CS Paper Radar

MechBench: Can AI Scientific Agents Discover Mechanisms Beyond Phenomenal Laws?

Zihan Yu, Jiadong Zhang, Jialin Cheng, Jingtao Ding, Yong Li

cs.AI cs.LGcs.SC ·submitted 2026-09-28 16:08 UTC · v1
benchmark

Abstract

Scientific discovery requires not only recovering mathematical laws that describe observable behavior, but also identifying the mechanisms that generate them. Existing benchmarks for symbolic regression and scientific agents primarily evaluate phenomenal-law recovery, leaving mechanism discovery largely untested. We introduce MechBench, a benchmark that explicitly separates these two capabilities. Each task is defined by a mechanistic model, a structured set of scientifically meaningful relations whose joint consequences entail an observable phenomenal law, while agents receive only observational data and scientific context. We evaluate mechanism recovery through mechanism probes, which query internal scientific consequences that cannot be inferred from the phenomenal law alone. To reduce reliance on memorized textbook mechanisms, we construct unfamiliar variants through controlled, scientifically interpretable mutations of canonical mechanisms, and screen for mechanistic indistinguishability to exclude ambiguous instances admitting comparable competing mechanisms. Experiments across representative scientific agents reveal a substantial phenomenal--mechanism recovery gap: for Codex with GPT-5.6-sol, phenomenal-law accuracy reaches 35.00% on the Core-set while mechanism accuracy is only 13.75%, with mechanism recovery failing in 64.29% of cases where the phenomenal law is correctly recovered. The gap widens as mechanisms become increasingly mutated, and even providing the correct phenomenal law leaves mechanism recovery below 50%. These results reveal a substantial generalization gap in mechanistic reasoning and establish mechanism discovery as a distinct challenge beyond recovering observable scientific laws.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Mechanist: AI as a Scientific Instrument for Discovering the Mechanisms of Intelligence

cs.AI cs.CLcs.HCcs.LG+1 ·2026-08-12 ·Mengru Wang, Junfeng Fang, Shuofei Qiao, Zhenqian Xu, Haoming Xu +15 more
similarity 0.77
Abstract · Work in progress

AI models are increasingly used in scientific discovery and human decision-making. Yet how AI models work and what risks they pose remain poorly understood. As AI development becomes faster and more automated, research on the mechanisms underlying AI remains largely manual. To bridge this gap, we introduce Mechanist, an agentic system that uses AI as a scientific instrument for the autonomous discovery of mechanisms underlying AI. To ground novel mechanism hypotheses, we construct a scientific knowledge graph of 13,000 studies on AI mechanisms, alongside a multidisciplinary database of 43 million papers spanning 26 fields. For reliable experiment execution, we curate a library of 32 foundational methods for mechanism analysis. Compared with Claude Code and existing AI-scientist systems, Mechanist generates higher-quality mechanism hypotheses and executes experiments more reliably. Across four case studies, Mechanist autonomously discovers new model behaviors and their underlying mechanisms, and translates these discoveries into mechanism-guided interventions and interdisciplinary design. Specifically, Mechanist first uncovers a counterintuitive safety risk in scientific laboratories, showing that unsafe traits can transfer to fine-tuned student models through apparently safe training data and emerge across modalities. Mechanist then develops a mechanism theory of belief, revealing how models represent world knowledge, form beliefs, infer the beliefs of others, and how these mechanisms emerge during pretraining. Building on this theory, Mechanist develops targeted interventions that improve model performance across diverse scenarios. Finally, Mechanist can also advance interdisciplinary discovery through mechanistic design, providing an alternative to the computationally intensive generate-and-rerank paradigm.

0.38

From Scientific Observations to Mechanisms: Benchmarking Hypothesis Generation by AI Scientists

cs.AI ·2026-10-04 ·Xiaxun Xie, Qingqing Long, Meng Xiao, Wei Ju, Yuanchun Zhou +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.76
Abstract

Data-driven mechanistic hypotheses are essential to scientific discovery because they explain how underlying processes produce observed phenomena. AI agents and AI scientists increasingly support scientific data analysis. However, their ability to turn empirical findings into mechanistic hypotheses remains insufficiently examined. To address this gap, we introduce MechHypoBench, the first benchmark for evaluating whether AI agents and AI scientists can generate such hypotheses from empirical data. It combines paper-derived mechanisms from 14 scientific fields with real-world datasets containing 17.98 million records. The construction retains the observational complexity of empirical data while providing a specified underlying mechanism. Agents analyze the observations and propose open-form hypotheses. We develop an evaluation framework that assesses open-form mechanistic hypotheses through their consequences under withheld conditions. Experiments with general agents and AI scientists reveal a substantial gap between generated hypotheses and the underlying mechanisms.

