CS Paper Radar

When Cyber Scoring Systems Diverge: An Empirical Comparison

Kirsi Hellsten, Joni Herttuainen, Ambrose Kam, Arlanda Johnson, David Welsh, Kimmo Kaski

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-29 10:31 UTC · v1

Abstract

Vulnerability scoring systems underpin cyber patch prioritization and risk management, but their comparative behavior is almost always assessed in the abstract, through correlation studies in IT vulnerability databases, rather than by the operational consequences they produce when embedded in a system-level risk model. Here we present an empirical comparison of four vulnerability scoring systems, namely CVSS (Common Vulnerability Scoring System), EPSS (Exploit Prediction Scoring System), SSVC (Stakeholder-Specific-Vulnerability Categorization), and IronMiner (operationally calibrated proprietary scoring system). As a substrate for comparison, we use a reconstruction of the 2015 Ukraine Power Grid operational-technology (OT) network that provides a documented incident topology. The results show a high degree of disagreement between the scoring systems. This suggests that the choice of the scoring system could significantly influence mitigation strategies and vulnerability prioritization, implying that a composite or hybrid scoring approach could offer a more suitable solution.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Ties at the Top: A Point-in-Time Comparison of CVSS and EPSS at a Fixed Budget

cs.CR ·2026-11-17 ·Gianluca Martinuz, Paolo Ceravolo
similarity 0.72
Abstract · 15 pages, 4 figures

Organizations must decide which vulnerabilities warrant further analysis and protective action when the volume of published vulnerabilities exceeds their analytical capacity. We present a methodology for comparing vulnerability-prioritization strategies under an explicit resource constraint, represented by a fixed number of CVEs selected from a common eligible population. We apply this methodology to the Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) and the Exploit Prediction Scoring System (EPSS). For CVEs published in the National Vulnerability Database (NVD) from 17 March to 31 December 2025 and from 1 January to 31 March 2026 (Q1), we reconstruct each CVE's scores and status 30 days after NVD publication, using archived source data. Each cohort has one ranking per strategy at a 5% budget. Positives are CVEs added to the Known Exploited Vulnerabilities (KEV) catalog within 180 days after their decision day. The catalog is maintained by the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA). EPSS captures 16 of 40 positives in 2025, versus 5 for CVSS; alternative selections among tied CVEs cannot raise CVSS capture above 9. In Q1, CVSS captures 4 of 11 and EPSS 3, but tie-breaking can reverse this ordering. The score alone leaves most of each CVSS list undecided: the tie-breaking rule allocates 1,678 of 1,919 CVSS places in 2025 and 589 of 758 in Q1 among CVEs tied at score 9.8. Most chosen CVSS scores come from non-NVD providers; disabling those scores reduces CVSS capture from 5 to 1 in 2025 and from 4 to 0 in Q1. A fixed-budget comparison should therefore report its decision cutoff, eligible population, score provenance, and tie-breaking rule.

0.15

CAPE - Context-Aware Prioritization Engine for Vulnerability Scoring and Management

cs.CR cs.SE ·2026-10-09 ·Rakesh Podder, Viktoria Koscinski, Indrajit Ray
code/data similarity 0.69
Abstract

Vulnerability patching is critical for safeguarding an enterprise's software ecosystem from cyber attacks. However, patching requires adequate preparation for potential system downtime and for unforeseen effects of the patched software on a live system. Thus, effective risk mitigation requires prioritization strategies that explicitly account for the operational context of the affected software. While vulnerability prioritization based on Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS), Exploit Prediction Scoring System (EPSS) and CISA Known Exploited Vulnerabilities (KEV) catalog, can help, their differing goals and methodologies often lead to inconsistent, context-unaware decisions resulting in mis-allocated remediation efforts. In this work, we present the Context-Aware Prioritization Engine (CAPE), a vulnerability analysis framework that enriches each vulnerability scanner report of vulnerabilities (CVEs) with deployment-specific evidence. This evidence is used to perform vulnerability reachability, centrality, and exploitability analysis, producing a ranked priority score for the effective distribution of remediation effort. We evaluate CAPE on 30 open-source agentic applications comprising 6,138 scanner-reported CVEs. Our evaluation shows that a significant majority of CVEs are not reachable and exploitable which results in significant disparities between CAPE and context-free baselines - the CVSS, EPSS, and KEV. It also shows that CAPE consistently surfaces confirmed-exploitable CVEs at higher priority than all baselines, demonstrating that context-aware analysis provides substantially more accurate remediation guidance than context-free severity scoring alone.

