CS Paper Radar

Multi-Behavioral Evolved Substrates Through Neuromodulation and Activation Selection

Romain Claret, Michael O'Neill, Paul Cotofrei, Kilian Stoffel

cs.NE cs.AI ·submitted 2026-09-10 13:22 UTC · v1
publishedcode/data

Abstract

Open-ended artificial life systems must acquire diverse competencies from a single evolving genotype. Biological brains combine neuromodulation, which reconfigures circuits without changing connections, with diverse neuron types matched to specific computational roles. Can artificial evolution achieve something analogous in indirectly encoded substrates? Using indirectly encoded substrates evolved via CPPNs, we show through more than 10,000 experiments that neuromodulation alone is insufficient: under evolutionary search, monotonic activation functions impose a 75% ceiling on parity tasks that persists regardless of capacity, topology, or population size. This is an evolutionary search barrier, not a representational limit, since Adam gradient descent achieves 100% on the identical architecture. We combine neuromodulation with per-task activation function selection, matching oscillatory primitives to parity tasks and monotonic to threshold tasks, producing multi-behavioral evolved substrates. The result: 100% simultaneous 5-task success across all 30 seeds (median 14 generations). This generalizes across the oscillatory activation class: all four functions reach 100% (30 seeds each). Neither mechanism suffices alone. The barrier extends to higher-arity and asymmetric tasks, while multi-layer depth provides an alternative path. For open-ended evolution, the computational primitive should itself be an evolvable trait. At inference, one evolved genotype expresses many behaviors.

Comment
10 pages, 3 figures, 3 tables. Published version of the paper presented at ALIFE 2026: Proceedings of the 2026 Artificial Life Conference (MIT Press). Code and data: https://github.com/RomainClaret/emr-hyperneat
Journal ref
ALIFE 2026: Proceedings of the 2026 Artificial Life Conference, MIT Press, 2026, p. 78
DOI
10.1162/ISAL.a.968

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Per-Node Activation Function Evolution in Indirectly Encoded Substrates: Solvability, Limits, and Emergent Diversity

cs.NE cs.AI ·2026-09-10 ·Romain Claret, Michael O'Neill, Paul Cotofrei, Kilian Stoffel
published similarity 0.77
Abstract · 9 pages, 2 figures, 10 tables. Published in ALIFE 2026 (MIT Press). This is the version of record, posted under CC BY 4.0

Biological neurons achieve computational diversity through specialized types: tonic, bursting, adapting, and fast-spiking cells coexist within the same circuit. Artificial neural networks, by contrast, apply a single activation function uniformly to all nodes, which limits what they can represent. We show that this uniformity creates hard limits for evolutionary search: across sparse evolved substrates, monotonic functions fail to solve parity beyond its smallest instance, XOR, while a single oscillatory unit suffices at all tested scales. The gap is one of search and sparsity, not representation: monotonic networks can represent parity with a modest number of hidden units, and gradient descent recovers that solution. We evolve, to our knowledge for the first time in indirect encoding, per-node activation function assignments from an 18-function palette across more than 4,500 experimental runs spanning Boolean logic, regression, and spatial classification. Testing each of the 18 functions individually on Parity-4 reveals a three-tier solvability structure: oscillatory functions achieve 100%, intermediate functions 6.7-80%, and all 9 monotonic functions 0%. This divide is not universal. Recurrence collapses it, and gradient descent inverts it entirely, showing that the barrier is specific to evolutionary search in sparse substrates. What activation functions a network can use, beyond its topology and weights, determines what evolutionary search can solve. Indirect encoding discovers heterogeneous per-node activation assignments unlikely to be chosen by hand.

0.56

Bio-Inspired Palette Evolution in Indirectly Encoded Substrates: Timescale Compatibility Shapes Activation Function Discovery

cs.NE cs.LG ·2026-09-15 ·Romain Claret, Michael O'Neill, Paul Cotofrei, Kilian Stoffel
top venue similarity 0.70
Abstract · 16 pages, 2 figures, 7 tables. Authors' accepted manuscript; published in Parallel Problem Solving from Nature - PPSN XIX (Springer, Lecture…

Indirectly encoded neural networks can assign different activation functions to individual nodes, but the right functions are rarely known in advance. When the available set contains only standard monotonic functions, problems like parity become unsolvable, yet an all-inclusive palette underperforms a curated one. How should evolution discover which functions to use? We address this as a meta-learning problem, designing 13 strategies (11 inspired by biological adaptation mechanisms, plus baseline and oracle controls) that modify the set of available activation functions during evolution. Each strategy translates a biological principle into an evolutionary operator: for example, circadian-inspired oscillatory gating cycles functions in and out of the palette on a fixed schedule, while immune-inspired Clonal Selection permanently protects functions that consistently correlate with fitness. We evaluate all strategies across more than 3,000 runs on parity and non-parity problems, first evolving the activation palette alone, then co-evolving a per-node aggregation palette on harder problems; an independent replication with new seeds confirms a stable high-reliability tier, with Circadian holding its top rank. Bio-inspired strategies match the solve rate of a tuned baseline but converge up to twice as fast, with Circadian halving total compute. Strategy rankings reverse across problem types, with no strategy dominating all domains. Strategy success is largely shaped by timescale compatibility: strategies whose characteristic timescale matches the evolutionary evaluation window consistently outperform those that operate too slowly. The practical guideline: match the mechanism's timescale to the evaluation budget. Rescaling the slowest strategy bypasses the oscillatory barrier entirely: all nine solutions solve parity with non-oscillatory activations paired with min or max aggregation.