0.16

EurekaBench: Measuring Agentic Ability to Discover New Scientific Insights

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-09-30 ·Jiayi Geng, Zhengxuan Wu, Kevin S. Chen, Seungone Kim, Joseph Janssen +10 more
benchmarkhighly cited similarity 0.72
Abstract

When Isaac Newton discovered the law of gravitation, he did so through an iterative process of analyzing observed data such as planetary patterns, finding the underlying mechanisms by describing patterns in mathematical equations, and refining his theory against the Moon's orbit, revealing the startling insight that the same force governs both falling apples and orbiting planets. Would it be possible for AI agents to make similar discoveries? To measure this ability, we introduce EurekaBench, a cross-domain benchmark that tests AI agents' ability to conduct long-horizon experiments and discover mechanisms that explain observations. We evaluate these mechanisms by the scientific insights that can be derived from them. EurekaBench contains an expert-verified set of 26 long-horizon tasks across neuroscience, computer science, chemistry, astrophysics, geophysics, and plasma physics, with a total of 306 scientific insights that the discovered mechanisms are expected to support. Our evaluation framework tests three axes of scientific discovery: agents' ability to follow known scientific constraints, the predictive accuracy of the discovered mechanisms, and whether these mechanisms yield scientific insights or inform future research. Our results show that current AI agents often overly fixate on predictive accuracy optimization, surpassing human scientists, while falling substantially short in deriving scientific insights.

0.47

SciGame: Let Agents Play the Scientific Discovery Games in the Real and Counterfactual World

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-10-27 ·Yusheng Zhao, Bowei He, Xue Liu, Mingxiao Li
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract · 25 pages, 11 figures, 9 tables

Large language model agents are increasingly used for scientific discovery. However, existing benchmarks mix law inference with programming, score data fitting instead of prediction on unseen inputs, and do not separate empirical evidence from pretrained priors. We introduce SciGame, a controlled benchmark that converts scientific literature into structured scientific cards. Each card yields a pair of Original and dimensionally consistent Counterfactual environments with the same task interface. SciGame contains a Historical collection of canonical laws and a live Temporal collection curated from papers published after model knowledge cutoffs. It evaluates agents in candidate-guided Identification and open-ended Discovery settings. Each setting runs under Prior-only, Fixed, and Adaptive protocols. Experiments on five frontier models yield three findings. First, familiar priors hurt performance once the governing relation is altered. Second, adaptive experimentation helps the strongest models but harms weaker ones under limited budgets. Third, good explanations can hide quantitative failures. Recovering the exact symbolic form remains the main bottleneck, even when agents interpret evidence correctly. Current agents can investigate systems actively, but inducing exact laws in unfamiliar settings remains an open challenge.

0.23

Can LLMs Discover Scientific Laws in Real and Parallel Worlds?

cs.AI cs.LG ·2026-09-01 ·Yiming Huang, Ziche Liu, Junxia Cui, Zhuohang Wu, Yiqian Wang +9 more
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract · 41 pages, 14 figures

Scientific law discovery has long been central to scientific progress, proceeding through iterative cycles of generating hypotheses, testing them against empirical evidence, and refining them under scientific constraints. As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly involved in scientific research, whether they can discover scientific laws and how to evaluate this ability remain open questions. A central evaluation challenge is to move beyond familiar published equations while keeping discovery tasks grounded in scientific data and constraints. We introduce SciLaws-Bench, a curated collection of scientific task packages grounded in the source literature, each linking a scientific problem, supporting data, published reference equations, and scientific-validity rubrics. Through agent-assisted curation and human verification, we assemble 118 problems spanning six disciplines, drawing on 381 papers, 291 candidate laws, and roughly 8M data points. Each problem supports two complementary evaluation settings. SciLaws-Real uses fixed scientific data to evaluate proposed laws for held-out predictive fit and scientific validity. SciLaws-Parallel evaluates recovery of a newly synthesized structural variant of a published equation through active queries to a simulator calibrated to the source data. Our evaluation reveals three limitations: good predictive fit need not imply scientific validity, recovering a published formula does not establish recovery of its new structural terms, and candidate selection remains a bottleneck in scientific law discovery. Project page: https://yiyihum.github.io/SciLaws-Bench

