CS Paper Radar

Cybernetic and Epistemic: A Missing Vocabulary for Trustworthy Agentic Delegation

Jérémie Lumbroso

cs.AI cs.HC ·submitted 2026-10-01 02:46 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

As code generation is increasingly delegated to AI systems, the bottleneck is shifting from writing code to supervising the systems that write it --- a shift CS-education researchers have begun to name. This shift exposes a vocabulary gap: the field asks for "human oversight" without a working distinction between the two things language does in a delegation channel --- coordinate action (cybernetic: words succeed when the world comes to match them) and coordinate understanding (epistemic: they succeed when they answer to the world and a hearer can check that they do). The failure this names is not cybernetic language but epistemic-form language doing cybernetic work: explanation-shaped output calibrated for approval rather than truth. Oversight that checks only whether an output was approved is satisfiable by rubber-stamping; oversight that holds an agent accountable requires the reasoning behind its work be retrievable and checkable. We present three delegation episodes --- illustrations, not controlled evidence --- in which epistemic engagement proved practicable while remaining auditable, one public record where a recommendation was withdrawn on its own stated terms, and one failure case illustrating oversight that requires no reasons for its discretionary choices. We propose a criterion for agentic-system governance, alongside existing technical trust properties: every consequential choice should carry the condition under which it would have gone otherwise, in a form a third party can test. Without such a condition, a third party cannot distinguish a decision from a rubber stamp. We give the criterion an operational form --- a two-part reconstruction test scoring a delegation record by whether a second reader can predict what the agent does under a perturbation --- and a deliberation-recording convention, ORRCF, that makes the condition a required component of every recorded choice.

Comment
Accepted at TAS 2026 (AAAI Fall Symposium Series), Nov 5-7, 2026, Arlington VA

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Trustworthy Agentic AI: Failure Modes, Mitigation Strategies, and a Lifecycle Framework for Autonomous LLM Systems

cs.AI ·2026-09-19 ·Fayeq Jeelani Syed, Rehan Ahmad, Ali Al Bataineh, Aakriti Adhikari
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Agentic AI systems built on large language models can plan over multiple steps, use external tools, retain information in memory, and coordinate with other agents. These capabilities make them more useful than static language models, but they also introduce new security and operational risks. Untrusted content from websites, emails, documents, and databases can enter the same context as system instructions; persistent memory can carry compromised information across sessions; and access to external tools can turn an incorrect model response into a consequential real-world action. This article reviews the trustworthiness of agentic AI across five interconnected dimensions: safety and robustness, alignment and human oversight, transparency and auditability, privacy and data governance, and regulatory compliance. It organizes key failure modes, including indirect prompt injection, backdoor triggers, goal misgeneralization, memory contamination, and cross-session data leakage, into a unified taxonomy. It also examines major mitigation approaches, such as instruction hierarchies, context isolation, spotlighting, process-based supervision, constrained tool use, and privacy-preserving memory, while distinguishing techniques supported by empirical evidence from those that remain largely conceptual. Building on this analysis, we introduce the Trustworthy Agent Development Lifecycle (TADL), a six-phase framework covering specification, design, training, evaluation, deployment, and monitoring. For each phase, TADL identifies relevant trust activities, expected evidence, and risk-based decision gates. Although TADL has not yet been empirically validated, it provides a structured foundation for developing and evaluating more secure and accountable agentic systems. The article concludes by identifying gaps in current benchmarks and outlining priorities for future research.

0.15

Accountable partial understanding: securing the epistemic attack surface of agentic systems

cs.CR ·2026-10-19 ·Josiah Dykstra
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 28 pages, 1 table. Under review

Attackers profit from what defenders do not understand. Software security has treated the gap between system behavior and human comprehension as a condition to narrow through analysis and assurance, booking the remainder as accepted risk. Agentic AI systems change that gap: when software reads, writes, explains, and authorizes security-relevant behavior, partial understanding moves faster, grows more opaque, and couples to delegated authority. This paper characterizes the resulting epistemic attack surface and presents a taxonomy of four interacting attack categories, which target the interpretation of intent, the production and consumption of evidence, the scope of delegated authority, and the comprehension of human supervisors. It then defines accountable partial understanding (APU) and specifies six necessary conditions: bounded scope with explicit assumptions, inspectable evidence, assigned responsibility, visible residual unknowns, actionability, and temporal maintenance. It explains why delegating interpretation to software agents differs from distributing knowledge among people and distinguishes APU from risk acceptance, explainable AI, assurance cases, formal verification, and human-in-the-loop oversight. From the conditions, the paper derives five design principles: bounded delegation, decoupled evidence, assumption tracking with invalidation, role-specific accountability views, and intervention-preserving design with residual unknown registers. It introduces two measurable probe dimensions, evidence linkage and invalidation latency, for testing whether accountability mechanisms hold under change and adversarial pressure. Three running examples (an AI coding agent, an autonomous cyber-defense agent, and an AI-mediated insulin delivery update) ground the analysis. Security without full understanding is already here; the task is to make it accountable.