0.62

TRON: Transferring Naturally Evolved Network Architectures into Neuroevolution

cs.NE cs.LG ·2026-10-26 ·Konstantinos Zacharopoulos, Alexandra Bekou, Jose M Serradell, Foteini Paraskevopoulou, Apostolos Fournaris +2 more
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Neural architecture search (NAS) is challenging because of the vast, non-linear space of artificial neural network (ANN) topologies. Evolutionary methods can generate architectures, but their effectiveness is limited by difficulties in preserving functional organization during mutation and recombination. Naturally evolved biological networks may provide organizational principles that support adaptation and evolvability. Here, we introduce TRON (TRansfer Of Natural networks), a neuroevolution framework that uses experimentally characterized protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks as architectural priors. Instead of starting from random topologies, TRON reuses biological interaction patterns as structural building blocks. It combines classical evolutionary operators with neuroevolution-inspired mechanisms, including speciation, and introduces species quarantine to protect newly generated architectures during early maturation. We evaluated TRON against established evolutionary and neuroevolutionary methods on three classification benchmarks (CORA, CITESEER, and PUBMED) and three regression benchmarks (DIABETES, FRIEDMAN, and CALIFORNIA). TRON achieved the highest predictive performance among the evaluated methods on all classification datasets and most regression tasks. It showed substantially lower variability across independent runs, indicating greater robustness and convergence stability, at increased computational cost. These findings support the use of PPI networks as effective architectural priors and suggest that biologically derived interaction networks provide more favorable substrates for neuroevolution than random topologies. More broadly, TRON demonstrates the feasibility of transferring naturally evolved network architectures into artificial intelligence systems, offering a direction for improving evolvability in NAS through the reuse of biological organizational principles.

0.23

The Cost of Becoming: Developmental Encoding Increases Phenotypic Diversity but Reduces Locality and Recombination Robustness in Evolved Robots

cs.NE ·2026-09-14 ·Lyes Saad Saoud
benchmarkposition similarity 0.63
Abstract

Developmental encodings are often motivated by the expectation that a structured genotype-to-phenotype process can improve evolvability, robustness, and adaptation. Yet an encoding that expands phenotypic variation may simultaneously make useful parental structure harder to preserve under mutation and recombination. We test this trade-off in a controlled evolutionary-robotics benchmark comparing three matched representations: direct encoding, a static generative encoding, and a temporal zygotic developmental encoding. All three conditions use 34 genome parameters, 34 adult-controller parameters, identical initial genome matrices, the same optimizer, the same mutation and crossover operators, the same environments, and the same number of fitness evaluations. Across 30 paired evolutionary runs per representation, developmental encoding does not reliably exceed direct encoding in final training or out-of-distribution fitness. It does, however, substantially increase final population phenotypic diversity and mutant-reachable phenotype diversity. The same representation exhibits lower mutation viability, lower genotype--phenotype locality, sharply reduced crossover offspring fitness and viability, and increased recombination novelty. Continued developmental dynamics also attenuate damage applied early in development relative to otherwise identical late damage. These results identify a representation-level trade-off: development can enlarge the neighborhood of reachable phenotypes and provide within-development damage attenuation while degrading the local inheritance of already-adapted structure. We argue that developmental encodings should therefore be evaluated not by performance alone, but by a joint geometry of generativity, locality, robustness, and inheritance compatibility.

0.25

Learning Time-Varying Connectomes for Stable Behavior Across Development

cs.NE q-bio.NC ·2026-11-04 ·Christof Fehrman, Jacob J. Morra, Eva A. Naumann
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 29 pages, 6 figures

Neural circuits must maintain functionality to drive effective behavior while their size, topology, geometry, and intrinsic dynamics change across development. To model developing visuomotor circuits and behavior, we investigated whether a single compact generative encoding could produce functional recurrent controllers across such changes. Building on the HyperNEAT algorithm, we represented this program as a compositional pattern-producing network that received developmental time as an input to generate age-specific connectivity. The developmental substrate prescribed neuronal birth, position, sensory organization, and intrinsic time constants. We tested this approach using two geometrically distinct developmental substrates and two visuomotor tasks: optomotor responses and phototaxis. Controllers optimized at only the initial or mature substrate generally failed when evaluated at other ages. In contrast, controllers optimized across multiple developmental snapshots maintained substantially higher and more consistent performance across trained and unseen ages. Optimization at only three developmental snapshots was often sufficient to produce effective behavior across the tested developmental interval. The resulting connectomes changed substantially with age and did not converge on a single trajectory of sparsity or connection-weight statistics. Controllers also differed in whether they relied on neurons born later in development. These results demonstrate that a shared spatiotemporal time-varying connectivity program can produce recurrent neural networks that preserve behavior across substantial developmental changes. Together, these results provide a framework for studying how functional stability can emerge without requiring structural or dynamical stability.

