CS Paper Radar

Tolerance-Based Fairness Auditing: Violation Certification and Sensitivity Screening

Jie Tang, Chuanlong Xie, Lixing Zhu

cs.LG stat.MLstat.ME ·submitted 2026-10-01 03:49 UTC · v1

Abstract

As artificial intelligence is increasingly deployed, algorithmic unfairness has raised growing concerns and intensified demands for transparent fairness auditing. In practice, the tolerable degree of algorithmic unfairness depends on the specific legal, ethical, or application context. Given a prespecified tolerance threshold, an important statistical question is how to determine whether a group disparity exceeds the allowable tolerance across different auditing objectives. To address this problem, we develop a unified tolerance-based fairness auditing framework for two complementary auditing objectives: violation certification, which prioritizes control of false violation declarations, and sensitivity screening, which prioritizes reducing missed violations. For the first objective, we develop a constrained empirical likelihood test for formal settings that uses least-favorable-point calibration and can be combined with false flagging rate control for simultaneous subgroup auditing. For the second objective, we develop split empirical likelihood and adjusted split empirical likelihood tests using an adaptive boundary-proxy principle for early-warning settings. Numerical experiments show the distinct error-control--sensitivity trade-offs of these procedures. A COMPAS analysis illustrates the framework in predictive fairness auditing.

Comment
47 pages, 8 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Efficient Active Auditing of Multi-Group Fairness with Bias Probes

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CYstat.AP+1 ·2026-09-30 ·Ayoub Ajarra, Debabrota Basu
similarity 0.70
Abstract

Over the past decade, Machine Learning (ML) has been trained under dual objectives: minimizing prediction error via Empirical Risk Minimization (ERM) while controlling unfairness bias. In practice, however, fairness-aware training often yields limited improvements over standard ERM, making reliable post hoc auditing essential. Existing auditing approaches for black-box models either rely on model reconstruction --exposing systems to extraction attacks-- or directly estimate fairness metrics, offering limited insight into which regions of the data distribution drive bias. More fundamentally, property-specific auditing --aimed at extracting only targeted fairness information without reconstructing the model-- remains poorly understood. In this work, we introduce the bias probe framework, which enables targeted and adaptive querying to reveal bias structure while preserving model confidentiality. Building on this framework, we propose ALeBi, an active auditor that learns such probes to efficiently estimate multi-group fairness metrics. We establish novel sample complexity guarantees governed by a property-specific complexity measure, resolving a previously posed open question, and extend our analysis to adversarial settings where the model owner may strategically obscure bias. Our results uncover a fundamental trade-off between model confidentiality and reliable auditing, and show that property-specific probing enables both accurate estimation and interpretable identification of high and low-bias regions. Extensive experiments support our theoretical findings and demonstrate the practical effectiveness of our approach.

0.12

VFR-Audit: Verdict-Level Reliability for Fairness Audits in Hospital Length-of-Stay Prediction

cs.AI ·2026-08-31 ·Md Jannatul Rakib Joy, Viet Vo, Caslon Chua
top venue similarity 0.68
Abstract · 12 pages, 5 figures. Accepted at the 35th ACM International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM 2026)

Fairness audits in clinical Artificial Intelligence convert continuous fairness metrics into binary pass-or-fail verdicts against operational thresholds, where hospital governance boards, payers, and regulators act on the resulting verdicts. Such audits are repeated over time and across hospital sites, thus the same verdict can flip between pass and fail across audits. Existing uncertainty methods such as Bayesian posteriors, bootstrap confidence intervals, and permutation tests address verdict instability only at the continuous-metric level. Converting metric-level uncertainty into a verdict-stability claim remains a manual step that scales poorly across the (model, metric, attribute) cells an audit covers. Existing uncertainty methods also leave open whether bias-mitigation steps, such as reweighing or per-group threshold shifts, yield a stable passing verdict at the cost of model discrimination measured as AUROC or AUPRC.To address this verdict-stability gap, we propose VFR-Audit, a framework built around the Verdict Flip Rate (VFR), a scalar bounded between 0 and 0.5 that measures the probability of verdict reversal under stratified bootstrap resampling. VFR-Audit reports VFR alongside three reliability axes, namely within-cohort resampling stability, audit-size sensitivity, and cross-hospital verdict agreement via Fleiss' kappa.

