, Rick Quax
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Variables can predict an outcome jointly while each is individually independent of it, causing structure learners to discard informative links. We investigate how to operationalise weaker faithfulness through two approaches: selective protection in an adjacency learner and explicit retention of alternative directed graph explanations. Matched experiments show that changes at both an early candidate-removal stage and later pruning can be necessary. In noisy XOR with a descendant (N = 10,000, 20 matched samples), combining reactivation and protection raises complete parent-pair recovery from 0/20 for either change alone to 20/20, while adding false edges. A confirmation study shows that the family estimator can preserve explanations lost by orienting the protected learner's selected skeleton: in one weaker signal XOR condition (N = 10,000) it retains the entire reference family in 48/50 samples, compared with 0/50 for the skeleton adapter. These gains are conditional. Protection can add only error, weaker effects produce false exclusions, and an ordinary faithful-chain comparison favours the PC learner. Complete nonempty family outputs decline at six/eight variables, and all 400 twelve/twenty-variable searches remain unfinished at the reporting cutoff. Neural controls show engineered retention, while the family estimator returns no accepted graph within its application budget. This operationalisation identifies two deletion stages that must be coordinated in the motivating example and shows when direct family search preserves explanations lost by selecting one skeleton. Finite evidence and computation remain substantial barriers to reliable general inference.

0.25

Where Privacy Belongs: Placement Diagnosis and Certified Selection for Private Counterfactual Explanations on Graphs

cs.LG ·2026-09-29 ·Yuxiang Yao, Zijun Zhao
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Counterfactual explanations for graph neural networks (GNNs) find the minimal intervention that flips a node's prediction--but computing one requires reading sensitive graph structure, and releasing it discloses that structure. Both existing placements fail. Privatizing the graph before explaining corrupts the target on exactly the borderline nodes needing recourse, manufacturing spurious flips that flip the privatized graph but not the true one. Explaining on the clean graph and perturbing the released explanation resists certification: re-auditing the standard heuristic shows an implied full-release budget of 573--753 on Cora and 256 on CiteSeer--orders of magnitude beyond its advertised budget--with worst-case single-entry leakage at AUC 1.0. We propose PrivCFS, which replaces certification-by-optimization with certification-by-construction: counterfactual selection over a fixed, data-independent candidate universe--edge interventions from a public prior graph, feature interventions from a public schema--whose no-op semantics give neighboring graphs the same output support. A validity-gated, clipped utility of global sensitivity $Δu \le 1$ released through the exponential mechanism gives pure $\varepsilon$-DP for the complete released object, composable over queries--to our knowledge the first such guarantee on graphs. Privacy noise is the cheapest stage: at $\varepsilon$=8 the release retains 94--97% of its support-restricted non-private optimum on the recourse population and 83--95% on the general one; the optimal edge-inference audit attains AUC 0.50 on average and 0.59 worst-pair, versus the heuristic's worst entry 1.0; and transfers to a 15K-node graph at 0.96 valid rate. The dominant cost is a measurable, monotone price in public disclosure, readable off one table before any budget is spent--turning explanation privacy from an accounting risk into a purchasable decision.

0.23

Color Refinement Distinguishes Connected Rooted Outerplanar Graphs

cs.DM cs.DSmath.CO ·2026-11-13 ·Louann Coste, M{ó}nika Csik{ó}s, Laurent Viennot
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Color refinement, also known as the $1$-dimensional Weisfeiler-Leman algorithm ($1$-WL), is a classical near-linear-time heuristic for graph isomorphism, which also captures the expressive power of message-passing graph neural networks. A long line of work asks on which graph classes $1$-WL, or its higher-dimensional variant $k$-WL, identifies every graph; the least such $k$ is the WL-dimension of the class. Planar graphs have WL-dimension at most $3$ (Kiefer, Ponomarenko and Schweitzer, 2019), and whether $2$-WL already distinguishes all planar graphs is a central open problem. We bring new insight on this question for outerplanar graphs, whose WL-dimension is $2$. We show that color refinement, i.e. 1-WL, distinguishes connected rooted outerplanar graphs: two non-isomorphic such graphs receive different stable colorings once a single vertex, the root, is individualized. The root is necessary, as there are non-isomorphic $2$-connected outerplanar graphs that color refinement does not distinguish. Our result extends to pseudo-rooted graphs, in which the stable coloring merely contains a singleton color class, and to non-connected graphs whose components all contain such a class. Consequently, the $(1,1)$-WL test of Rattan and Seppelt (2023) distinguishes all outerplanar graphs. We proceed by inversion: we reconstruct a connected rooted outerplanar graph, up to isomorphism, from its color graph, the weighted quotient of the graph by its stable color classes, together with its root color. The reconstruction runs in time linear in the output size and is canonical, which yields a near-linear-time canonization algorithm for these graphs. Our main tool is a dichotomy lemma, formalized in Rocq: in a rooted outerplanar graph with an equitable coloring, every block either receives pairwise distinct colors or admits a color-preserving mirror symmetry fixing its vertex closest to the root.

0.14

Lethe: Link Inference Attacks For Evaluation of Edge Unlearning Methods

cs.LG ·2026-10-15 ·Andrea D'Angelo, Francesco Gullo, Davide Mottin, Sayan Ranu, Giovanni Stilo
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract · Accepted at NEURIPS 2026 Evaluations & Datasets track

Graph Unlearning (GU) aims to remove the influence of specific training data from a Graph Neural Network without retraining anew. While most methods address removal of nodes and features, Edge Unlearning (EU), aiming at forgetting edges, has recently attracted dedicated attention as a standalone problem due to the hardness of completely removing the impact of an edge in the model. Despite this, no dedicated benchmark for EU exists besides isolated evaluations on feature-rich datasets such as Cora and Citeseer where GNNs exploit node features rather than graph structure. As such, we show two systematic limitations in existing evaluations: dedicated EU methods can be slower than retraining anew, and accuracy metrics are uninformative due to the negligible impact of edge removal. To address this gap, we introduce Lethe, the first comprehensive benchmark for Edge Unlearning, featuring 15 methods and 8 datasets. Our benchmark emphasizes large graphs, introduces evaluation tasks of varying difficulty, and proposes empirical measures based on link inference attacks rather than proxy accuracy metrics. We provide a comprehensive empirical analysis, demonstrate the shortcomings of current evaluations, and release Lethe as a reproducible, extensible benchmark.

0.30