CS Paper Radar

Don't CLAP: Are Music-Text Models Bag-of-Words?

Yuan-Chiao Cheng, Alexander Lerch

cs.SD cs.CLeess.AS ·submitted 2026-09-24 20:48 UTC · v1

Abstract

Text-to-music systems are assessed on audio quality and on how faithfully the music follows its prompt, and the CLAP score, the cosine similarity between a music-text model's audio and text embeddings, is the standard objective metric of faithfulness. We ask how accurately that score reflects the text: when an attribute is linked to an instrument (e.g., distorted guitar), does the text embedding capture that binding? To find out, we introduce an attribute swap perturbation: the caption of a real recording is edited by exchanging exactly one property, timbre, lead versus accompaniment, or order of first appearance, between two instruments. We then test four contrastive music-text models and one large audio-language model on whether the audio scores higher against the original caption than against the perturbed one. No contrastive model distinguishes the two captions reliably. The audio-language model does better, but further experiments show that its advantage rests largely on audio-agnostic language priors. Our results thus provide compelling evidence that the CLAP score and related metrics do not capture fine-grained musical meaning or attribute bindings; their representation is closer to a bag-of-words that leaves them insensitive to meaning-changing perturbations of the caption.

Comment
5 pages, 4 figures, 1 table

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

TTM-Bench: A Framework for Text-to-Music System Performance Benchmarking

cs.SD cs.LGcs.MMeess.AS ·2026-09-16 ·Giorgia Adorni, Michela Papandrea, Battista Rimoldi, Tiziano Leidi
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Text-to-music (TTM) systems are increasingly used to generate musical audio from natural-language descriptions. Robust evaluation is therefore essential, yet reliable performance comparison remains challenging. This difficulty stems from differences in system architecture, supported conditioning information, and access mode, as well as heterogeneous and fragmented metrics that cannot be applied uniformly across systems. To address these challenges, we introduce TTM-Bench, a framework that defines a common protocol for systematic, reproducible performance benchmarking of contemporary TTM systems. It evaluates performance along two dimensions: musical-content alignment, quantified by interpretable semantic, genre, and musical-descriptor agreement scores against a common musical specification and summarized by an aggregate score; and computational efficiency, characterized by generation latency and real-time factor, alongside resource use for local models and cost for hosted services. We demonstrate the framework through a preliminary comparative case study, illustrating the complementary evidence captured by these dimensions. The results show that higher musical-content alignment does not systematically coincide with lower computational demands, highlighting the importance of assessing TTM performance through distinct, interpretable measures rather than a reductive overall indicator.

0.22

MQAScore: Fine-Grained Text-Music Alignment Evaluation via Large Audio Language Model

cs.SD cs.AIeess.AS ·2026-10-22 ·Wei-Jaw Lee, Chun-Ping Wang, Xuanjun Chen, Yi-Hsuan Yang
similarity 0.71
Abstract · Submitted to ICASSP 2027

Text-to-music alignment is commonly evaluated by the global similarity between text and audio embeddings, which collapses all described attributes into a single score and obscures which ones are missing. We instead introduce MQAScore, which verifies each atomic musical concept along five clip-level dimensions (genre, instrument, mood/theme, vocal, and usage) by the probability that a large audio language model (LALM) answers affirmatively to a binary question. To assess evaluator reliability, we construct verification labels from presence/absence annotations and LLM-guided concept substitutions, and propose the Sensitivity-Invariance Ratio, which measures how selectively an evaluator responds to meaning-changing substitutions. Experiments show that concept-level scoring improves both question-answering and similarity-based evaluators, and MQAScore can be a more reliable and interpretable fine-grained complement to global similarity for evaluating text-to-music alignment.

