CS Paper Radar

Between the Commits: Process, Error, and Claim Reliability in a Wholly AI-Authored Codebase

Douglas Leith

cs.SE cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-24 12:59 UTC · v1
dataset

Abstract

We present: (i) a new dataset consisting of the full development history of a 21,000-line Python tool built entirely by Claude AI, with no human-authored code or tests, (ii) two code-provenance tracing tools, (iii) three taxonomies for instruction intent, commit provenance, and response reliability, (iv) application of these to analyse the dataset. We find that: (i) user coding agent CLI instructions differ in kind from IDE-chat instructions, with a greater focus on comprehension, planning and consultation, (ii) code development is mainly proactive, (iii) 14.3% of AI code-generation events contain a real error later caught by the AI-authored test suite, (iv) roughly 1 in 4-5 of the AI's interactive responses contains one or more factual errors.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

How Researchers Use and Verify AI Coding Assistants: Tasks and Validation Practices in Scientific Programming

cs.SE cs.HC ·2026-09-18 ·Gabrielle O'Brien, Reed Milewicz, Nasir Eisty
survey similarity 0.72
Abstract

Generative AI has entered research programming, yet there is little evidence about which tasks researchers hand to it or how they decide whether its code is correct. We draw on 527 free-text responses to a 2025 survey of researchers who write code, most of them at U.S. universities. In each response, a researcher recounts a single task from their own work, the way they used an AI tool for it, and what they did to assess the result. We coded the task and the evaluation strategies reported, and related both to programming experience, research area, and confidence ratings. Use was concentrated in five tasks: data handling, visualization, debugging, mathematical/scientific computing, and statistical analysis. Evaluation was informal and individual. Over half of accounts described running the generated code, while automated tests and review by another person were rare. Use cases and evaluation strategies varied little with programming experience, but confidence did: Less experienced programmers trusted the AI more than themselves, and experienced programmers the reverse. Evaluation confidence was not associated with the strategies reported. Its strongest correlates were confidence in the tool and in oneself. Validating AI contributions to scientific code rested largely on individual judgment, outside shared infrastructure for testing or review. Interfaces could support task-appropriate evaluation rather than leave it to the user.

0.20

What is the Difference Between Me and You? Benchmarking the Quality Gap Between Human-Written and AI-Generated Code

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-09-11 ·Cristina Improta, Pietro Liguori, Domenico Cotroneo
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.68
Abstract · Preprint. This manuscript is currently under peer review

AI coding assistants are becoming co-authors of production software, yet their evaluation centers on functional correctness, leaving open whether their code differs from human code in the quality dimensions dominating lifecycle cost. We compare human-written and AI-generated code at scale: 787,562 function pairs across Python, Java, and C, each human function mined from open-source repositories paired with implementations generated from its docstring by three AI assistants (OpenAI GPT models, DeepSeek-Coder, Qwen2.5-Coder). We characterize structural complexity and statistical naturalness, and map static-analysis findings onto Orthogonal Defect Classification for defects and the Common Weakness Enumeration for vulnerabilities, making authors and languages directly comparable. AI-generated code is structurally compressed and stylistically templated: roughly half the size and branching of human code, clustering apart at the style level. Defect profiles differ in kind: human code concentrates issues of mature codebases, AI code repetitive boilerplate; security is language-dependent, with LLMs producing more, and more severe, findings in Python and Java but fewer high-severity memory-safety findings than humans in C. Once size is controlled for, complexity metrics carry little signal, while naturalness separates authors. Finally, we release CQBench, a benchmark of 27,346 issue-prone tasks with baselines and an evaluation pipeline for quality assurance and security testing.

0.55

Executable Code Knowledge: Code as a Native, Validation-Carrying Knowledge Representation for AI Coding Agents

cs.CL ·2026-08-17 ·Xueping Gao
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 11 pages. Submitted to AgenticDev 2026, co-located with ASE 2026

AI coding agents need more than relevant snippets: they need business semantics, validation evidence, relations, and assurance that their context is current. Existing systems usually infer or externalize this knowledge through retrieval, summaries, graphs, rules, or reverse specifications. We investigate a complementary representation in which selected code units directly carry agent-usable knowledge. We introduce Executable Code Knowledge (ECK) and define an Executable Code Knowledge Unit (ECKU) as a source-bound object combining stable identity, semantics, executable behavior, contracts, evidence, relations, provenance, validation state, and a query interface. Our Python prototype supports code-local authoring, manifest export, evidence execution, exact changed-line impact, freshness checking, and agent-facing projections. Across three real Python repositories and 26 controlled patch tasks, direct ECK provides executable test coverage for 11/11 evidence-bearing tasks and exact selectors for 9/11; hiding declared evidence reduces exact recovery to 1/11 (paired exact McNemar p=0.0078). ECK-derived rules recover 11/11 exact selectors, showing that rules are effective delivery artifacts while ECK supplies source binding, validation state, impact, and freshness. Exact changed-line impact matches independently authored labels on all 26 patches (12 unit links; precision, recall, and F1 all 1.000). AST-bounded fingerprints classify 50 positive changes and 17 unrelated same-file controls correctly, whereas static rules snapshots detect none of the 50 stale cases. Model-backed patch-review and cross-layer studies measure projection fidelity rather than independent impact discovery. These results support a hybrid architecture: retrieval for coverage, ECK for source and evidence governance, and projections for delivery.

