CS Paper Radar

LLM-Assisted Automatic Security Proofs for Cryptographic Protocols: How Far Are We?

Tianjian Liu, Shicheng Feng, Jin'ao Shang, Xiaoting Lyu, Bin Wang, Zonghua Zhang, Lei Xue, Wei Wang

cs.CR cs.SE ·submitted 2026-09-28 15:38 UTC · v1

Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) have shown strong potential for assisting software and security analysis tasks, yet their effectiveness in cryptographic symbolic protocol verification remains insufficiently understood. In this paper, we conduct the first systematic evaluation of the capability of state-of-the-art LLMs in cryptographic symbolic protocol verification. To quantify this capability, we propose \textsc{CRoST} (Coverage Rate of Solve Tree), a proof-based metric derived from the verifier's proof skeleton that measures the similarity between generated lemmas and reference lemmas. We then establish the rationale of \textsc{CRoST} through both theoretical analysis and empirical validation. The evaluation results show that state-of-the-art models achieve 38.82\% coverage on average, with 14.4\% of generated lemmas exceeding 80\% coverage, indicating that LLMs can already generate useful lemmas to a certain extent. However, they still exhibit non-trivial failure modes on complex multi-phase protocols, show diminishing returns under naive scaling, and incur substantial verification overhead. These findings clarify the practical potential and limitations of LLMs for protocol verification and motivate future work on complex real-world protocols.

Comment
12 pages, 12 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Understanding the Usability of Cryptographic Verification Tools

cs.CR ·2026-09-14 ·Tarikul Islam, Yasin Islam, Khandakar Ashrafi Akbar, Imtiaz Karim
similarity 0.70
Abstract

Cryptographic protocol verification tools are widely used to analyze the security of complex protocols, yet how users interact with these tools remains comparatively understudied. We present an exploratory human-centered study of experienced users of Tamarin, ProVerif, and related protocol verifiers. Our survey included researchers, graduate students, and practitioners with hands-on experience using Tamarin, ProVerif, or related tools. The findings reveal usability barriers across the verification workflow, including difficulties debugging non-termination and performance issues, and the lack of systematic methods for validating formal models against real protocols. When proofs fail without concrete attacks, users commonly simplify models, add helper lemmas, and revisit modeling abstractions. Participants also called for actionable diagnostics, clearer explanations of results, visualization, and automation for recurring proof tasks. Our findings suggest that persistent usability challenges arise from the gap between protocol-level reasoning and the verifier's formal model, proof procedures, and diagnostic output. We derive concrete design priorities for improving the accessibility, interpretability, and usability of cryptographic protocol verification tools.

0.31

Synthesizing Proofs Using Proof Sharding and Exploration

cs.PL cs.SE ·2026-09-22 ·Seyed Armin Vakil Ghahani, Manos Kapritsos
theory similarity 0.70
Abstract

Distributed systems are hard to implement correctly, and subtle bugs can go undetected using traditional testing. Formal verification offers an alternative for proving the correctness of complex distributed systems. Despite previous efforts to automate and facilitate formal verification, it is still hard to integrate formal verification in software development. Programmers need to query the theorem prover repeatedly to find the correct proof of their system. This cycle of going back and forth with the theorem prover involves a lot of human intervention and is a barrier to adopting formal verification in software development. In this paper, we address the challenges of scaling formal verification in practice by reducing the human intervention required to find the correctness proof of a distributed system. We propose ProofSaX, an automated tool that shards large verification tasks and explores the proof search space for each shard independently to synthesize correctness proofs. We use controlled exploration when adding possible proof annotations to handle the search-space explosion problem. We evaluate ProofSaX on a variety of safety proofs for distributed systems. We show that ProofSaX can find the last proof annotation in 86 out of 103 proof-completion tasks, with runtimes ranging from one minute to two hours.

0.20

Vero: Can AI Agents Build Formally Verified Software Repositories?

cs.LG cs.AIcs.LOcs.PL+1 ·2026-08-13 ·Zhe Ye, Hantao Lou, Yuechun Sun, Peiyang Song, Zhengxu Yan +6 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.67
Abstract

