CS Paper Radar

Collapse, Not Invariance: Diagnosing Auxiliary Objectives in Speech Anti-Spoofing

Ksenia Lysikova, Kirill Borodin, Maxim Maslov, Grach Mkrtchian

cs.SD ·submitted 2026-09-30 18:21 UTC · v1

Abstract

Speech anti-spoofing countermeasures degrade when the generator, codec or channel changes, and a common remedy is an auxiliary objective that shapes the embedding space; whether it does is invisible to EER, a pure ranking metric. We compare seven such objectives with cross-entropy over 113 runs on five corpora, AASIST3 at three seeds plus four pre-trained detectors, and measure the embedding space of the 24 AASIST3 runs directly. Raw augmentation displacement makes cosine consistency look effective, but the gain is a smaller space, not a more stable one: normalised by the spread, no configuration consistently improves on cross-entropy. Every trained space is dominated by the single decision axis expected for two classes, whose training-set structure does not transfer, and four runs collapse to a near-constant output that displacement rewards and EER reports as poor accuracy. No auxiliary objective keeps an advantage over cross-entropy across architectures, corpora and seeds.

Comment
Submitted to IEEE ICASSP 2027

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

ASR-Protected Fusion and Reference-Anchored Policy Optimization for Joint ASR and Word-Level Speech Anti-Spoofing

cs.SD ·2026-10-25 ·Xueping Zhang, Xiaoxiao Miao, Tiantian Feng, Ming Li
code/data similarity 0.72
Abstract

Existing anti-spoofing systems report either an utterance-level score or a time-based spoof interval: the former cannot show which words are spoofed, while the latter does not directly match the transcript and must be post-aligned with words, so alignment errors can lead to wrong word-level labels. Standard ASR model outputs only text; spoof information in the audio is lost after recognition and is not passed with the transcript. Yet changing only a few words can change the meaning of a sentence, leaving downstream systems to use incorrect text without knowing which words are spoofed. We therefore treat partial anti-spoofing as tagged ASR: the model transcribes speech and marks spoofed words at the same time, directly linking spoof labels to output words. We adopt the audio LLM and use ASR-Protected Subspace Gated Fusion (APSGF) to fuse spoof cues with ASR features. Spoof cues are added only outside an ASR-protected subspace, so they do not disturb recognition features. After cross-entropy training, we fine-tune the model with Reference-Anchored Policy Optimization (RAPO). Since the SFT policy is already concentrated, multiple samples from the same input tend to receive similar rewards, resulting in weak group-wise advantages. RAPO instead generates a single sample with low sampling randomness and anchors its advantage to the reward of a reference model. This allows the model to reinforce responses that outperform the reference while suppressing those that underperform it. Experiments on five datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in jointly detecting spoofed words and preserving ASR accuracy. The code is publicly available.

0.25

Not All Attacks Are Learned Equally in Speech Deepfake Detection

eess.AS ·2026-09-10 ·Avantika Singh, Aurosweta Mahapatra, Ismail Rasim Ulgen, Nicholas Andrews, Kong Aik Lee +1 more
published similarity 0.71
Abstract · Accepted to IEEE Spoken Language Technology (SLT) 2026

Speech deepfake detection (SDD) models are trained on multi-attack datasets containing diverse spoofing systems, such as text-to-speech (TTS) and voice conversion (VC). In standard classifier training on multi-attack datasets, all attacks are treated as one spoofed class, and performance is reported using overall Equal Error Rate (EER). This aggregate view obscures how individual attacks shape learning and generalization. To better understand this attack-level behavior, we first balance TTS and VC exposure using sample and attack omission. We then measure attack-wise EER at inference and analyze attack-wise training loss and predictive entropy to characterize optimization. Results show that attacks contribute unequally: some attacks have high EER sensitivity and concentrated entropy with low loss, indicating strong influence on the decision boundary. We define these as high-impact attacks. To reduce uneven generalization across attacks, we propose a replay-regularized, attack-aware curriculum that steps exposure based on measured attack influence. Experiments on ASVspoof 2019, 2021, ASVspoof 5, and Fake-or-Real show improved overall robustness and reduced attack-level imbalance compared with standard multi-attack training.

