CS Paper Radar

Is Reasoning Always Useful? Rethinking Reasoning Utility in Universal Multimodal Embeddings

Wenxiao Fan, Jingling Fu, Luohang Liu, Xinyuan Shan, Lichen Ma, Yu He, Junshi Huang, Yan Li, Kan Li

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-08-26 10:50 UTC · v1
top venue

Abstract

Reasoning-enhanced universal multimodal embeddings (UME) improve heterogeneous retrieval, but plausible rationales do not necessarily produce discriminative rankings. We study this gap by comparing the discriminative (DISC) and reasoning-driven generative (GEN) branches of UME-R1, a state-of-the-art reasoning UME method. We decompose reasoning utility into positive-target gain, hard-negative gain, and their margin difference. Positive similarity increases for 56.6%, but 15.7% are false-helpful cases where reasoning moves hard negatives closer even more. Local-neighborhood and token-attribution diagnostics suggest why: reasoning often de-condenses retrieved neighborhoods, but utility requires separator-aligned movement, while influential CoT tokens frequently encode evidence shared by positives and hard negatives. Motivated by these diagnostics, we propose SURE (Score-structure Utility Router for Embeddings), which improves UME-R1-7B by 1.5 points and yields consistent gains on two additional embedding models on MMEB-V2, without retraining, label-based policy selection, or extra VLM forward passes.

Comment
EMNLP2026(Findings)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

AntEmbed: Dual-Mode Multimodal Embedding Model for Efficient and Fine-Grained Retrieval

cs.IR ·2026-11-12 ·Kehang Jia, Teng Liu, Juntao Li, Hua Chen, Jinxiong Chang +2 more
similarity 0.78
Abstract · 13 pages

Discriminative embeddings encode original multimodal inputs efficiently but struggle with fine-grained semantics. Generative embeddings use reasoning to capture query intent and relevance evidence, but incur higher computational costs. We propose AntEmbed, a dual-mode multimodal embedding model that supports efficient retrieval and reasoning-enhanced fine-grained matching in a unified embedding space. First, we construct retrieval-oriented reasoning content that captures query intent and confusion-aware semantic evidence. We treat original and reasoning-enhanced candidate inputs as semantically equivalent views, and use multi-positive contrastive learning with a single embedding token to align discriminative and generative embeddings. Second, cross-mode self-distillation transfers fine-grained semantic information from reasoning-enhanced to original representations through candidate similarity-distribution distillation and query representation alignment. This strengthens discriminative embeddings without requiring additional online reasoning. Both retrieval modes share a single candidate index. On MMEB-v2, AntEmbed-8B achieves an overall score of 81.5 with reasoning-enhanced embeddings, outperforming the strongest baseline by 3.1 points.

0.07

UMER: Unifying Embedding and Ranking via Pair-Aware Discriminative Reasoning for Universal Multimodal Retrieval

cs.AI ·2026-08-19 ·Libiao Chen, Xiyang Liu, Yanheng Wei, Tao Wang, Zhenyu Tang
benchmark similarity 0.76
Abstract

Universal multimodal retrieval aims to support diverse instruction-aware retrieval tasks, demanding both efficient corpus-scale matching and fine-grained semantic reasoning. Recent MLLM-based embedding methods typically derive representations from hidden states, while Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning is emerging as a promising strategy for embedding enhancement by encoding intermediate semantic evidence into the representation space. However, existing CoT methods typically use item-wise reasoning over queries and candidates in isolation, providing no explicit evidence to distinguish a positive from a semantically confusable hard negative. Moreover, contrastive embeddings capture global similarity but struggle with meta-tasks requiring answer verification, category judgment or fine-grained reasoning. In this paper, we propose UMER, a Unified Multimodal Embedding and Ranking framework for universal multimodal retrieval. UMER replaces item-wise reflection with Pair-Aware Discriminative Reasoning, which compares query--candidate pairs to identify instruction-relevant matching and discrepancy evidence. UMER jointly learns contrastive embeddings for efficient global matching and discriminative ranking for explicit pairwise relevance judgment within a single MLLM. A complementary mutual distillation strategy further transfers reliable pairwise preferences between the embedding and ranking functions. On the MMEB-V2 benchmark, UMER achieves state-of-the-art performance under comparable experimental settings while supporting budget-adjustable inference.

