CS Paper Radar

Exact Hill Shares Are Simultaneous Guarantees

Bo Li, Hanyu Li, Chenghua Liu

cs.GT ·submitted 2026-09-18 07:09 UTC · v1
benchmarktheory

Abstract

Fair division of indivisible bads seeks allocations that guarantee every agent a bundle whose cost is no larger than a meaningful fairness benchmark. The canonical minimax share has widely been used; unfortunately, it is not a simultaneous guarantee. Hill (Ann. Probab., 1987) initiated a complementary approach in which the share depends only on the number of agents and the largest possible single-item value. Li et al. (ACM Trans. Econ. Comput., 2024) gave the exact Hill formula and proved that its monotone closure is a simultaneous guarantee. The closure treats the largest-item cost only as an upper bound and can be strictly larger than the share conditioned on the \emph{actual} largest item. They asked whether this smaller exact share is itself simultaneously guaranteed for three or more agents. We resolve this open question affirmatively. For any number of agents and arbitrary heterogeneous largest-item costs, there is one allocation that satisfies every agent's exact Hill's share. We further provide a polynomial-time algorithm computes such an allocation. Our algorithm combines an ordered moving knife with a tail-domination invariant, and a one-sided trimmed subset-sum routine for the two-agent endpoint without computing an exact minimax partition.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Improving the Bounds on Approximating Weighted Maximin Share for Chores

cs.GT cs.AI ·2026-10-11 ·Trung Thanh Nguyen, Khaled Elbassioni, Jörg Rothe
similarity 0.76
Abstract

We investigate the problem of allocating indivisible chores among agents with arbitrary positive weights and additive nonnegative cost functions. An allocation is said to be $α$-weighted-maximin-share (WMMS) fair if the cost incurred by each agent is at most $α$ times her weighted maximin share. We establish that every instance admits a $4.124234528$-WMMS allocation. Moreover, for instances in which all weights and costs are rational numbers represented in binary, we give an algorithm that computes a $4.12424$-WMMS allocation in time polynomial in the number of agents, the number of chores, and the total binary encoding length of the input. Complementing these upper bounds, we construct a family of instances with strictly positive, identically ordered costs for which the optimal WMMS approximation factors converge to $e$. Together, our results substantially narrow the previously best-known gap of $[2,12]$ established by Li et al.~\cite{LWX26} to $[e,4.12424]$.

0.15

Pairwise Maximin Share Allocations Need Not Exist

cs.GT ·2026-09-05 ·Haris Aziz
similarity 0.74
Abstract

We study the fair allocation of indivisible goods among agents with strictly positive additive valuations. Pairwise maximin share fairness (PMMS) asks that, for every ordered pair of agents, the first agent value her own bundle at least as highly as the best worst-case share she could secure by repartitioning the two agents' combined bundles into two parts. Whether a PMMS allocation always exists for positive additive valuations has remained open since the notion was introduced. We resolve this question in the negative. We construct an instance with four agents and strictly positive additive valuations that admits no complete PMMS allocation.

0.43

On best of both worlds allocations with subadditive valuations

cs.GT ·2026-09-27 ·Uriel Feige
theory similarity 0.73
Abstract

We consider allocation of indivisible goods to agents with equal entitlements and subadditive valuations. As an ex-post fairness notion we consider the maximin share (MMS), and as an ex-ante fairness notion we consider the maximum expectation share (MES), which is always at least as large as the MMS, and sometimes much larger. We present a simple transformation that for every $0 < ρ\le 1$, given any algorithm that produces $ρ$-MMS allocations, transforms it into a randomized allocation algorithm that offers $ρ$-MMS ex-post simultaneously with $η$-MES ex-ante. We prove several new properties of MES, and use them to show that $η\ge \min[\fracρ{2 + ρ}, \frac{1}{4}]$. We also present cases in which the transformation results in a higher value of $η$. Applying our transformation to currently known allocation algorithms shows for subadditive valuations the existence of randomized allocations that are simultaneously $Ω(\frac{1}{\log\log n})$-MES ex-ante and $Ω(\frac{1}{\log\log n})$-MMS ex-post, and for XOS valuations the existence of randomized allocations that are simultaneously $\frac{4}{27}$-MES ex-ante and $\frac{4}{17}$-MMS ex-post.

0.26

Exact MMS Allocations under Personalized Bivalued Valuations: Goods and Chores

cs.GT cs.DS ·2026-08-16 ·Yuhao Zhang
benchmarktheory similarity 0.73
Abstract

The maximin share (MMS) is a central fairness benchmark for allocating indivisible goods and chores. We study additive valuations in the personalized bivalued setting, where each agent assigns one of two agent-specific values to every item. Whether exact MMS allocations always exist in this setting has remained a major open question, as highlighted by Ebadian, Peters, and Shah and by Garg, Huang, and Segal-Halevi. We answer this question affirmatively: we prove that exact MMS allocations always exist for both goods and chores and can be computed in polynomial time. Our proof combines a quota-based reformulation with an envelope relaxation, a sparse extreme-point construction, and flow-based rounding that controls the total rounding loss.

