CS Paper Radar

Consequences of Polylogarithmic Membership Comparability for SAT

Sebastian Ben Daniel

cs.CC ·submitted 2026-09-28 11:41 UTC · v1

Abstract

We study the consequences of membership comparators that exclude one possible membership vector, deterministically or with a relative advantage over uniform guessing. For every polynomially bounded arity, a randomized polynomial-time comparator of error at most $(1-1/poly(n))2^{-t}$ gives $ NP/ poly\cap coNP/ poly$ recognition with common advice. The proof uses limited independence, polynomial occurrence certificates, and a self-contained positive-relation advice transfer. For SAT at arity $O((\log n)^d)$, both this relative-gap hypothesis and deterministic comparability imply $PH=S^{NP}$, the uniform bound $PH\subseteq BPTIME(2^{O((\log n)^{d^2})})$, and symmetric verification with polynomial-length certificates and an oracle-free deterministic $2^{O((\log n)^d)}$ predicate. Polynomial-advice deterministic decoding has the same exponent $d$. Applying the randomized simulation to an unconditional diagonal language yields, for every fixed $\varepsilon>0$, $\mathrm{BPP}\subsetneq BPTIME(2^{O((\log n)^{d^2+\varepsilon})})$, without advice. The larger clock remains subexponential under every fixed number of self-compositions. A layered oracle satisfies deterministic comparability and $NP^O=coNP^O$ but excludes randomized NP algorithms with smaller logarithmic power, establishing a relativized limit on the SAT exponent $d$. This expanded version also develops the full weak-advantage regime, where saving $2^{-O((log n)^d)}$ gives randomized SAT exponent $d$ and PH exponent $d^k$ at fixed level $k$; the quasipolynomial and exponential hierarchy consequences; binary-comparator advice bounds; and the certificate-length boundary between the randomized regimes. Under deterministic comparability, uniform deterministic promise-unique search additionally gives $UEXP=EXP$. The ordinary second-level collapse $PH=Σ_2^p$ for $d>1$ remains unproved.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Linear Certificates for Membership Comparability, Quadratic Barriers for Selectors

cs.CC ·2026-09-25 ·Sebastian Ben Daniel
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Selectors and comparators supply only partial information about membership: a selector names a member of any pair that meets the language, while a binary membership comparator merely excludes one of the four membership vectors of a pair. We ask how much nonuniform advice turns such information into exact recognition. Our main result extends the optimal nondeterministic advice bound for P-selective sets to every binary membership-comparable language: $2-mc \subseteq NP /(3n+5)\cap\mathrm{coNP}/(3n+5)$, with common fixed advice and certificates of at most $5n+12$ bits. The class is strictly larger; some 2-mc sets are not truth-table reducible to any P-selective set. The proof replaces the tournament king by an independent two-step cover of true signed literals, together with a short-forcing-or-exact-majority dichotomy, and it relativizes. Via an advice-preserving isolation transfer, a deterministic polynomial-time algorithm for promise Unique-Circuit-SAT gives $2-mc \subseteq P/O(n)$. For selectors we determine tight orders of ordinary advice: $Θ(n)$ for errorless average-case computation and $Θ(n^2)$ for worst-case bounded-error computation, the latter independent of the interpreter's coin bound. One oracle realizes both orders on a single language and separates ordinary from coin-dependent advice. The quadratic and linear lower bounds hold for tournament-query procedures and relativized languages, not unconditionally for unrelativized P-selective sets.

