CS Paper Radar

Developing a Unified Verification and Validation Activity Standard at JPL

Maximilian Vierlboeck, Ellen Van Wyk, Natalia Sanchez, Bogdan Oaida, Torrance James Eberhart, Marie Piette Gomez, Christopher Delp, Marijke G. Jorritsma, Alex Desharnais

cs.SE eess.SY ·submitted 2026-09-23 15:56 UTC · v1

Abstract

Verification and validation practices (V&V) at NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) have diverged over the past decade, creating fragmentation that increases overhead, reduces cross-project efficiencies, and inhibits institutional knowledge transfer. We present a unified V&V activity schema developed through human-centered design workshops involving 29 practitioners across multiple mission types and disciplines. The schema builds on a relationship-based architecture that allows for separating methods (Test, Analysis, Inspection, Demonstration, and Review of Design) while maintaining a common attribute set. Formalized as a platform-agnostic SysML model, the schema defines bidirectional relationships between requirements, V&V activities, venues, and evidence. Implementation in JPL's Jama platform demonstrates controlled customization through templates and modular item types, balancing rigor with agility while enabling automations, pattern reuse, and digital thread integration.

Comment
21 pages, 10 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

EngiWorld: What Can Frontier Agents Deliver in Professional Engineering Environments?

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-09-29 ·Hongcheng Gao, Hailong Qu, Yu Lei, Henghui Sun, Haoyang Li +17 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · Project page: https://engiworld.github.io

Autonomous agents have made rapid progress in general-purpose computer use, yet reliable automation of professional industrial engineering remains out of reach. Engineering workflows require reasoning over geometric and physical constraints and keeping dependencies consistent across software and design stages. We present EngiWorld, a benchmark designed around the capabilities that real engineering projects require, from operating a single application to solving engineering problems end to end. It contains 1,301 expert-curated tasks spanning six engineering domains (CAD, CAE, CAM, BIM, EDA, and DCC) and 26 professional software applications, with both GUI and CLI interfaces. The tasks are organized into six types, corresponding to capabilities that real engineering projects require. We further introduce an artifact-centric evaluation methodology built on a unified suite of domain verifiers. The verifiers programmatically check whether final and intermediate artifacts are geometrically valid, physically feasible, and compliant with design rules. Beyond binary success, they also score how well optimized designs meet their specifications. Evaluation of seven frontier models reveals a substantial capability gap: the strongest model scores only 44.7/100, and just 3.6% of runs on tasks that require cross-software coordination succeed. EngiWorld provides a rigorous foundation for measuring progress toward agents that operate professional engineering software end to end.

0.45

RocketAgent: A Long-Horizon Engineering Agent for Multidisciplinary Design of Liquid-Rocket Thrust Chambers

cs.AI ·2026-10-05 ·Junxiang He, Runze Mao, Kun He, Teng Zhang, Liming Zheng +2 more
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Liquid-rocket thrust-chamber design involves interdependent analyses in which downstream constraints can require earlier design decisions to be revisited. Managing these dependencies across heterogeneous tools requires consistent design information and coordinated updates throughout the workflow. We present RocketAgent, a long-horizon engineering agent for multidisciplinary preliminary design of liquid-rocket thrust chambers. A single plan-owning Coding Agent coordinates engineering skills for performance sizing, subsystem optimization, geometry generation, and multiphysics assessment. A provenance-aware knowledge graph supports method selection, while a typed Design Intermediate Representation maintains shared parameters, artifacts, and decisions. Revision-aware checks invalidate affected results and block superseded inputs, with consequential changes subject to engineering approval. In a representative simulation-based design, RocketAgent continued from an infeasible cooling search through an engineer-authorized operating-point revision, identified feasible subsystem designs, and coordinated subsequent geometry generation and multiphysics assessment to support final configuration selection. Separate module tests assessed surrogate predictions and nozzle adaptation. A two-configuration comparison across three controlled scenarios verified the expected dependency invalidations and superseded-input blocking before solver execution. The representative case demonstrates sustained coordination across a multidisciplinary design workflow, while the controlled tests establish the behavior of the revision mechanisms supporting that execution.

