CS Paper Radar

Diagnosing the Refuted Mismatched Decoding Converse for Binary-Input Channels

Jonathan Scarlett

cs.IT ·submitted 2026-09-23 13:43 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

We revisit the claimed converse theorem for mismatched decoding over binary-input discrete memoryless channels (Balakirsky, 1995) and the subsequent work refuting this converse via a numerical counter-example (Scarlett, Somekh-Baruch, Martinez, and Guillén i Fàbregas, 2015). A notable gap in the existing understanding is that no concrete flaw was identified in Balakirsky's analysis. In this paper, Balakirsky's proof is "diagnosed", and it is demonstrated that (i) his permutation lemma is flawed regardless of the correctness of his combinatorial approximation lemma; (ii) there are at least two specific incorrect steps regarding restricted codes and selector sequences, and these appear to be unlikely to admit a local repair; and (iii) the proposition in which these incorrect steps are used is false in general.

Comment
This work is AI-assisted, and a full declaration is given at the end of the paper

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

When Majority-Vote Fails: Sequence Reconstruction under Fixed-Weight Substitutions

cs.IT ·2026-10-21 ·Vivian Papadopoulou, Yonatan Yehezkeally, V. Arvind Rameshwar, Antonia Wachter-Zeh
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract

We consider the problem of binary sequence reconstruction where a sequence is transmitted multiple times over a channel, and each undergoes substitution errors by an arbitrary error vector of Hamming weight exactly $t$. We determine $N_{\mathrm{wc}}$, the minimum number of distinct channel output observations guaranteeing unique reconstruction by an optimal decoder, and show that the bit-wise majority-vote decoder, which was proved by Levenshtein (2001) to be optimal for channels corrupting up to $t$ bits, is in fact suboptimal here. Despite this suboptimality, we prove a condition that admits a practical early-termination rule, necessary for every decoder at any number of outputs $N$, and sufficient for bit-wise majority-vote even below $N_{\mathrm{wc}}$. We evaluate the number of outputs at which this condition is triggered, numerically, and show that it frequently occurs below $N_{\mathrm{wc}}$ when the block-length $k>2t+1$. Finally, we propose an alternative algorithm aimed at guaranteeing unique reconstruction with fewer observations than bit-wise majority-vote, and demonstrate through exhaustive enumeration that it successfully decodes channel output-sets where bit-wise majority-vote fails.

0.11

Comments on the recent improvements of the MRRW bounds

cs.IT math.COquant-ph ·2026-09-01 ·Alexander Barg
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 17 pages. This note contains a set of comments on the results in Chapter 2 of the OpenAI manuscript "Ten Advances in Mathematics and Theoret…

The asymptotic McEliece--Rodemich--Rumsey--Welch bound (1977) limits the largest attainable rate of binary codes as a function of the relative distance. After a nearly half-century hiatus, this result was recently improved in two concurrent works, by OpenAI and by O. Alrabiah and V. Guruswami. The two arguments look entirely different, a Delsarte certificate on the one hand, a classical-quantum channel and the pretty good measurement on the other, and they yield the same bound. The purpose of this note is to explain why: in both proofs, a subspace is attached to every codeword and moved with it, and the bound counts how many such subspaces fit in the ambient space, exactly in the first case and in the probabilistic sense of typicality in the second. We also present the OpenAI proof in the language and context of coding theory, as an extension of the spectral method in which the single vector attached to a codeword is replaced by a subspace.

0.47

An Upper Bound to the Undetected Error Exponent with Erasure Decoding at Positive Rates

cs.IT ·2026-10-11 ·Seyed AmirPouya Moeini, Marco Dalai, Albert Guillén i Fàbregas
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract

We study the undetected-error exponent of discrete memoryless channels with erasure decoding. Assuming that the undetected-error and erasure probabilities vanish, we derive an upper bound on the undetected-error exponent at positive rates. The bound uses Somekh-Baruch's genie-aided argument where an auxiliary output provides the decoder with a list of codewords. It recovers Telatar's tight rate-zero converse and is at least as tight as the straight-line bound. A numerical example shows that the improvement over the straight-line bound can be strict.

0.16

Concatenation Locality under Successive Adjacent Transpositions

cs.IT ·2026-11-01 ·Adelin Ataba, Aryeh Lev Zabokritskiy
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract · 32 pages

We study codes correcting up to $t\geq1$ successive adjacent transpositions, using block concatenation to support blockwise encoding and decoding. A fixed set $P$ of words of length $b$ over a $q$-symbol alphabet generates, for every $m$, the length-$mb$ code of all concatenations of $m$ words from $P$. For our explicit constructions, the prepared encoder and decoder depend only on the block parameters and are reused at every concatenation length. We first prove that correction at every concatenation length is certified by a single finite test at $2t+1$ blocks, and this test is tight over a $q$-symbol alphabet exactly when $\binom q2\geq2t$. For binary words and $b\geq2t+1$, we give an explicit construction with total redundancy at most $mt\log_2 b+O_t(m)$, matching the optimal per-block redundancy $t\log_2 b+O_t(1)$ among block sets correcting at every concatenation length. Among all binary $t$-correcting codes of length $mb$, the optimal total redundancy is $t\log_2(mb)+O_t(1)$. Using all concatenations of one block set makes our total redundancy grow linearly in $m$ and buys independent block encoding, with one encoder and decoder at every length. The construction encodes and decodes in time linear in $mb$ for fixed $b,t$, and recovers the $j$-th source block from the first $jb$ received symbols. We also prove that, whenever the length-$mb$ code corrects $t$ transpositions, the $j$-th source block is determined within $2tb$ received symbols beyond position $jb$, and that explicit binary block sets with rates tending to one as $b$ grows with $t$ fixed attain this bound in the worst case. Finally, we prove that every ordinary correcting code contains a constant fraction of its words whose arbitrary concatenations retain correction, for fixed $q,t$.