0.38

Zero Knowledge for Free up to Linear Query Bounds: Quasilinear-Size Constant-Query Zero-Knowledge PCPs

cs.CC ·2026-10-21 ·Inhyuk Park, Chenglin Fan
theory similarity 0.69
Abstract · The abstract is shortened due to the length limit of arXiv

We show that for all polynomials $T$ and $b$, every relation in NTIME($T$) has a binary PCP with $O(1)$ non-adaptive queries, perfect completeness, soundness error 1/2 and length $(T+b)\cdot(\log(T+b))^{O(1)}$, which is perfect zero knowledge against every adaptive, possibly malicious verifier making at most $b$ queries. This improves the length $\tilde O(T+b^2)$ of Zeilberger, O'Connor, Gur and Spooner (2026), who observed that Dinur's gap amplification preserves zero knowledge. The simulator runs in expected polynomial time (or in strict polynomial time, with a failure symbol or with negligible statistical error). For $b\le T$ the length is $T\cdot\mathrm{polylog}\,T$, the form of the shortest known constant-query PCPs without zero knowledge. Unless NP $\subseteq$ BPP, the dependence on $b$ is optimal up to the polylogarithmic factor for polynomial-time simulators: zero knowledge is free up to linear query bounds. Zero-knowledge interactive oracle proofs achieved length $\tilde O(T+b)$ in 2016-17; we obtain it for PCPs. Gur, O'Connor and Spooner (STOC 2025) asked whether NP has such PCPs of quasilinear length (their Open Problem 1). This paper answers it for every polynomial query bound, with the simulators above in place of a strict polynomial-time perfect simulator. The proofs were developed with extensive AI assistance and have been checked by the authors. We mask the Reed-Solomon proof of proximity of Ben-Sasson and Sudan at every node of its recursion. By a locator lemma, at every node, whatever $k$ of its proof symbols reveal about its input is determined by $O(k)$ input values. We prove it with the coprime-order argument of Bafna and Vyas (2026); our treatment of domain points is new. Dinur's gap amplification gives constant query complexity. The query count and the polylogarithmic exponent are absolute but very large.

0.10

A New Characterization of Streaming Decidability of Boolean CSPs Under Deletions

cs.CC ·2026-11-05 ·Aditya Bandekar, Amatya Sharma, Santhoshini Velusamy
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract

We characterize the single-pass streaming space complexity of Boolean CSP satisfiability in the strict-turnstile model for every fixed constraint language $Γ$ of $k$-ary Boolean relations that is not trivially satisfiable. Constraints can be inserted or deleted with nonnegative multiplicities; satisfiability is decided for those remaining at the end. While Sharma and Velusamy [ESA 2026] characterized insertion-only complexity via non-redundancy (up to logarithmic factors), we show that strict-turnstile complexity is governed by the integer capturing degree. For $R\subseteq\{0,1\}^k$, let $d_R$ be the minimum degree of an integer-coefficient polynomial vanishing exactly on $R$ over the Boolean hypercube, and set $d_Γ=\max_{R\inΓ}d_R$. On polynomial-length streams, we obtain an $O_k(n^{d_Γ}\operatorname{polylog} n)$-space randomized algorithm and an $Ω_k(n^{d_Γ}/\log n)$ lower bound for all algorithms. Moreover, our algorithm outputs a sparse instance preserving every satisfying assignment. This yields, to our knowledge, the first insertion-only versus turnstile separation for streaming CSPs. It also differs from the Fourier-degree characterization of exact optimization by Kol, Paramonov, Saxena, and Yu [ITCS 2023]. For $k\ge3$, $k$-XOR with literals has three distinct space complexities: $\widetildeΘ(n)$ for insertion-only satisfiability, $\widetildeΘ(n^{\lceil k/2\rceil})$ for strict-turnstile satisfiability, and $\widetildeΘ(n^k)$ for exact optimization in either model.

