CS Paper Radar

An Exposition of GPT Astra's Proof of Lower Bound on DP Continual Counting

Jalaj Upadhyay

cs.CR cs.DScs.LG ·submitted 2026-09-22 17:21 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

The goal of this note is to give a detailed proof, to the best of our understanding, of the recent presentation by Harrison and Leeman (arXiv:2609.17650v01 and arXiv:2609.17650v02) of the proof by Astra on the lower bound for differentially private continual counting. We believe a more natural and easy proof is possible and hope that this note will help in that effort. Prior to the initial preprint by Harrison and Leeman (arXiv:2609.17650v01), Bairaktari and Larsen (arXiv:2607.00876) gave an elegant proof to show a lower bound of $Ω(\log^{3/2}(n))$ for both pure and approximate-DP continual counting, and in personal communication had informed us that they have a proof of optimal $Ω(\log^{2}(n))$ for pure-differential private continual counting as well. They have subsequently published their $Ω(\log^{2}(n))$ bound, which is now a joint work of Bairaktari, Dahl, and Larsen (arXiv:2607.00876v3). Their new result is an elegant extension of their technique for approximate-differential privacy. Although the two proofs are technically different, the Astra argument uses related tree geometry introduced in Bairaktari and Larsen.

Comment
This is full proof of GPT generated proof for DP continual counting written in preprint https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.17650v2

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Tight Lower Bounds for Differentially Private Continual Counting

cs.DS cs.CR ·2026-09-15 ·Charlie Harrison, Ethan Leeman
theory similarity 0.74
Abstract

The Binary Tree Mechanism is a standard algorithm for differentially private continual counting, but its asymptotic optimality under pure differential privacy has remained unresolved since its introduction. We resolve this question. For fixed $0 < \varepsilon \le 1$, we prove asymptotically tight lower bounds of $Ω(\log^2 n)$ for worst-case expected $\ell_\infty$ error and $Ω(\log^3 n)$ for mean and maximum per-coordinate expected squared error. These bounds hold for arbitrary mechanisms, even when the entire stream is available in advance. The same lower bounds hold under approximate differential privacy whenever $δ\le n^{-c}$, for any fixed $c>0$. Our lower bounds match the Binary Tree Mechanism instantiated with Laplace noise, establishing its asymptotic optimality under both pure differential privacy and approximate differential privacy in the standard regime of $δ\ll1/n$. Our proof uses a single hard distribution with a bounded exponential score on a tree. A simple modification of the score allows the same framework to establish tight lower bounds for all three error measures.

0.42

Improved Quasi-Polynomial-Time Approximation for Maximum Independent Set

cs.DS cs.CC ·2026-10-26 ·Zhao Song
similarity 0.60
Abstract

We give a deterministic quasi-polynomial-time algorithm for the maximum independent set problem. If an $N$-vertex graph contains an independent set of size $2^{-t}N$, where $t$ is an integer with $1\le t\le\sqrt{\log N}/12$, then our algorithm finds an independent set of size $2^t$ in time $N^{O(t)}$. This gives an approximation ratio of $N/2^{Ω(\sqrt{\log N})}$ in time $N^{O(\sqrt{\log N})}$, improving on the approximation ratio $N/2^{Ω((\log N)^{1/3})}$ obtained by Lovett [Lov26]. A limitation of this form of analysis follows from the integrality gaps of Tulsiani [Tul09]. These gaps imply that a universal guarantee of the form $\operatorname{Las}_{R(t)}(G)\ge2^{-t}N\Longrightarrowα(G)\ge2^t$, at $2^{o(\sqrt{\log N\log\log N})}$ levels, cannot hold over a range extending beyond $t=O(\sqrt{\log N\log\log N})$. Thus, the exponent $1/2$ is the limit of this form of analysis, up to a factor of $\sqrt{\log\log N}$.

