CS Paper Radar

Not All Synthetic Data Are Equal: Expert-Committee Audit Screening for Imbalanced Crash-Injury-Severity Prediction in Automated Driving Systems

Zewei Li, Qiaoqiao Ren, Hang Yang, S. C. Wong, Stergios-Aristoteles Mitoulis, Yun Ye

cs.LG ·submitted 2026-08-30 22:22 UTC · v1

Abstract

Automated driving systems (ADSs) are increasingly operating on public roads, raising safety concerns, yet reliable prediction of crash injury severity remains difficult because crash reports are limited, severe outcomes are rare, and injury classes are highly imbalanced. Existing augmentation methods mainly increase minority-class sample size but rarely assess whether generated samples are credible for safety-critical prediction. This study proposes Expert-Committee Audit Screening (ECAS), a credibility-aware sample acceptance framework for ADS crash injury severity prediction under data imbalance. Using 1,477 incident-level ADS crashes from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Standing General Order records, ECAS audits generated minority samples through a real-data-only expert committee based on label support, boundary separation, committee agreement, and local plausibility. Within-class percentile normalization and Pareto non-dominated sorting select accepted samples without manually assigned evidence weights. With a fixed backbone combining normalizing flow augmentation and a Tabular Prior-data Fitted Network (TabPFN) classifier, the best ECAS configuration achieved the highest balanced accuracy, macro-F1, and minor-injury recall among all evidence configurations. Local neighborhood analysis showed that ECAS-accepted samples were better supported by nearby real minority crashes than unscreened retained samples. Shapley additive explanations and partial dependence plots further indicated that lower injury severity classes were mainly associated with crash counterpart and pre-crash movement, whereas moderate-plus injuries were more sensitive to posted speed limit and operating context. These findings support a shift from quantity-oriented augmentation to credibility-aware sample acceptance for ADS safety prediction and risk governance.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Toward Auditable and Calibrated AI for Dementia-Related Crash Severity Prediction: A Selective Deferral Framework to Support Human Review

cs.AI cs.HC ·2026-09-19 ·Gaurab Chhetri, Anika Baitullah, Subasish Das
similarity 0.68
Abstract · This is the author's preprint version of a paper accepted for presentation at HICSS 60 (Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences),…

Public crash databases increasingly support automated safety analysis, but crash severity prediction remains difficult to translate into public-sector decision workflows when models are evaluated primarily as ordinary classifiers. This study reframes dementia-related crash severity modeling as a decision-aware triage problem in which a system must classify crashes into no-injury/property-damage-only (O), minor or moderate injury (BC), and fatal or severe injury (KA), while also controlling outcome leakage, reporting severe under-triage, calibrating confidence, and preserving every raw prediction for audit. Using 4,781 Texas crash records with structured fields and police narratives, we evaluate structured, narrative, fusion, calibrated fusion, BERT-family, and local large-language-model baselines under a stratified 70/15/15 split. In the reported split, leakage-controlled Gemma obtains the highest observed macro-F1 (0.545; 95% bootstrap CI [0.507, 0.583]). The best calibrated fusion model obtains macro-F1 of 0.522 and expected calibration error of 0.033. Selective deferral improves performance among cases retained for automatic classification. At 70% coverage, macro-F1 rises to 0.573 and severity cost falls to 0.577, while deferred cases are treated as candidates for a proposed human-review process and are not further evaluated in the present experiment. The study contributes a reproducible, leakage-controlled, and uncertainty-aware evaluation framework for crash AI systems, emphasizing auditability and selective deferral rather than accuracy alone.

0.27

CHOIR: heterogeneity-aware conformal prediction for crash injury severity across driver safety strata

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-09-10 ·Amir Rafe, Subasish Das
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Transportation agencies increasingly predict crash-injury severity with statistical and machine-learning models, but these models do not state how often their output contains the recorded injury level or for which groups of drivers it fails, a gap that matters most for motorcyclists and unrestrained drivers. This study develops and evaluates a certification layer that gives any fitted severity model a finite-sample, distribution-free coverage guarantee within prespecified safety strata. The layer, CHOIR (Conformal Heterogeneity-aware Ordinal Inference with Risk control), combines groupwise and weighted conformal prediction with conformal risk control to return contiguous KABCO intervals, and adds a declared sensitivity analysis for medically assessed injury and bounds on fatal omission. It is evaluated on 4.04 million Texas crashes from 2017-2023, one sampled driver per crash, with seven base models from the ordered logit to a tabular foundation model, and on held-out counties and later years. Under one pooled threshold every model reaches 0.90 coverage overall but covers motorcyclists or unrestrained drivers at 0.868 or lower, and class-balanced gradient boosting covers unrestrained drivers at only 0.374. Calibration within four safety strata places all 28 model-by-stratum estimates between 0.898 and 0.907, at the cost of sets spanning 3.6 to 4.6 of five categories for these groups, and the certified ordered logit is within 0.03 categories of the narrowest model. Injury-model coverage should therefore be certified within safety groups rather than on average, calibration rather than model complexity determines validity, and a statewide threshold should not be applied to small rural counties without local calibration data.

