CS Paper Radar

Learning Beyond Full Imitation: Task-Preserving Knowledge Distillation

Qianfeng Yuan, Wenbing Tao

cs.LG ·submitted 2026-09-30 09:06 UTC · v1

Abstract

Knowledge distillation transfers knowledge by encouraging a student to match a teacher's predicted class probabilities. These probabilities express not only confidence in the correct class, but also relations among incorrect alternatives. Yet closer imitation does not necessarily yield a better student. A student may already distinguish the correct class more sharply than its teacher, so further imitation can require giving back discrimination it has acquired. Our main result is an exact separation between full imitation and conditional learning. When the correct class's score advantage over each alternative must be preserved, full teacher-to-student KL minimization is blocked exactly when the student assigns no more probability than the teacher to every incorrect class. Crucially, the teacher's relative probabilities among incorrect classes remain fully learnable. We characterize the exact price of this transfer: a minimum increase in correct-class log-odds that compensates for the largest conditional-probability mismatch. Label fitting and conditional matching can therefore be completed even as full teacher KL diverges. This separation motivates task-preserving knowledge distillation (TPKD), which keeps the label gradient intact and minimally corrects the conditional gradient so that its output update preserves the label step's gains against every incorrect alternative. The corrected conditional direction retains more than half of the original first-order conditional descent at the same step size, with a tight bound. For a fixed positive conditional target and sufficiently small constant output steps, label and conditional errors vanish together. Experiments trace this learning from exact head updates to ordinary network training. TPKD reaches 88.05% accuracy on CIFAR-100 and 93.81% on CLINC150, improving over standard distillation by 0.47 and 0.35 percentage points across three seeds.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

ReTaCo: Residual-Target Control for On-Policy Distillation

cs.LG ·2026-09-30 ·Zixiang Ni, Zhuo Hu, Renjie Cao, Weijie Ren, Binqin Shi +6 more
theoryhot direction similarity 0.68
Abstract

On-policy distillation (OPD) trains a student on its own generated prefixes with token-level teacher feedback, but transmitting or storing the teacher's full-vocabulary distribution at every token is costly. Entropy-aware OPD (EOPD) adds forward supervision to reverse KL to help the student recover plausible tokens it underestimates, using only the teacher's top-$k$ probabilities to limit cost. Because EOPD renormalizes these probabilities, its target assigns no mass to the omitted vocabulary. We prove that the resulting loss keeps pushing the student's top-$k$ mass toward one even after the student matches the teacher's relative probabilities within the top-$k$ set, so the teacher itself is not a stationary point whenever the omitted tokens have positive teacher probability. We propose ReTaCo (Residual-Target Control), which keeps the top-$k$ tokens individually and groups the remaining tokens into one residual symbol, and pairs this forward target with a single-sample estimator whose expectation equals the full-vocabulary reverse KL. With teacher top-$k$ mass $m$, the residual target is $(1-β)(1-m)$ for $β\in[0,1]$: $β=0$ preserves the teacher's mass, and larger $β$ moves more mass onto the top-$k$ tokens without changing their relative probabilities. At a fixed prefix, we prove that the population objective has a unique optimum whose top-$k$ mass lies between $m$ and $m+β(1-m)$ and increases monotonically with $β$; at $β=0$, underestimated top-$k$ tokens still receive non-vanishing recovery gradients. Numerical optimization confirms these predictions, and across three teacher-student pairs, ReTaCo outperforms EOPD on most mathematics and code benchmarks.

0.21

Tail-Aware Top-$k$ On-Policy Distillation

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-08-12 ·Huipeng Huang, Hongxin Wei
code/datahighly cited similarity 0.68
Abstract

On-policy distillation (OPD) has emerged as an effective paradigm for transferring knowledge between language models, where a student is trained to align its next-token distribution with the teacher's along its own trajectories. To provide dense supervision at tractable cost, many works minimize the reverse Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence between the student and teacher's normalized distributions over the teacher's top-$k$ tokens. However, this normalized objective discards the information about tail probability: the total probability outside the teacher's top-$k$ tokens. As a result, the optimization can steadily increase the student's tail probability and entropy, empirically degrading downstream accuracy. To address this issue, we propose Tail-Aware Top-$k$ OPD (\textbf{TA-OPD}), a novel distillation method that restores the missing tail probability signal. In particular, TA-OPD minimizes the reverse KL divergence over the top-$k$ tokens plus a tail token that carries the tail probability. In effect, TA-OPD better aligns the student's next-token distribution with the teacher's, preventing the increase in tail probability and entropy caused by top-$k$ normalization. Extensive experiments demonstrate the superiority of TA-OPD, improving Avg@8 by up to 8.05 points on common benchmarks. Our code is available at https://github.com/HuipengHuang/TA-OPD.

