CS Paper Radar

Participation-Sensitive Convergence and the Fragment First, Converge Later Pattern in Asynchronous Online Learning: A Topological Analysis Across 22 OULAD Courses

Hitoshi Inoue, Koichi Yasutake

cs.CY cs.LG ·submitted 2026-10-01 14:10 UTC · v2
published

Abstract

Asynchronous online learning offers temporal flexibility at a structural cost: learning communities tend to fragment rather than cohere. $β_0$, the number of disconnected behavioral clusters from Zigzag Persistent Homology, serves as a cohort-level indicator of this structure. Two questions remained unverified at scale: (1) does apparent $β_0$ convergence reflect genuine behavioral alignment or learner dropout? and (2) do assessment deadlines produce reproducible fragmentation-convergence cycles? We address both across all 22 OULAD courses (N > 22,000; 857 week-pairs). Changes in $β_0$ strongly co-vary with active learner changes (pooled r = 0.387; median per-course r_delta = 0.459, 20/22 courses), identifying $β_0$ as a participation-sensitive indicator: $β_0$ and active learner counts co-respond to deadline events rather than one causing the other. Deadlines produced fragmentation in 82.6% of assessments and the full Fragment First, Converge Later (FFCL) cycle in 60.2%. 3-phase analysis confirmed structural fragmentation as the dominant long-term trajectory (90.9% of courses), moderated by curriculum structure. These findings establish $β_0$ as a participation-sensitive structural indicator with direct implications for AI-augmented learning analytics design.

Comment
Author's version, posted under the non-commercial rights retained in the APSCE copyright transfer agreement. v2: method description corrected - epsilon = 1.5 (not 1.00), connected components computed directly (no persistent-homology library), beta0 over weekly-active learners (not a fixed cohort). Results unchanged
Journal ref
Proceedings of ICLEA 2026: 2nd International Conference on Learning Evidence and Analytics, Asia-Pacific Society for Computers in Education, 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Longitudinal Learner Participation Profiling in Online Learning: Heterogeneous Consensus Clustering under Unequal Observation Windows

cs.LG cs.CY ·2026-10-12 ·David Otoo-Arthur, Terence L. van Zyl
published similarity 0.65
Abstract · Accepted for presentation at SACAIR 2026 and publication in the conference proceedings

Learning management system traces are clustered to identify participation profiles, but unequal observation windows may cause profiles to reflect duration rather than participation alone. Using 16,448 complete learner--course sequences from 4,599 learners across 152 courses at a South African public university, we evaluated eight participation measures. All remained related to observation-window length even when expressed as rates or shares. Course-grouped adjustment reduced these relationships. Five retained measures were evaluated using K-means, Gaussian mixtures, Ward agglomerative clustering and K-medoids, with standardised measures and principal-component summaries. Evidence supported a broad two-profile grouping and a more detailed adjusted four-profile consensus: Gradually declining, Early-concentrated, Cyclical variable and Sustained active. Profile membership accounted for 2.87% of the variation in duration in the primary consensus, versus 38.18% using original measures. Mean assignment support was 0.739; 8.35% of assignments fell below 0.50, with greatest uncertainty in Sustained active. Two week-by-week sequence analyses agreed strongly with each other but only modestly with the four-profile consensus, indicating that the profiles combined multiple aspects of participation rather than distinct sequence patterns. Profiling should therefore assess duration effects, compare clustering methods and participation summaries, and report assignment consistency.

0.26

Period Segmentation in Transition Network Analysis: A Topological Data Analysis Approach

cs.CY cs.LG ·2026-09-25 ·Hitoshi Inoue, Koichi Yasutake
publishedunusual similarity 0.64
Abstract

Temporal dynamics in learning behavior can be revealed through period segmentation in Transition Network Analysis (TNA). Cristea et al. demonstrated that segmenting courses into halves and quarters reveals how learning strategies evolve and relate to academic performance. Building on this approach, we investigate whether Topological Data Analysis (TDA), specifically connected components ($β_0$) change points from Zigzag Persistent Homology, can provide data-driven period boundaries that identify intervention windows. Analyzing 22 courses from the Open University Learning Analytics Dataset, we find that $β_0$-based segmentation captures greater between-period variation than time-based segmentation (median variance ratio (VR) = 4.10$\times$; 21/22 courses show VR $>$ 1.1). Permutation tests confirmed significance ($p < 0.05$) in 18% of individual courses, with 73% showing positive improvement over random breakpoints. Only one course showed better performance with time-based segmentation. However, analysis of academic outcomes reveals a key insight: final-period behavior shows lower correlation with outcomes in $β_0$-based segmentation than in time-based segmentation, reflecting a marked behavioral collapse where engaged learners rapidly disengage. We interpret this as evidence that final-period behavior reflects rather than causes outcomes: students who will pass maintain engagement, while those who will fail disengage. This reframes the value of $β_0$: rather than improving prediction, change points identify intervention windows. These are periods where behavioral structure shifts and targeted support may be most effective.