0.15

Constant-Probability Witness Isolation Implies $\mathrm{NP}\subseteq\mathrm{P/poly}$

cs.CC ·2026-09-24 ·Sebastian Ben Daniel
published similarity 0.64
Abstract

Valiant and Vazirani isolate a satisfying assignment of a circuit with probability $Ω(1/n)$. Dell, Kabanets, van Melkebeek, and Watanabe showed that success above $2/3$ implies $\mathrm{NP}\subseteq\mathrm{P/poly}$ and asked about the range in between. We show that every positive constant already implies the collapse: if a randomized nonuniform polynomial-size pruning procedure succeeds with probability $ε$ on affine circuit inputs with at most $2^{\lfloor 2/ε\rfloor}$ satisfying assignments, then $\mathrm{NP}\subseteq\mathrm{P/poly}$. Success $10/\log L$ on affine inputs with at most $L^{1/3}$ satisfying assignments suffices, where $L$ is the description length, and on inputs with one or two satisfying assignments the threshold $2/3$ drops to $3/5$. No cryptographic assumption is used, and the procedure may read the entire circuit. The proof compiles a pool of circuits into one circuit whose satisfying assignments are indexed by tags in $\mathbb{F}_2^d$. Each member is assigned an affine region of tag space, and if one member is unsatisfiable, the satisfying set shrinks to that member's region. Because regions may overlap and have different dimensions, the collapse reduces to a combinatorial bound: no set of tags meets more than a $2/d$ fraction of an equally weighted family of affine subspaces of all dimensions below $d$ in exactly one point. This regional counting cannot go below order $1/\log L$. The range between $Θ(1/n)$, achieved by affine hashing, and $O(1/\log n)$ remains open.

0.62

Witness Encryption via Prime-Order Generic Groups

cs.CR ·2026-09-16 ·Isaac M Hair, Amit Sahai
similarity 0.64
Abstract

For every constant $c > 0$, we unconditionally construct witness encryption for NP in the classical generic cyclic group model with the following properties. For SAT instances of size $n$, encryption runs in time poly$(n)$, and any satisfying assignment can be used to decrypt in poly$(n)$ time with correctness error $2^{-n}$. If no satisfying assignment exists, every generic adversary making at most $n^{(\log n)^c}$ group queries has distinguishing advantage at most $n^{-(\log n)^c}$. Along the way, we give the first superconstant-factor NP-hardness of approximation result for homogeneous MinRank under randomized polynomial-time reductions. We obtain a gap of $(\log n)^c$ for any prescribed constant $c>0$, even when YES instances are required to have a rank-one matrix of the form $\mathbf u\mathbf v^T$ where $\mathbf v$ is a 0/1 vector. The main results of this paper were discovered by Codex / ChatGPT 6 Astra Ultra using harness components from the UCLA Moonshot Harness Project, in response to a general strategy for witness encryption suggested by the authors. See the end of the introduction for a discussion.

0.30

Exact $\ell_p$-CVP via Euclidean SVP in Polynomial Space

cs.DS cs.CR ·2026-11-05 ·Jiseung Kim, Minkyu Kim, Hyung Tae Lee
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 30 pages, 1 figure

We give a randomized, rank-preserving reduction from exact $\ell_p$-CVP to exact Euclidean SVP for every integer $p\ge2$. For rational inputs of bit length $\ell$ on full-rank lattices $L\subset\mathbb R^N$, the reduction uses $(Cp)^N\poly(p,\ell)$ oracle calls and additional bit operations, where $C$ is an absolute constant. It uses $\poly(p,\ell)$ working space outside the oracle, and all oracle queries have rank $N$ and $\poly(p,\ell)$ bit complexity. For $p=2$, the reduction transfers polynomial-space exact SVP algorithms to exact CVP with $2^{O(N)}\poly(\ell)$ time overhead. Instantiating it with the SVP algorithms of Kannan and of Feng, Gao and Liu yields randomized polynomial-space CVP algorithms running in time $N^{N/(2e)+o(N)}$ and $N^{N/(4e)+o(N)}$, respectively. For every fixed integer $p\ge3$, the same reduction yields exact $\ell_p$-CVP algorithms for arbitrary rational targets either in randomized time and space $2^{O(N)}$, or in randomized time $N^{N/(4e)+o(N)}$ and polynomial space. These algorithmic bounds are up to polynomial factors in $\ell$. The reduction performs local search sequentially over the cosets of \(2L\), where \(L\) is the input lattice, while tracking the excess of the current objective value over the optimum. Within a coset containing a closest vector, midpoint inequalities bound the unknown correction in terms of this excess, which in turn allows us to construct many short corrections that reduce the excess bound by a factor of four. A counting argument shows that these improving corrections form a sufficiently large fraction of the lattice points in a known search region, and a sparsification-based sampler assigns sufficiently large probability to every nonzero vector in that region, using at most one SVP call per sample. For \(p\ge3\), the same framework is extended using a diagonal weighted norm computed from the current point.