0.23

Near-Optimal Bounds for Sketching the Schatten Norms

cs.DS cs.CCmath.ST ·2026-08-23 ·Lin F. Yang
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract · 94 pages, added the turnstile streaming lower bound, upper/lower bound for all non-even p>0

Let $k_{1,\varepsilon}(n)$ be the smallest number of real linear measurements needed by a randomized oblivious sketch that estimates the nuclear norm of every fixed real $n\times n$ matrix within a factor $1\pm\varepsilon$, with probability at least $2/3$. For every fixed $0<\varepsilon<1$, we prove \[ \frac{n^2}{(\log n)^{A_\varepsilon}} \le k_{1,\varepsilon}(n) \le C_\varepsilon \frac{n^2\{\log\log(e^e n)\}^2}{\log(e n)}. \] Previously, the best unrestricted bounds for general linear sketches of the Schatten--1 norm were $Ω(n)$ and the trivial $O(n^2)$ upper bound (Li, Nguyen, Woodruff'19), leaving a polynomial gap. Our bounds close that gap up to polylogarithmic factors and give a nontrivial logarithmic saving below the $n^2$-measurement storage bound. The result extends much further. Write $k_{p,\varepsilon}(n)$ for the analogous sketch dimension for the Schatten--$p$ norm. For every fixed finite $p>0$ that is not a positive even integer, there are positive constants $A_{p,\varepsilon},C_{p,\varepsilon},c_p$ such that \[ \frac{n^2}{(\log n)^{A_{p,\varepsilon}}} \le k_{p,\varepsilon}(n) \le C_{p,\varepsilon}\frac{n^2}{(\log n)^{c_p}}, \] so $k_{p,\varepsilon}(n)=n^{2-o(1)}$ throughout the non-even regime. Together with the known tight bounds $Θ_{p,\varepsilon}(n^{2-4/p})$ for positive even $p$ and $Θ_\varepsilon(n^2)$ for $p=\infty$ (Li, Woodruff'16), our results close the remaining polynomial gap across the Schatten family and complete, up to polylogarithmic factors, the polynomial-order classification of general linear sketches for all Schatten-$p$ norms.

0.16

Subgraph Counting with Local Node Differential Privacy

cs.DS cs.CR ·2026-10-15 ·Sofya Raskhodnikova, Adam Smith, Connor Wagaman, Anatoly Zavyalov
top venuetheory similarity 0.60
Abstract · To appear at the ACM-SIAM Symposium on Discrete Algorithms (SODA) 2027

We study the problem of approximately counting subgraphs under local node differential privacy (LNDP), a recently introduced model that enforces strong privacy guarantees in analyses of distributed social networks. We design a noninteractive $(\varepsilon,0)$-LNDP algorithm that, given any public $k$-node template graph $H$, counts occurrences of $H$ in a sensitive undirected $n$-node graph with additive error $O(n^{k-\frac{1}{2}}/\varepsilon^{k-1})$, for any constant $k$. We complement this algorithm with a lower bound showing that every noninteractive $(\varepsilon,δ)$-LNDP algorithm for counting copies of any $k$-node template graph with maximum degree greater than $1$ must have error $Ω(n^{k - \frac{1}{2}})$. Thus, our algorithm achieves optimal error for counting constant-size subgraphs, up to $\mathrm{poly}(1/\varepsilon)$ factors. Our results substantially expand the types of network statistics known to be approximable under LNDP: prior work considered only functions of the degree distribution. In addition, our lower bound yields the first known $\mathrm{poly}(n)$ gap between central and local node differential privacy when accuracy is required for all input graphs. Previous separations either only involved $\mathrm{poly}(1/\varepsilon)$ factors or only applied to promise problems.

0.32

Top-Down Lower Bounds for All Depths

cs.CC ·2026-09-30 ·Oliver Korten
publishedtheory similarity 0.59
Abstract · 20 pages

We prove that Parity requires $2^{n^{Ω(1)}}$ size De Morgan circuits of constant depth using a new method which is completely "top-down" in the sense of [HJP95]. The proof relies crucially on the core ideas developed in a line of work [HJP95, PPZ99, MW19, GRSS24] which previously established top-down lower bounds for circuits of depth 3 and 4. We first present a proof of a lower bound $\exp(n^{3^{-d}})$. In this case, nearly all of the relevant combinatorial ideas necessary for the proof are already present in some form in [GRSS24]. We then present two extensions of this argument, the first achieving a lower bound $\exp(ε_d n^{1/(2d-2)})$ for some $ε_d>0$ depending only on $d$, and the second achieving the essentially tight lower bound $\exp(ε_d n^{1/(d-1)})$. These improved results each hinge on establishing a key lemma which quantifies the extent to which a high entropy random variable in $\{0,1\}^n$ will look close to uniform after projecting it onto a random small set of coordinates $R \subseteq [n]$.