0.33

A Digital Twin to Improve Cyber-Social Impact

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-10-20 ·Vita Santa Barletta, Danilo Caivano, Gabriel Cellammare, Andrea Dimauro, Pasquale Mesagna +1 more
top venue similarity 0.64
Abstract · 16 pages, 5 figures

The increasing complexity of Industrial Control Systems (ICS) and their integration with IT infrastructures has significantly expanded the cyber threat landscape. Traditional cybersecurity models, primarily based on the Confidentiality, Integrity, and Availability (CIA triad), fail to capture the broader societal and operational impacts of cyberattacks. This paper proposes a novel framework that integrates Digital Twin technology with a Cyber-Social Security model to simulate, analyze, and quantify cyber threats in critical infrastructures. Virtualized ICS environments built with Mininet and MiniCPS are used to model attack scenarios and assess their consequences across technical and social dimensions. At the core of the framework lies the Cyber-Social Vulnerability Scoring System (CSVSS), a quantitative metric that extends CVSS with a Social Impact dimension grounded in the Entity and Place pillars, producing a single, reproducible severity score that reflects real-world consequences. Crucially, the framework does not automate risk assessment but keeps the human analyst at its center: a Large Language Model (LLM) performs a first-pass analysis, mapping vulnerabilities and drafting risk reports, while the analyst, supported by explainable AI feedback, validates the findings and retains decision authority over critical cases. Experimental results demonstrate the framework's ability to model and score cyber-social impact, while the human-in-the-loop design is presented as a conceptual principle to preserve oversight.

0.43

AI-Based Vulnerability Assessment Capability and Cyber Attack Graph Analysis

cs.CR ·2026-09-28 ·Joni Herttuainen, Kirsi Hellsten, Vesa Kuikka, Ambrose Kam, Arlanda Johnson +2 more
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Cyber threats targeting mission-critical infrastructure are becoming more sophisticated while the barrier to launching attacks continues to fall. Traditional point solutions like antivirus and firewalls are reactive and fail to address the combinatorial complexity of modern attack surfaces. This paper presents an investigation combining two complementary methodologies: Lockheed Martin's Vortex/Crow framework, which applies multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) over industry-standard cyber knowledge graph to identify and prioritize attack vectors and TTPs (tactics, techniques, and procedures); and Aalto's probabilistic attack graph model that combines network topology and its vulnerabilities to compute system-level risk metrics. The 2015 Ukraine Power Grid cyberattack serves as a well-documented validation scenario. Applied independently to the same operational technology (OT) network topology, both methodologies converge on the same attack vectors and exploit sequences as those documented in the incident record, thus providing mutual cross-validation. Attack graph analyses using node-level elimination experiments identify industrial control systems (ICS) as the most critical enablers of attack propagation, representing high-priority targets for defensive hardening. Comparison of CVSS (v2.0) and IronMiner vulnerability scoring yields in general consistent results, with IronMiner providing more actionable differentiation at network periphery nodes. The layered methodology of baseline assessment and node-level elimination proves to be scalable to large enterprise networks, thus offering defenders a structured, AI-enabled path to prioritize mitigation under realistic time and resource constraints.

0.24

Towards Early Warning of Real-World Vulnerabilities: An Evidence-Aware Decoupled Method for CVSS Vector Prediction Based on Unstructured Disclosures

cs.CR ·2026-11-04 ·Jianhong Ma, Wenhao Li, Xixing Li, Chenyu Yan, Haowen Chen
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.59
Abstract · 21 pages, 12 figures; includes 3 pages of supplementary material

Early assessment of Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) vectors from Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) can reduce the delay between initial public disclosure and official National Vulnerability Database (NVD) scoring. Existing predictors, trained mainly on standardized late-stage descriptions, degrade on noisy and incomplete pre-NVD reports. We introduce PARSE, a vulnerability-disclosure lifecycle model, and VPre, an early assessment framework built on two-level Evidence-Aware Decoupling. Decoupling Level I, Security-Evidence Screening, separates security-relevant evidence from noisy early reports at the report and sentence levels. Decoupling Level II, Evidence-Matched Routing, decouples the prediction task of the eight CVSS metrics into a scattered-evidence class and an explicit-evidence class based on validation-set measurements, matching each with a targeted predictor: large-language-model reasoning for the former, lightweight supervised classification for the latter. On the 851-report held-out test split of the 5,581-report VPre-Bench, VPre achieves a mean absolute error of 0.7239 -- 44.7% below the reproduced BERT-Small-NVD early-transfer baseline; paired timestamps across the full benchmark show an average 38-day lead before official scoring (observed range 21-60 days). Under the 38:1 PARSE-Triage noise setting, STDU's report-level screening reaches 0.98 precision, 1.00 recall, and 0.99 F1. Controlled ablations support the contributions of both decoupling levels.

