CS Paper Radar

Beyond the Headset: A Systematization of Knowledge on Extended Reality Privacy and Security in Healthcare

Nafisa Anjum, M. Rasel Mahmud

cs.CR cs.HC ·submitted 2026-09-29 16:05 UTC · v1
publishedsurveybenchmarkhighly cited

Abstract

Extended reality (XR) systems are increasingly used in healthcare applications ranging from surgical planning to remote rehabilitation and mental health support. However, the rich streams of sensor, biometric, behavioral, and environmental data that enable these applications also introduce substantial privacy and security risks. Adversaries may exploit insecure communication, sensor side channels, application-layer vulnerabilities, or data-processing pipelines to infer sensitive information or disrupt clinical workflows. Despite growing interest in XR security and privacy, the healthcare-specific literature remains fragmented. In this Systematization of Knowledge (SoK), we review 65 peer-reviewed studies published between 2017 and 2024 across XR, security, privacy, and healthcare venues. We develop a unified threat taxonomy spanning device, user, network, and cloud layers and introduce XR-PRISM, a quantitative Privacy and Risk Impact Scoring Metric for systematically characterizing security and privacy risks. Our analysis identifies several gaps in the literature: more than 70% of proposed countermeasures lack standardized risk evaluation, fewer than 15% of studied attacks require high attack prerequisites, and reproducibility is limited by the scarcity of publicly released artifacts and datasets. Based on these findings, we outline a research roadmap emphasizing shared benchmark datasets, stronger artifact-release practices, improved cloud-layer protections, and more comprehensive detection, mitigation, and recovery mechanisms. This SoK provides a structured and data-driven foundation for understanding existing risks and guiding the development of more secure, privacy-preserving, and usable XR healthcare systems.

Comment
Published in 31st ACM Symposium on Virtual Reality Software and Technology
DOI
10.1145/3756884.3766045

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Understanding Users' Security, Privacy, and Trust Concerns in Healthcare AI Systems

cs.CR cs.CY ·2026-11-15 ·Tushar Nayan, Mohammed Al Duniawi, Song Fang, Aokun Chen, Arjun Arunasalam +1 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Artificial intelligence is increasingly integrated into healthcare systems, from clinical information retrieval to workflow automation and decision support, which introduces new security, privacy, and trust risks with direct implications for patient care. While prior work has examined these risks from technical and regulatory perspectives, less is known about how these risks are naturally discussed in online communities. To address this gap, we conduct a large-scale analysis of 14 medical communities on Reddit and extract 6,514 relevant posts. Through systematic qualitative coding and LLM-assisted classification, we investigate concerns expressed in healthcare AI discussions, their prevalence, and how they evolve over time. Our analysis reveals that users perceive healthcare AI as expanding traditional healthcare trust boundaries and attack surfaces through integrations with electronic health records, third-party services, cloud platforms, and automated clinical workflows. Posts express concerns about over-privileged access to sensitive records, opaque data flows, unauthorized secondary use, and unsafe automation can amplify the consequences of errors and misuse. We identify four attitudes toward these risks: exploring questions of accountability and harm, cautiously accepting AI with stronger safeguards, skepticism about system trustworthiness, and resignation to growing data exposure and automation. Longitudinal analysis shows that SP&T discussions have increased significantly, with shifts coinciding with major healthcare AI deployments, privacy incidents, and regulatory developments. These findings illuminate changing trust relationships and data-governance challenges, informing the design and governance of safer, more transparent, and accountable healthcare AI systems.

0.43

Automated screening of privacy risks in medical AI

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CR ·2026-10-21 ·Konstantinos Vrettos, Eleftherios Tzanis, Haridimos Kondylakis, Evangelia E. Vassalou, Florence X. Doo +1 more
hot direction similarity 0.63
Abstract · 37 pages, 5 figures

Medical artificial intelligence (AI) models are often shared without their training data, assuming this protects the patients who contributed them. However, a model can reveal whether a patient's records were used in training, a privacy breach known as a membership inference attack. This risk is usually reported as a cohort average, which can appear negligible while individual patients are almost certainly exposed. Identifying potentially vulnerable records before developing a production model could make privacy assessment more practical. We measured each patient's vulnerability to membership inference attack, across 7,789 models trained on six clinical datasets in four modalities, including two adapted pretrained medical models. Training choices changed how many patients had high attack scores, but the patients who ranked highest by risk largely stayed the same across the configurations we tested. Stronger weight decay reduced the exposed cohort up to threefold, yet largely the same patients remained most at risk across training recipes, architectures and initializations, including foundation models. Therefore, we developed a lightweight screening tool that uses four small models to identify patients with high risk of exposure before production-model training. We also assessed if flagged patients could be protected without removing their data. Privacy screening should become incorporated into data preparation for clinical AI.

