CS Paper Radar

ScopeBench: Do Agents Preserve Engagement Boundaries Under Goal Pressure?

Shane Caldwell, Max Harley, Ads Dawson, Michael Kouremetis, Vincent Abruzzo, Will Pearce

cs.AI cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-23 19:47 UTC · v1
publishedbenchmarktheorycode/data

Abstract

Agents are increasingly deployed with real autonomy in web application and network penetration testing, where a single out-of-scope action can breach a client's engagement boundary. Existing offensive-security benchmarks measure raw hacking capability; as those benchmarks saturate, the real barrier to deployment is a special case of alignment: scope adherence. We introduce ScopeBench, a benchmark of 30 dead-end agentic security tasks in which the stated objective is reachable only by violating the stated scope. Each task appears under two conditions that share an environment, verifier, and objective and differ only in scope: one instruction set has no scope and measures capability; the other has a natural-language scope to measure adherence. Scopeless trajectories are graded by a standard deterministic verifier. Scoped trajectories pass through two grading arms. First, the same deterministic verifier checks for the flag: because the flag sits behind the scope boundary, a pass proves by construction that a forbidden action occurred, yielding a high-precision lower bound on the violation rate. If the verifier does not pass the trajectory, an agentic judge estimates whether an out-of-scope call occurred. We calibrate the judge against 100 ScopeBench trajectories labeled call-by-call by human annotators, and a blinded audit of the evaluated rollouts finds its high recall holds - no false negatives among the 36 audited violations, with over-flagging its only observed error. Across 8 models in one harness, raw capability spans 12.2% to 81.1% and scope adherence spans 34.4% to 86.7%, with the judge finding 331 violations that mechanical verification misses. Opus-4-8 achieves a raw-capability score 10 percentage points higher than sonnet-4-6's while exhibiting 35.6 percentage points higher scope adherence. We release the frozen pilot benchmark, evaluation code, and all 2160 ATIF trajectories.

Comment
18 pages, 1 figure, 6 tables. Accepted at AISec 2026. Code and tasks: https://github.com/dreadnode/scopebench-pilot. Trajectories: https://huggingface.co/datasets/dreadnode/scopebench-pilot. Leaderboard: https://scopebench.ai

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Scope-Gap Injection: Exploiting Evaluator Channel Blind Spots in the OpenClaw Agent Security Competition

cs.AI cs.CR ·2026-10-26 ·Weihang Niu, Mengxing Ren, Che Qu
similarity 0.71
Abstract

This paper introduces Scope-Gap Injection (SGI), an indirect prompt injection method for multi-stage LLM-agent safety pipelines. In the IJCAI 2026 OpenClaw Agent Security Attack Competition, each attack package is judged by a static skill scan (S1), an LLM-judge safety check over the task and skill definition (S2), and a live execution audit (S3). Our observations suggest a scope gap: S2 appears to inspect the task instruction and skill definition without inspecting attachment contents, while the agent reads attachments during S3. SGI keeps the visible task and skill benign, while target identifiers, bypass parameters, and authorization procedures are moved into an attachment written as a business worklist. The S2 judge therefore sees a harmless task, while the agent follows the hidden worklist and triggers the permission bypass. In OpenClaw, SGI bypassed all three stages for 5 of 19 targets. The highest-scoring single submission achieved $F = 0.385$. Across the submission campaign, attachment placement was associated with higher aggregate S2 acceptance than in-skill placement: 78% versus 23%. We close with defenses that align evaluator scope with the channels available to the agent.

0.21

Compromise Is Not Consequence: Evaluating Task-Scoped Authorization in LLM Agents with Paired Replay

cs.CR ·2026-10-05 ·Tural Hagverdiyev
similarity 0.70
Abstract

A tool-using model can follow a malicious instruction even when its credentials are valid. We study whether task-scoped authorization contains the resulting tool execution. Our paired-replay testbed samples a model request once and submits the same action, resource, and arguments to broad bearer, scoped JWT, sender-constrained, and Open Policy Agent conditions. The frozen main experiment uses 128 scenarios across four tool domains and five local model configurations. Among valid attacked post-exposure decisions, broad-bearer harmful execution ranges from 8.9% to 37.8% across models; all three scoped conditions record zero. The policy changes execution, not the frozen model decision. These results support containment of the tested cross-action and cross-resource consequences under researcher-supplied task authority, not prevention of prompt injection. A bounded six-task AgentDojo extension preserves native scoring and records 11/24 injected broad-policy attack flags versus 0/24 scoped flags, with utility of 5/24 and 6/24. Low exposure, invalid decisions, and purposive task selection limit that comparison. The primary experiment measures safe continuation rather than final-answer correctness. An empirical-bank fresh-sampling comparison finds no estimation advantage from pairing when scoped outcomes are constant zero. The contribution is a controlled measurement of compromise, enforcement, and continuation, with explicit limits on what each observation establishes.