0.36

A Geometric Theory of Robust Fairness Audits

cs.LG ·2026-08-25 ·Binita Maity
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

Neighborhood-based fairness audits evaluate individual fairness by comparing predictions among similar individuals in feature space. Despite their widespread use, little is known about the robustness of the auditing procedure itself. Because these audits rely on nearest neighbor relationships, small perturbations in feature space can alter local neighborhoods and produce different fairness assessments even when model predictions remain unchanged. We develop a geometric framework for analyzing the robustness of neighborhood-based fairness audits under bounded perturbations. Our analysis establishes sufficient conditions for neighborhood invariance, quantifies how neighborhood replacement propagates to audit instability, and introduces audit volatility, a measure of the expected sensitivity of fairness audits under repeated perturbations. Experiments on benchmark datasets support the theoretical analysis and show that the proposed framework explains the observed stability of neighborhood-based fairness audits.

0.22

Counterfactual, Per-Decision Bias Auditing for Automated Hiring: Localizing and Explaining Disparate Impact in Applicant Tracking Systems

cs.CY cs.CR ·2026-08-21 ·Jay Barach
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 10 pages, 5 figures, 8 tables

Automated applicant tracking systems increasingly decide who advances in hiring, and litigation and regulation now demand that those decisions be auditable. Existing tools sit at two extremes. Group fairness metrics such as the disparate impact ratio summarize a whole population but cannot say which individual decisions were unfair or why, while local explainers such as SHAP attribute a single prediction but are not connected to the legal standard by which hiring bias is judged. We present the AI Bias Firewall (AIBF), a method that audits an applicant tracking system one decision at a time. AIBF neutralizes a candidate's protected-attribute proxies, re-scores the decision, and measures the resulting counterfactual shift, which yields a signed per-decision bias in score points, a flag for decisions the protected attributes changed, and a plain-language explanation naming the responsible factors. We evaluate on two real public datasets, Adult and COMPAS, rather than on synthetic data. The per-decision counterfactual shift is faithful, aggregating to reproduce the known group level disparity, for example a mean shift of +7.5 points for the privileged group and -8.0 for the disadvantaged group on Adult, consistent with the measured statistical parity difference. AIBF identifies the decisions that protected attributes flipped with an area under the ROC curve of 0.963 on Adult, against 0.672 for a baseline that flags by group membership, and it identifies the harmed candidates so precisely that reviewing only five percent of decisions surfaces fifty-five percent of them, against six percent under group based review. We also report a limitation: correcting flagged decisions raises the disparate impact ratio substantially but not to legal parity, because features labeled as merit carry residual proxy correlation. AIBF is released under the Apache 2.0 license with code and experiments.

0.10

Rethinking Fairness Metrics for Multi-Class and Multi-Group Assessment: Not Everything is Binary

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-11-02 ·Matteo Grazioso, Fabio Naccarella, Chiara Gallese, Marco S. Nobile
similarity 0.65
Abstract · Submitted to ACM Transactions on Intelligent Systems and Technology (TIST)

Artificial Intelligence, and Machine Learning in general, is becoming pervasive across all domains and disciplines. By means of this data-driven approach, algorithms can learns complex task just by learning from samples. However, if the data-set is biased, they might lead to the development of unfair computer systems, that is, characterised by a prejudice towards specific individuals or groups, which might get an unmotivated output from the system. This circumstance lead to the development of multiple metrics designed to quantify the level of unfairness of an algorithm. However, a generalised assumption in the literature is that the sensitive features and the output labels are binary. When the data is not binary, it is forcefully binarized using a one-versus-the-rest simplification. In this work, we discuss the limitations of existing metrics and propose novel, mathematically sound, and generalized multi-group and multi-class formulations of the metrics. Ultimately, our results highlight the empirical assessment distortion caused by binarization strategies, which reveals the limitations of binary fairness metrics in the multi class setting.