AI agents are increasingly used for programming, but do not provide any guarantee on the correctness of generated code. Verified code generation, in which an agent produces both an implementation and a machine-checked proof of its specification, offers a stronger path toward trustworthy AI-generated software. Existing benchmarks in this direction either focus on individual functions or only evaluate proof generation with provided implementations. It is still an open question whether agents can make coherent implementation and proof choices across real multi-module codebases. To bridge this gap, we introduce Vero, the first benchmark to evaluate joint implementation and proof synthesis at the repository level. Vero contains 43 multi-module instances sourced from real-world repositories spanning Python, Dafny, Verus, and Coq, and covering diverse domains from cryptographic protocols to distributed systems. Each instance consists of a multi-module Lean 4 repository with predetermined API interfaces, manually curated formal specifications, and reference implementations, supporting both proof-only and code-and-proof evaluation modes. To improve benchmark reliability, Vero also includes an audit mechanism where agents are allowed to formally prove unsatisfiability of provided specification or incorrectness of reference code, which surfaces and corrects latent code and specification errors during curation. We evaluate frontier coding-agent configurations with Lean toolchain access. The strongest agent fully solves only 27 of 43 instances and closes no specifications on the hardest repositories. Vero provides a concrete testbed for measuring progress toward repository-scale verified software synthesis, where current agents still fall short. We release the benchmark, curation pipeline, and evaluation harness at https://github.com/sunblaze-ucb/vero.

0.54

Seal, Then Sample: Sampled Layerwise Proofs for Verifiable LLM Inference from GPT-2 to 70B

cs.CR cs.IR ·2026-09-23 ·Youki Lim, Sam Yong
code/data similarity 0.67
Abstract · 15 pages, 4 figures, 8 tables. Raw experiment logs and data tables: https://github.com/TrueOpen/slp-experiments

Verifying outsourced language-model inference requires a precisely identified computation and an audit whose cost a service can afford. We present Sampled Layerwise Proofs (SLP), a protocol and prototype that commits the boundary activations of every chunk of an inference trace, absorbs all commitments before any challenge is drawn, and then proves a verifier-selected subset of chunks together with the chunks that bind the prompt and the answer. Audit coverage becomes a runtime parameter over one set of commitments: on a TinyLlama-1.1B trace, proving seven of 47 chunks takes 22.0% of the time and 6.8% of the proof size of proving all 47. Because proof cost is dominated by weights rather than tokens, SLP packs concurrent requests into one trace under a block-diagonal causal mask and binds the prompt and answer of each request to its slot. Twelve packed requests are proved in 181.9 s, 6.5 times less than twelve separate proofs at the measured single-proof cost, and a simulated service proves twelve requests at 30.6 s per request with 0.6 s of verification each, rejecting a tampered answer. Disk-backed integer weights and streamed polynomial commitments let a single Llama-2-70B run complete on a 2 TB CPU host: 163 chunks sealed, five proved, a 4.34 MiB proof in 1,259 s, verified in 46.3 s without the weights. The proven object is a fixed-point canonical model; we trace a severe fidelity loss to the residual-stream bit width, repair it with an LLM-aware observer, and measure 84.8-84.9% argmax agreement with the floating-point reference over 334,705 WikiText-2 test positions. The limits are stated as precisely: guarantees cover proven chunks only, a fixed invalid chunk in the 70B setting is covered with probability 3/161, a manifest-only Fiat-Shamir schedule can be ground at 12.5 ms per attempt and needs an externally ordered challenge, and all measurements use a test reference string.

0.59

From Sorry to QED: Refining LLM Math Proofs via Angelic Execution

cs.AI ·2026-11-17 ·Yanju Chen, Hanzhi Liu, Ruizhe Qian, Jiaming Shan, Xu Yang +3 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) can now generate Lean proof scripts that capture the high-level structure of many mathematical arguments. However, these scripts frequently fail on complex theorems: a single missing side condition or misapplied lemma can cause the prover to abort early and discard an otherwise viable proof outline. This paper presents MathEye, a framework that converts imperfect LLM-generated proof scripts into fully verified Lean proofs by combining symbolic reasoning with minimal human interaction. At the core of MathEye is angelic proof checking, an optimistic execution model that replaces failing proof fragments with placeholders while preserving the overall structure of the argument. This optimistic check produces an angelic proof that isolates the exact proof obligations that the LLM fails to discharge. Because these unresolved obligations are often logically interdependent, asking a mathematician to address every placeholder directly is inefficient. To minimize human effort, MathEye performs residual analysis over a proof dependence graph that captures symbol-level data flow in the angelic proof. By formulating obligation selection as a MaxSAT optimization problem, MathEye selects a minimal-cost set of essential obligations whose resolution suffices to complete the entire proof. MathEye presents these essential obligations to the mathematician in ordinary mathematical language and uses the mathematician's answers to automatically reconstruct the complete Lean proof. Experiments on 30 real-world benchmarks across analysis and algebra show that MathEye solves 93.3% of the problems while reducing the number of required user interactions by 55%.