0.30

Beyond Post-Hoc Rewards: Privileged Reasoning Exploration for Multimodal Embeddings

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-10-23 ·Tianyu Yang, Yijun Tian, Lars Benedikt Kaesberg, Jan Philip Wahle, Bela Gipp +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.75
Abstract

Advances in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have driven substantial progress in multimodal embeddings. Recent methods exploit generative capabilities by augmenting embedded inputs with self-generated reasoning to produce more informative embeddings. However, conventional retrieval supervision for training embedding models specifies pairwise relevance relations without explicitly guiding the reasoning used for input augmentation. Such reasoning is neither directly observed nor uniquely determined by the input, allowing multiple plausible traces to introduce semantic cues of varying retrieval utility. Existing approaches largely optimize reasoning conditioned on the input alone, limiting the exploration of retrieval-relevant traces. We introduce PILOT, a framework that models reasoning as a latent variable and instantiates its prior and posterior distributions as distinct reasoning modes of a shared MLLM. The prior conditions only on the input, whereas the posterior uses additional training-time relational evidence to guide reasoning exploration. To translate the posterior's broader exploration into inference-time improvements, we derive an importance-weighted variational objective and instantiate it as a prior-posterior co-evolution framework that improves both modes under a shared inference-compatible reward while selectively transferring posterior trajectories to the prior according to their utility and prior reachability. On the 78-task MMEB-V2 benchmark, PILOT outperforms the primary baseline across all 12 task groups at both 2B and 7B parameters, improving overall scores by 3.2 and 3.3 points, respectively, with the largest gains in visual-document retrieval (+6.1 and +6.4 points). Our results show that relational supervision is most valuable not as a post-hoc reward but as a signal for shaping how reasoning is explored in training reasoning-enhanced embedding models.

0.13

Reason What Matters: Retrieval-Grounded Reasoning for Universal Multimodal Embeddings

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-09-14 ·Mingzhou Jiang, Peixi Wu, Hang Cheng, Yunhao Zhou, Biao Yang +5 more
similarity 0.74
Abstract

Universal multimodal embedding (UME) maps multimodal inputs into a shared embedding space for diverse retrieval tasks. Recent methods improve embeddings through Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning optimized with GRPO using retrieval rewards. However, existing methods overlook the mismatch bettween candidate-aware retrieval supervision and input-only CoT generation: (1)trajectory-level rewards convey retrieval outcomes without explicitly identifying the input-supported evidence that distinguishes the positive from hard negatives; (2) input-only generation cannot directly assess whether further reasoning improves retrieval, potentially producing redundant CoTs with substantial latency. To bridge this gap, we propose Reason What Matters (ReWAM), a retrieval-grounded framework that aligns candidate-aware supervision with input-only generation. Specifically, we introduce Retrieval-Aware Self-Distillation (RASD), which extracts privileged guidance from input-supported facts and evidence distinguishing the positive from hard negatives. Conditioned on this guidance, an on-policy self-teacher provides token-level feedback to refine credit assignment, directing policy updates toward retrieval-relevant reasoning grounded in the input. We further propose Retrieval-Adaptive Inference (RAI), which learns a retrieval-aware stopping criterion from prefix-level retrieval feedback. It stops redundant reasoning without candidate access and uses speculative decoding to further reduce CoT latency. Extensive experiments on MMEB-V2 and MRMR demonstrate that ReWAM achieves state-of-the-art retrieval performance while delivering up to 5x the inference throughput of competitive explicit-CoT UME methods. ReWAM thus enables high-quality retrieval through efficient input-only reasoning, making explicit CoT practical for corpus-scale multimodal retrieval. The code will be publicly available.

0.16

Can Linguistic Reasoning Vectors Enhance Multimodal Reasoning Ability?

cs.AI ·2026-09-25 ·Ziyi Wang, Li Li, Aolin Zhou, Yankun Shen, Chonghan Liu +2 more
top venue similarity 0.72
Abstract · Accepted at NeurIPS 2026

Most Vision-Language Models (VLMs) are built by extending pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) with visual modules and multimodal alignment. However, this multimodal scaling often degrades the language-side reasoning ability originally encoded in the base LLM. While the base LLM retains usable reasoning after scaling, the aligned VLM itself cannot reliably access this ability. Therefore, recovering the degraded reasoning capability in VLMs would benefit more from seeking help from the base LLM than from the VLM alone. Motivated by this, we propose LIFT (Language-side reasonIng Facilitation and Transfer), a lightweight vector-intervention method that transfers reasoning capability from the base LLM to the VLM without retraining the backbone. LIFT defines Reasoning Vectors as answer-token hidden-state differences between a Reasoner path with an explicit reasoning trace and a Solver path without it, and injects these vectors into language-side activations of the target VLM. LIFT further supports learnable vector adaptation while keeping the VLM backbone frozen. We evaluate LIFT on two VLMs across six reasoning benchmarks, comparing Reasoning Vectors extracted from the base LLM and from the aligned VLM under matched protocols. Results show that LLM-derived vectors consistently outperform VLM-derived vectors, confirming that the base LLM is a more effective source for recovering reasoning. LIFT partially recovers degraded reasoning through lightweight language-side interventions. Further analyses show that Reasoning Vectors influence intermediate reasoning behavior rather than merely altering final answers. The source code will be released soon.

