CS Paper Radar

Resource versus Responsiveness: Benchmarking SDN Controller Runtimes for a Moving-Target-Defense Control Plane at Scale

Souhail Chakkour, Umesh Biswas, Charan Gudla

cs.NI ·submitted 2026-09-28 16:38 UTC · v1

Abstract

Network Moving Target Defense (MTD) built on Software-Defined Networking (SDN) continuously rotates host-facing addresses to invalidate an attacker's reconnaissance. Each rotation creates a burst of control-plane mutations, while new connections may simultaneously require reactive flow installation. Yet SDN controller runtime is usually treated as an implementation detail in the MTD literature. We show that it materially affects performance. We port the same Continuity-Preserving Address Mutation (CPAM) logic to three widely used controllers: Ryu (single-threaded cooperative Python), OpenDaylight, and ONOS (both multi-threaded JVM), and evaluate them on an identical 500-host campus fabric using an RFC 8456-aligned methodology with ten runs per controller. All three provide near-zero loss, sub-millisecond jitter, and preserve established sessions, but their control-plane behavior differs sharply. OpenDaylight and ONOS keep reactive latency low and stable, whereas Ryu serializes reactive flow installation behind periodic rotation work, increasing reactive RTT by about 100x and causing a small number of setup-time failures. Ryu uses far less memory, while ONOS achieves OpenDaylight-class reactive latency with the lowest CPU utilization of the three and a smaller live heap than OpenDaylight. These results expose distinct resource-versus-responsiveness operating points and show that controller selection should be treated as a first-class design decision in SDN-based MTD.

Comment
Preprint. 8 figures, 3 tables. Extends our preliminary DSN-S 2026 work on CPAM with a three-controller evaluation of Ryu, OpenDaylight, and ONOS on a 500-host SDN testbed

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Rethinking Software-Defined Networking Link Discovery with Dynamic Randomization

cs.NI cs.CR ·2026-09-13 ·Mingming Chen, Teryl Taylor, Frederico Araujo, Benjamin E. Ujcich, Thomas La Porta +1 more
code/data similarity 0.60
Abstract

Software-defined networking (SDN) separates the control and data planes, enabling programmable, centralized network management. A core SDN service is topology discovery --- a periodic process that identifies network links. However, our analysis of five open-source SDN controllers and ten discovery protocols shows that all remain vulnerable to at least one form of link-fabrication attack. The common root cause is their reliance on traditional Link Layer Discovery Protocol (LLDP) packets, whose static identifiers expose their discovery purpose and attract adversaries to exploit them. We propose ChameleonDisc, a dynamic link-discovery protocol that simultaneously prevents and detects topology-poisoning attacks by eliminating this root cause. Our key insight is that an SDN controller can infer topology without embedding meaningful information in discovery packets. ChameleonDisc removes targetable static LLDP signatures and employs a moving-target defense that combines decoy, obfuscation, and camouflage techniques instantiated dynamically at runtime to prevent topology poisoning and detect manipulation. We implement ChameleonDisc on OpenDaylight and demonstrate effectiveness against all identifier-based topology-poisoning attacks. On a 252-link topology, median convergence is 1.37--4.53\,s for legitimate link changes and 4.06\,s for malicious relay detection, with 13.0 percentage points of additional mean CPU and negligible retained-heap difference. Across topologies up to 816 links, ChameleonDisc provides a tunable security--performance trade-off; expanding discovery intervals reduces CPU and mapping state at the cost of increased attack-detection latency.

0.32

Moving Target Defense in SDN-enabled EV Charging Network

cs.CR cs.GTcs.NI ·2026-10-08 ·Roland Plaka, Mikael Asplund, Simin Nadjm-Tehran
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Software-Defined Networking (SDN) is emerging as a promis- ing technology for EV Charging infrastructure (EVCI) since it enables flexible, programmable control of EVCI networks, yet its security gain to EVCI remains underexplored. SDN-enabled EVCI faces an increas- ing number of cyber threats arising from the convergence of IT and OT components; in particular, low-rate Denial-of-Service (DoS) attacks. Ear- lier works identify a trend toward low-rate attacks in OT networks that may exhaust SDN switch flow tables and which can result in disabling the entire charging sites without triggering volume-based defenses. In this paper, we propose CS-SHIELD, a Moving Target Defense mecha- nism for SDN-enabled EVCI communication. We showcase the imple- mentation of the proposed mechanism that detects malicious flow table rules via cross-layer identity verification and responds by reassigning virtual IP addresses to all active chargers. Experiments on an emulated SDN testbed with a real charging protocol implementation demonstrate that CS-SHIELD maintains full site availability under attack, responds quickly, adds only a negligible delay under normal conditions. The reas- signing (shuffle) approach at each reaction makes the earlier reconnais- sance knowledge by the attacker rendered worthless.