0.30

A Simple Algebraic Proof of the PCP Theorem

cs.CC ·2026-08-18 ·Prashanth Amireddy, Amik Raj Behera, Srikanth Srinivasan, Madhu Sudan, Sophus Valentin Willumsgaard
publishedtheory similarity 0.63
Abstract · Fixed an error in Lemma 3.3 and modified the tests accordingly

We give the simplest known algebraic proof of the PCP theorem, involving only ingredients like code concatenation, polynomial interpolation, and polynomial multiplication. Specifically, we prove that graph 3-coloring has a polynomial-sized proof that can be verified by a verifier tossing logarithmically many coins and querying a constant number of bits in the proof. In particular, our proof does not involve any PCP compositions; notably, it does not invoke the NP-completeness of any fixed problem, such as SAT or 3-coloring, in the construction of the verifier. The main innovation in our work is a clean, coding theoretic, way to encode univariate polynomials that allows us to implement ``low-degree testing'' using just a constant number of bits of queries. Insights from recent attempts to simplify the PCP proof by the authors (STOC 2026) and Goldreich (ECCC 2025) allow us to observe that low-degree was the key bottleneck in converting previous algebraic constructions of the PCP verifier into a constant query PCP. Thus, by overcoming this bottleneck, we get the full PCP verifier using elementary and self-contained steps. As concrete support for the claimed simplicity, we include the full pseudocode of the PCP verifier, assuming finite field arithmetic, and a full description of the completeness (aka ``honest'') prover, assuming multivariate polynomial arithmetic including interpolation and evaluation, that fit in about a page each.

0.32

0/1 integer programming over polytopes of Chvátal rank one is as hard as lattice problems

cs.CC math.OCcs.DM ·2026-10-07 ·Alberto Del Pia
similarity 0.62
Abstract

A rational polyhedron has Chvátal rank at most one if a single round of Chvátal-Gomory cuts yields its integer hull. In 1973, Chvátal asked whether 0/1 integer programs over polytopes of bounded Chvátal rank can be solved in polynomial time. For polyhedra of bounded Chvátal rank, integer feasibility is in NP $\cap$ coNP, so it is unlikely to be NP-hard. We answer Chvátal's question negatively already in its most restricted form: for Chvátal rank one, for integer feasibility, and even for the SAT polytopes of formulas whose clauses have at most three literals. Our answer holds under either of two standard assumptions from lattice-based cryptography. First, a polynomial-time algorithm for integer feasibility on such SAT polytopes of Chvátal rank one would solve bounded distance decoding with polynomial factors in deterministic polynomial time, contradicting the conjectured hardness of approximating lattice problems within polynomial factors. Second, assuming the hardness of learning with errors, an average-case analog of bounded distance decoding, the problem is also hard on average, for a polynomial-time samplable distribution of formulas. This also gives negative answers to related questions of Cornuéjols, Lee, and Li. We first prove these results for parallelepipeds, where they rest on an elementary sufficient condition: a polyhedron has Chvátal rank at most one if its width is less than one along every row of some unimodular matrix. For our parallelepipeds, such a matrix exists but is hard to find. For SAT polytopes, we represent candidate lattice vectors by their residues modulo small integers, and binary arithmetic on additional 0/1 variables checks that these vectors lie in the lattice.

0.27