0.32

When Agents Act Unwatched: The Reduced-Supervision Paradox in Agentic AI

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-08-28 ·Hanjing Shi, Dominic DiFranzo
position similarity 0.66
Abstract · 24 pages, 4 tables. Expanded preprint with a structured public-artifact audit and three worked action paths

Agentic AI is sold on a simple promise: the system keeps acting when the user stops watching. That promise creates an accountability inversion. As stepwise supervision recedes, verification does not disappear; it moves into the runtime infrastructure that defines authority, records action, interrupts execution, checks outcomes, and supports repair. We call this the reduced-supervision paradox. Using a 63-artifact audit, we examine its public visibility across 46 research papers and 17 engineering, documentation, security, and governance sources. We find that agents' action surfaces are far easier to reconstruct than the mechanisms needed to answer for their actions. Tool mediation and monitoring traces were clearly visible in 40 and 37 artifacts, whereas checkpoint placement was clearly visible in 6, validator independence in 4, recovery in 2, and contestability in 1. Three action paths show why this imbalance matters. A repository path can preserve rich diffs after a consequential change. A browser path can cross organizational boundaries faster than permissions travel. A service path can follow policy while leaving affected people without recourse. We argue that observability can become a substitute for accountability when it shifts verification onto users after meaningful intervention is no longer possible. Our action-path diagnostic instead asks whether a delegated action remains connected to authority, evidence, interruption, independent judgment, recovery, and challenge. The claim is deliberately bounded to public visibility; it does not establish the prevalence or effectiveness of undisclosed controls. We contribute an action-level account that recasts the harness from a technical wrapper into accountability infrastructure.

0.25

Where Accountability Lives: Mapping Human Responsibility to Workflow Artifacts in Agentic Software Development

cs.SE ·2026-08-16 ·Sabry E. Farrag, Youssef Saber
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 30 pages, 5 tables. Source collection of 118 archived documents and 12 processing scripts deposited at Zenodo, doi:10.5281/zenodo.21965182

Coding agents author commits, open pull requests and push code in production repositories. Responsibility is settled in two layers that do not refer to each other: platform controls gating what an agent may do, and provider terms allocating responsibility for its output. Objective: Where the two layers disagree at a workflow event, and what each states there about authority, execution, verification, consequence and record. Method: A qualitative document study of 121 items archived byte-exact: documentation for four agentic coding tools, the platform controls on their output, and eighteen policy documents from seven providers, read by deductive content analysis against an a-priori system of five dimensions and nine workflow events. An independent second coder blind-recoded the verification-mechanism classification, a complete enumeration and not a sample (Cohen's kappa 0.81, n = 13, on whether a mechanism compels; 0.75, n = 12, on who performs it). Results: Cursor's terms make the user responsible for evaluating the use of any suggestion; its documentation describes a product that performs that evaluation and records it as an approval. No collected artifact records that the verification the terms make the user's duty took place. At merge two tools compel a person, one documents an agent approving below a configured risk threshold, and one only advises. Six of the fifteen mechanisms that compel a check have a default the vendor states; nine have one this study inferred. Readers who had not made them refuted five of the eight absence claims; three survived, one materially qualified. Conclusions: The terms attach duty and consequence to output as a class, the platform records events, nothing records the duty discharged. One vendor documents a product that forms the approval judgement, and the terms allocate consequence against the artifact regardless.

0.39

Approval Laundering: Systematizing Approval--Execution Binding Failures in AI Coding-Agent Harnesses

cs.CR cs.AIcs.SE ·2026-09-30 ·Yang Wang
highly cited similarity 0.65
Abstract

Modern AI coding-agent harnesses (Claude Code, Codex CLI, Cursor) rest their security boundary on a largely unexamined assumption: that the action A a human approves is the same action A' the harness executes, where A is fixed by a stated policy for what a scope grant or session-scoped approval authorizes. We show this assumption fails systematically and reproducibly. We introduce Approval Laundering, a taxonomy of six failure modes by which a harness's enforcement mechanism silently substitutes A' for A after approval: Scope, Argument, Temporal, Tool, Delegation, and Semantic laundering. Unlike prior work that evaluates risk classifiers against static corpora or infers implicit authorization boundaries, we study credential-binding integrity: given an already-approved action, does the harness dispatch exactly that action? Instrumenting Claude Code's pre-execution mediation point (PreToolUse), we conduct a controlled, headless, repeated-measures study of all six classes (N=19-20 runs each), reporting a Bound-Gap Rate (BGR) with Wilson confidence intervals and inter-rater agreement (kappa=1.0). We prototype Approval Token, a keyed capability Hk(principal, agent_id, session_id, tool, arguments, scope, expiry) issued by a mediator that never returns the key to the agent, evaluated via paired before/after replay of 118 runs (McNemar's exact test). The token fully eliminates Delegation laundering and, for our seeded session-identity-mismatch construction, Temporal laundering (p<10^-5), but by design leaves Scope laundering unaffected and shows no significant reduction in Argument laundering (p=1): an honest negative result, since these two classes leave every recorded dispatch field unchanged, diverging one process level below what a field-only verifier can observe. We discuss implications for defenses that bind only at the tool-invocation boundary.