0.26

HIPAA-Compliant AI Deployment Patterns in Clinical Settings: Privacy-Preserving Techniques and Governance Controls

cs.CY ·2026-08-13 ·Vinod Dhiman
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Artificial intelligence (AI) is moving from research prototypes into clinical workflows, yet the deployment of AI systems that process protected health information (PHI) remains constrained by the U.S. Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and by the absence of shared engineering guidance for satisfying it. Existing work tends to treat privacy-preserving machine learning and regulatory governance as separate concerns, leaving practitioners without a concrete mapping from architectural decisions to compliance obligations. This paper contributes a catalog of five reusable deployment patterns for clinical AI that jointly address the HIPAA Privacy and Security Rules: a de-identified analytics zone, cross-entity federated learning, confidential inference within trusted execution environments, a PHI-minimizing retrieval-augmented clinical assistant, and a synthetic data sandbox for development. Each pattern is specified in terms of context, governing forces, structure, and residual risk, and is mapped to the administrative, physical, and technical safeguards of the HIPAA Security Rule as well as to the NIST AI Risk Management Framework and ISO/IEC~42001. We further present a threat model for clinical AI and a decision procedure for selecting patterns based on data sensitivity, trust boundaries, and latency requirements. The goal is to give security engineers, compliance owners, and clinical informaticists a common vocabulary that turns abstract regulatory duties into verifiable architectural controls.

0.04

Towards End-to-End Privacy-Preserving AI for Real-Time ECG Monitoring

cs.CR ·2026-10-18 ·Beyazit Bestami Yuksel
published similarity 0.63
Abstract · 9 pages, 4 figures, 2 tables. Accepted to MICCAI 2026 Doctoral Symposium (Springer LNCS)

Healthcare artificial intelligence is shifting from centralized archives toward distributed pipelines that combine wearables, edge processing, cloud analytics, and multi-institutional learning. In this regime, electrocardiogram (ECG) streams cross multiple trust boundaries, so privacy cannot be reduced to a single transmission control. Existing privacy-enhancing technologies typically secure isolated stages and leave gaps between acquisition, analysis, and institutional collaboration. This doctoral research develops a unified lifecycle framework for end-to-end privacy-preserving ECG AI. Rather than introducing another privacy mechanism, it orchestrates complementary privacy-enhancing technologies across the clinical ECG lifecycle, allocating each mechanism to the trust boundary where its security, computational, and operational properties are most appropriate. Three interoperable modules instantiate the framework: AES with CKKS-based homomorphic statistics for secure monitoring; adaptive chaotic protection for low-latency edge transmission; and federated learning with homomorphic aggregation under heterogeneous partitions. Across prototype monitoring, signal-security analysis, and simulated collaboration, the programme shows that privacy layers can be composed without collapsing diagnostic utility, while exposing overhead and fidelity limits that constrain clinical translation.

0.26

From Temporary Access to Persistent Surveillance: Why Matter Matters in Smart Homes

cs.CR ·2026-10-02 ·Nicolas Nino, Timothy Minning, Le Guan
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 14 pages, 5 figures

Matter aims to unify smart home ecosystems through an open, interoperable, and secure standard, relying on cryptographic mechanisms for device authentication and data confidentiality. However, its openness also exposes protocol details, credential structures, and implementation characteristics to adversaries. We show that an attacker with temporary physical access can exploit design and implementation flaws to extract credentials and impersonate devices and controllers. These replicas integrate seamlessly into the fabric, enabling persistent surveillance and control even after the attacker departs. Notably, the attack is vendor-agnostic and requires no device-specific reverse engineering, as long as the device is not physically secured. We validate its practicality through a proof-of-concept on a simulated smart home with both commercial devices and development boards. Our findings uncover previously underestimated attack surfaces in Matter, particularly under physical access scenarios, and motivate four targeted mitigation strategies.

