CS Paper Radar

Approximate Polynomial Satisfiability is in the Counting Hierarchy

Nikhil Balaji, Mahsa Shirmohammadi, Sébastien Tavenas, James Worrell

cs.CC ·submitted 2026-09-30 19:46 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

The Approximate polynomial satisfiability problem (APS), introduced by Guo, Saxena, and Sinhababu (CCC 2018), asks whether the zero vector lies in the Zariski closure of the image of a given polynomial map. Specifically, for a field $k$ with algebraic closure~$K$, the problem asks whether $\boldsymbol 0 \in\overline{\boldsymbol f(K^n)}$ for a polynomial map $\boldsymbol f=(f_1,\ldots,f_m)$ with $f_i\in k[X_1,\ldots,X_n]$. APS is a natural topological analogue of Hilbert's Nullstellensatz, namely the question of whether a given system of polynomial equations has a common zero. APS captures several problems in algebraic complexity, including border rank, hitting sets for border classes, and null-cone membership; it is known to be NP-hard and in PSPACE. We show that APS lies in the Counting Hierarchy (CH) over both the rationals and finite fields, substantially improving the known PSPACE upper bound. Our proof builds on a recent breakthrough due to Andrews, Garg, and Schost (FOCS 2026) on deciding Hilbert's Nullstellensatz in CH. As a corollary, our result improves the complexity of certifying hitting sets for border classes from PSPACE to CH. We also give a polynomial-time reduction of Hilbert's Nullstellensatz to APS, valid in any characteristic. In characteristic zero, we give a reduction of APS to the decision problem for the existential theory of real closed fields. Overall, our results place approximate polynomial satisfiability closer in complexity to exact polynomial feasibility and as a byproduct give improved complexity bounds for several problems arising in approximative complexity.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Approximate Polynomial Satisfiability and Integral Closure Membership in the Counting Hierarchy

cs.CC ·2026-10-30 ·Sanyam Agarwal, Archit Hari, Anurag Pandey, Himanshu Shukla
theory similarity 0.82
Abstract · Made some minor changes

Andrews, Garg, and Schost (FOCS~2026) recently, in a breakthrough result, placed Hilbert's Nullstellensatz (HN) in the Counting Hierarchy ($\CH$) using constant-depth circuits for multivariate resultants. While HN deals with exact polynomial satisfiability, Guo, Saxena, and Sinhababu (CCC~2018; Theory of Computing~2019) introduced approximate polynomial satisfiability (APS) as a natural approximative analogue of polynomial system satisfiability. They proved its $\mathsf{NP}$-hardness and a $\PSPACE$ upper bound, and used APS to construct hitting sets for $\overline{\mathsf{VP}}$ in polynomial space, substantially narrowing the GCT chasm in geometric complexity theory. We place APS in the Counting Hierarchy for rational polynomials given by arithmetic circuits. Our proof combines Noether normalization with a geometric restriction on how points in the image of a polynomial map approach the origin, reducing APS to a test on multivariate resultants which allows solvability in $\CH$. It complements the independent and concurrent proofs of Balaji, Shirmohammadi, Tavenas, and Worrell, and Andrews, Garg, Oliveira, and Schost. Moreover, we also place integral closure membership testing in the Counting Hierarchy. Here, the question is whether a given polynomial $f$ is integral over $\C[f_1,\ldots,f_m]$. Our approach uses a global annihilator criterion and an effective degree bound to reduce non-integrality to APS in polynomial time. In fact, we show that the reduction holds both ways, and Integral Closure Membership Testing is equivalent to APS under polynomial-time reductions.

0.17

Some algebraic and geometric computations in CH via Chow forms

cs.CC cs.SC ·2026-11-03 ·Robert Andrews, Abhibhav Garg, Rafael Oliveira, Éric Schost
similarity 0.69
Abstract

The problem of decomposing an algebraic variety into more structured components (such as equidimensional, irreducible, or connected components) is a fundamental problem in computer algebra and algebraic geometry. In this work, we study the computational complexity of computing equidimensional components of algebraic varieties, represented via Chow forms. We improve the state-of-the-art complexity bounds from PSPACE to CH, the counting hierarchy, for a number of problems related to equidimensional decomposition, including deciding (1) whether the Chow form of the $k^{\text{th}}$ equidimensional component of a given projective variety vanishes at a given point, (2) whether a given monomial is in the support of the Chow form of the $k^{\text{th}}$ equidimensional component of a given projective variety, (3) membership in a given equidimensional component of a given algebraic variety, and (4) membership in the closure of the image of an irreducible variety under a polynomial map. As an application of our algorithm to decide membership in the closure of the image of a variety under a polynomial map, we show that the approximate polynomial satisfiability problem can be decided in CH. We also show that the degree of the $k^{\text{th}}$ equidimensional component of a given projective variety can be computed in $\text{FP}^{\text{CH}}$. Our main technical result is the construction of a polylogtime-uniform family of constant-depth, exponential-size threshold circuits that compute the Chow forms of the equidimensional components of a given projective variety. We construct these circuits by combining the machinery of geometric resolutions together with the uniform constant-depth, exponential-size threshold circuits of Andrews, Garg, and Schost (FOCS 2026) for the multivariate resultant.