0.38

When Skills Tell Agents Not to Ask: A Large-Scale Study of Oversight Directives in Agent Skills

cs.CR cs.AIcs.SE ·2026-10-27 ·Timofey Sanko, Yuan Tian
code/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · preprint

Agent skills, reusable instruction packages centred on a SKILL.md file, extend AI agents on demand, and a single line in a widely copied skill reaches every agent that loads it. Some lines are oversight-loosening directives: they tell the agent to proceed without approval, to bypass checks with --no-verify, or to keep working without checking in. Although such directives can remove a checkpoint from every agent that loads them, no prior work has examined them. We present the first large-scale study of oversight-loosening directives, analyzing 1.53 million English skills from GitSkills. We split skills into units (sentences, bullets, table cells, and code lines), develop a codebook that labels oversight directives by polarity, mechanism, and scope, label 2,097 units by hand, and train a detector to scale the analysis. Our results show that about one in seventeen skills (about 88,000 skills) contains a loosening directive. These directives most often loosen oversight through permission flags, and most of them (70.1%) apply unconditionally rather than only in specific contexts such as CI. Compared with skills that have the same amount of oversight language, skills that run shell code, install packages, or use sudo have 1.7-1.8 times the odds of containing a loosening directive, an association that holds across all our robustness checks, and they do not compensate with more tightening. Loosening spreads through a few upstream skills rather than through edits by their adopters: 2.4% of the skill families that carry loosening account for half of all copies of loosening-carrying skills, and 1.1% of distinct loosening units for half of all loosening occurrences. Open-source skill scanners catch at most 46% of loosening directives, with a precision below 0.4, while the LLM behind them, prompted with our codebook instead, catches 61% at a precision of 0.71.

0.22

Correct Is Not Governed: Provenance Integrity in Agentic Workflows

cs.AI cs.CR ·2026-08-13 ·Jesus Salas
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 19 pages, 2 figures

Agentic workflows are commonly evaluated by whether they reach the correct outcome. That is insufficient in institutional settings, where a correct action may rely on the wrong authority, an unsupported completion claim, or work made stale by a later change. We define governed execution as work whose decisions, completion, and response to change are supported by inspectable provenance. We present Matrix, a deterministic causal-state layer that records authority and fact dependencies, verifies completion evidence, and selectively invalidates affected work. Across controlled comparisons, governed and direct workflows often reached the same outcomes, but only the governed path consistently preserved governing evidence, refused unsupported closure, and limited recovery to dependent tasks. A role-separated transfer challenge then failed: a deterministically enforced completeness contract severely over-blocked synthetic packets produced outside its authoring context. These results do not establish Matrix as a general accuracy enhancer; they support its primary role as an institutional integrity layer for making agentic work auditable and independently verifiable.

0.47

Poster: Towards ProofWeave: A Privacy-Minimised, Integrity-Anchored Evidence Plane for Continuous Agentic Assurance

cs.CR ·2026-09-28 ·Guy Lupo, Nguyen Hung Nguyen, Viet Vo, Chamikara M. A. P., Guangdong Bai
top venue similarity 0.63
Abstract · 3 pages, 2 figures. Poster accepted at ACM CCS 2026

Agentic AI systems increasingly act via tools, memory, delegation, and external services. Existing observability and provenance mechanisms can reconstruct events post hoc, but they rarely show, at the time of the record, whether each policy-relevant action was checked by the intended control before execution. This leaves a trust-observability gap for continuous monitoring, detection, and response: later assurance may rest on evidence that is incomplete, privacy-leaking, mutable, or detached from the policy context that governed the event. What's missing in the literature is contemporaneous, policy-bound evidence that the intended control was evaluated under the policy in force at the time. We introduce ProofWeave, a record-time chain-of-evidence concept for agentic AI assurance. At each policy-relevant action boundary, ProofWeave generates a privacy-minimised and integrity-anchored evidence transaction that binds (i) agent intent or action, (ii) control response, and (iii) a policy-at-time snapshot. Each transaction is committed to an append-only ledger and materialised into a derived proof graph. A bounded Weaver Agent translates policy intent into proof obligations, while deterministic validators check evidence completeness, privacy minimisation, policy binding, and integrity. In the minimal scenario, an agent attempts to transmit a secret to an unapproved external sink. The audit compares a logs-only correlation baseline with ProofWeave across verdict latency, join ambiguity, privacy exposure, tamper detection, and resistance to graph-only proof injection. ProofWeave reduces candidate bindings per verdict from up to `10,201` to one, validation operations from up to `10,201` to approximately `26`, and assurance evidence storage from `0.79`MiB to `0.15`MiB per project.

0.32