0.31

Temporal Anchors and Editing Sensitivity in Partial Speech Spoofing: A Controlled Study

cs.SD ·2026-10-03 ·Xiaosu Su, Yun Cao, Yiping Ni, Xiaowei Yi
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract

Partial-spoof detectors must reject synthetic content while accepting benign edits. We diagnose temporal anchors and boundary-consistency training using frozen WavLM features, nonlinguistic unit controls, and source-locked evaluation. Genuine-genuine and genuine-fake splices contrast editing false alarms with synthetic-content misses; they do not isolate a unique causal artifact. With layer-6 features, phone units have higher PartialSpoof evaluation frame EER than soft frames (11.18% versus 9.59%). In 500 retrospective PS-eval cases, augmentation reduces genuine-splice false alarms; synthetic-core misses increase at 5% PS-development FPR but not demonstrably at 1%. A 200-case Llama A follow-up retains the false-alarm reduction but does not establish a miss-rate increase. Constructed-case ranking can improve while fixed-threshold misses rise. Consistency gives no uniform gain, and encoder-layer rankings change across corpora. We report frame and event localization with three seeds, including word units, and treat PS evaluation as retrospective. Audit code, selected training scripts, and result summaries are available at https://github.com/mysxs/partial-spoof-diagnostics.

0.24

Unsupervised Data Drift Monitoring for Deployed Deepfake Speech Detectors

cs.SD cs.AIcs.CRcs.CV+1 ·2026-10-12 ·Lukáš Prokeš, Vojtěch Staněk, Anton Firc, Kamil Malinka
similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted at IEEE International Workshop on Information Forensics and Security (WIFS) 2026

Deepfake speech detectors are typically evaluated as binary classifiers on fixed benchmarks, but deployed systems face evolving attacks, codecs, speakers, and recording conditions, with labels unavailable during operation. This makes it difficult to know when a detector operates in familiar conditions and can be relied on. We propose an unsupervised drift monitor that operates on the internal embeddings of a deployed detector. The monitor compares each input against bona fide and spoof references using regularized Mahalanobis distances. These distances define trusted, ambiguous, and novel regions of the detector embedding space, allowing unfamiliar inputs to be routed for review. We evaluate the monitor on four modern detectors on three datasets. The monitor raises alerts for dataset mismatches and substantially reduces the security-critical case of accepting deepfakes at the cost of reduced automatic coverage. The results also show that drift affects both classes: bona fide recordings can move away from the training reference, increasing alert rates even in in-domain settings. Our findings suggest that deployed deepfake speech detectors should be treated not only as a binary classification, but also as a reliability problem.

0.21

Language Orthogonalization for Zero-Shot Cross-Lingual Audio Deepfake Detection

eess.AS cs.CL ·2026-09-15 ·Minu Kim, Ji Sub Um, Hoirin Kim
similarity 0.67
Abstract · Submitted to ICASSP 2027

Audio deepfake detectors need to transfer to languages absent from training, as multilingual speech synthesis outpaces labeled anti-spoofing resources. While detectors increasingly rely on self-supervised speech models (S3Ms), these backbones encode language-dependent structure that confounds spoof cues. We address this confound through language orthogonalization, a target-free ridge map that removes S3M variation projected onto continuous language-identification (LID) embeddings. Across six languages, six S3M backbones, and all Leave-N-Out settings, it consistently reduces EER across unseen languages. Cross-lingual EER correlates with LID-space distance, where orthogonalization yields larger gains for more distant transfers.

