CS Paper Radar

Security Limits of Mining Before Validation in Nakamoto Consensus

Yifan Zhou, Jiang Xiao, Kaihua Qin

cs.CR cs.DC ·submitted 2026-09-24 08:30 UTC · v1

Abstract

Mining before validation allows miners to extend a newly received block before completing its validity checks, giving them a head start in the race for the next block reward. This head start, however, comes with a security risk: rejecting one invalid block also discards the honest work built on it, an effect missed when validation is treated as instantaneous. We quantify this risk in a model of Nakamoto consensus with bounded network delay and a validation-time bound independent of processing load. We establish an explicit threshold on adversarial mining power below which honest miners' fully validated chains continue to grow and agree on a stable history with high probability over any fixed observation period. We also construct an attack that repeatedly draws honest mining onto invalid branches. When the adversary produces more than one block on average during the allowed validation time, the attack can eventually remove a target block at any fixed initial confirmation depth. Combined with ordinary private mining, this attack yields a matching asymptotic bound in the fully decentralized regime, where each honest miner has negligible mining power. The results show how validation latency limits the security of mining before validation, beyond the constraint imposed by network delay.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Fully Fluctuating Sleepy Consensus from Minimal Assumptions

cs.DC ·2026-09-02 ·Javier Nieto, Yuval Efron, Joachim Neu, Ling Ren
published similarity 0.66
Abstract

Bitcoin's proof-of-work (PoW)-based protocol is remarkable for how little it asks of its participants. Not only can miners take breaks from work whenever they please, but it is almost unique in offering a path of contrition: corrupt miners can reclaim honest status simply by resuming mining on the longest chain. The protocol only requires that honest miners hold the majority of computational power at any given time. Analogous proof-of-stake (PoS) protocols, usually formalized via the sleepy model of Pass and Shi (2017), have fallen short of matching this robustness. In fact, sleepy consensus protocols in the plain PKI model must heavily restrict fluctuations in adversarial participation over time. The recent work of Efron, Neu, and Pitassi (2025) enables fully fluctuating participation in the sleepy model by introducing the external adversary model. Their protocol, however, relies on verifiable delay functions (VDFs), a strong cryptographic primitive that somewhat resembles PoW, by assuming that the adversary cannot compute sequential work significantly faster than honest nodes. In this work, we design a sleepy consensus protocol for fully fluctuating participation with an external adversary under an honest majority, from minimal assumptions: a public key infrastructure (PKI) and a verifiable random function (VRF). In particular, we make no VDF or hardware assumptions. Our key technique is graded wakeness, a novel primitive that allows nodes to form consistent opinions on which other nodes are awake. We further extend our protocol to handle uncorruption, where corrupt nodes return to honesty. This extension requires only a mild additional assumption on the unpredictability of VRF outputs for liveness.

0.29

Mitigating 51% Attacks in Blockchain Systems Through Early Detection and Checkpoint-Based Defense

cs.CR ·2026-09-13 ·Victor Kebande
similarity 0.62
Abstract

The 51% attack remains one of the significant security concern in Proof-of-Work (PoW) blockchains, where increasing hash-power concentration can create a malicious majority-control risk and enable adversarial chain reorganization. This paper proposes a two-layer defense that combines early hash-power monitoring with checkpoint-based mitigation. The first layer monitors mining-power concentration and provides an early warning before the critical majority-control threshold is reached. The second layer uses checkpointing to restrict the depth of accepted chain reorganizations. Monte Carlo simulations are used to evaluate both mechanisms under different attack scenarios. Across 1,000 simulation runs, a 45% warning threshold provided a mean warning-to-critical lead time of 10.531 minutes before the modeled 50% critical threshold was reached. At the selected checkpoint depth of N = 6, approximately 63.68% of simulated reorganization attempts were rejected, while the mean reorganization-depth outcome decreased from 7.948 to 1.634 blocks, representing an approximately 79.4% reduction. The results demonstrate that early detection and checkpoint-based mitigation provide complementary mechanisms for reducing the potential impact of 51% attacks under the evaluated conditions.