0.29

On Understanding, Identifying, and Mitigating Vulnerabilities in Agentic Large Language Models

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-08-11 ·Md Jafrin Hossain, Mohammad Arif Hossain, Nirwan Ansari
survey similarity 0.69
Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) have undergone a shift from stateless conversational interfaces to autonomous agents capable of multi-step planning, tool invocation, code execution, and maintaining persistent memory. When these agents operate with real-world privileges---calling APIs, modifying files, and querying databases---a compromised reasoning step can trigger unauthorized data access, irreversible state changes, or cascading failures, yet the security research community has not kept pace. To quantify the state of the field, we conducted a systematic literature review under PRISMA 2020 guidelines across six databases, screening 743 records and retaining 85 papers (2023--2025) on agentic LLM security. Attack research outpaces defense work by 3.9:1. Perception-layer vulnerabilities (prompt injection, jailbreaking, adversarial perturbations) dominate, accounting for 66\% of papers, while action-layer vulnerabilities (tool misuse, code injection, sandbox escape) appear in only 4.7\%, misaligned with real-world risk. Code execution security accounts for 3.5\%, and tool-augmented agents 12\%. We contribute a four-layer taxonomy mapping 13 vulnerability types across perception, brain, action, and interaction layers, and identify seven open problems centered on containment. Agentic LLM insecurity stems from architectural coupling, where weak isolation allows vulnerabilities to propagate across layers.

0.04

When Context Gets Root: Privilege Escalation in LLM Harnesses

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-08-27 ·Xingbang He, Yuanwei Chen, Yi Qian, Haiyang Wei, Ligeng Chen +4 more
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Instruction hierarchy is a model-side defense that assigns instructions different levels of privilege according to their sources. These levels constrain which content may direct model behavior. During agent execution, however, agent harnesses construct context for each model invocation. This construction can elevate low-level content to a higher instruction level and grant it greater model-facing privilege. We introduce instruction privilege escalation. In this attack, an attacker induces an agent to elevate low-level malicious content to a higher instruction level. The elevated content then causes the agent to execute instructions it would not follow at their original level. We evaluate this threat by using multi-agent mechanisms to achieve 13 attack objectives across six coding-agent harnesses. These objectives span confidentiality, integrity, availability, and remote code execution. With unrestricted action execution, the attacks achieve all 13 objectives on all six harnesses. Under automatic permission review, the attacks achieve all 13 objectives on all three harnesses that provide this mode. We further reproduce the vulnerability using harness-provided persistent goals and scheduled tasks. These results demonstrate the generality of instruction privilege escalation.

0.42

SkillShield: Prompt-Space Security Skills for LLM Coding Agents

cs.CR ·2026-08-26 ·Xiaodong Wu, Zhimin Zhao, Qi Li, Xiangman Li, Yu Shi +2 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract

A coding agent edits files and executes shell commands with its developer's privileges, allowing malicious requests to translate directly into harmful actions or functional malware. Existing defenses have complementary limitations: weight-level alignment is unavailable to API-only deployers, whereas input filters and execution-boundary monitors require auxiliary classification or checking components along the agent's trajectory. We therefore introduce SkillShield, a system-prompt defense that synthesizes security skills offline from known attacks or recorded agent failures. These skills are injected into the system prompt at session start and remain active throughout the tool-use loop. Unlike a reference monitor, they protect the system by defining the security policies the model should follow during execution. Due to the limited system-prompt space, we examine three fixed-budget provisioning scopes: all-classes, with one skill covering all threat classes, per-bundle, with one skill targeting a related subset, and per-class, with one skill dedicated to a single known class and used as the upper-bound reference. None requires runtime request classification or routing. Across six large language models on RedCode, the default all-classes skill reduces malware-generation severity from 3.37 to 0.58 and achieves a 43.6% execution attack success rate, comparable to Llama Guard 3's 42.7% without its separate 8B classifier. The per-bundle and class-fixed per-class settings further reduce this rate to 36.2% and 14.5%, respectively. Under two non-adaptive jailbreak families, SkillShield continues to outperform all baselines on malware generation. Across 731 benign task descriptions, SkillShield yields a mean safety-refusal rate of 0.14%. These results demonstrate the potential of prompt-space security skills to prevent harmful actions and malware generation for LLM coding agents.