0.28

Polar: LLM-Powered Synthesis of Real-World Cyber Evidence for Prioritization and Mitigation

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-10-05 ·Luoxi Tang, Yuqiao Meng, Ankita Patra, Weicheng Ma, Muchao Ye +1 more
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Cyber threat analysis increasingly depends on evidence distributed across vendor advisories, vulnerability databases, and threat intelligence sources. Turning these fragmented observations into timely decisions requires models to connect technical severity with evolving exploitation evidence and available defensive actions. We present POLAR, an LLM-powered framework for synthesizing real-world cyber evidence into threat-centric assessments for prioritization and mitigation. POLAR first disentangles overlapping incidents and grounds each threat in source-linked evidence. For prioritization, it infers severity metrics from cyber evidence and combines the resulting assessment with temporally ordered exploitation signals to estimate near-term exploitation likelihood. For mitigation, it links the synthesized threat data to authoritative remediation knowledge and organizes applicable actions according to threat urgency and operational constraints. We evaluate POLAR on real-world vulnerability evidence collected from public resources and compare it with multiple baselines. Across heterogeneous incidents and zero-day settings, POLAR improves threat ranking and mitigation retrieval while producing evidence-linked intermediate assessments that support analyst inspection. The results establish evidence synthesis as a practical foundation for LLM-based cyber decision support across related security tasks.

0.12

Predicting CVSS and CWE from CVE Descriptions with Fine-Tuned Small Language Models

cs.LG cs.CR ·2026-10-16 ·Tara Dixit, Jessie Dong, Summer Li
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 23 pages, 5 figures, 21 tables

Until April 2026, the National Vulnerability Database labeled nearly every published Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures (CVE) entry with a Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) v3.1 vector, a severity tier, and a Common Weakness Enumeration (CWE) weakness type. Now, NIST enriches only the high priority CVEs, leaving many newly published vulnerabilities unlabelled with the classifiers that security teams use for patch triage. In CVE enrichment, we predict the eight base components of CVSS v3.1 vector, base score, severity tier, and CWE from the vulnerability's textual description alone. To prevent leakage between near-duplicate descriptions, all systems are trained only on CVEs published in 2022 and 2023. Results are evaluated on all 36,325 usable 2024 CVEs in the pinned NVD snapshot. All scores are either directly predicted, or calculated from predicted vectors using the CVSS formula. A fine-tuned 3.8B-parameter model Phi-3.5-mini, trained with LoRA in 2.5 hours on a single Apple M5 Pro chip, achieves 69.9% accuracy on severity and 70.9% on CWE. It matches the official vector exactly for 48.8% of test CVEs, outperforming TF-IDF logistic regression by 2.8 to 4.7 points on all accuracy metrics based on zero-exclusion paired bootstrap intervals. When we evaluate the base model with a zero-shot prompt, it achieves 20.8% accuracy on severity in a sample of 2,000 CVEs. In this same sample, its stated scores match its own vector precisely for only 3.4% of CVEs. However, deriving scores from predicted vectors boosts the critical recall of TF-IDF logistic regression from 50.7% to 73.3% with no additional cost. And since the errors of the fine-tuned model and TF-IDF affect different CVEs, at least one system matches the correct severity tier for 75.8% of test CVEs.

0.09

Assessing Socio-Cyber Vulnerability Using Survey and Social Media Data

cs.SI ·2026-08-26 ·Shutonu Mitra, Qi Zhang, Tomas Neguyen, Hossein Salemi, Fengxiu Zhang +4 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract

The rapid growth of social media participation has increased exposure to socially engineered cyber threats (e.g., phishing, romance fraud, and tech-support scams), yet prevailing assessment tools remain fragmented: the Common Vulnerability Scoring System (CVSS) is primarily technical and largely omits human susceptibility, while the Social Vulnerability Index (SVI) is community-oriented and lacks cyber-specific modeling. To address this gap, we propose the Social Cyber Vulnerability Index (SCVI), an interpretable, uncertainty-aware metric combining two components: (i) an Individual Vulnerability Index (IVI), capturing awareness, behavior, psychological factors, and prior victimization, and (ii) an Attack Severity Index (ASI), capturing attack frequency, consequences, and sophistication. We validate SCVI across heterogeneous modalities: a nationally scoped survey (iPoll; 4,596 U.S. adults) and social-media narratives (450 Reddit r/scams reports, 2016-2024), demonstrating computation from both structured questionnaires and CI-driven feature extraction from text. Sensitivity analysis and 10,000-iteration Monte Carlo simulations show stable rankings under plausible weight variability and reveal context-dependent drivers. SCVI captures distinct socio-technical signals (Spearman correlation with CVSS $ρ= 0.33$; with SVI $ρ\approx -0.01$) and surfaces demographic and regional disparities. SCVI also provides substantially stronger separation between victim and non-victim groups than CVSS and SVI, supporting identification of high-risk populations and prioritization of interventions against emerging AI-enabled scams.

0.29