0.46

Random ($\log{n}$)-CNF Formulas Are Hard for Depth-$2$ Frege with Modular Gates

cs.CC ·2026-10-29 ·Jonas Conneryd
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract

We prove that, with high probability, refuting a random $k$-CNF formula on $n$ variables with ${M = n2^{k}}$ clauses for $ω_n(1) \leq k \leq O(\log{n})$ requires polynomial calculus degree at least ${n/2-O(n/\sqrt{k})}$ over every field. Through Pang's recent tradeoff between $\mathsf{AC}^0[p]$-Frege size and polynomial calculus degree [Pang 2026, arXiv:2610.00837v2], this implies a size lower bound of $\exp(Ω_p(\sqrt{k} \log{n}))$ for depth-$2$ $\mathsf{AC}^0[p]$-Frege. In this range of $k$, the bound is superpolynomial in $M$ while $M \leq \mathrm{poly}(n)$. We also prove a nearly matching degree upper bound of $n/2-n\ln(k)/{2k} +O(n/k)$, which shows that other formula families are needed to obtain lower bounds for full $\mathsf{AC}^0[p]$-Frege through Pang's tradeoff.

0.17

Lower Bounds for Private Graph Optimization Problems using Reconstruction Attacks

cs.DS cs.CR ·2026-09-09 ·Jacob Imola, Rasmus Pagh, Lukas Retschmeier
top venuetheory similarity 0.58
Abstract · 32 pages, 3 figures. To appear at PODS 2027

This paper studies fundamental graph optimization problems under differential privacy (DP) and shows new, reconstruction-based lower bounds. We consider a graph $G = (V, E, \vec{w})$ where the vertex set $V$ and edges $E$ are public and the weights $\mathbf{w}:E\rightarrow \mathbb{R}$ must be kept differentially private under an $\ell_1$ neighboring relation. For the problems of releasing a minimum-weight spanning tree and a minimum-weight perfect matching, we show new, tight error bounds of $Ω(n\cdot\log(m/n)/ε)$ on worst-case graphs with $n$ vertices and $m>2n$ edges. The upper bounds are known pure DP algorithms while the new lower bound holds even under approximate $(\varepsilon,δ)$-DP as long as $δ\leq (n/m)^{Ω(1)}$. Our lower bounds improve the $Ω(n/ε)$ lower bounds of Sealfon (PODS~'16). The fact that approximate DP does not reduce error for MST under the $\ell_1$ neighboring relation contrasts with the recent upper bound of Pagh et al. (PODS~'25) which shows that approximate DP allows much better error under the $\ell_\infty$ neighboring relation. Going beyond worst-case graphs, we give lower bounds for large families of sparse graphs with expansion properties. We show a lower bound of $Ω(n / ε)$ for the minimum spanning tree for any graph where the minimum cut is at least $Ω(\log(n))$. Finally, we consider the problem of private hierarchical clustering under Dasgupta's cost function (STOC~'16) and show the first approximate DP lower bound parameterized by the minimum weight of a balanced cut. This extends lower bounds of Deng et al. (ICLR~'25) to general graphs and to approximate DP.

0.60

Unconditional Boolean Dynamic Lower Bounds from Disjointness

cs.DS cs.CC ·2026-10-07 ·Young Kun Ko
theory similarity 0.58
Abstract · 48 pages, 3 figures. v2: main result stated for the multiphase problem; appendix extended to further dynamic problems; introduction revised.…

We prove an unconditional $Ω((\log n/\log\log n)^2)$ lower bound on the maximum of the worst-case update time and expected query time for the insert-only version of Patrascu's multiphase Disjointness problem [STOC 2010]. The bound holds in the zero-error cell-probe model with logarithmic word size. Patrascu's reductions transfer it to directed reachability under edge insertions, already on directed acyclic graphs of depth $2$. This improves the $\widetildeΩ(\log^{3/2} n)$ bound of Larsen and Yu [SICOMP 2025] to the quadratic-logarithmic scale previously attained for dynamic range counting and multiphase Inner Product. The bound also transfers to a broad collection of dynamic graph, algebraic, geometric, and string problems. We also obtain a separation between amortized and worst-case time for streaming regular-expression membership. For a simple family of expressions of maximum length $M$ over a polynomial-size alphabet, a deterministic algorithm uses $O(1)$ amortized time per symbol on every input stream, whereas every zero-error cell-probe algorithm with word size $w=Θ(\log M)$ requires $Ω((\log M/\log\log M)^2)$ time on some symbol. The proof adapts Ko's 2.5-round multiphase communication framework [FOCS 2026] from Inner Product to Disjointness. Our main technical observation is that the protocol's verification step allows a one-sided corruption bound to replace the discrepancy property used for Inner Product.

0.24