CS Paper Radar

Fixing the Fixpoint: A Formal Theory of Convergence Detection for Incremental Recursive Computation

Chengxi Yang, Tej Chajed, Thomas Reps

cs.PL cs.DB ·submitted 2026-09-30 18:16 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

Modern incremental computation theories like DBSP have enabled efficient incrementalization of general recursive computations. To do so, they require a runtime Fixpoint Detection (FPD) mechanism to detect whether an iterative computation has reached the fixpoint and thus should terminate. However, we show that the commonly suggested "FirstZero" strategy is unsound even in naturally arising cases, and that exact FPD is impossible for arbitrary DBSP circuits with expressive primitive nodes. This issue reveals a fundamental gap between the mathematical specification and implementations of such theories. To fill this gap, using DBSP as a core calculus, we develop a formal theory of convergence detection. Within this theory, we define internal convergence (IntConv) as a declarative criterion corresponding to the internal-state-stability strategy used by practical implementations, and prove that IntConv is a sufficient condition for external convergence. We then define the state fixpoint (StFP) predicate and a sound and complete StFP detector. Combining the StFP detector with fixed-input and zero-output checks yields a sound and complete IntConv detector. Moreover, for a large class of useful circuits (programs) including Datalog queries, nested while queries, and their incrementally optimized versions, we show that IntConv is not only sound but also complete (meaning any convergence in the theory implies the convergence in our criterion). As a result, our theory provides semantic guarantees for convergence detection on all these circuits. Our results are formally verified in Lean, with the formalization available at https://github.com/Arcadia-Y/fixing-the-fixpoint/.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Garlene: Guarded Recursion in Lean

cs.LO cs.PL ·2026-09-21 ·Sergei Stepanenko, Patrick Bahr, Rasmus Ejlers Møgelberg
theoryhot direction similarity 0.63
Abstract

Extending the recursion principles of a formal system is an enticing but dangerous endeavour with a well-documented history of leading to consistency bugs. Nakano's guarded recursion is an elegant, type-based approach to soundly extend type theory with a powerful recursion principle. This makes guarded recursion useful for many applications, from programming with infinite structures such as streams to reasoning about advanced programming language features using synthetic guarded domain theory. Sadly, guarded recursion is not directly supported by any major interactive theorem prover, which leaves users of guarded recursion with unmechanised pen-and-paper proofs or mechanisations that depend on unmaintained theorem provers. In this paper, we present an implementation of guarded recursion as an embedded language in Lean consisting of a simply-typed lambda calculus for definitions and a higher-order logic for reasoning. Using Lean's excellent support for metaprogramming, our language allows users to write guarded recursive definitions in an intuitive syntax and to prove properties about them using a dedicated proof mode. We give our language a presheaf model, which we use to prove the soundness of our language and to allow users to export guarded recursive definitions and their theorems into standard Lean developments. To demonstrate the usefulness of our language, we present several case studies for programming and reasoning with guarded recursion.

0.24

Tree Equivalence of Higher-Order Recursion Schemes Is Undecidable

cs.FL cs.LO ·2026-10-29 ·Mingkun Xiao, Yixuan Sun
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract · 31 pages, 3 figures. Rocq artifact: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23734555

Higher-order recursion schemes (HORS) are finite, simply typed recursive programs that generate potentially infinite trees. Their monadic second-order model-checking problem is decidable. We prove that tree equivalence of deterministic HORS is undecidable and, more precisely, $Π^0_1$-complete under total computable many-one reductions. The lower bound holds for safe, productive schemes of order at most four over the fixed ranked alphabet $Σ_2=\{e:0,d:2\}$, consisting of one nullary and one binary symbol. Adapting the counter-guard witness of Boiret, Piorkowski, and Schmude, we generate all candidate executions of a two-counter machine by producing both continuations at every counter test. An integer weight is nonzero exactly on legal prefixes. Functions at fixed simple types represent the polynomial of growing degree. A shift recurrence updates them without storing a separate step counter, allowing the witness to be implemented by safe applicative HORS rules. At candidate halts, the intermediate schemes generate unary observation subtrees whose lengths encode the two natural-number components of the signed weight. Invalid candidates give matching observations; a legal halt produces a finite discrepancy. Fixed constructor contexts encode these intermediate trees over $Σ_2$. For the upper bound, a finite monotone semantics decides head convergence and supports an algorithm computing exact tree prefixes at any prescribed finite depth, including positions labelled $\bot$.