0.26

Cross-Domain Joint DDoS Detection in Multi-Controller SDN via Confidence-Based Entropy Fusion

cs.CR ·2026-08-18 ·Zhaoyang Zhang, Shen Wang, Xiaofeng Tao
similarity 0.58
Abstract

In multi-controller Software-Defined Networking (SDN), Distributed Denial-of-Service (DDoS) attacks exhibit a "dispersed source, concentrated target" pattern across domains, i.e., attack traffic originates from multiple edge-controller domains but converges on a victim in a single aggregation controller domain. While entropy-based DDoS detectors are effective in single-controller settings, their direct application in multi-controller SDN reveals a previously overlooked anomaly. Through systematic experiments, we identify an aggregation bias: during the post-attack transition phase, the aggregation controller continues to generate excessive false positives, while edge controllers have already returned to normal. We attribute this phenomenon to the coupled effects of OpenFlow statistics lag and unconstrained dynamic-threshold drift. To address this issue, we propose a cross-domain confidence-fusion framework that leverages lightweight edge-side messages to calibrate aggregation-controller decisions without sharing raw traffic data. The framework is non-intrusive, communication-efficient, and incrementally deployable. Experiments on a three-controller linear Mininet testbed with 24 hosts over 10 runs show that the method preserves edge-controller performance while reducing the aggregation false positive rate from 8.87% to 1.96% and increasing the F1 score from 89.04% to 96.89%.

0.24

BALLAST: Physics-Aware Moving Target Defense for Industrial Control Systems Using a Digital Twin Safety Oracle

cs.CR eess.SY ·2026-10-13 ·Oscar Mogollon-Gutierrez, Mohammadhossein Homaei, Alberto Lopez-Trigo, Andres Caro, Mar Avila
theory similarity 0.56
Abstract · 25 Pages, 14 Tables and 7 Figures

Industrial Control Systems run on static network configurations, which leaves an attacker unlimited time to map the plant. Moving Target Defense answers this by shuffling addresses, but almost every published scheme never checks whether the reconfiguration will itself disturb the physical process it protects, so the defense can destabilise a control loop or trip an actuator. We present BALLAST, which places a learned Digital Twin between the security policy and the plant as a safety oracle. A physics-informed LSTM surrogate forecasts the physical effect of a candidate network change, a reinforcement learning agent trades security entropy against process stability, and a connection-draining handover lets in-flight Modbus transactions complete before the old mapping is withdrawn. An explicit shield rejects any action whose predicted trajectory would leave the safe operating envelope. On the SWaT water treatment testbed, Ballast cut the success rate of an adversary's reconnaissance sweep by 85 percent and recorded no safety violation across 50 runs, a 95 percent upper bound of 5.8 percent on the violation rate, against five violations and a tracking error 19 times larger for RL-MTD, the closest published analogue to our design. Measured against the strongest baseline on the physical metrics, a threshold-triggered scheme that itself records one violation rather than RL-MTD's five, Ballast still improves the tracking error by a factor of 2.5 and removes that remaining violation. The gain costs a small and deliberate concession in raw deterrence. Twin inference meets the 50 ms budget on a workstation core and an embedded GPU, and is projected to meet it on both edge CPUs when the three envelope stages are evaluated in a single batched call; the complete decision-to-enforcement path was measured only on the workstation.

0.27

NetConfArena: An Executable Benchmark for LLM Agents in Closed-Loop Network Configuration

cs.NI cs.AI ·2026-08-24 ·Chang Liu, Xiaohui Xie, Xinyi Chen, Yong Cui
benchmark similarity 0.56
Abstract

Large language model (LLM) agents are increasingly attractive for automating network configuration, yet their reliability and failure patterns are poorly understood. An essential prerequisite is to assess such agents in a realistic but risk-free environment. Existing benchmarks, however, fall short: they often treat configuration as static command generation or rely on overly simplified settings. Such evaluations understate the core challenges of network configuration, where correctness requires reasoning about protocol complexity and topology dependence. We present NetConfArena, an executable benchmark for evaluating LLM agents in closed-loop network configuration. NetConfArena places agents in emulated multi-device networks, provides a standardized and compact action interface for task execution, and evaluates the resulting network behavior with hidden task-specific executable test cases. The benchmark relies on an LLM-assisted, emulation-grounded pipeline, which converts human-oriented network materials into reusable parameterized task templates. We evaluate representative LLM agents on 480 task instances instantiated from 96 protocol-focused task templates, yielding 3840 execution trajectories, and show that failures are not limited to command errors. The failures also reveal gaps in task-specification adherence and robust planning and execution. These findings suggest two future directions: using validated trajectories as supervision signals to improve foundation models, and designing harness mechanisms that make agent execution more reliable and accountable.