0.63

Do We Really Need KL Divergence for On-Policy Distillation of Large Language Models?

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-09-27 ·Wenze Lin, Jiyuan Long, Jiale Zhao, Shenzhi Wang, Xitai Jiang +9 more
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract

Since the advent of knowledge distillation, KL divergence has been the standard loss in distillation. Recently, on-policy distillation (OPD) has emerged as an efficient post-training paradigm for LLMs. As a distillation method, OPD naturally inherits KL divergence as its standard loss. However, in this work, we find that KL divergence may not be necessary for OPD. We show that simply preserving the update direction is sufficient for effective OPD. As long as the update direction is toward the teacher, OPD works. More precisely, it is not the direction of every token, but the direction of a small subset of tokens where the teacher and student disagree strongly. We first show that simply assigning a reward of (+1) to tokens where the teacher probability is higher than the student probability and (-1) where it is lower, which merely encourages updates toward the teacher, reproduces almost the same training mode as OPD with reverse KL. We further show that only the direction of a small subset of tokens with large teacher-student disagreement is critical, and training works as long as their update direction is toward the teacher, even if other tokens are pulled away from the teacher. And as an application of these findings, we introduce Consensus Multi-Teacher On-Policy Distillation (C-MOPD) to improve Multi-Teacher On-Policy Distillation (MOPD). Unlike MOPD, which routes each sample to a single teacher and may cause capability conflicts across domains, C-MOPD lets every sample be supervised by all teachers. Experiments show that C-MOPD consistently outperforms MOPD on both math and code benchmarks. Our code is available at https://github.com/LeapLabTHU/KL-Free-OPD.

0.32

Learning What to Imitate: Entropy-Aware Distribution Mixing

cs.LG ·2026-10-05 ·Juan Garcia Giraldo, Matteo Santelmo, Eduard Durech, Imanol Schlag, Valentina Pyatkin +1 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 32 pages, 7 figures

Small language models are often post-trained as students on reasoning traces from stronger teacher models to efficiently learn new skills. However, token-level imitation on traces that lie far outside the student's expected distribution often produces \textit{confident conflicts}, whereby the student is required to imitate a continuation that it deems unlikely (i.e., low-probability) despite being confident in a different continuation (i.e., in a low-entropy state). To mitigate the degradation in generalisation and catastrophic forgetting caused by these conflicts, we propose \textbf{Entropy-Aware Mixing}: a dynamic per-token interpolation of the student and teacher distributions, gated by the student's predictive entropy. We implement both convex and geometric interpolations for both offline trace generation (via speculative decoding, then SFT) and on-policy forward-KL distillation. Our results show that entropy-aware mixing stabilises distillation, improving in-distribution and out-of-distribution math reasoning while better preserving general capabilities than fixed-teacher supervision. Nonetheless, the optimal entropy schedule depends on the training source, with offline-generated traces favouring concave schedules (greater overall teacher influence) and on-policy training favouring linear or convex schedules (teacher concentrated in high-entropy states).

0.15

Reward-Aligned Reweighting for On-Policy Distillation

cs.LG ·2026-09-28 ·Haofeng Xu, Junwei Su, Lansong Diao, Wenchao Zhou, Chuan Wu
hot direction similarity 0.67
Abstract

On-policy distillation (OPD) trains a student language model with dense feedback from a stronger teacher on student-generated trajectories. Yet standard OPD weights token-level distillation terms uniformly, implicitly treating local teacher preference as a proxy for correction utility. A decision's task value, however, depends on how the student completes the subsequent reasoning. This mismatch can cause imitation to suppress viable student strategies or reinforce paths the student cannot reliably execute. Verified trajectory outcomes provide complementary evidence about continuation quality, but do not directly identify the utility of individual decisions. We introduce Reward-Aligned Reweighting for On-Policy Distillation (R$^{2}$-OPD), which uses outcome agreement and the magnitude of teacher--student disagreement to continuously reallocate teacher supervision. It gives reward-aligned corrections greater relative influence while retaining dense feedback, moving beyond uniform imitation and hard filtering. Our analysis formalizes the mismatch between local teacher preference and student continuation value and establishes sufficient conditions for reallocation to improve first-order task progress over uniform OPD. Across seven mathematical reasoning benchmarks, R$^{2}$-OPD achieves the highest average accuracy among the compared training methods in both cross-size and same-size distillation. It outperforms standard OPD on all seven benchmarks, with average gains of 3.5 and 2.4 percentage points for 1.7B and 4B students, respectively. An extension to code generation yields an average gain of 1.6 percentage points over standard OPD. These results highlight outcome-guided supervision allocation as an effective way to translate dense teacher feedback into stronger student performance across model scales and task domains.