0.67

Study-Strategy Clusters from EdNet Logs Track Engagement, Not Mastery

cs.LG cs.CYstat.AP ·2026-08-17 ·Qingchuan Lyu, Yingxin Li, Albert Yang
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Learning analytics often treats unsupervised clusters of intelligent tutoring system (ITS) logs as learner types that should predict learning. We test that assumption on EdNet-KT3. Clustering study-strategy features (resource use, revision, video, problem practice) for 5{,}000 active learners yields a silhouette-selected parent cut ($k=5$) with 4 contrast poles (reading-focused, video-heavy, revision-heavy, and problem-first) plus a large near-mean residual ($\sim$64.9\%). Reclustering that residual adds four finer styles, giving a bootstrap-stable hierarchy of 8 named strategies. We split each learner's timeline by respond count so clusters use only the early half and outcomes only the late half. Early clusters predict later engagement (continuing to practice and finishing late sessions, especially persistence, $η^{2}\approx 0.106$; completion $η^{2}\approx 0.021$) but not later unassisted accuracy (correctness on late first-attempts without help; $p_{\mathrm{adj}}\approx 0.093$). Volume rises with some styles, yet volume-only clustering barely matches strategy labels (ARI$=0.064$). A knowledge-tracing model (SAKT) on the seven TOEIC exam sections predicts next correctness only modestly better than a baseline that knows only how hard each section usually is (AUC lift $+0.051$; CI $[+0.045,+0.058]$), and that mastery signal is nearly independent of behavior styles (ARI$=0.007$). Behavioral clustering here describes study styles and engagement, not knowledge gains.

0.32

Neural Succession: A Mesoscopic Theory of Invasion, Coexistence, and Stabilization in Continual Learning

cs.LG ·2026-09-28 ·Shoaib Ahmed Dipu, Md Salman Shamil, Sayeed Shafayet Chowdhury
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · 20 pages, 10 figures, 7 tables. Code available at https://github.com/shoaibdipu/Neural_Succession/

Continual learning is usually studied through mechanisms that preserve old knowledge. We develop Successional Learning Theory (SLT), a mesoscopic account in which the current representation is a resident community, the incoming task is an invader, forgetting is resident displacement, joint retention is coexistence, replay is resident reinforcement, and training moves from establishment toward stabilization. Its empirical coordinate is directional pre-invasion compatibility, measured on the resident model before the incoming task is learned. Across eight experiments, compatibility orders later forgetting on the 20 directed Split-CIFAR-10 transitions (three-repeat r=-0.789, incoming-task cluster 95% CI [-0.90,-0.72], every repeat alone r<=-0.67), forecasts held-out forgetting with 24% lower error than a no-information baseline, and reproduces under controlled MNIST permutations and CIFAR-10 rotations (r=-0.804, -0.718). On an 84-transition suite, compatibility separates coexistence from exclusion at every retention threshold (AUC 0.93-0.97). Replay repairs every transition with at most 325 stored examples and is most efficient where displacement is largest. Compatibility reaches |r|=0.720, while activation, representation, Jacobian, and fixed-coefficient Lotka-Volterra specializations do not. Plasticity and feature turnover fall reliably from early to late training (15/15 and 14/15 runs). We formalize a minimum habitat-modification bound, a displacement floor, a sufficient coexistence condition, an identifiability law with a range-restriction corollary, successional stabilization, and local reinforcement. The identifiability law also predicts where the coordinate loses leverage, and the prediction matches three CIFAR-100 partitions and five optimizer regimes. SLT is a pre-adaptation diagnostic that complements replay, regularization, and projection methods.

0.47

Coopshift: Post-Training Amplifies The Memory Curse In LLM Cooperation

cs.GT cs.CLcs.MA ·2026-10-16 ·Jiayuan Liu, Shiyi Du, Tianqin Li, Emanuel Tewolde, Keyang Xuan +1 more
similarity 0.56
Abstract

How does post-training change cooperation during repeated interaction? Within each of seven released model lineages, we compare pretrained (Base), supervised fine-tuned (SFT), and subsequent preference- or reward-optimized (Aligned) checkpoints across seven social dilemmas. Copies of each checkpoint play one another for 200 rounds, with visible history limited to the last two or forty rounds. The memory curse refers to lower cooperation when agents can see more past rounds. Our central finding is that post-training amplifies this decline. Averaged across the six binary-action games, expanding visible history reduces cooperation at every SFT and Aligned checkpoint. At each post-trained stage, these declines exceed Base's in six of seven lineages. Most of this average amplification is already present at SFT. With long history, both post-trained stages also cooperate less than Base on average in each binary-action game. In the symmetric binary games, their fitted cooperation rates fall more steeply on average than Base's as per-round cooperation costs rise, benefits fall, or noncooperation becomes more rewarding. The difference in cooperation rates between Aligned and SFT also changes from one-shot decisions to repeated play. When given the same past records, their choices depend on whether the instructions describe a final round or possible future interaction. Post-training evaluation should therefore go beyond isolated choices to assess whether cooperation is sustained in repeated interaction and how it depends on payoffs and visible history.