0.32

Domain Theory Meets Interaction Trees in Rocq

cs.LO ·2026-09-28 ·David Nowak, Vlad Rusu
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · In Proceedings FROM 2026, arXiv:2609.30324

We present a domain-theoretical formalization of interaction trees in the Rocq prover. Unlike existing formalizations, ours does not rely on Rocq's built-in coinduction. Hence, we avoid complications occurring in earlier works, such as artificially including silent steps to comply with Rocq's productivity checker, treating monad laws as weak bisimulations, and coinductive bisimulation reasoning. We define an inductive program equivalence relation as the congruence closure of a base relation on primitive effects with respect to action sequencing and least upper bounds. This enables reasoning about possibly non-terminating programs by reducing their equivalences to equivalences of their terminating approximations, which are then proved by induction. This relation is proved correct: provided the base relation is correct, equivalent computations have equal denotations in any monad that faithfully implements the effects. We illustrate the framework by showing the equivalence of two programs encoding the Syracuse sequence, whose termination is an open mathematical conjecture.

0.38

Progression- vs Automata-based Anticipatory Monitoring of LTL over Finite Traces (Extended Version)

cs.LO cs.AI ·2026-09-26 ·Sarah Winkler, Toryn Klassen, Sheila McIlraith, Marco Montali
similarity 0.60
Abstract

When safety-critical systems are developed from a known internal specification, their correctness can be established by model checking. In the frequent case where such a specification is unknown or inaccessible, runtime verification presents an attractive alternative, e.g., to ascertain that autonomous and agentic systems as well as business processes satisfy desirable properties and/or comply with safety requirements. In this paper we study anticipatory monitoring, an advanced form of runtime verification, where the monitoring state is determined by both the trace prefix seen so far, and all its possible finite-length, future continuations. We focus on monitoring linear-time properties that may involve arithmetic constraints. Automata-based approaches, the de-facto standard in this setting, are notorious for their computational complexity. We propose an alternative approach based on progression and LTLf satisfiability checking, for both propositional and arithmetic settings. We experimentally compare the automata- and progression-based approaches, and a third method that combines the two. Our experiments suggest that the progression-based approach often succeeds in producing a verdict when the automata constructions do not terminate, especially for the arithmetic setting. For the propositional setting, the combined technique provides a good tradeoff.

0.03

Detecting Empty Abstractions and Pruning Dead Paths in the Linux eBPF Verifier with Abstract Step Functions

cs.PL ·2026-11-17 ·Harishankar Vishwanatha, Srinivas Narayana, Santosh Nagarakatte
similarity 0.58
Abstract · 23 pages

The Linux kernel's eBPF verifier uses abstract interpretation to ensure the safety of user-provided programs before execution. It tracks each register with multiple interval domains and a bitwise domain (tristate numbers). Refining the abstract state at conditional branches can produce mutually contradictory constraints across domains, indicating an unreachable path. However, the verifier lacks an empty-set ($\bot$) representation and cannot detect when these domains have an empty intersection, causing it to analyze dead paths. Passing such contradictory states into domain reduction or downstream operators violates their implicit non-emptiness precondition, triggering domain invariant violations. This has been a multi-year issue in the Linux kernel causing production outages, false rejections, and state explosion. This paper presents a sound and complete constant-time emptiness check across the eBPF verifier's abstract domains to prune dead branches. We introduce abstract step functions, a general framework that tests whether intervals and non-convex domains intersect in O(1) time without scanning individual values. We develop tnum_step, a formally verified constant-time operator that jumps to the next integer satisfying a tristate bitmask. Using tnum_step, we design a multi-domain emptiness check that detects contradictory states during branch refinement and immediately prunes unreachable branches, eliminating the root cause of dead-branch invariant violations. Our technique prevents invariant violations, state explosion, and false rejections while incurring negligible (1.48%) overhead across Linux kernel selftests and production suites such as Cilium. Our tnum_step operator has been upstreamed into the mainline Linux kernel.