0.23

Where ADS Crashes Differ: A Harmonized Comparison Against Human Baselines

cs.CY ·2026-10-30 ·Doyeon Jang
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Crash-rate comparisons between automated driving systems (ADS) and human drivers require an exposure denominator that only a few operators publish. We instead ask a composition question: given a crash, does the mix of crash types differ between ADS and human-driven vehicles? The question needs no mileage and can therefore cover every ADS operator. We assemble the NHTSA Standing General Order (SGO) ADS incident files across both file generations into 2,450 distinct in-scope incidents (2021-2026), of which 828 fall within the 2021-2024 window covered by the Crash Report Sampling System (CRSS), the national police-reported human comparator. A schema-constrained large language model (LLM) codes each SGO narrative into the CRSS crash-type taxonomy. Because SGO compels reporting far below the police-reporting threshold, we bracket reportability with an objective severity floor and a reasonable-person rubric, and claim a difference only where it survives both. Two composition differences hold under every reportability definition, tow definition and weighting of the human side, and under both definitions of driverless operation: turn-across-path crashes are under-represented among ADS crashes (0.23-0.46x the CRSS share under the primary driverless definition) and so are single-vehicle crashes (0.19-0.56x). In severity-floor rear-end crashes the ADS vehicle is the striking party at a quasi-induced-exposure ratio of 0.121 (95% CI [0.05, 0.23]) against a human baseline of 1.000. If the ADS vehicle is also struck more often than its exposure implies, this ratio overstates the ADS-human difference. We also document three pitfalls in the federal data: an operator-specific coding of driverless operation, a tow-away criterion confounded by fleet recovery practice, and an occupancy confound that accounts for about 42% of the apparent ADS-human severity gap.

0.31

LLM Ensemble Fault Classification for Automotive HiL Validation

cs.SE ·2026-08-11 ·Hamza Ouarrad, Mohammad Abboush, Andreas Rausch
top venue similarity 0.61
Abstract · 8 pages, 3 figures. Accepted at the 23rd Workshop on Model Driven Engineering, Verification and Validation (MoDeVVa 2026), co-located with M…

Automotive HiL validation generates large multivariate test recordings whose analysis remains challenging due to manual review effort, rule-based limitations, and the need for explainable diagnostic decisions. Recent machine-learning and deep-learning approaches have improved fault diagnosis, but they often require large labelled datasets, generalise poorly across operating conditions, and provide limited insight into their predictions. This paper proposes an explainable multi-LLM ensemble framework for sensor-level fault classification in automotive validation. The framework uses compact evidence representations of fault-injection recordings and combines the outputs of heterogeneous large language models to improve diagnostic robustness, ranking quality, confidence reliability, and interpretability. The approach is evaluated on gasoline-engine and electric-vehicle HiL systems across three driving settings and ten single-fault classes. Among the individual models, Mistral Small~24B provides the strongest overall single-model trade-off, achieving 0.903 Top-1 accuracy, 0.887 MCC, and the lowest Brier score of 0.102. The final Top-3 ensemble combines Mistral Small~24B, Qwen2.5~32B, and Phi-4~14B using confidence-weighted voting, improving the scenario-averaged results to 0.917 Top-1 accuracy, 0.913 macro F1, and 0.902 MCC, while also providing the best calibration among the tested ensemble strategies. A Top-5 ensemble does not improve over the Top-3 configuration, indicating that model complementarity is more important than ensemble size. The results show that coordinated multi-LLM reasoning can support robust, calibrated, and engineer-interpretable fault classification for automotive HiL validation.

0.35

Adapting a Large Language Model Crash-Severity Pipeline to Tennessee: Performance Across Sampling Strategies

cs.CE ·2026-09-24 ·Abhilasha Saroj, Pranav Govindu, Bharat Sharma, Usman Ahmed
similarity 0.60
Abstract

State crash databases differ in structure, coding, and injury-severity distributions, limiting direct reuse of predictive workflows across jurisdictions. This study adapts the SafeTraffic Copilot large language model (LLM) crash-severity workflow to a three-year Tennessee inventory of 624,392 crashes. Tennessee crash, roadway, vehicle, and person attributes were harmonized and converted into textual prompts while unavailable values were preserved rather than inferred. Llama 3.1 8B was fine-tuned using low-rank adaptation to classify five injury-severity categories. Random, county-based, and severity-balanced sampling strategies were evaluated using separate in-sample and unseen-test experiments; unseen-test experiments used 70/15/15 training, validation, and test splits. On their respective unseen test sets, random and county-based models achieved weighted F1-scores near 80%, but macro F1 remained below 47% and fatal-crash F1 below 27%, showing that strong aggregate performance can mask weak recognition of rare outcomes. Within its balanced evaluation population, the severity-balanced model achieved weighted and macro F1-scores of 57.7% and a fatalcrash F1-score of 65.9%, yielding more even class-level performance. Because each sampling strategy used a different test subset, crossstrategy differences are descriptive rather than controlled rankings. The results highlight the importance of interpreting LLM crashseverity performance together with sampling design, class balance, class-level metrics, and evaluation-population composition.