0.33

PoVD: Efficient Consensus Protocol based on Verifiable Delay Function

cs.DC ·2026-09-18 ·Rui Jiang, Xintong Ling, Bin Cao, Jiaheng Wang, Xiqi Gao +1 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Consensus protocols ensure the robustness and scalability of blockchains and decentralized applications built on them. However, existing consensus mechanisms often impose high computational cost or require heavy communication overhead. To address these challenges, we propose proof of verifiable delay (PoVD), a lightweight consensus protocol based on the verifiable delay function (VDF). We present the detailed protocol of PoVD, including the block mining and verification rules, and illustrate how PoVD can flexibly adjust the block time distribution according to the network condition. Through mathematical proof, we point out that, under a relatively weak network assumption, PoVD can achieve a lower fork rate than PoW while maintaining the same throughput. Our experiments verify that PoVD exhibits low computation and communication complexity and can also improve the blockchain consistency, making it particularly suitable for resource-constrained nodes and bandwidth-limited networks.

0.16

PDoS: A Profitable Denial-of-Service Attack against Proof-of-Work Blockchain Liveness

cs.CR cs.GT ·2026-09-11 ·Junjie Hu, Tianzhu Han, Na Ruan
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 34 pages, 10 figures

The security and liveness of Proof-of-Work (PoW) blockchains fundamentally depend on the economic rationality of miners. Existing incentive-driven denial-of-service attacks, such as BDoS, can deter rational miners from participating, but require the attacker to continuously absorb substantial economic losses and are therefore difficult to sustain in high-value networks. Meanwhile, prior infiltration-based withholding attacks are designed to extract revenue rather than to directly disrupt chain liveness. We present PDoS, a hybrid attack that combines block header signal deterrence with parasitic revenue extraction. PDoS disrupts blockchain liveness while exploiting the victim pool's share-reward mechanism to subsidize the attack cost, thereby lowering the adversarial hash-power threshold required to induce rational miners to shut down. We further show a counterintuitive result: in high-fee or high-MEV environments, higher block value can make PoW systems less secure by increasing the attacker's parasitic revenue and pushing the attack across the break-even point into a self-sustaining, or even profitable, regime. To the best of our knowledge, PDoS is the first attack to demonstrate that disrupting PoW blockchain liveness can be economically self-sustaining and even profitable.

0.39

Beyond Leaderless: Randomized Consensus Against Mobile Crashes

cs.DC ·2026-10-31 ·Ittai Abraham, Kaya Alpturer, Pranav Garimidi, Joachim Neu, Tim Roughgarden +1 more
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 32 pages, 6 figures

Many consensus protocols fail to terminate under attack from an adversary that has the power to move between replicas and repeatedly crash one of them, even in synchrony. We present Multi-Leader Fixed-View Simplex (ML-FVS) to defend against such an adversary while keeping the simple structure and good-case latency of Simplex consensus. Our protocol extends fixed-view Simplex with multiple leaders, each of which may broadcast a proposal. At the voting deadline, each replica votes on the set of proposals it has seen so far. A hidden threshold beacon revealed after the votes gives a priority order on the multiple leaders, resolving each vote to its highest-priority proposal. Our model combines permanent adaptive Byzantine faults with mobile crashes. For a constant crash budget and $Δ$-delayed Byzantine corruption, we obtain $O(Δ)$ expected latency over repeated views whose leaders start honest. With immediate Byzantine corruptions, the protocol still achieves liveness. We also evaluate the protocol under random network delays and stochastic faults, finding that multiple leaders reduce view failures even when rational leaders delay their proposals to increase rewards.