0.38

Crossing the Cyber Divide: Sim-to-Sim and Sim-to-Real Transfer for RL Agents

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-09-30 ·Sabrina Saika, Yinuo Du, Aritran Piplai
code/data similarity 0.54
Abstract · 13 pages, 3 figures, 1st Workshop on Real-world AI Security and Engineering for Cybersecurity Systems (RAISE) 2026

Cyber attack agents are typically trained and evaluated within a single simulator, making it unclear whether learned policies transfer beyond the environments in which they were developed. This limitation hinders both deployment and fair comparison, as cyber simulators differ substantially in their state representations, observation models, and action spaces. In this paper, we study policy transfer across cyber environments and argue that simulator-to-simulator and simulator-to-real transfer can be viewed as instances of the same underlying alignment problem. We propose a framework that separates state alignment from action translation, enabling a policy trained in one environment to operate in another without retraining. We evaluate transfer across four cyber platforms, CyberBattleSim, NetSecGame, CyberWheel, and NASim, including emulated deployments in NASim. Our experiments show that zero-shot transfer is feasible, fully preserving source-policy performance in closely aligned environments and achieving 45.2% win rates when transferring policies whose source performance is 60.5%. In emulated virtual machine environments, transferred policies exhibit a Jensen-Shannon divergence of 0.085 from native policies, indicating strong behavioral similarity. Code and benchmarks are available at: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/RL-Transfer-between-env-4F47/.

0.62

DYNAS: A Dynamic Network Penetration Testing Framework Using Deep Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning

cs.CR cs.LGcs.NI ·2026-10-29 ·Md. Rakibul Hassan, Majedul Islam, Md. Ashraful Alam, Muhammad Iqbal Hossain, Swakkhar Shatabda
published similarity 0.54
Abstract · Accepted at the NSS 2026: 20th International Conference on Network and System Security (submission version)

As network scale and uncertainty complicate automated penetration testing, reinforcement learning (RL) environments must support controlled evaluation under defensive and non-stationary conditions. We present DYNAS (Dynamic Network Attack Simulator), which combines parameterized large-scale scenario generation with stateful intrusion detection responses, explicit scan false-positive and false-negative noise, temporary service unavailability, and duration-based action timeouts. We further introduce Pen-DHRL, a recurrent manager--worker policy that selects persistent subgoals using IDS-conditioned global context. We compare Pen-DHRL with GNN, Invariant, and Attention baselines across four scenario variants and multiple training regimes. Under IDS-disabled training followed by IDS-enabled evaluation, Pen-DHRL obtains approximately 64\% and 24\% higher reward per step on Bridge and Dynamic, respectively, and approximately 26\% and 30\% more captured hosts on VarA and VarB than the next-best baseline. With all defensive dynamics active from the beginning of training, Pen-DHRL achieves positive mean episode returns in all four scenarios, whereas the flat baselines produce negative mean returns in all 12 architecture--scenario combinations; staged curriculum training produces positive mean returns across all 16 evaluated combinations.

0.36

NosRacer: Dynamic Detection of Race Conditions in On-Device Network Operating Systems

cs.DC cs.SE ·2026-10-08 ·Runze Wu, Jingbo Zhai, Shanming Ping, Lingzhi Ouyang, Hua Duan +6 more
published similarity 0.54
Abstract · 18 pages, 5 figures, 6 tables. Accepted to SIGOPS ATC 2026

Commercial on-device network operating systems (NOSes) run the complex control planes of production routers and switches, where configuration update tasks are executed by multiple loosely coupled components through asynchronous message passing. Such executions are prone to race conditions: the same ordered input commands may produce different outcomes when messages are delivered in different orders. The race conditions are difficult to expose because they often manifest only as subtle, delayed malfunctions. Existing static analysis techniques lack scalability and precision for large-scale industrial NOSes, while dynamic ones incur substantial system-execution cost when attempting to cover the space of asynchronous message interleavings. To address the challenges above, we present NosRacer, a dynamic analysis framework for race condition detection in industrial-grade on-device NOSes. NosRacer uses a two-phase design. The concentration phase reduces analysis scope by leveraging the locality of configuration update tasks. Race condition detection is then limited to a small subset of involved components and crucial state variables, thereby reducing the detection cost. The perturbation phase proactively perturbs message asynchrony to increase the likelihood of executions with race-condition-exposing message interleavings. It keeps perturbation practical by grouping compatible perturbations for parallel execution and adaptively strengthening perturbations. We implement NosRacer in a commercial, actively developed NOS. NosRacer is integrated into the existing testing factory and used to detect race conditions in 5 key control-plane components. NosRacer achieves 66% precision and detects 21 race conditions confirmed by developers as severe bugs, while keeping the detection overhead below 10%.

0.34