0.28

Emergent Intelligence: Resonant Oscillators Produce Proactive Adaptive Behavior

cs.NE ·2026-09-18 ·Alex Fedosov, Maxim Yakimenko, Sander Stepanov
code/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 22 pages, 9 figures, 14 tables. Code: https://github.com/FoundAItion-ai/Its/tree/v1.1.7/PY/VisualCube . Data: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo…

Most artificial neural systems are built to map given inputs to outputs. Adaptive agents face a prior problem: they must act without enough evidence, seek encounters with the world, and revise behavior when evidence appears. We propose another starting point for intelligent neural networks: proactive search without signals, curiosity at its most basic. We ask whether it can come from a minimal untrained circuit. The spiking unit studied here inverts its response to input: with no signal in its window it fires faster; once signals arrive it switches to a slower, inverted regime. Search needs three or more such oscillators in counter-phase, each reading the same input in a different time window. With no training, supervision, parameter tuning, or controller, the composite switches on its own between exploratory spiral search and exploitative tracking, finding both first-degree symmetry and second-degree groups. The switch comes from temporal disagreement between its fast and slow readings of the same signal. We view the circuit as evolutionarily trained: its abilities come from structure, not experience. Ablation over 63 configurations and 63,000 trials shows the switch needs both temporal staggering and counter-phase opposition, neither enough alone: the behavior is emergent, not programmed. The spiral persists at zero rotational diffusion, so it is structural, and degrades gently under perturbation. More oscillators improve spiral regularity but cut resource capture, so the smallest sufficient circuit wins. We propose that this principle underlies search in simple organisms, navigation and decisions in complex ones, and, being so simple and common, goes unnoticed unless you strip the logic bare. Eventually, networks of such proactive primitives may offer another foundation for AI architectures that explore our world rather than merely predict the next symbol in a sequence.

0.52

Continual Reinforcement Learning with Neuroevolution

cs.NE cs.LG ·2026-10-01 ·Eleni Nisioti, Andrea Cossu, Kathrin Korte, Sebastian Risi
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Despite many studies about causes and remedies of plasticity loss in Reinforcement Learning (RL) under continual task changes, no RL method has yet consistently achieved a good balance between adaptation and forgetting. Here we turn to an alternative optimization paradigm, neuroevolution (NE): algorithms that search directly in weight space through mutation and selection over a population of neural networks. Across a wide array of environments and environmental changes, with policies ranging from a few hundred parameters to million-parameter networks, we compare evolution strategies (ES) and genetic algorithms (GAs) against state-of-the-art continual RL variants and population-based RL. ES most consistently achieves a good stability-plasticity trade-off, while the GA is the most plastic method but forgets more than ES. To explain this, we study the return landscape around each method's solutions. ES finds the widest neighborhoods, i.e.\ regions of weight space in which perturbed policies still solve the task, and the size of the overlap between the neighborhoods of consecutive tasks correlates with a method's stability-plasticity trade-off. Rewarding behavioral diversity in a GA through novelty search makes the population even more plastic, at the cost of forgetting. Finally, symptoms of plasticity loss commonly reported in RL do not transfer to NE. Overall, these results establish NE as a competitive alternative to RL under continual task changes, and suggest that training under perturbations in weight space may be a useful mechanism for continual learning more broadly.

0.53

Big Brains and Changing Environments: Cause or Consequence?

cs.NE cs.AIq-bio.PE ·2026-09-14 ·Sian Heesom-Green, Jonathan Shock, Geoff Nitschke
published similarity 0.60
Abstract

Large brains are metabolically costly, and associations with changing environments do not imply they evolved there, as the Cognitive Buffer Hypothesis (CBH) would suggest. They may instead evolve in stable conditions and later facilitate colonization of changing environments. Using neuro-evolution in an artificial seasonal foraging task, we compared agents evolving exclusively in changing environments to agents first evolved in static environments before transitioning. Results show that larger neural networks in dynamic environments arise mainly from prior static evolution, achieving superior performance under unpredictable changes. Our results challenge strict CBH predictions, provide agent-based (computational) support for a colonization-based account and highlight the role of evolutionary history in brain size evolution.

0.39