0.28

Capacity regimes for Boolean function computation via channels

cs.IT ·2026-08-11 ·Jingge Zhu, Matthias Frey
similarity 0.59
Abstract · A part of this work has been reported in https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.12640

Consider a point-to-point communication system in which the transmitter holds a binary message of length $m$ and transmits a corresponding codeword of length $n$. The receiver's goal is to recover a Boolean function of that message, where the function is unknown to the transmitter, but chosen from a known class $F$. We are interested in the asymptotic relationship of $m$ and $n$: given $n$, how large can $m$ be (asymptotically), such that the value of the Boolean function can be recovered reliably? This problem generalizes the identification-via-channels framework introduced by Ahlswede and Dueck. In this paper, we formulate the notion of computation capacity, and derive achievability and converse results for a large class of functions $F$, characterized by the Hamming weight of functions. Different from the classical transmission problem, the performance of the function computation problem is jointly characterized by the computation capacity and the rate function, namely how $m$ scales with $n$ asymptotically. Our results give a complete characterization of the rate function of the computation problem, and provide upper and lower bounds on the computation capacity, where they differ by a factor of at most $2$.

0.52

Algebraic Geometry Codes Approach the Half-Singleton Bound with Constant Field Size

cs.IT cs.DSmath.CO ·2026-09-04 ·Neehar Verma, Camilla Hollanti, Razane Tajeddine
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract

We study linear codes for insertion and deletion (insdel) errors through the lens of evaluation codes. We develop a general framework for analyzing random puncturings of evaluation codes, where the edit distance is controlled by only the size of the evaluation domain and the maximum number of zeros of a nonzero function in the underlying function space. Our proof generalizes the results of Con, Guo, Li, and Zhang (ICALP 2025), and simultaneously simplifies their arguments by avoiding an in-depth analysis of longest common subsequences. We demonstrate the applicability of our core theorem by instantiating it with random puncturings of Reed--Muller codes. We then recover the result that random Reed--Solomon codes approach the half-Singleton bound over linear-sized fields while also improving the dependence on the additive gap $\varepsilon$ from $2^{O(1/\varepsilon^2)}$ to $2^{O(1/\varepsilon)}$. Finally, by applying the framework to algebraic geometry codes arising from asymptotically good towers of function fields, we show that there exist randomized families of structured linear codes over constant-sized fields that approach the half-Singleton bound.

0.34

MacKay-Neal Codes Achieve Capacity under MAP Decoding

cs.IT ·2026-10-07 ·Kenta Kasai
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract · 22 pages

Statistical-mechanical analyses predict that MacKay-Neal codes can achieve channel capacity at fixed degrees. We prove this prediction for the uncoupled $(\ell,3,3)$ MN socket ensemble for every fixed integer $\ell\ge4$. For each binary-input memoryless symmetric channel of capacity strictly greater than $3/\ell$, the ensemble-average block error probability under maximum a posteriori (MAP) decoding is $O(\log N/N)$, where $N$ is the transmitted blocklength. The actual transmitted rate converges to $3/\ell$. The result includes both punctured and transmitted variables and does not condition the sparse square matrix on invertibility. The proof establishes an entropy inequality for six bits subject to even parity by an analytic argument that reduces the domain by symmetry, restricts its interior stationary points, where both partial derivatives vanish, to the diagonal, and controls the resulting scalar functions by explicit polynomial bounds. Exact configuration counts then bound the conditional entropy on the binary symmetric channel. A standard comparison by mutual information extends the entropy bound to general symmetric channels; independent output erasures and a minimum-distance estimate for the transmitted code yield the bit and block error bounds.

0.42

Plotkin-type Bound on Function-Correcting Codes for Monomial Mappings

cs.IT ·2026-10-03 ·Kanchana Lokshmii Jagatti, B. Sundar Rajan
published similarity 0.59
Abstract · Proceedings of IEEE International Conference on Advanced Networks and Telecommunications Systems (ANTS), 2026 (To appear)

Function-correcting codes, recently introduced by Lenz et al.\ (2023), provide a framework for the receiver to provide a higher level of protection against channel errors than the level of protection for messages. In this paper, we derive a generalised Plotkin-type bound on the redundancy of FCCs under the Hamming metric for arbitrary functions over finite fields. The proposed bound recovers the classical Plotkin bound for classical error-correcting codes as a special case. We further obtain explicit Plotkin-type bounds for linear functions, Hamming-weight functions, and Hamming-weight threshold functions. In addition, we study FCCs for monomial mappings $f(x)=x^n$ over $\mathbb{F}_{q^k}$, which are widely utilised in coding theory, cryptography, and finite geometry, and derive an explicit Plotkin-type redundancy bound.

0.14