0.05

How Powerful are LLMs in Generating Formal Program Specifications?

cs.SE ·2026-08-13 ·Fanpeng Yang, Xing Li, Shuling Wang, Jie An, Zeyu Sun +5 more
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract

Formal verification provides strong guarantees of software correctness, but its adoption is limited by the high cost of writing precise formal specifications. While recent large language models (LLMs) have shown strong capabilities in theorem proving and verified code generation, their true ability to generate program specifications remains unclear. Existing evaluations require either verifying implementation conformance or proving semantic equivalence between specifications, both of which are formidably difficult and may conflate proof difficulty with specification quality. To address this problem, we introduce Coins, a Rocq based evaluation framework that assesses specification quality by instantiating specifications under evaluation on trusted test cases and generating concrete proof obligations. This design aligns with the asymmetric nature of formal reasoning, where successful proofs provide reliable evidence while proof failures are inherently ambiguous. Using Coins, we conduct a large scale study on HumanEval with a curated set of human written Rocq specifications. Our results show that specification generation remains a formidable challenge, and that verification complexity can obscure genuine differences in specification quality. Overall, we find that accurate specification evaluation, rather than model scaling alone, is central to understanding the power of LLMs for specification synthesis, and that test case based formal reasoning offers a more faithful and discriminative measure of progress.

0.37

Confidence-Guided Protocol IR for LLM-Aided Security Protocol Modeling

cs.CR ·2026-09-29 ·Siqi Li, Yufan Cai, Hongshu Wang, Xinyue Zuo, Zhe Hou +1 more
code/data similarity 0.65
Abstract

Large language models offer a promising interface for translating natural-language protocol descriptions into formal security models, but their outputs remain difficult to trust without expert validation. In this paper, we present a human-in-the-loop framework for generating Tamarin-verifiable formal models of security protocols. Our key observation is that the main correctness bottleneck is the semantic accuracy rather than the syntactic validity of the intermediate protocol representation. To address this problem, we introduce a protocol intermediate representation (IR) that serves as a human-auditable semantic checkpoint between natural-language parsing and formal model generation. The IR explicitly captures protocol participants, message flows, value provenance, cryptographic operations, proof targets, and compromise assumptions. We further design an interactive interface that highlights uncertain fields and guides users to inspect the most critical semantic decisions based on model confidence before model generation. Rather than replacing formal-methods experts, our approach uses LLMs to produce auditable semantic drafts while leveraging verification tools to check the resulting formal models. Code and verification artifacts are available at https://github.com/laplace1002/TamarinAgent.git.

0.25

Maestro: Agentic Formal Proof Development by Coordination

cs.LG ·2026-10-19 ·Haoyu Li, Zeren Shui, Yuhao Zhang, Ferhat Erata, Benjamin Mikek +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract

Lean is increasingly used to verify mathematical proofs and software produced by LLM agents, but writing formal proofs remains hard. Existing prover systems take a divide-and-conquer approach that recursively decomposes hard proof goals into easier lemmas and splits again any lemma that resists proof. However, a lemma can resist proof for different reasons, including insufficient guidance, a false statement, or a flaw in the decomposition that produced it. Existing systems cannot tell these apart as a failed attempt reports little beyond its failure, and responses are confined to the failing node without considering the rest of the proof or revising the plan above it. The system may thus keep decomposing obligations along a flawed proof direction until the budget runs out, causing the whole proof attempt to fail. We introduce Maestro, a Lean prover harness that handles failures through global coordination. Provers report why they failed, not just that they failed, and a coordinator that sees the whole proof chooses an appropriate response, such as guiding a stuck prover, correcting a false lemma, or retracting a flawed subtree and replanning it. The same harness extends to verified code synthesis, where a checked counterexample sends the code back for repair. We evaluate Maestro with four frontier LLMs on seven mathematics and three software verification benchmarks. It proves more targets than each model's native coding agent (Claude Code or Codex) on every benchmark the agent has not already saturated, with the largest gains on research-level mathematics. With Claude Opus 5, it discovers its own proofs of 34 of the 48 theorems in the June 2026 release of arXivLean, against 19 for the native agent. It also outperforms all published prover systems on every benchmark they share, solving 669/672 PutnamBench, 59/60 Lean-IMO-Bench, and 6/6 IMO 2026.

0.37