0.53

The Role of Agentic Instruction Categories for Code Generation: A Study of Five Python Libraries

cs.SE ·2026-10-15 ·Warren Gerald Polandra, Yoshiki Higo, Raula Gaikovina Kula
published similarity 0.68
Abstract · Accepted to APSEC 2026 Technical Track

Agentic coding systems increasingly rely on repository-level agent files, such as AGENTS.md, to communicate project knowledge and developer intent. However, it remains unclear which categories of agent instructions enable efficient agent-file generation and accurate code generation. We evaluate five instruction categories: Repository Overview, Function Description, Implementation Detail, Testing, and Reconstruction Steps, across all 31 non-empty combinations using two Large Language Models (LLMs), Gemma 4 and GPT-5.4, and five human-written Python libraries. Our study addresses two research questions, comprising five sub-questions, on agent file generation and code generation. Results show that the number of instructions alone does not determine token usage for agent-file generation, with substantial variation across models and libraries. Although most AI-generated libraries compiled successfully regardless of the instruction combination, functional correctness remained limited. No Gemma 4 variant passed all tests, whereas 12.99% of GPT-5.4 variants did. Function Description achieved Gemma 4's highest partial-pass rate, while Reconstruction Steps achieved GPT-5.4's highest full-pass rate. For structural similarity to human-written code, Reconstruction Steps was most frequently associated with libraries closest to the originals in Lines of File and total Cyclomatic Complexity, while Testing and Reconstruction Steps were jointly most frequent for File Count and Function Count.

0.24

PR4Code: A Pull Requests Dataset for AI Code Generation

cs.SE ·2026-10-29 ·Benedetta Donato, Leonardo Mariani, Daniela Micucci, Oliviero Riganelli
publisheddataset similarity 0.68
Abstract · Published in IEEE Access

AI-driven code generation is evolving from handling small, localized code-completion tasks toward supporting the implementation of full software features. To support this transition, this paper introduces PR4Code, a dataset of 4,508 Java and 8,831 Python curated Pull Requests (PRs) collected from GitHub, each enriched with metadata, commit histories, and detailed code changes. Unlike resources focused on isolated code fragments, PR4Code captures the feature implementation process, delivering a large and diverse collection of real-world development tasks that can be used to assess AI-driven solutions. Our analysis reveals substantial variability in PR structure, commit granularity, and textual content. In addition, we release scripts to regenerate and update the dataset, ensuring reproducibility and maintainability.

0.63

Plans They Abandon, Reports They Author: The Narrative Layer of Autonomous Agents

cs.HC ·2026-09-10 ·Obada Kraishan, Kulsawasd Jitkajornwanich
highly cited similarity 0.68
Abstract · 14 pages, 4 figures. Under review

When a coding agent finishes a task, the developer reviews a summary the agent wrote about itself, not a display someone designed. We ask how much of the agent's work that summary carries, and whether it drifts toward the plan the agent stated when execution departed from it. Across 5,851 real developer sessions and 355,942 tool calls, a self-report referred to about one action in eleven, and a reader working from the report alone recovered roughly a fifth of the action log. Neither figure depended on whether the session later needed human correction. Reports did not generally resemble the stated plan more than the executed one, but they did so increasingly as execution diverged from the plan. We hand-validate both measurement steps that use a language model, report the one that failed alongside the one that passed, and draw conclusions only from measures that survived.

0.40

Practical Implementation Report on Introducing Spec-Driven Development Using AI Agents in Software Development PBL

cs.SE ·2026-08-31 ·Hidetake Tanaka, Hiroshi Igaki, Kazumasa Shimari, Kiyoshi Honda, Naoki Fukuyasu
published similarity 0.68
Abstract · Accepted for publication in the 38th International Conference on Software Engineering Education and Training (CSEE&T 2026) : 18 pages, 1 tab…

In recent years, autonomous AI agents such as GitHub Copilot and Claude Code have been rapidly gaining popularity. This study reports on the practical implementation of Spec-Driven Development, a software development methodology premised on AI agents, within a Software Development Project-Based Learning (SDPBL) course for third-year undergraduate students. We defined a workflow consisting of four phases, namely investigation, planning, implementation, and review. We also established an environment tailored for the SDPBL course where AI agents generate documentation and code during each phase. We analyzed the results from three perspectives, namely students' subjective AI usage, implementation throughput, and code comprehension. The analysis reveals that AI usage patterns varied across development phases and teams. Moreover, while AI agent utilization increased implementation throughput, it also tended to encourage students to proceed with development without fully understanding the code. This study demonstrates that regular verification of code comprehension by instructors and appropriate feedback are essential for maintaining educational effectiveness when introducing SDD into SDPBL.

0.59

What Open-Source Projects Tell Their Coding Agents: A Census of AGENTS.md and CLAUDE.md

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-10-22 ·Pawel Zarzycki
similarity 0.67
Abstract · Corrected abstract metadata formatting and restored missing numerical values; paper unchanged

Coding agents can be guided with instruction files in a repository. We examine this emerging practice through a census of 22,854 popular, active GitHub repositories in thirteen languages, treating each repository's root 'AGENTS$.$md' and 'CLAUDE$.$md' as one instruction set. Agent instructions appear in 26.3% of repositories and 59.6% of the most-starred; where both files exist, 'CLAUDE$.$md' usually points to 'AGENTS$.$md'. We analyse 341,852 statements using model-assisted annotation and human review. The annotations reveal a practical mix of project knowledge and rules about code, building and workflow. Collaboration rules name concrete requirements, from test plans to commit formats, yet 74.0% of directives give no reason. Projects disagree on AI attribution: commit-message rules more often prohibit it than require it, while pull-request rules more often require disclosure. A third of instruction sets have a generator-associated signature, a tool-inserted block, shared text or an AI-marked creation commit; four in five are edited after creation. Prespecified tests associate repository popularity with rules on pull requests and AI contributions. Exploratory analyses link activity to process-oriented content and show that LLM and agent projects are over-represented among adopters. The models agree much more closely with each other than with the human reviewer's topic assignments, a caution for automated annotation. We release the annotations, taxonomies and pointers to the analysed file versions.

0.42