0.31

AISA: AI Safety Assistant Framework for Continuous Improvement of Highway Construction

cs.CL ·2026-08-17 ·Mason Smetana, Trevor Neece, Lev Khazanovich
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 17 pages, 5 figures

Job Safety Analysis (JSA) and pre-task planning can benefit from prior incident records, yet historical accident data is often stored as unstructured narratives that are difficult to consult at the point of planning. A novel framework centered on large language models (LLMs) for highway construction safety reporting and planning is proposed as a foundation for future agentic applications, prioritizing deterministic, local inferencing. The first aim is to enable classification and quality scoring of incident narratives for existing and future reporting purposes. The second is to evaluate retrieval of relevant historical accidents, related imagery, and trusted industry documents for incorporation into daily safety plans. Neural probes were trained to classify incidents along four multiclass and two binary Occupational Injury and Illness Classification System (OIICS) fields and to derive an overall quality score, evaluated on a test set of over 15,000 narratives and a held-out set of 100 author-labeled records, benchmarked against a majority-vote LLM ensemble. The retrieval of historical accidents, reference imagery, and industry documents was benchmarked across embedding models using standard information retrieval metrics. OIICS classification reached 75% held-out accuracy, though the two binary flags were degenerate. The quality score, while meaningful on one database, was distorted on out-of-distribution fatalities in the held-out dataset. Accident retrieval recovered relevant incidents far above chance, performing best on lexically distinct construction activities. On document question answering, an open-weight decoder embedding model surpassed proprietary models. Overall, this work provides a new framework rooted in local inferencing and text embedding models for future agentic applications, with emphasis on bridging external data to JSA reports.

0.28

Incident-Data Robustness Analysis of the OWASP Top 10 for LLM Applications (2026): How a Community-Expert Ranking Holds Up Against a Large-Scale LLM Incident Corpus

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-08-18 ·Kyriakos "Rock" Lambros, Steve Wilson
code/data similarity 0.59
Abstract · 26 pages, 19 figures. Exploratory incident-data analysis by two members of the OWASP GenAI Security Project Top 10 for LLM Applications work…

The OWASP Top 10 for LLM Applications ranks the risks that a community of security practitioners judges most important. We ask a narrower question: checked against the record of real incidents, does that expert ranking agree with the data? We assembled a large-scale corpus of LLM-security incidents (7,714 snapshotted and 6,639 labeled against the 20-entry taxonomy) drawn from CVE, GHSA, OSV, and AIAAIC, and derived an incident-based ranking with a Bayesian measurement-error model that corrects each category's count for classifier precision and recall. The 2026 candidate list blends the two signals at fixed weights, 0.75 on the expert vote and 0.25 on the data, so the corpus corrects the consensus without overturning it. The agreement between the two rankings is weak: Cohen's $κ\approx 0.20$, with a 90% interval that crosses zero. The expert ranking is nonetheless robust. A pre-registered bake-off of four frontier classifiers returns no winner. None beats the incidence floor's balanced accuracy of 0.863. A ground-truth check leaves the floor's ordering (Spearman $ρ= 0.918$ against held-out truth) in place. This is an exploratory analysis by two working-group members, not the official OWASP release, and it does not supersede the official list or process.

0.52

Estimating Uncoded Crash Factors with Tabular Foundation and System One Models: Kumo Tabular and Jev

cs.LG stat.APstat.ME ·2026-10-07 ·Amir Rafe, Subasish Das
code/data similarity 0.59
Abstract · 26 pages, 9 figures, 8 tables. Code: https://github.com/pozapas/kumo-jev-crash-records

Road safety programs count the coded fields of police crash records, while the officer's narrative, which often records factors the fields omit, is rarely read. A safety office thus cannot tell how much its counts miss or where to review. This study develops and evaluates a system that joins both views of the 5,601,890 Texas crashes from 2017 to 2025 into population estimates with stated validity. An in-context tabular foundation model, Kumo Tabular, reads the coded record of every crash, a calibrated System One model, Jev, reads the narratives of two probability samples, and human judgments recalibrate its probabilities. A multiwave predict-then-debias estimator joins the three tiers, and a second human tier drawn with recorded probabilities checks the estimates by design. For hydroplaning, medical episodes, fatigue, animals, and phone use, the narrative documents more injury crashes than the coded field, 15,074 against 7,340 for phone use, and the human check agrees with all fifteen estimates within its margin. A re-read list ranked by Kumo Tabular finds confirmed discordance 7 to 58 times as often as random reading. At the planning cost of human coding, one further round of human judgments would cut the root mean square relative half-width from 22.0 to 16.2 percent, against 21.2 for reading every narrative. Two calibrated readers of different views, joined by a sampling design, give a safety office counts, a discordance map, a validated re-read list, and a reading budget, with Kumo Tabular reading the table at 15 times the speed of TabPFN 3.5.

0.32