CS Paper Radar

Where the Numbers Come From: Auditing Evaluation in Provenance-Based Intrusion Detection

Jihwan Moon, Gunhee Kim, Myeongjang Pyeon

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-27 13:01 UTC · v1
benchmark

Abstract

Reproducing a provenance-based intrusion detector's score does not establish what that score says about its emitted alarms or the information its encoder uses. We audit nine released implementations, execute four detectors using their own code, and isolate three measurement effects. First, a fixed-alert comparison separates label choice from neighbourhood credit: ThreaTrace reports precision 0.938 with neighbourhood credit, although only seven of its 994 alarms carry its own attack label. Second, removing test-label checkpoint selection lowers attack detection precision (ADP) by 0.16 to 0.33 across four forty-member word2vec configurations without changing detector order. Third, a buffer-reuse defect gives a linear encoder unintended degree-dependent inputs. Correcting it lowers type-only ADP in every identical-input initialization pair on two hosts, while historical word2vec effects depend on the host. These findings qualify claims from the inspected implementations about alarm precision, performance magnitude and static-attribute sufficiency. STRICT connects them to six checkable reporting requirements. Because the comparisons condition on benchmark targets, they neither validate those labels nor establish a universal detector ranking.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

How Reliable Are NVD CWE Labels? A Large-Scale Semantic Audit with Seclometry

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-08-22 ·Yu Nong, Yao Du, Majid Behravan, Haipeng Cai
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.64
Abstract

CWE labels in the National Vulnerability Database (NVD) are widely treated as ground truth for vulnerability search, scanner evaluation, benchmark construction, learning-based security tools, and vulnerability prioritization. Yet their reliability has not been systematically measured at scale, despite growing concerns about NVD's enrichment backlog and anecdotal reports of inaccurate, ambiguous, or missing labels. This paper presents a large-scale, code-semantics-grounded measurement of CWE labeling quality in NVD. We build CWEAgent, a validated auditing instrument based on seclometry, a structured representation of vulnerability semantics that captures the root cause, trigger condition, violated security property, exploit mechanism, and impact of vulnerable code. On a manually curated benchmark of 100 open-source CVEs, CWEAgent achieves 85% top-1 accuracy and 92% ambiguity-aware accuracy. Applying CWEAgent to 15,556 open-source CVEs disclosed from 2017-2026, we find that only 49.70% of NVD CWE labels exactly match the code-grounded label. Another 31.37% are defensible alternatives under taxonomy ambiguity, while 3.63% are evidence-inconsistent likely errors. Label reliability varies sharply by assigning organization and weakness type, and apparent project- or language-level differences are largely composition effects of those underlying weakness types. Evidence-inconsistent labels have also increased over time. Through manual review of 434 confirmed mislabels, we identify six recurring error patterns, showing that CWE noise is a structural problem in vulnerability metadata rather than isolated annotation mistakes.

0.28

From Runnable to Verifiable: An Independent Reproducibility Study of LLM/Agent-Driven Vulnerability Validation Artifacts

cs.CR ·2026-08-10 ·Bo Chen
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract · 16 pages, 2 figures, 6 tables

Security research artifacts---repositories, PoC exploits, and validation pipelines---are increasingly produced by LLM/agent-driven vulnerability workflows, yet the gap between \emph{publicly available}, \emph{runnable}, \emph{signal-producing}, and \emph{semantically confirmed} artifacts is poorly measured. We conduct a pre-registered reproducibility audit of this literature. A search covering 2023--2026 with dual screening yields a 104-paper consensus corpus, of which 59 papers (56.7\%) have a publicly reachable artifact. We execute an 18-paper sample at R0/R1 and all 102 cases of the anchor benchmark (arXiv:2509.24037), with patched-counterfactual verdicts on 30 signal-producing cases and matched-negative-control verdicts on 19. Three findings stand out. First, 58/102 (56.9\%) anchor cases contain a script-internal CVE identifier that diverges from the declared directory CVE. Second, only 10/18 (55.6\%) paper-level artifacts complete their declared workflow at R0, rising to 11/18 (61.1\%) after environment-only R1 repair. Third, artifact-embedded oracles prove unreliable: 20/30 patched-counterfactual audits still produce the claimed signal on the patched build, 7/19 matched negative controls still trigger on benign input, and the oracle confusion matrix has sensitivity 60\% and specificity 45\%. A trigger on the vulnerable build is not evidence of CVE-specific reproduction without a clean patched counterfactual. These are exploratory results from a pre-registered protocol, and our protocol---pre-registered post-conditions, R0/R1 repair ladder, G1--G3 semantic evidence levels, and patched-counterfactual oracles---is a reusable template for the security reproducibility community.