0.23

AllMusicCaps: Album Reviews as Complementary Supervision for Music CLAP

cs.SD ·2026-08-26 ·Pablo Alonso-Jiménez, Xavier Lizarraga-Seijas, Xavier Serra, Dmitry Bogdanov
publishedbenchmarkdatasetcode/data similarity 0.70
Abstract · Accepted at ISMIR 2026. Code, weights, and data available at https://github.com/MTG/allmusiccaps

Recent open text-audio contrastive models (CLAPs) are typically trained with LLM-generated captions derived from tag datasets or web search results, which tend to be accurate but expressively narrow. As a complementary source, we explore human-written album reviews, specifically expert reviews from AllMusic: they exist at scale and carry narrative cues, evaluative adjectives, and scene framing that other sources lack. Since raw reviews are too noisy for direct use as captions, we first build a caption corpus with 24,5346 samples via an LLM preprocessing pipeline that identifies descriptive musical quotes and rewrites them into training-ready captions. We find that album review supervision yields the largest retrieval gains on a human-written caption benchmark (Song Describer), particularly for complex queries that other existing caption datasets leave uncovered. In addition, we revisit the training recipe and show that SigReg regularization, which encourages an isotropic Gaussian distribution in the embedding space, improves MLP probing across classification tasks, as well as text-to-music retrieval. The resulting model outperforms open CLAP-style baselines on text-to-music retrieval, zero-shot classification, and most MLP probing tasks. We release the review-derived caption dataset and model weights to support future research.

0.37

Unifying Score and Performance for Fine-Grained Music Understanding in Audio-Language Models

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-09-09 ·Milan Liessens Dujardin, Song-Ze Yu, Kevin Miao
benchmark similarity 0.68
Abstract

Large audio language models (LALMs) have shown promising progress in broad music-understanding tasks such as tagging, retrieval, and captioning. Music understanding that requires finer hearing over both the content and how it is realized within a performance through dynamics, phrasing, articulation, time, and other performance techniques, however, remains at an earlier stage. Existing audio-language model (ALM) training pipelines typically rely on coarse, weakly grounded captions and therefore provide little support for learning these subtle nuances in music, limiting their ability to serve real-world applications in education or artistic practice. We therefore introduce MuNo-SP (Music Notation unifying Score and Performance), a text-based representation that jointly encodes score content and performance information. Building on MuNo-SP, we develop an automatic training-data generation pipeline that uses aligned scores and performances to produce long-form auditory analyses and musically informed question-answer pairs. We use this pipeline to construct MAESTROCaps, a classical piano dataset comprising 148 long-form performance analyses and 31,080 question-answer pairs derived from 148 aligned score-performance pairs. In a human evaluation, MuNo-SP analyses were preferred by majority vote over MIDI-only analyses for eight of nine excerpts. MuNo-SP also performed strongly on a benchmark of score-performance understanding, suggesting that integrating score and performance information enables more reliable and musically informative LALM supervision than a MIDI-only baseline.

0.17

FUSEMOS: Perceptual Evaluation of Text-to-Music Generation with Dual-Encoder Fusion and Ranking-Aware Composite Loss

eess.AS ·2026-11-05 ·Jing Yang, Haoyu Wang, Ningning Pan, Zhao Wang, Jianxuan Yang +1 more
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.68
Abstract · Accepted to ICASSP 2026

Perceptual evaluation of generated music is essential for developing text-to-music (TTM) generation systems. Existing automatic music perceptual evaluation methods rely solely on the contrastive language audio pretraining (CLAP) model to extract both audio and text features for predicting human-annotated mean opinion scores (MOS), particularly for overall musical impression (OMI) and textual alignment (TA). However, CLAP is limited in capturing fine-grained musical attributes such as timbre and expressiveness \emph{etc}. To address this, we propose FUSEMOS, a dual-encoder fusion framework that integrates CLAP with MERT, a self-supervised model pretrained on large scale music audio, to better capture both high level semantic alignment and detailed musical characteristics for more accurate OMI and TA estimation. Furthermore, to overcome the limitations of conventional regression losses in measuring human preferred relative ranking of music segments, we design a novel ranking-aware composite loss function. Experiments conducted on the MusicEval benchmark demonstrate that our approach outperforms the existing SOTA methods in both mean squared error and rank correlation metrics by a large margin.