0.23

MultiGait: A Multi-Sensor Multi-Perspective Multi-Session Biometric Inference Benchmark and its Dataset

cs.CR cs.CV ·2026-09-01 ·Julian Todt, Felix Morsbach, Philip Dissert, Thorsten Strufe
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

A lack of suitable datasets has limited the research into the privacy risks of novel smart city sensors, such as thermal cameras, depth cameras, and lidar. Given the number of unsubstantiated privacy claims and their potential widespread deployment into many people's everyday life, understanding the privacy risks of these sensors -- in isolation and in like-for-like comparisons -- is crucial. With MultiGait, we collected the first multi-sensor, multi-perspective, multi-session gait-focused dataset, for the corresponding, and additional more far-reaching investigations. The dataset, validated with multiple state-of-the-art recognition systems, comprises various walking modes and annotated personal attributes for 199 individuals, to ensure the benefit for advanced studies including cross-sensor recognition and anonymization at the edge. MultiGait represents a foundation for rigorous privacy investigations, demonstrated through an extensive identity inference benchmark across eight sensors, four perspectives, and three recording sessions. Our benchmark incidentally reveals that sensors often assumed to be privacy-friendly do still entail considerable identity inference risks, while the poor cross-session generalization of existing methods underscores an important research gap.

0.34

PrivacyFlow: Privacy in AI Agents through Information Flow Analysis and Consequence-Aware Risk Management

cs.CR cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-10-29 ·Robin Staab, Tom Wollschläger, Vahab Mirrokni, Reza Shokri
benchmark similarity 0.61
Abstract

Autonomous LLM agents executing multi-step workflows over personal data often misalign with user privacy expectations and leak sensitive, out-of-context information. Although Contextual Integrity (CI) formalizes this problem, existing benchmarks and defenses rarely operationalize CI for realistic multi-step task sequences in evolving environments. In this work, we first introduce agentic PrivacyBench, a benchmark of 5873 tasks in 986 task sequences with dynamic environment updates and CI-grounded allow-sets for sensitive information. We also introduce PrivacyFlow, a defense that separates deliberative privacy planning (System 2) from task execution (System 1), treating each sharing decision as a structured risk-management problem. Before execution, PrivacyFlow traces the provenance and purpose of each planned data flow, models recipient background knowledge, and simulates what external actors could infer. This allows us to model the downstream consequences of disclosure, including inference attacks and context-dependent harms. It then weighs the remaining disclosure risk against task utility and executes a minimized plan, blocks it, or consults the user. Across six models, PrivacyFlow significantly reduces step-level privacy failures and raises the share of completed task sequences without a detected privacy violation by 22--55 percentage points. We further highlight a new privacy--utility--autonomy tradeoff: allowing PrivacyFlow to proactively prompt the user in case of uncertainty can increase authorized task completion at the cost of shifting decision effort back to the user. Our results suggest that proactive CI reasoning can substantially improve agentic privacy and motivate further study of this tradeoff.

0.06

Bad Diagnosis: Analyzing Consent and Data Collection Practices of Mobile Medical Apps

cs.HC cs.CRcs.CY ·2026-10-16 ·Ethan Myers, Lorenzo De Carli, Shantanu Sharma, Ritwik Banerjee, Joel Reardon +1 more
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Mobile health (mHealth) apps collect personally-identifiable information while handling uniquely sensitive medical data, ranging from mental health records to real-time glucose or heart rate monitoring -- yet they remain poorly understood at scale. We present the first comprehensive analysis of consent and data collection practices across 10,000+ mHealth apps on the Google Play Store, combining static analysis and privacy policy examination. We develop a rigorous operational definition to distinguish health apps from general wellness programs, and design a measurement framework to detect misuse of permissions and violations of consent. Our analyses reveal a troubling ecosystem: 69.15% of apps request at least one permission unrelated to their stated purpose, with over 52.9% apps requesting location data, and 50.5% and 34.9% apps requesting camera and microphone access, respectively -- despite no functional justification based on app descriptions and stated purposes. Most alarmingly, nearly 93% of apps fail to provide users with a consent form, directly violating regulatory requirements such as GDPR; and even among the remaining 7%, 1 in 14 demonstrate a gap between the obtained consent and collection of personally identifiable information. These findings demonstrate an urgent need for stronger enforcement of privacy regulations in mHealth apps. We plan to release our dataset and measurement tools for continued monitoring of this critical space.

0.25