0.19

STAKE: Preventing a colluding majority from double spending

cs.GT ·2026-10-01 ·Zahra Naderi, Vincent Gramoli
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Blockchains typically operate in open networks where it is hard to control the delay of messages. While classic blockchain protocols assumed synchrony, newer protocols try to remain secure despite unexpected network delays. Unfortunately, in the traditional model where $n$ participants can either be honest or Byzantine, we need a supermajority, or $\lfloor 2n/3\rfloor + 1$, of them to be honest. Recent work have explored the question of reducing the number of needed honest nodes in a game theory model to a majority sometimes by introducing $k$ rational players and $t$ Byzantine players. Yet, to our knowledge, no blockchain protocol managed to reduce it further. In this paper, we offer a blockchain protocol called Secure and Tolerant Algorithm through ($k,t$)-robust Equilibrium (STAKE) that works with only $\lfloor n/3\rfloor + 1$ honest players. STAKE requires each consensus participant to stake a sufficiently large amount $s$ compared to their liquidity $\ell$. We show that the probability that a coalition manages to execute $ζ$ double spending attacks (we call them a $ζ$-uple attack) drops exponentially fast with $ζ$. This allows us to demonstrate that STAKE reaches a ($k,t$)-robust equilibrium, or that rational players do not collude with Byzantine, even with a relatively low $s/\ell$ ratio.

0.12

Vigil: Accountable Liveness against Selective Silence

cs.DC cs.CR ·2026-09-16 ·Jiawei Cheng, Huiping Sun, Rui Zhou, Jinjue Zhou, Zhong Chen
theory similarity 0.55
Abstract · 20 pages, 8 figures

BFT accountability is well understood for safety violations, and recent work attributes global liveness violations; \emph{recipient-selective} silence remains unresolved. A selectively silent adversary withholds messages from some honest nodes while behaving correctly toward others. It can stall consensus yet evade every existing mechanism. We initiate a systematic study of accountability against selective silence. Negatively, a lone attacker silent toward at most $f$ honest nodes is indistinguishable from an honest node, yielding a universal lower bound $K_{\mathrm{SI}} \ge f{+}1$ on the \emph{silence identification threshold}; moreover, any feedback-free repair after a silence-induced violation costs $Θ(n^3)$. Positively, \textsc{Vigil}, a Tendermint variant, matches these bounds with attack-adaptive forwarding, via bitmap cross-attestation, core-based membership, and challenge--response auditing. It pays $O(n)$ authenticators per node when no selective silence occurs (plus $Θ(n^2)$ bitmap metadata bits per node), relays in proportion to the attack's width (sub-threshold silence can force up to $n^3/27$ relays per view, a cost we price exactly), and majority-accuses any node silent toward more than a tunable resilience $τ_A$ of honest peers ($K_{\mathrm{SI}} = τ_A{+}1$, optimal at $τ_A = f$). We also price the residual sub-threshold griefing surface exactly and extend identification to $x$-partial synchrony. Real-network experiments on a three-region WAN, together with a simulator held to exact equality with every closed form, confirm each threshold and cost: at $2\%$ loss, an $f{+}1$ accusation bar falsely accuses $91.2\%$ of honest nodes, while our majority bar accuses $0.002\%$.

0.19

Capital Costs Protect the Network: Mining Gap Dynamics in Proof-of-Work Blockchains Under a Stochastic Mempool

cs.CR ·2026-10-15 ·Hasan Selçuk Kılıç, Nail Akar
similarity 0.54
Abstract · 52 pages, 10 figures

Proof-of-Work blockchains increasingly rely on transaction fees to keep miners engaged as block subsidies decline. An immediate outcome of this is that miners may sit idle at the start of a round until enough high-fee transactions accumulate in order to make mining worthwhile. This idle period is known as the mining gap. We model the high-fee transaction backlog as a Lindley-type recursion under a two-tier fee market and use its stationary distribution to characterize the mining gap. Under Bitcoin's difficulty-adjustment mechanism, the expected gap grows strictly with the hashpower active on the network and consumes the entire round as that hashpower grows without bound. A free-entry condition determines a unique long-run equilibrium hashpower. Capital cost caps the equilibrium hashpower and prevents the mining gap from occupying the entire round. We further characterize how the block subsidy, transaction fees, and operating cost shape the equilibrium hashpower and the mining gap.

0.26