0.22

Robust Decentralized Fairness Auditing

cs.LG ·2026-10-07 ·Sayan Biswas, Jade Garcia Bourrée, Anne-Marie Kermarrec, Palak, Martijn de Vos
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Emerging legislation requires large language models (LLMs) to be audited for compliance with regulatory standards, particularly fairness. Such black-box audits typically assume a single auditor with access to a large, representative set of queries. In practice, it can be difficult for an auditor to obtain such a query set, but multiple auditors can together cover the relevant demographic groups by auditing the LLM collaboratively with their individual query sets. However, relying on multiple auditors raises a fundamental trust problem, as they may act on behalf of the LLM provider to portray a misleading appearance of fairness, i.e., fairwashing. We propose Auditopus, a novel approach for robust decentralized fairness auditing. In Auditopus, auditing proceeds in rounds without a central server. In each round, every auditor issues a fixed number of queries to the LLM, and sends only cumulative statistics vectors of its query results to other auditors instead of sensitive queries in clear. The fairness of the audited LLM is then estimated by aggregating all the vectors. We show theoretically and empirically that even a single adversarial auditor in the network can steer this estimate by fabricating the vectors it sends, making an unfair LLM appear fair. To address this threat, Auditopus has each honest auditor locally down-weight any auditor whose cumulative statistics vectors are statistically inconsistent with previous ones. We implement Auditopus and compare it to robust aggregation baselines on two datasets with two pre-trained LLMs. Against an attacker that optimizes the vectors it sends to make the LLM appear fair, Auditopus reduces audit error by up to 78% on average relative to no defense and at least 62% relative to the robust aggregation baselines. Even when 49% of the auditors are adversarial, Auditopus never lets a very unfair or moderately unfair LLM pass as fair.

0.13

What Do Compliance Detectors Read? An Audit of Activation Probes and Guard Models

cs.AI ·2026-08-17 ·Saisab Sadhu, Aadit Sengupta, Vinay Kumar Sankarapu, Pratinav Seth
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract

Regulatory compliance monitoring in deployed language models is increasingly implemented as a legal and audit control, checking model outputs against written rules spanning data protection, healthcare, financial regulation, and platform policy. Such monitoring is meaningful only if a detector's verdict depends on the stated rule rather than on surface features of the scenario. We show this condition fails across the current class of compliance detectors, a failure we call rule blindness. Deleting, permuting, or substituting the governing rule leaves detection accuracy unchanged for every guard and activation probe we test, including a policy-conditioned guard that correctly cites the governing clause yet barely changes its verdict when that clause is swapped for its permissive counterpart. A purpose-built benchmark crossing two rules with two scenarios, so that neither alone predicts the label, confirms the failure under a design no prior benchmark rules out, and shows that step by step reasoning, not any fast detector we test, is what escapes it. Auditing at scale requires a retraining-free detector, so we introduce the Internal Compliance Score (ICS): a training-free activation readout calibrated from ten labelled pairs and scored by a single projection. We hold ICS to the same scrutiny as the guards it audits: a pre-registered criterion for beating trivial baselines is not met, and a bag-of-words model matches its pooled generalisation exactly. It remains useful because it is inexpensive, letting us audit four deployed guard models, an 8B zero-shot judge, and thirteen benchmarks, and it raises the mechanically verified pass rate when used to rank candidate responses, though an adaptive white-box attack removes this gain. We release the counterfactual protocol and crossed-rule benchmark so rule blindness can be tested in future probe and guard claims.

0.33

When Post-Processing Fairness Constraints Help and When They Harm: Evidence from Eight Cross-Domain Evaluations

cs.LG cs.CY ·2026-09-22 ·Nithin Raghava Ramachandra Narla
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · 18 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables. Code, data loaders and figures: github.com/nithinnarla/fape-fairness-ml

Fairness audits in production ML typically occur once, at deployment, on a single domain. Both fail in practice: fairness can shift after retraining or a changing user base, and interventions validated on one dataset are rarely tested across the heterogeneous domains an organization deploys. We present FAPE (Fairness Auditing for Production Environments), a four-stage framework evaluating a single post-processing intervention, Fairlearn's ThresholdOptimizer, across eight domain evaluations: criminal justice, income prediction, legal admissions, credit lending, agricultural lending, a multi-domain benchmark corpus, healthcare, and education. Each is scored on demographic parity and equalized odds difference, plus disparate impact ratio and accuracy cost where computable. Intervention effectiveness tracks baseline disparity magnitude: across model-domain pairs the constraint improved disparity in 9 of 14 high-disparity cases and worsened it in 3 of 4 near-fair ones. Each of the five high-disparity exceptions reverses under one of two measurement checks, a minimum group size or thresholds fit on held-out data. A CUSUM monitor started at deployment, tested on a simulated shift, separates constrained models that never met a 0.1 parity convention from those that met it and later regressed. A single deployment-time audit is therefore an unreliable guide, which argues for baseline-disparity screening and continuous monitoring

0.31