0.10

Provenance, Not Behaviour: A Serialisation Artifact in Edge-IIoTset and a Leakage-Free Benchmark for Precision-Agriculture Intrusion Detection

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-08-16 ·Mostafa M. Galal
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract · 29 pages, 13 tables. Code: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21941210 Benchmark: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21941319

Edge-IIoTset is the reference benchmark for machine-learning intrusion detection in the industrial Internet of Things, and results reported on it cluster above 99%. We show that much of that performance is not intrusion detection. The preprocessing recipe distributed with the dataset instructs researchers to one-hot encode seven categorical columns. Four of them separate attack from normal traffic with an accuracy of 1.0000 on their own, through the spelling of the placeholder written for an absent protocol field: the string "0" in the normal-traffic branch of the dataset build against "0.0" in the attack branch. The label is recoverable from a serialisation artifact encoding file provenance, with no network behaviour modelled, and separates every row of both curated subsets. Under 5-fold x 3-repeat cross-validation, five of six standard classifiers attain exactly 1.0000 +/- 0.0000 accuracy and the sixth attains 0.99998. Under a corrected protocol, naive Bayes falls by 0.3005 macro-F1 and the strongest model settles at 0.9503 +/- 0.0011. Label, ordinal and frequency encoding leak identically. Because the curated subsets also lack Modbus and per-device identity, we rebuild the benchmark from the raw captures under uniform parsing, producing AgriEdge: 1,276,122 rows, five devices with full attribution, and no column separating the classes above 0.0288. A leave-one-device-out sweep locates the generalisation boundary at the perception/actuation layer, where random forest falls from 0.9988 to 0.5083 balanced accuracy. Non-IID federated partitioning costs at most 0.0037 macro-F1, but a 20-round LoRaWAN training run costs 4.6 hours of uplink.

0.22

Candidate Comparability Before Promotion: Conditional Validation in Adaptive Network Intrusion Detection

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-09-03 ·Roberto Fernández-Barrios, Iker Pastor-López, Amaia Pikatza-Huerga, Pablo García Bringas
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract · 29 pages, 3 figures, 11 tables. Supplementary material (Online Resource 1) is included as an ancillary file

Adaptive network intrusion detection systems retrain classifiers after drift alarms, but an alarm detects change; it does not establish that a challenger should replace the deployed incumbent. Promotion is security-relevant because it changes the model responsible for subsequent attack detection, and evaluating it has a methodological problem: promotion conclusions may depend on how the challenger was constructed and on how much evidence supports it. We test that dependence on CICIDS2017, UNSW-NB15 and ToN-IoT with self-contained challenger pipelines, nested candidate-size controls, a common-harness comparison of nine update policies, and a final sensitivity confining every exact feature vector to one evaluation, training or probe role. Incumbent-owned frozen preprocessing amplified apparent promotion harm; with self-contained challenger pipelines the mean full-drift harm did not persist. Raising nominal candidate evidence from 512 to 2,000 samples per class improved promotion under pool-constructed progressive drift by +0.53, +1.67 and +0.38 balanced-accuracy points: positive and statistically resolved in all three benchmarks, but materially benchmark-dependent rather than homogeneous, and driven mainly by fewer false positives. Policy conclusions were partially robust: policy ordering changed with candidate comparability, no policy globally dominated, and earlier compatibility statements for a label-free estimator and a calibrated ensemble narrowed. Validation helped evidence-disadvantaged challengers but added no average benefit at parity. Thirteen replays on real, time-ordered traffic showed no net harm from always deploying. Challenger construction and evidence should be controlled, reported and interpreted explicitly when promotion is evaluated.

0.40

Analysis of Federated Aggregation under Model Poisoning and Backdoor Attacks: A Reconstructed Cross-Dataset and Cross-Architecture Benchmark

cs.LG cs.CRcs.CV ·2026-08-11 ·Soumya Mazumdar, Vineet Kumar Rakesh, Tapas Samanta
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.62
Abstract · 30 pages, 7 main figures, 7 main tables; includes 11 pages of Supplementary Information with 14 supplementary figures. Code and reproducibil…

Robust comparisons of federated aggregation methods require joint consideration of predictive performance, threat definitions, metric semantics, and execution provenance. A 500-cell seed-1 evaluation matrix was reconstructed across five aggregation methods, five datasets, five architectures, and four recorded conditions: clean, sign-flipping, Gaussian, and BadNets. Successful execution logs were identified for 454 original runs and 36 repaired or rerun executions, whereas 10 clean SVHN cells were supported by summary-only provenance. Trimmed Mean achieved the highest clean macro-mean accuracy (76.02%) and the lowest mean within-task rank (1.70). Krum attained the highest recorded accuracy under both sign-flipping and Gaussian configurations. These relative rankings remained unchanged when analysis was restricted to 21 task pairs for which original successful logs were available for every method-condition combination. Audit of the supplied BadNets metric implementation established that every test input is triggered prior to target-label counting; consequently, the retained metric represents Triggered Target-Label Rate (TTLR) rather than a conventional target-excluding attack success rate. An audit of the supplied FedPARETO scaffold further identified a pathway in which predictive summaries may characterize an uncorrupted local model while the aggregation weight is applied to a separately corrupted update, introducing a potential discrepancy between reported predictive outcomes and the updates used for aggregation. The canonical matrix contains a single identified seed for each cell, and exact attack and configuration lineage is incomplete. Accordingly, the findings should be interpreted as descriptive comparisons within the recorded configurations and not as statistical estimates or universal claims regarding robustness.