0.59

SRHarness: A Harness for Agentic Symbolic Regression

cs.AI cs.LGcs.SC ·2026-09-28 ·Zihan Yu, Shixuan Zhou, Hao Huang, Jingtao Ding, Yong Li
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Recent agentic symbolic regression approaches increasingly rely on large language models to analyze data, select scientific operations, and refine hypotheses over long search trajectories. In such systems, performance depends not only on the underlying model and search strategy, but also on the runtime infrastructure that supports scientific search. We introduce SRHarness, a domain-specific harness for agentic symbolic regression built around three mechanisms: composable scientific actions that provide a common interface over raw, transformed, and candidate-derived quantities; persistent scientific state that retains evaluated hypotheses and exposes compact model-facing views; and trajectory lifecycle management that coordinates continuation, branching, restart, and termination. On LLM-SRBench, SRHarness consistently improves both numerical generalization and symbolic recovery under matched LLM backbones. With DeepSeek-v4-flash-0731, it achieves 93.69% symbolic accuracy on LSR-Transform, compared with 62.16% for SR-Scientist, and retains 72.97% accuracy on an anonymized variant that removes scientific descriptions and variable semantics, versus 39.64% for SR-Scientist. Under the same DeepSeek-v4-flash-0731 backbone, SRHarness also substantially outperforms Codex (72.97% vs. 20.72%) and reaches performance comparable to Codex with GPT-5.5, while simply providing Codex with the same scientific tools does not reproduce this advantage. These results show that effective agentic symbolic regression depends not only on models or tools, but also on structured runtime support for organizing scientific actions, accumulated hypotheses, and long-horizon search.

0.21

Science sandboxes measure the scientific capability of AI agents

cs.AI q-bio.QM ·2026-08-31 ·Arya S. Rao, Rodrigo I. Castro, Sager J. Gosai, Kenneth B. Hsu, Yasha Ektefaie +6 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 72 pages, 5 main figures, 3 tables, and 5 supplementary figures; includes supplementary agent instructions and harness

Scientific progress depends not only on finding solutions, but on learning the rules that explain why they work and using that understanding to design better experiments. We introduce science sandboxes, a framework for studying this capability in AI agents through repeated cycles of experimentation, feedback, and hypothesis revision. Science sandboxes invite an agent to query the natural world in different ways, ranging from "wet" physical experiments, to "damp" predictive models trained on empirical data, to "dry" invented rules. By establishing a common experimental loop and a protocol for evaluating agents within it, science sandboxes allow assessment of both quantitative performance on specific metrics and qualitative scientific reasoning, across a spectrum of empirical verifiability. Here, we instantiate this framework in two biological settings, models of regulatory genomics and protein fitness prediction, and examine the capabilities of frontier agents. Across these settings, we could see when agents successfully optimized a quantitative metric without understanding the rules underlying the system. In particular, their scientific reasoning deteriorated when they encountered systems whose rules fell outside familiar biological priors. By highlighting such failure modes, science sandboxes make the frontier of scientific capability measurable and provide a controlled setting in which to study and ultimately expand it.

0.41

Minimum Description Length Unsupervisedly Separates Law-Grade from Statistical-Grade Knowledge in a Self-Improving Science Agent - and Reveals 86% of Its Own Discoveries Are Statistical

cs.AI ·2026-10-23 ·Wenbin Mao, Pei Zou
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 6 pages, 2 figures. Companion paper: arXiv:2610.14843

AI systems that discover scientific relations now generate candidate "laws" at scale, but the bottleneck has shifted from generation to vetting: which candidates deserve belief? We show that a deployed self-improving science agent - one that has admitted 252 relations through held-out prediction courts - already computes the quantity that answers this question: the Minimum Description Length compression ratio used for model selection doubles, when read under discrete accounting, as an unsupervised epistemic grader. The compression-ranked top band of the agent's ledger recovers exactly the canonical laws among its discoveries (vis-viva across seven planets, Balmer/Rydberg) plus cross-measurement identities - enrichment $p=3.6\times10^{-12}$ under a hypergeometric test - with zero counterexamples and physically coherent band structure. The same lens retroactively reveals that 86% of the ledger compresses nothing ($\mathrm{cr}\approx 1$): the agent had been recording statistical regularities, including a learned predictor with held-out $R^2=0.541$ admitted through the prediction gate, under a narrative of compression as the unified value of knowledge - a narrative that was never true for them. We formalize the resulting dual-axis bookkeeping - prediction value ($R^2$) and compression value (cr) as nearly decoupled axes of knowledge - demonstrate its robustness to quantization, and register forward falsifiable predictions. The episode is, to our knowledge, the first measured instance of a discovery agent auditing its own knowledge ledger by an internal measure and finding itself over-claiming.

0.17