0.39

Propositional Dynamic Logic with Program Costs

cs.LO math.LO ·2026-11-02 ·Krishna Manoorkar, Wolfgang Poiger
similarity 0.58
Abstract

We introduce $\mathbb{N}\mathtt{PDL}$, a resource-aware variant of Propositional Dynamic Logic ($\mathtt{PDL}$) capable of accounting for program costs measured by natural numbers (such as time or space in the sense of computability theory). In this framework, programs correspond to transition systems weighted by extended natural numbers, and the syntax of our logic includes formulas expressing which properties are reachable by program executions within specific cost constraints. First, we explain how the standard program constructs of non-deterministic choice, sequential composition, iteration, and tests are interpreted in this weighted setting and establish the validity of their corresponding reduction axioms. Using an appropriate adaptation of the (Fischer-Ladner) filtration technique, we proceed to prove decidability and completeness for $\mathbb{N}\mathtt{PDL}$ as our main results. We furthermore provide upper and lower complexity bounds for this logic using translations between standard $\mathtt{PDL}$ and $\mathbb{N}\mathtt{PDL}$.

0.13

Capturing Bisimulation-Invariant Exponential-Space Complexity Classes

cs.LO cs.CC ·2026-10-11 ·Florian Bruse, David Kronenberger, Martin Lange
publishedtheory similarity 0.58
Abstract · In Proceedings GandALF 2026, arXiv:2610.08898

Otto's Theorem characterises the bisimulation-invariant PTIME queries over graphs as exactly those that can be formulated in the polyadic mu-calculus. This extends to a characterisation of the full bisimulation-invariant exponential-time hierarchy, using a higher-order extension of the polyadic mu-calculus, called PHFL, which is naturally stratified by type order. The bisimulation-invariant fragment of k-EXPTIME is captured by the fragment of PHFL whose formulas have type order at most k. This is obtained using a generalisation of the Immerman-Vardi Theorem by Freire and Martins. Here we provide such a characterisation of the exponential-space hierarchy. We show that the bisimulation-invariant fragment of k-EXPSPACE is captured by the fragment of PHFL of type order k+1 whose formulas are tail-recursive. Tail recursion limits the interplay between fixpoints and higher-order functions so that model checking based on fixpoint iteration can be made more space efficient in a way comparable to tail recursion in programming languages. The capturing result makes use of a generalisation of Vardi's characterisation of PSPACE as first-order logic with partial fixpoints, namely that k-EXPSPACE is captured by higher-order logic of order k+1 with partial fixpoints.

0.40

Function Contracts for Bounded Model Checking of C Programs

cs.SE ·2026-10-19 ·Weiqi Wang, Marie Farrell, Liping Zhao, Lucas C. Cordeiro
code/data similarity 0.58
Abstract · 20 pages. Artifact: https://github.com/LukeW1999/esbmc-function-contracts

Bounded model checking unrolls a program into a single formula, so a function holding a loop costs the solver a fresh copy of that loop at every call site. Function contracts break that coupling. Verify the body once against its contract, then replace each call by a stub derived from it. CBMC supports this through dynamic frame condition checking, applied at industrial scale, but with no formal account of why the replacement is sound and no characterisation of what the frame check costs. We present the function-contract framework for ESBMC. The clause syntax, both phases, and the first assigns enforcement the tool has had are all introduced here. Its technical core is an observational frame rule: snapshot the locations the contract does not permit the function to write, then compare them at exit. The encoding emits a number of verification conditions set by how many globals the program has, not by how many writes the body performs, while dynamic frame condition checking grows with the write count. That is a property of the encoding rather than a timing, so it moves with neither the machine nor the solver. The rule itself is the classical one; what we add is its bounded form inside a BMC encoding, with the pipeline's algebraic skeleton machine-checked in Lean 4 and the limits of that model stated. We evaluate on synthetic sweeps, SV-COMP tasks, an ANSSI X.509 parser, the FreeRTOS heap_1 allocator, and the ML-KEM reference implementation whose CBMC contracts we reuse unchanged. At the coefficient count FIPS-203 mandates, neither tool finishes on the monolithic route inside ten minutes, and both finish on the modular one. The framework is merged into ESBMC master. Contracts are what is left when unrolling runs out of room.

0.48