0.35

MARQ: A Modular, LLM-Agnostic Requirement Quality Assessor Infused with Systems Engineering Knowledge

cs.AI cs.SE ·2026-10-26 ·Jannatul Shefa, Alejandro Salado, Paul Wach, Taylan G. Topcu
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Requirements engineering (RE) is foundational to systems engineering (SE), as requirement defects can propagate downstream and adversely affect development outcomes. Although large language models (LLMs) are promising for requirement quality assessment, prior work shows that off-the-shelf models miss a large share of expert-identified defects, perform unevenly across quality criteria, and vary across executions. This study investigates whether infusing expert-derived SE knowledge can improve LLM-based requirement quality evaluation beyond off-the-shelf capability. We present MARQ, a modular, LLM-agnostic prototype that supplements LLMs with a criterion-specific knowledge stack operationalizing INCOSE requirement quality criteria and evaluated against off-the-shelf baselines on an expert-labeled NASA requirement set using Claude Opus 5, GPT-5.6 Sol, and the open-weight Gemma 3 12B, with 100 executions per model. MARQ achieves median F1 scores of 0.80 for Claude Opus 5, 0.62 for GPT-5.6 Sol, and 0.53 for Gemma 3 12B, compared with off-the-shelf baselines of 0.55, 0.52, and 0.18, respectively. However, the nature of these gains is model-dependent. Claude Opus 5 improves defect detection and false-alarm control; GPT-5.6 Sol gains detection and better execution-level consistency at the cost of more false alarms; and Gemma 3 12B reaches the performance of off-the-shelf proprietary models, although it remains highly variable. Criterion-level analysis shows gains concentrated in Correctness and Conformance, trade-offs between misses and false alarms within individual criteria, and model-dependent responses across several criteria. These findings position SE knowledge infusion as a promising model-agnostic pathway for strengthening trustworthy LLM-based RE support while underscoring the need for criterion-specific interventions and human-in-the-loop review.

0.04

Integrating Semantics into Research Data Management: Modelling and Validating Materials Science Experiment Workflows

cs.DB ·2026-08-21 ·Samuel García Vázquez, Victor Dudarev, Alfred Ludwig, Markus Stricker, Maribel Acosta
similarity 0.59
Abstract · Preprint of the paper accepted for publication at the International Semantic Web Conference (ISWC) 2026. The final version will be published…

The incorporation of Semantic Web technologies within scientific environments is becoming an increasingly popular Research Data Management (RDM) practice. While ontologies offer flexible, reusable and machine-readable vocabularies to describe domain-specific research data, Knowledge Graphs (KGs) facilitate the integration of heterogeneous data sources into an interoperable collection. Furthermore, KGs offer additional advantages, notably the use of expressive SPARQL queries, or the ability to define complex data validation rules with SHACL. This work describes the modelling of a relational RDM system with an ontology, and the subsequent construction of a KG based on it. Enabled by the highly interconnected nature of research data and experiment workflows present in the system, we not only show how we can easily and reliably build an efficient KG from such domain-specific RDM systems, but also how doing so enables more advanced use cases. This is demonstrated by the modelling of ideal counterparts for the experiment workflows logged in the KG, which are then used to programmatically generate SHACL shapes that fully validate the conformance of the latter. By integrating this functionality within a UI, we allow researchers to plan, reuse, share, and track the progress of their daily experiments.

0.08

Scaling Verifiable Environments for Long-horizon Work Agents

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-10-04 ·Jiazheng Zhang, Long Ma, Yunxian Yang, Zhiheng Xi, Zhikai Lei +21 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Work agents operate over digital artifacts to execute professional knowledge-intensive work, requiring training environments that support long-horizon interaction and trustworthy verification. However, hand-crafted environments incur prohibitive engineering overhead that prevents environment scaling, whereas synthesis methods sacrifice workspace complexity, realism, or grounded verifiability. To bridge this gap, we introduce WorkForge, a scalable synthesis framework for constructing verifiable work-agent environments from real-world resources. Starting from expert workflows, WorkForge first identifies the resources, decisions, and deliverables required by each workflow. It then retrieves relevant real-world files and organizes them into a workspace. WorkForge inspects the workspace to extract concrete, checkable facts about its content. These factual anchors fix which task types the workspace can support and how their outcomes can be verified. Therefore, WorkForge derives each task's instructions, solution plan, and complementary programmatic and semantic verifiers directly from these factual anchors, keeping verification traceable to observable workspace evidence. Furthermore, we construct 16.7K verifiable environments across 40 professional domains, with workspaces collectively covering 60 file types. Post-training Qwen3.5-35B-A3B-Base improves GDPVal from 45.5 to 73.6 and APEX Score from 5.0 to 21.3, while enabling Qwen3.5-27B to achieve highly competitive performance and outperform strong competitors. Our analyses confirm the efficacy of the proposed method and reveal consistent scaling behaviors across both data volume and interaction horizons.