0.27

Spooftral: Can Voxtral Audio-Language Model Detect Speech Spoofing?

eess.AS cs.CL ·2026-09-23 ·Avishai Weizman, Yehuda Ben-Shimol, Itshak Lapidot
published similarity 0.67
Abstract · 8 pages, 3 figures, 5 tables. Accepted to the Spoken Language Technology (SLT) 2026

Self-supervised learning (SSL) countermeasures (CMs) have shown strong performance in recent years. However, they often show degraded performance while facing unseen spoofing attacks and mismatched conditions. This study examines the Voxtral audio-language model (ALM) framework for spoofing detection, as a step toward combining CM capabilities within the ALM framework. We analyze how Voxtral captures spoofing cues through audio-text processing and propose an instruction-guided approach that uses label-sequence likelihoods to evaluate bonafide and spoofed speech. Experiments on the ASVspoof databases show that without task-specific adaptation, the LLM layers emphasize semantic representations, reducing the separability of spoof-discriminative acoustic cues compared to the Whisper-based audio encoder. Consequently, spoofing-related information becomes less separable after language-model processing. We also applied lightweight adaptation using weight-decomposed low-rank adaptation (DoRA) to the Voxtral model and propose the Spooftral model, achieving an equal error rate (EER) of 4.25% on the ASVspoof5 evaluation set.

0.38

Unified Shared Encoder in Spoof-Aware Speaker Verification with Hybrid Wavelet Prompt Tuning

eess.AS cs.SD ·2026-10-01 ·Aref Farhadipour, Srikanth Madikeri, Teodora Vukovic, Volker Dellwo, Petr Motlicek
published similarity 0.65
Abstract · accepted at IEEE SLT 2026

Spoofing-aware speaker verification (SASV) must confirm who is speaking and that the speech is genuine, but current systems gain one at the expense of the other. Modular cascades are accurate yet run two large self-supervised encoders, whereas end-to-end models are efficient but lose accuracy when a single embedding has to serve two conflicting objectives. We show that this trade-off between efficiency and specialization is avoidable. A single frozen W2V-BERT~2.0 backbone is adapted per task by deep hybrid Wavelet Prompt Tuning (WPT), so each branch obtains its own view of the shared encoder through dedicated prompts and a task head, and the scores are combined only at inference. Training only about 7M parameters, a small fraction of those a strong two-encoder cascade requires, the system surpasses it on SpoofCeleb evaluation with 0.03% CM-EER and 0.038 min a-DCF against 0.16% and 0.047. Because the backbone is shared and frozen, new branches attach without retraining the heads and prompts already in place. On ASVspoof5, with adversarial attacks and codec distortions, it reaches 0.092 min a-DCF and 3.60% CM-EER using only the provided data, indicating that the design holds under realistic in-the-wild threats.

0.37

Tracking the Trend in How Speech Synthesizers Deceive People

cs.CR cs.SDeess.AS ·2026-08-20 ·Milan Šalko, Anton Firc, Kamil Malinka, Vojtěch Staněk, Martin Perešini +2 more
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.65
Abstract · Accepted at the 6th Symposium on Security and Privacy in Speech Communication (SPSC 2026)

Advances in speech synthesis have made deepfake audio highly realistic. Earlier studies reported 70-80% human detection accuracy, but relied primarily on older synthesizers. We compare human detection for three selected voice synthesis tools released in 2019, 2022, and 2024 with 82 IT professionals, and benchmark humans against six pretrained detectors on the same material. For fully synthetic speech (full spoofs), the F1 score drops from about 90% for RTVC and YourTTS to 48% for ElevenLabs, although listeners were explicitly warned that deepfakes were present. For partial spoofing, where only one sentence of an utterance is altered, strict accuracy falls to 9%, and listeners classify the synthetic sentence as bona fide 77% of the time. Humans and detectors fail in complementary ways, and neither reliably localizes short manipulations. Additionally, listeners increasingly mislabel bona fide speech as fake, eroding trust in unmanipulated audio. These findings show that human perception alone is unreliable for the selected modern and partial-spoof conditions and motivate procedural verification, provenance, watermarking, and segment-level detection.

0.21