0.56

VaME: Exploring Variational Latent Reasoning for Multimodal Embeddings

cs.CV ·2026-09-27 ·Peixi Wu, Mingzhou Jiang, Feipeng Ma, Biao Yang, Yunhao Zhou +9 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.71
Abstract

Universal multimodal retrieval requires compact embeddings that preserve task-relevant semantic information across diverse modalities. Prior works have incorporated latent reasoning into multimodal embedding learning to refine this information before embedding extraction. However, most existing approaches remain confined to deterministic latent paths, without exploring alternative trajectories to discover better embeddings. Thus, we propose VaME (Variational Multimodal Embeddings), a framework that models latent reasoning as a learnable distribution over trajectories. Specifically, we first introduce Variational Latent Reasoning (VLR) to enable autoregressive exploration in latent space, guided by answer reconstruction through a lightweight decoder. Meanwhile, we augment the original embedding-token readout with a latent-fused embedding to facilitate exploration during subsequent reinforcement learning. Finally, we optimize latent reasoning over stochastic variational trajectories through reinforcement learning, using Semantic Decoding Reward (SDR) to favor semantically meaningful trajectories with interpretable decoded outcomes. On the 78-task MMEB-V2 benchmark, spanning image, video, and visual-document retrieval, VaME outperforms most explicit CoT-based models and all latent-reasoning baselines. VaME also demonstrates robust performance on reasoning-intensive benchmarks such as MRMR, with substantial gains after reinforcement learning. Importantly, VaME achieves these gains with at least a 4.25x inference speedup over the deterministic latent autoregressive baselines. The code will be made publicly available.

0.21

CORE: Improving Compositional Reasoning in MLLM Embedding via Reranker Distillation

cs.CV cs.AIcs.CLcs.IR ·2026-09-03 ·Tingyu Song, Mingxin Li, Yanzhao Zhang, Dingkun Long, Chu Liu +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract

MLLM-based embedding models remain limited in compositional retrieval, often failing to distinguish scenes containing the same concepts but different attribute-object bindings. Yet the same backbone can resolve such distinctions when used as a cross-attentive reranker, motivating us to distill its compositional judgments into the embedding model. We propose CORE, which synthesizes candidate lists spanning five compositional matching levels and introduces a Rank-KL objective that trains the embedding model to reproduce the reranker's fine-grained ranking. We further introduce a graded evaluation protocol and compare contrastive learning, pairwise CoSENT, and listwise Rank-KL under the same data and tuning budget. Our comparison shows that both CoSENT and Rank-KL use the multi-level supervision more effectively than contrastive learning, with Rank-KL achieving the strongest overall performance. Across three compositional reasoning benchmarks (COLA, SUGARCREPE++, NEGBENCH), CORE-RERANKER-8B achieves an 82.7% total average, outperforming Jina-Reranker by 10.7 points, while CORE-EMBED-8B achieves the best total average (0.666) among all evaluated embedding models. The improvements transfer to the MCMR benchmark without sacrificing retrieval performance on COCO and Flickr30K.

0.37

CrossModalQA: A Cross-modal and Multi-hop Benchmark for Multimodal Retrieval-augmented Generation

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-08-31 ·Jiacheng Cai, Zijin Hong, Zheng Yuan, Huachi Zhou, Qinggang Zhang +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract · 20 pages, 7 figures

Despite the strong capabilities of multimodal large language models (MLLMs), their parametric knowledge remains incomplete and difficult to update, motivating multimodal retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) to ground responses in external text and images. However, existing benchmarks face two major limitations: (i) they typically emphasize single-hop retrieval or reasoning over a small set of provided contexts rather than open-domain evidence discovery; and (ii) they provide fragmented coverage of cross-modal reasoning paths, leaving complex multi-hop and multi-image reasoning underexplored. In this paper, we introduce CrossModalQA, an open-domain benchmark for evaluating multimodal retrieval and reasoning over heterogeneous corpora. CrossModalQA contains 1,863 question-answer pairs constructed from 4,987 Wikipedia articles and 4,431 Wikimedia Commons images. It covers five complementary reasoning paths: vision-to-text, text-to-vision, vision-to-text-to-vision, multi-image intersection, and image-set reasoning. Every question requires retrieving and composing distributed textual and visual evidence, with an average reasoning depth of 3.50 hops. We construct the benchmark through multimodal knowledge graph-guided subgraph sampling and apply rule-based consistency checking and LLM verification to ensure multimodal dependence and traceable evidence. Extensive experiments demonstrate that existing multimodal RAG systems struggle to recover complete evidence chains and can underperform closed-book models when incomplete retrieval introduces distracting context. Further analysis reveals that complete cross-modal retrieval contributes more to answer accuracy than generator scaling, while multi-image retrieval and reasoning remain the primary bottlenecks limiting end-to-end performance.

0.16