0.21

$D^2$-OPD: Separating Direction and Distance in Extrapolative On-Policy Distillation

cs.LG cs.CL ·2026-11-04 ·Bowen Fang, Dingmin Wang, Hengzhi Pei
code/data similarity 0.67
Abstract

On-policy distillation (OPD) trains a student model to match a teacher's next-token distributions on student-generated prefixes. Extrapolative OPD further extends the teacher's log-probability shift relative to a reference policy to construct stronger learning targets. However, existing methods couple extrapolation direction and distance, allowing the magnitude of the teacher's shift to dictate how far the target moves. We propose $D^2$-OPD, decoupling these two factors: a per-prefix hard KL constraint bounds the target's distance from the teacher, while an adaptive combination of the teacher's post-training shift and the initial student--teacher gap determines the extrapolation direction. We optimize the student toward this target using forward KL, providing learning signals even for low-probability tokens. We evaluate three settings: where standard OPD performs well, where it struggles with base-model initialization, and where no teacher reference is available. On mathematical reasoning benchmarks, $D^2$-OPD attains the highest score in all three settings, outperforming the strongest baseline by up to 9.45 points. Ablations validate the contributions of each component.

0.13

Persistent Negatives for Adversarial Black-Box On-Policy Distillation

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-09-25 ·Haixu Ma, Saad Lahrichi, Weiwei Li, Kevin Han, Weiqiang Wu +9 more
hot direction similarity 0.67
Abstract

Black-box On-Policy Distillation (OPD) seeks to improve a student from its own generations when the teacher provides sampled responses but not token probabilities. Adversarial distillation offers one route: it learns a discriminator over prompt-matched teacher and student responses and uses its score as the policy reward. However, sampling discriminator negatives from the latest student at each step couples the learned reward to a negative distribution that changes after every policy update. We address this moving-target problem with persistent-negative adversarial distillation, a live-pool method that replaces a fraction of each discriminator batch with historical, prompt-matched teacher--student comparisons. Under matched discriminator compute, historical comparisons train the discriminator, while GRPO remains on-policy with fresh student responses. Our analysis identifies the Bayes-optimal reward as a teacher-to-negative log-density ratio and, under explicit assumptions, shows how persistent negatives anchor the discriminator and reduce reward-estimation MSE relative to fresh-negative training. Across two student families, three judges, and four judged-chat benchmarks, persistent-negative adversarial distillation consistently improves performance over current methods at matched discriminator compute. It also yields smoother fresh-policy discriminator trajectories, with fewer below-chance dips. These findings identify the discriminator's negative distribution as an important design axis in black-box on-policy distillation.

0.31

Bernoulli On-Policy Distillation: Don't Ignore High-Confidence Student Tokens

cs.LG ·2026-11-01 ·Mingyu Cao, Yaokai Jin, Shiwei Liu, Lu Yin
code/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · 14 pages, 7 figures, Code: https://github.com/duterscmy/Bernoulli-OPD

On-policy distillation (OPD) trains a student language model on its own trajectories using token-level supervision from a stronger teacher. We show that standard sampled reverse-KL OPD systematically suppresses updates to high-confidence tokens, such that their weak gradient contribution does not necessarily imply weak or uninformative teacher supervision. We introduce Bernoulli On-Policy Distillation (Bernoulli OPD), which directly matches the teacher and student probabilities for that token. This yields a bounded probability space correction that preserves teacher-student disagreement while avoiding the additional confidence-dependent suppression induced by vanilla OPD. Fixed-rollout analyses show that Bernoulli OPD substantially restores optimization signal to high-confidence tokens while remaining sensitive to teacher-student disagreement. We further analyze the resulting model behavior through confidence distributions, answer calibration, policy movement, and training dynamics, showing that Bernoulli OPD's gains cannot be explained simply by longer reasoning, larger optimization steps, or more uniform imitation of the teacher. Code is available at https://github.com/duterscmy/Bernoulli-OPD.

0.19