0.19

Common zeros of homogeneous polynomials and the weight hierarchy of projective Reed-Muller codes

cs.IT math.ACmath.AG ·2026-11-05 ·Rodrigo San-José
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract

We determine the maximum number of common zeros in projective space of any set of linearly independent homogeneous polynomials of the same degree, when the degree is smaller than the cardinality of the finite field. This proves the conjecture of Beelen, Datta, and Ghorpade, resolving a longstanding problem on common zeros and determining the complete weight hierarchy of the corresponding projective Reed-Muller codes. The proof uses Green's hyperplane restriction bound, combined with a footprint argument that reduces the problem to the affine case solved by Heijnen and Pellikaan. Wei duality then determines the hierarchy in sufficiently large degrees, recovering the complete hierarchy in every degree for the projective plane. Finally, we prove an upper bound valid in every degree, and conjecture that it is always sharp.

0.13

Pseudo-solutions of polynomial systems and the lower bound problem for $\mbox{AC}^0[p]$-Frege systems

cs.CC math.LO ·2026-09-28 ·Jan Krajicek
theory similarity 0.63
Abstract · only change: author name spelling corrected

The problem to establish a lower bound for $\mbox{AC}^0[p]$-Frege refutations of a system of polynomial equations over ${\bf F}_p$ was in K. (2024) reduced to the existence of a pseudo-solution (a notion defined there) for the system. Here we reduce this further, for the system expressing the negation of the PHP, to a property of search trees querying values of linear maps on the vector space of low degree polynomials over ${\bf F}_p$.

0.35

Ideal Membership in Polynomial Calculus: Complexity and Reductions

cs.CC ·2026-09-23 ·Alex Bortolotti, Monaldo Mastrolilli
theory similarity 0.63
Abstract

The Ideal Membership Problem (IMP) asks whether a polynomial f belongs to an ideal <p_1, ..., p_m> of Q[x_1, ..., x_n]. Polynomial Calculus (PC) certifies membership by deriving f from the generators, and a degree-d derivation needs at most n^O(d) steps. We write PC-IMPd for the problem of producing a degree-bounded PC certificate, and call it solvable when one is guaranteed to exist and can be found in time n^O(d). Over Q, unlike over finite fields, a derivation may need exponentially many bits. We study PC-IMPd on instances arising from constraint satisfaction problems, and ask for which constraint languages L it is solvable. Our main contribution is a reduction framework for PC-IMPd, based on pp-definitions, pp-interpretations, and pp-encodings, that mirrors the algebraic approach to CSP complexity. Solvability is preserved by these constructions and, in the language of algebras, by passing to subalgebras, finite direct powers, and homomorphic images. We obtain new tractable classes over ternary and larger domains: every language closed under the median operation on a finite chain has solvable PC-IMPd, by reduction to the Boolean majority algebra, and in particular so does every language over {0, 1, 2} closed under a fixed-value majority. This also places IMPd(L) in P for such languages, advancing the classification of IMPd over ternary domains. In the process, we settle the last open case of the Boolean dichotomy for IMPd(L) and complete the Boolean classification of PC-IMPd(L) with an unconditional lower bound for an instance of PC-IMP1. A recent PC-to-SoS simulation reduces degree-automatability of Sum-of-Squares (the open problem of finding a degree-d SoS proof in time n^O(d) when one exists) to solvability of PC-IMPd. Each new tractable class therefore yields a family of constraint systems on which SoS proofs are degree-automatable.