0.38

MixCards: Evaluating Structured Descriptions of Multi-Source Sound Scenes

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-10-28 ·Sripathi Sridhar, Yujin Kim, Giovana Morais, Liang-Yuan Wu, Mehmet Atilay Kucukoglu +4 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.68
Abstract · Benchmark dataset: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23702059 Code: https://github.com/Sound-Captioning-for-Accessibility/mixcardbench

Audio captioning benchmarks typically evaluate a single unstructured free-text description of an audio scene, providing limited insight into how a model fails to understand polyphonic audio. A plausible caption may omit a source, or conflate multiple sources into one, or assign an attribute of one source to another, and conventional captioning evaluation cannot locate these errors. We introduce MixCardBench, a benchmark for structured captioning of polyphonic audio, which evaluates models in two stages: first, identifying and temporally localizing the sources in a scene, and second, generating a structured MixCard describing the semantic, temporal, and acoustic properties of each source. The benchmark contains 4884 ecologically plausible synthetic soundscapes with up to nine overlapping speech, music and sound effects sources built from high-quality recordings and source-level annotations, where each source has a reference MixCard. We evaluate six state-of-the-art large audio language models and find substantial limitations in current models, which struggle considerably with speech and sound effects timing and detection, with the strongest model reaching only around 60% mean card-field score. Performance varies significantly across attributes, exposing capability differences that are hidden by aggregate caption scores. We assess the quality and ecological validity of MixCardBench through human validation, distribution matching and a listening study, and show that human corrections have little effect on model rankings, and our synthesized soundscapes are closer to in-the-wild YouTube videos than source guided but otherwise random synthesis. The benchmark dataset and code are publicly available, and demo examples are at https://mixcards-anon.github.io/mixcards-demo/

0.20

MUUNRiver-Bench: Diagnosing Relation-Dependent Music Retrieval with Multimodal Instructions

cs.SD cs.AI ·2026-09-14 ·Zhancheng Guo, Congren Dai, Shangda Wu, Jianhuai Hu, Danni Zhao +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.68
Abstract

Music retrieval is relation-dependent: given a reference track, a listener may seek its style with a new theme, a cover, or a comparable voice, and these intents demand contradictory rankings. We present MUUNRiver-Bench, a diagnostic benchmark whose reference-audio queries use natural-language instructions to define relevance. A pipeline combining expert genre priors, LLM-generated prompts and lyrics, synthesis, and expert review yields 3,440 tracks spanning 13 genres and 116 sub-genres, and seven tasks: similar-music, style-preserving lyric-rewriting, lyric-preserving style-rewriting, cover, vocal-timbre, isolated-vocal, and segment retrieval. Across six models in eight configurations, task-wise rank reversals reveal complementary biases: acoustic encoders favour local identity, whereas text-aligned encoders favour semantic relations. Frozen encoders diagnose default similarity preferences; instruction-aware and audio-text fusion systems provide exploratory tests of textual conditioning, with neither simple fusion scheme consistently improving its backbone

0.18

Randomized Scores and Diverse Timbres: Augmenting Automatic Music Transcription with Online-Generated Data

eess.AS ·2026-10-08 ·Haiwen Xia, Chao Zhang, Qiuqiang Kong
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 5 pages

Automatic music transcription (AMT) is limited by the scarcity of audio recordings paired with precise symbolic annotations. Synthetic data can provide supervision at scale, but it remains unclear whether effective transfer depends on realistic score structure or broad timbral coverage. We study these factors separately through an online sampler--renderer pipeline. A unified corruption sampler ranges from unmodified MIDI clips through partial corruption to deeply randomized note-event distributions. The renderer converts these events to audio while independently controlling instrument and timbral coverage. A fixed transcription model is trained jointly on offline recordings and newly rendered examples. Controlled ablations reveal an asymmetry between the two factors: moderate corruption of the note-event distribution does not impair transfer and can improve it, whereas broader renderer-side timbral support consistently improves out-of-domain generalization under a fixed note-event distribution. Finally, online-rendered examples complement real and existing synthetic data in a strong combined-data regime. These results suggest that synthetic AMT data should prioritize coverage of note-level attributes and their timbral realizations over realistic joint score structure.

0.22