0.40

Improved Impossibility Bounds for Maximin Share Allocations

cs.GT ·2026-09-14 ·Tomer Ezra, Tamar Garbuz
benchmarkhighly cited similarity 0.72
Abstract

The maximin share (MMS) is a central fairness benchmark for allocating indivisible items, but it need not be simultaneously attainable even under additive preferences. While extensive work has developed approximation guarantees, quantitative impossibility bounds have received comparatively little attention. We establish improved asymptotic and constant impossibility bounds for both goods and chores. For every sufficiently large number $n$ of agents, we construct additive goods instances in which every allocation gives some agent at most a $1-Ω((\log n)^{-2})$ fraction of her MMS. This strengthens the $1/n^4$ shortfall of Feige, Sapir, and Tauber (2021) to an inverse-polylogarithmic shortfall. For chores, we construct instances in which every allocation gives some agent cost at least a $1+Ω((\log n)^{-2})$ factor of her MMS. Consequently, for every fixed $\varepsilon>0$, guarantees of $1-O(n^{-\varepsilon})$ for goods and $1+O(n^{-\varepsilon})$ for chores are impossible. Both asymptotic constructions use $n+O(\log n)$ items. Together with concurrent existence results of Feige (2026), this determines the threshold $n+Θ(\log n)$ for guaranteed MMS existence under additive preferences, for both goods and chores. We also give four-agent, eleven-item instances that improve the universal impossibility bounds from $39/40$ to $20/21$ for goods and from $44/43$ to $31/30$ for chores.

0.40

Online Fair Division with Upgrade Recourse

cs.GT ·2026-10-12 ·Yichen Huang, Nicholas Teh
highly cited similarity 0.72
Abstract

We study the online fair division of indivisible goods. In the standard model, where assignments are irrevocable, no algorithm can guarantee any positive fraction of the maximin share (MMS). Reassigning earlier goods can restore fairness, but it may take value away from agents who already hold them. We ask how much fairness can be maintained if every reassignment must leave each affected agent at least as well off. We consider two forms of such upgrade recourse. Under item-level upgrades, each good an agent holds must be kept or replaced by a distinct good she values at least as much; under bundle-level upgrades, only her total value must not decrease. For item-level upgrades, we show that the optimal MMS factor is essentially $1/H_n \approx 1/\ln n$, where $H_n$ is the $n$-th harmonic number, and that fixed picking sequences nearly attain it. Since these sequences use only the agents' rankings of individual goods, knowing the actual values cannot improve the optimal factor for up to 33 agents, and improves it by at most a vanishing margin as $n$ grows. Bundle-level upgrades allow substantially stronger guarantees. By permitting several-for-one exchanges, they turn this vanishing factor into a constant: we achieve exact MMS for two agents and more than half of MMS for any number of agents, in both cases together with relaxations of envy-freeness. Finally, we show that predictions about future goods let online algorithms inherit any offline MMS guarantee, losing only an additive term bounded by the prediction error. Under item-level upgrades, however, insisting on exact MMS when predictions are correct leaves no positive guarantee when they are wrong.

0.33

Maximin share allocations for two types of items

cs.GT ·2026-10-13 ·Yu Chen, Kai Jie Wong, Xiaorui Zhang
published similarity 0.72
Abstract · A preliminary version was presented at the Fourth IJCAI Workshop on Computational Fair Division [Aug 2026]

We study the fair allocation of indivisible items among $n$ agents with additive valuations (or costs) using the fairness notion of maximin share (MMS). Since MMS allocations do not always exist when $n > 2$, one direction in the literature has been to identify special classes of instances in which exact MMS allocations can be guaranteed. We show that, when items can be divided into two types of chores, MMS allocations always exist and can be computed in polynomial time using a novel geometric approach inspired by prior work in job scheduling. We further discuss how our technique extends to instances with two types of goods, as well as mixed instances consisting of one type of objective good and one type of objective chore.

0.16

Tight Maximin Share Guarantees of EFX and PMMS

cs.GT ·2026-08-31 ·Qinghua Qin
benchmarktheory similarity 0.72
Abstract

In the fair division of indivisible goods among autonomous agents, allocations frequently satisfy strong pairwise fairness criteria while failing to guarantee an agent's full maximin share. Maximin share (MMS) is a global benchmark: the value an agent can guarantee by partitioning all goods into $n$ bundles and receiving her least preferred bundle. In contrast, local pairwise fairness notions---most notably envy-freeness up to any good (EFX) and pairwise maximin share (PMMS)---evaluate fairness through bilateral bundle comparisons. We resolve the open question of determining the optimal universal MMS approximation factor guaranteed by either local notion under nonnegative additive valuations, proving that both factors equal exactly $10/17$. For the lower bound, we show that both EFX and PMMS imply a common local residual inequality: the value of any foreign bundle after removing its least valuable item cannot exceed the focal agent's allocated value. We design a continuous piecewise weight function that converts this local constraint into the global $10/17$ MMS guarantee. The same charging argument establishes that $α$-EFX implies $(10α/17)$-MMS. For tightness, we construct an explicit family of complete allocations that simultaneously satisfy PMMS and EFX$_0$, including comparisons involving zero-valued goods, and whose MMS ratios converge to $10/17$. For each fixed number of agents, we also establish exact reciprocal identities connecting fair division to scheduling: the EFX guarantee is the reciprocal of the pure price of anarchy in selfish identical-machine covering, while the PMMS guarantee is the reciprocal of a locality gap for exact repartition of two machines.

0.38