0.18

Specification-Driven Data Architecture Reconstruction: From Physical Code to Logical and Conceptual Specifications

cs.LO cs.DBcs.SE ·2026-09-12 ·Oleg Grynets, Olena Pochernina, Vasyl Lyashkevych
similarity 0.58
Abstract · 15 pages, 3 figures, 7 tables, 35 references

Legacy database migrations often begin with incomplete or outdated documentation, leaving physical data definition language (DDL) as the principal evidence of data architecture. However, DDL does not fully encode conceptual intent, and model-generated completions can be plausible without being correct. This study proposes and evaluates a provenance-aware, deterministic-first pipeline for reconstructing logical and conceptual data specifications from Oracle-oriented DDL while explicitly separating observed facts, deterministic derivations, and large language model (LLM) suggestions. The pipeline performs DDL investigation, parsing, consolidation, primary-key backfilling, type normalization, and declared relationship-graph construction before optional LLM-assisted enrichment. It preserves source provenance in the deterministic catalog and declared relationship graph, and records inferred primary-key and foreign-key candidates in a separate reviewable overlay. We evaluated the implementation on 249 artifactized schema samples comprising 1,225 SQL files. The pipeline completed 244 samples (97.99%); 52 completed samples contained no extractable DDL. Across completed samples, the deterministic path reconstructed 208 tables and recovered 278 declared foreign-key records; 168 of the reconstructed tables lacked an explicitly parsed primary key before backfilling. LLM enrichment generated 100 foreign-key candidates in 36 samples, but the parent-table admissibility rate was only 17.9% for logical-specification candidates and 17.5% for conceptual-specification candidates. These findings show that the proposed deterministic-first architecture can preserve an auditable structural baseline, quantify observed primary-key and relationship gaps, and prevent model-generated hypotheses from being silently promoted to source-grounded architectural facts.

0.30

DRAFT-Bench: Evaluating Frontier Agents Across the Professional Design Lifecycle

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-11-06 ·Rong Pan, Jianqiang Wang
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Can frontier general-purpose agents understand client intent, explore creative directions, execute revisions, and prepare production deliverables? We introduce DRAFT-Bench (Design Reliability Across Feedback and Tasks), a lifecycle-oriented evaluation of requirement elicitation, creative exploration, constrained editing, iterative revision, and production handoff. Its Requirement-to-Artifact framework links evolving requirements, protected properties, artifact versions, and delivery obligations. We compare native Codex/Astra and Claude Code across 35 design briefs under 43 conditions, alongside a separate 40-scenario RFQ track. Astra completes 43/43 design conditions and Claude 35/43. All scored core runs receive full structural credit, yet on the 28 core conditions scored for both systems, semantic checks flag violations in 11 for Astra and 5 for Claude; these are model judgments, not expert-confirmed failure rates. RFQ coverage is high, but success ordering changes across cohorts. SKU expansion, revision dependencies, and White ink files expose ambiguity among unmet obligations, missing inputs, and evaluator interpretations. These findings separate execution, requirement compliance, and professional acceptance. Unpaired tracks and different tools preclude claims of RFQ-to-delivery success, factory acceptance, or a pure model ranking.

0.27

Designing for Imperfect Prompts: A Simulation-Based Evaluation of an LLM-Based Enterprise Data Assistant Using Knowledge Graphs

cs.HC cs.AIcs.DB ·2026-10-16 ·Niklas Wagner, Alexander Mädche
published similarity 0.56
Abstract · Published in the Proceedings of the 34th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS 2026)

Enterprise data assistants using large language models (LLMs) promise democratized data access in organizations. Yet in our real-world deployment within the CFO unit's data lake at an industry partner, we observed that business users frequently pose imperfect prompts that include domain-specific vocabulary and lack schema references or structural information. This Design Science Research study examines automatic resolution using a semantic mediation layer. We design and evaluate two design variants: schema-based mediation via semantic similarity, and knowledge graph-based mediation leveraging an automatically constructed knowledge graph from the data lake. Our simulation-based evaluation using real-world data, supported by LLM-as-a-Judge assessments and human validation, shows that knowledge graph-based mediation outperforms the schema-based approach in Precision, Recall, F1, and preserving user intent. We propose a design principle for knowledge graph-based mediation, demonstrating that structured knowledge representation bridges user intent and database structure and guides the design of enterprise data assistants across skill levels.

0.41