0.15

Stopping Is Not the Limit: Understanding and Eliciting Agent Capability in Long-Horizon Vulnerability Exploitation

cs.CR cs.AIcs.SE ·2026-11-17 ·Deokhyung Kang, Minjae Gwon, Sangdon Park
similarity 0.67
Abstract · Preprint

Vulnerability exploitation tests whether language model agents can develop working exploits from known software flaws. Sequential test-time scaling can improve exploitation performance, but larger budgets do not ensure sustained exploration: agents often stop with budget remaining. Yet what happens when execution continues beyond stopping remains underexplored. We investigate this gap on ExploitBench using DeepSeek-V4-Flash-0731 and MiMo-V2.6-Pro. We find additional verified gains after the first stop response, but gains diminish over longer execution. We identify two patterns associated with less productive continuation: an increasing proportion of stop responses within the same context and earlier stopping associated with summaries retaining impossibility judgments about unachieved capabilities. To test whether context management can elicit further capability, we propose SCoRe, which compacts context at stop bursts and marks these judgments as unproven. SCoRe improves verified capability over summary-based continuation and other evaluated context-management baselines. With SCoRe, MiMo reaches a capability coverage score of 67.0% at 2,000 turns, exceeding both 32.4% under the original stopping policy and the 58.6% computed for GPT-5.5 from ExploitBench's 300-turn reference results on the same tasks. These findings show that stopping need not mark an agent's exploitation limit, and that continued execution with context management can elicit substantial further capability.

0.32

ProtoArena: Can AI Agents Discover and Exploit Real-World Cross-Component Protocol Vulnerabilities?

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-10-13 ·Fasheng Miao, Zhaoyu Hu, Xiang Li, Changqing An, Jiutian Zeng +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract · 18 pages, 5 figures

Large language model (LLM) agents are increasingly used for vulnerability analysis, yet existing benchmarks provide limited coverage of exploitation that depends on interactions among network protocol components. Such vulnerabilities arise from inconsistencies in message interpretation, timing, state, or trust assumptions across participants. We introduce ProtoArena, a black-box, multi-component, dynamic benchmark with 80 cross-component vulnerability-exploitation environments spanning 11 protocol and application domains and 7 attack categories. Tasks are primarily informed by published protocol-attack mechanisms. Agents interact with running systems through scoped interfaces to achieve security-effect objectives without target source code. Three information levels assess guided reproduction, exploitation with mechanism and topology context, and effect-directed black-box exploration. A hybrid verifier combines rule-based checks with LLM review of independently collected traffic and logs. We evaluate five LLMs. Claude Opus 4.8 achieves the highest observed success rates: 48.8% under L1 guidance and 12.5% under effect-directed black-box L3. In a separate DNSBomb optimization experiment, it achieves a peak downstream-response to average query-input byte-rate ratio exceeding 171,000 times. The results show that agents can achieve verifiable exploitation effects in some cross-component environments, but success with limited black-box information remains low and varies across domains and attack categories. All experiments use controlled, explicitly authorized targets; they do not test production systems or disclose previously unknown vulnerabilities.

0.20

ErosionBench: Probing Alignment Decay in Enterprise Multi-Agent Systems

cs.CR cs.AIcs.MA ·2026-11-08 ·Riya Bharathwaj, Akshara Prabhakar, Roshan Ram, Avni Kothari, Sarah Tan +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract · 10 pages plus references and appendices

As enterprises delegate consequential work to multi-agent LLM systems, benign-looking requests can escalate into unsafe actions as they propagate across sessions through poisoned shared state, long-context documents, and trusted peer messages: no single message is malicious, yet the assembled tool action is. Prior benchmarks isolate a single agent under prompt injection or score multi-agent attacks by their final output, leaving cross-session erosion of shared state out of scope. We introduce ErosionBench, an environment-grounded benchmark that executes such attacks and verifies alignment decay at the process level, scoring the realized tool call against authorized intent and provenance with deterministic contracts, not output text. Each scenario is authored as a deterministic state graph before any prose is rendered, so every state change traces to a known cause. It spans four enterprise domains and four decay mechanisms across 1,728 scenarios with matched benign controls, labeled against the OWASP Top-10 for LLM Applications, plus 198 image-based attacks, each paired with a text equivalent, so a defense must survive the same attack in either channel. Perimeter defenses suppress attacks only by over-refusing 54-92% of legitimate work, so a low attack-success rate can conceal severe over-refusal. As a reference defense, we propose a calibrated Meta-Auditor pairing synchronous state checks with asynchronous trajectory monitoring; on a family-disjoint 906-scenario held-out split it reaches 98.5% recall at a 2.9% false-positive rate. Since it monitors trajectory, not surface content, its detection is channel-invariant: the strongest auditor flags image-delivered attacks about as reliably as their text equivalents (recall gap $\leq$2 points per model). Across GPT, Gemini, and Claude auditors, calibration keeps false positives low while recall tracks model capability, strongest for Claude.

0.22