0.24

Discrete-time polynomial systems with inputs and outputs: structure, reachability, observability, and minimal realizations

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-09-29 ·Eduardo D. Sontag
similarity 0.61
Abstract

We study the realization problem for discrete-time input/output polynomial systems. These are formalized using tools from commutative algebra and algebraic geometry as systems whose state spaces are algebraic varieties, or more abstractly the set of k-points of an affine k-scheme, where k is an arbitrary infinite field. The input/output behaviors of such systems are described by "polynomial response maps" in which outputs are polynomial functions of past inputs. The main results show that every polynomial response map admits a canonical (quasi-reachable and algebraically observable) realization, which is unique up to isomorphism. The key to the approach is to linearize dynamics by considering a "dual" system in which states are functions defined on states. Finite dimensionality of the canonical realization, and its polynomiality, are characterized in terms of the space, algebra, and field of observables of the map, as well as in terms of algebraic input/output difference equations, and by a Jacobian rank criterion. A particular subclass consists of the maps that we call "bounded," defined by the property that their degree in the past inputs is uniformly bounded. Bounded maps are shown to be finitely realizable if and only if they are realizable by finite-dimensional state-affine systems, whose theory in turn reduces to that of rational formal power series. We also study the lattice of quasi-reachable realizations of a given map, including normal realizations. This work is an update of the PhD thesis written by the author in 1976; connections to recent work are briefly discussed in the last section.

0.38

Degree profiles of uniform polynomial consequences: Linear lower bounds for Nullstellensatz and Polynomial Calculus

cs.CC cs.LOmath.LO ·2026-11-05 ·Søren Riis
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 78 pages. Tutorial, Lean formalisation and verification records: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23965838

This paper proves asymptotically optimal linear degree lower bounds for Nullstellensatz and Polynomial Calculus, yielding a four-way polynomial-versus-exponential proof-size classification for uniform polynomial consequences over fields of positive characteristic. The size bounds use full, explicit coefficient lists, including zeros. Apart from a fixed finite initial range, exactly one of four cases occurs: $\mathrm T_1$, bounded degree; $\mathrm T_2$, degree at least linear in the universe size $n$; $\mathrm T_3$, constant degree on some residue classes and at least linear degree on the others; or $\mathrm T_4$, infinitely many recurring finite degrees, with bounded-degree subsequences and finite $Ω(n)$ peaks at arbitrarily large sizes. Thus the size patterns are polynomial bounds, exponential lower bounds, a periodic mixture, or polynomial subsequences with finite exponential peaks, respectively. Underivable targets have degree $\infty$, and both proof systems assign the same type. The result strengthens my 2008--2009 refutation classification and extends it to uniform consequences. The proof uses degree-preserving lifting with onset and period bounds linear in the degree. A common $p$-adic hardness spectrum describes the four types topologically. Distinguishing any two types is undecidable already for refutations. The linear degree bounds, four-way classification and pairwise undecidability results have been formalised and verified in Lean. The Lean formalisation, verification records and an accompanying tutorial are available in the supporting materials (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23965838).

0.41

Tight Lower Bounds for Algebraic Communication and Applications

cs.CC ·2026-09-15 ·Manon Blanc, Prateek Dwivedi, Magnus Rahbek Dalgaard Hansen, Nutan Limaye, Meena Mahajan
publishedtheory similarity 0.59
Abstract · Strengthened the deterministic Equality lower bound, thereby also proving the Unordered Equality lower bound. Minor improvements to the pres…

Communication complexity studies how much information must be exchanged to solve a problem whose input is split among two or more parties. In this work, we study an algebraic variant, where the inputs are vectors over a field $\mathbb{F} \in \{\mathbb{R}, \mathbb{C}\}$. There are two players, Alice and Bob, with inputs $X\in \mathbb{F}^n$ and $Y\in \mathbb{F}^n$, respectively. In the polynomial evaluation problem, the goal is to compute the value of a polynomial $g\in \mathbb{F}[X,Y]$ on the given input. In the set-recognition problem, the goal is to decide whether $(X,Y)\in S$, for a given set $S\subseteq \mathbb{F}^{n} \times \mathbb{F}^n$. In both settings, Alice and Bob send evaluations of polynomials depending only on their own inputs. In the set-recognition problem, a referee receives the messages and may apply polynomial tests to the messages received so far; the outcomes of these tests determine acceptance or rejection. The protocols may be deterministic or probabilistic. We give non-trivial upper bounds for a range of natural polynomial evaluation and set-recognition problems. We also prove reductions between different problems. Our main technical contribution is a general framework for proving lower bounds for algebraic set-recognition problems. Using this framework, we prove several probabilistic lower bounds for natural problems. In a number of cases, these lower bounds match the corresponding upper bounds, giving tight or near-tight characterizations of their algebraic communication. Finally, we give two applications of our framework. First, we use the communication lower bounds to prove lower bounds for a class of left-to-right algebraic algorithms, which we call algebraic scanners. Second, we show that our lower bound arguments extend beyond polynomials to a more general algebraic computational setting inspired by the Blum--Shub--Smale model.

0.27