0.30

From Early Participation to Later Completion: Evidence from a Large-Scale Self-Paced Learning Programme

cs.HC ·2026-09-28 ·Sakshi Sharma, Pavani Ayinampudi, Aditya B. M. V., Jinal Gupta, Prakash Hegade +3 more
similarity 0.54
Abstract · 12 Pages, 3 figures, 3 tables

Large-scale learning programmes generate records that make learner participation observable across different activities. Participation points are commonly used to record and encourage such participation, but their value may extend beyond the activities for which points are awarded. Existing evaluations often examine gamification outcomes within the activities or learning environments in which the game elements are implemented, providing limited evidence about whether early participation points contain information about later participation outside the points system. This study examines whether early participation points can provide information about learners' later participation in a self-paced learning track that does not award participation points. Using anonymised records from 876 learners in a large-scale remote software-upskilling internship, we examined participation points generated from live-session attendance and poll responses against later self-paced course completion. The primary analysis used the 438 learners who earned at least one point during the first week, while the full cohort was retained for the no-point analysis. Week-one participation points distinguished learners who later completed a self-paced course with an AUC of 0.89, increasing to 0.95 by the fourth week. Similar AUCs were observed at both stages of the self-paced course sequence, while the absence of week-one points identified learners who did not start or did not complete a self-paced course with 95% precision. These findings indicate that early participation points can provide information about later participation outside the activities that generate the points. Such information can help large-scale learning programmes identify learners who may require timely attention while learning is still in progress, without treating participation points as a measure of overall learner engagement.

0.40

Effects of a Behavioural Commitment Scheme on Study Regularity in a Self-Paced Learning Platform

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-10-01 ·Meenakshi V., Pavani Ayinampudi, Aditya B. M. V., Jinal Gupta, Prakash Hegade +3 more
published similarity 0.53
Abstract · 16 pages, 2 figures, 6 tables. Accepted as a long paper at the International Conference on Technology for Education (T4E 2026). Authors' ver…

Online education has enabled learners worldwide to take up courses from reputed institutions. However, a self-paced online course cannot guarantee the motivation and engagement that a learner experiences in a real-time classroom. Self-paced access also makes platform load unpredictable, which drives up the compute cost. We propose a Commitment Scheme for course access that aligns learner commitment with platform capacity. Learners book their study slots in advance; the instructor sets the budget of learning hours available for the course; and learners who use a full window earn additional watch hours. A booked window records an intention to study at a stated time, and a learner who appears in that window implements it. The byproduct is a platform load that can be forecast and bounded. The study involved two courses taken in sequence by the same learners, with the slot booking system activated only in the second. In-window study was observed on 86.8% of booked windows, and the median committer placed 95.5% of all study time inside self-booked windows. Among learners who studied across the launch, study regularity improved from 1.01 to 1.33 active days per week, with a supporting difference of +1.37 days per week against the same learners' preceding course. Commitments made on the same day as the study slot were honoured more often than advance bookings (88.8% against 62.5% two days ahead), which is consistent with the classic intention-behaviour gap.

0.40

What fidelity metrics miss: a structural check on synthetic educational data

cs.CY ·2026-09-23 ·Hitoshi Inoue, Koichi Yasutake
similarity 0.51
Abstract · Accepted for presentation at 1st Workshop of Trustworthy Educational Data Sharing and Secondary Use: ReLEAF Data Challenge, The 34th Interna…

Secondary use of educational records is increasingly mediated by platforms that share a differentially private synthetic version of a dataset and validate specific findings against the real data on request. The synthetic version is evaluated by comparing summary statistics of each variable, yet reported confirmation rates suggest that such comparisons do not predict which findings survive. We propose a structural check: the number of connected components of a weekly proximity graph over learners, tracked across a term. Across four annual cohorts of lower-secondary study-habit logs, the synthetic versions reproduced the level of this quantity and the shape of the weekly partition, but its variation across the term was between 2.6 and 4.9 times smaller than in the real data at a common working point, without exception, and those changes fell in different weeks: the synthetic cohorts single out the term's examination weeks and the real cohorts do not. We also show that a routine rule for setting the graph threshold makes naive comparisons between two datasets invalid, and illustrate this with an error of our own. The real curves are also distinguishable from marginal-preserving surrogates of themselves in all four cohorts, where three of the four synthetic ones are not, a comparison that needs no real data; these differences trace to what the generator was given.

0.31