0.30

Silent Blindness: Fault Vulnerability of Hardware Malware Detectors

cs.CR cs.AR ·2026-10-27 ·Alireza Abolhasani Zeraatkar, Parnian Shabani Kamran, Parsa Mirfasihi, Saleh Khalaj Monfared, Hussain Al-Asaad
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Hardware malware detectors (HMDs) classify hardware performance-counter measurements to identify malicious execution. Faults in their decision logic or parameters can weaken detection and allow malware to be classified as benign. We investigate this vulnerability through structural fault injection across a design space comprising 18 classifiers, four counter budgets, and AdaBoost and Bagging ensembles. The simulation evaluates 453,174 decision stuck-at and selected parameter bit-flip events on a 7,400-instance. Primary comparisons use 128 completed configurations. These completed-subset results are distinguished from the simulation summaries covering 140 configurations with enumerable fault sites. Fault outcomes are classified by their security consequences, including evasion, false-alarm increases, and metric silence. A fault is critical when malware recall decreases by at least five percentage points. Tree-based models exhibit a lower mean critical-fault fraction than function-based models, 5.3% versus 14.3%; exhaustive-only analysis preserves this ordering. Moreover, 72.3% of evaluated tree faults are metric-silent, changing both recall and false-positive rate by less than 0.1 percentage points without necessarily preserving individual predictions. Among the 27 completed matched comparisons, Bagging reduces criticality in 26, whereas AdaBoost increases it in two. Finally, an exact minimax selection method identifies protection candidates under additive unit costs and ideal correction. For a representative J48 detector, protecting 16 of 115 structural units reduces predicted maximum recall loss from 60.1 to 3.3 percentage points. These results characterize structural-model sensitivity and potential protection benefits; faulted RTL correspondence and physical hardening overhead remain unvalidated.

0.12

Trusting the Tool: Asymmetric Deference of LLM Vulnerability Auditors to Static-Analysis Evidence

cs.SE cs.CRcs.LG ·2026-10-23 ·ZhiHong Liu, Shuyao Gao
code/data similarity 0.62
Abstract · 33 pages, 9 figures, 5 tables. Submitted to IEEE Access. Code: https://github.com/lzh0082-cloud/CODE-DETECTION

Pipelines that combine large language models (LLMs) with static analysis let the model consume the analyser's output as evidence, but whether the model distinguishes true from false evidence, and whether its scrutiny depends on what the evidence claims, has not been measured. We built an intraprocedural analyser for C/C++ that produces proof obligations and audited vulnerable and patched functions from PrimeVul under six evidence conditions that differ only in the notes, including fabricated assurances that a missing check exists and fabricated alarms that an added check is missing. The study covers 916 pairs in four disjoint sets, eleven model configurations from four vendors and 16,572 audits; no model is trained or fine-tuned. True evidence barely improved accuracy (+0.02). False evidence acted asymmetrically: relative to true notes about the same operations, false assurances lowered the detection of real vulnerabilities by up to 19 points, whereas false alarms never significantly lowered accuracy and were disputed far more often. An internally registered replication on seven new models confirmed that false assurances move verdicts towards their claim more than false alarms do (mean asymmetry +0.16, 95% CI +0.10 to +0.24). Instructions in the audit prompt did not reliably reduce deference; the best one failed to replicate. Verifying each claim in a separate call and showing the refuted claims raised accuracy under false assurances by 12 points in a pre-specified test (p=0.002) without loss under true evidence; for a second model the gain was smaller and not significant. Pipelines should therefore verify a tool's guarantees before the model relies on them, and studies should measure deference in a direction-aware way.

0.70

Recording-Aware Evaluation of Multimodal OT Intrusion Detection

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-10-16 ·Mustafa Umut Ozbek, Khalil El-Khatib, Li Yang
publishedbenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 12 pages, 3 figures, 5 tables. Accepted for presentation at the Industrial Control System Security Workshop (ICSS 2026), held in conjunction…

Machine-learning-based intrusion detection systems (IDSs) for operational technology (OT) are commonly evaluated on benchmark datasets in which normal and attack data are collected in separate recordings. In such settings, high performance may reflect recording-associated differences as well as attack behavior. We introduce a recording-aware evaluation procedure that compares attack windows with background from the same recording, uses prior data for model fitting and calibration, tests temporal alignment against randomized event schedules, and reports event coverage together with alarm burden. On the ProvICS multimodal dataset, cyber modalities strongly distinguish the benign and attack recordings before the first labeled attack. Same-recording evaluation reverses the apparent modality ranking across all studied window sizes: the physical view becomes the strongest individual modality, while cyber-only fusion shows the largest difference between cross-recording and same-recording AUC, reaching 0.54. Operational analysis further shows that permissive event-overlap metrics can overstate detection when a small number of long alarm episodes cover multiple actions. An external analysis on HAI shows smaller and reference-dependent recording sensitivity. These findings show that cross-recording benchmark performance should be interpreted alongside same-recording, forward, temporal, and operational evaluations.

0.44