CS Paper Radar

The TellTail of Embeddings: Fingerprinting Retrievers in Black-Box Systems

Abdullah Garra, Matan Ben-Tov, Mahmood Sharif

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-10-02 20:30 UTC · v1

Abstract

Dense embedding models are core to modern text retrieval, enabling systems ranging from web search to retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). Yet, retrievers are usually deployed within opaque systems, exposing only ranked results, cited sources, or generated answers. This opacity prevents users from verifying which retrievers providers serve and may create a false sense of robustness against retrieval attacks. We show that attackers can infer retrievers' identity only through queries. We introduce TellTail, a fingerprinting attack for identifying retrievers behind black-box systems across a spectrum of access levels. Despite sharing many properties, retrievers can be steered to emit distinct results. When retrieved passages are exposed, TellTail compares retrieval overlap to deduce the underlying model. When only the final generated response is exposed, TellTail optimizes model-specific queries that induce a chosen retrieval behavior on the target retriever but transfer poorly to others. Interestingly, the poor transferability that limits attacks elsewhere is exactly what makes them useful for fingerprinting. We evaluate TellTail using 53 retrievers under three increasingly restrictive settings. TellTail perfectly identifies the deployed retriever from full retrieval rankings; in 94.3% of attempts with unordered top-3 results; and in 92.5% of cases from language-model-generated answers alone. Furthermore, fingerprinting succeeds against a popular RAG system (OpenWebUI). Overall, TellTail shows that retrieval-based systems leak the identity of their embedding model---exposing intellectual property and enabling reconnaissance ahead of model-specific attacks such as corpus poisoning.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

RAG-CT: Mitigating Privacy Risks on Retrieval-Augmented Generation Systems via Scanning Prompt Distribution

cs.CL cs.AIcs.CR ·2026-09-14 ·Xingyu Lyu, Jiayimei Wang, Jianfeng He, Ning Wang, Yidan Hu +1 more
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has emerged as a powerful paradigm for improving the quality of generated contents of Large Language Models (LLMs) by grounding responses in external knowledge, thus reducing hallucinations and factual errors. However, recent studies have highlighted a critical vulnerability: adversaries can exploit the retrieval process to extract personally identifiable information (PII) from the underlying corpus. To mitigate this risk, we propose a novel defense, RAG-CT, that identifies malicious queries by analyzing their entropy and margin distributions and using a score-based detection method. Extensive experiments with four state-of-the-art attack strategies and four defense baselines on two datasets show that our approach significantly reduces PII leakage while outperforming existing defenses. This work provides a lightweight yet effective mechanism to protect RAG systems against PII leakage without requiring modifications to the underlying LLM or retriever.

0.05

Isolation Is Not Confidentiality: Security Boundaries of Geometric Access Control in RAG

cs.CR ·2026-11-10 ·Steve Nouyep, Maxime Puys, Sébastien Salva
similarity 0.70
Abstract

Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) systems increasingly rely on vector databases containing documents governed by different access-control policies. Recent search-preserving geometric approaches enforce such access control by structuring the embedding space so that transformed embeddings, which we call protected representations, remain retrievable without exposing information across policy boundaries. We provide a unified security analysis of this paradigm, covering policy isolation, representation confidentiality, query forgery resistance, and policy-membership hiding. We consider both a curious cloud service provider observing the protected representations stored in the vector database and a curious user holding aligned pairs of original embeddings and protected representations. Evaluating the available implementations of the works proposing these geometric transformation mechanisms across three encoders, we find that geometric transformations preserve retrieval utility and provide strong policy isolation, but do not provide the other security properties. A curious user can recover the original embeddings from a few hundred pairs and forge policy-compatible queries at a higher cost that grows with encoder dimension for secret per-policy transformations. Moreover, policy-dependent geometry can leak policy membership even when unauthorized retrieval is prevented. These results show that policy isolation, confidentiality, forgery resistance, and membership hiding are distinct security objectives.

0.29

RAGSentinel: Certifiable Geometric Consensus for Robust Retrieval-Augmented Generation

cs.CR cs.AIcs.IRcs.LG ·2026-08-25 ·Yueyang Quan, Anjun Gao, Yufei Xia, Minghong Fang, Zhuqing Liu
top venuetheory similarity 0.68
Abstract · To appear in EMNLP 2026 (Main Conference)

Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) improves the factuality of large language models by grounding responses in external documents, but it also exposes a critical security vulnerability: adversarial documents injected into the knowledge database can enter the context window and steer the model toward targeted incorrect answers. Existing post-retrieval defenses rely on instruction following, parametric knowledge, or text-level consistency, all of which can be imitated or optimized against by adaptive attackers. We propose RAGSentinel, a training-free, label-free defense for black-box RAG systems. RAGSentinel uses a surrogate encoder to measure query-conditioned hidden-state shifts induced by retrieved documents, removes shared topic directions, and filters poisoned documents as geometric outliers from a robust majority consensus. We prove that, under an honest-majority assumption and a representation-level separation condition, RAGSentinel exactly recovers a poison-free majority-sized context. Experiments across three question-answering datasets, three LLM families, and multiple poisoning attacks show that RAGSentinel consistently achieves low attack success rates while preserving competitive accuracy and remaining effective against adaptive attacks with full pipeline knowledge.

0.36

DSPrompt: Dynamic Soft Prompt Defense Against M-RAG Corruption

cs.CR cs.CL ·2026-08-17 ·Chang Liu, Yuni Lai, Mingyue Cui, Cong Tian, Yunyan Zhang +3 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Multimodal Retrieval Augmented Generation (M-RAG) is increasingly vulnerable to adversarial attacks where malicious data are crafted to produce embeddings that align with benign entries in the vector space, deceiving retrieval and inducing harmful outputs. Existing defenses primarily operate at query time, relying on auxiliary detectors, similarity re-ranking, or feature-consistency checks. However, these approaches suffer from non-trivial inference overhead, generalize poorly to unseen attack strategies, and often assume specific attack distributions. To address this, we propose DSPrompt, a Dynamic Soft Prompt defense framework that directly reshapes the retriever's embedding semantics, without modifying the retrieval pipeline. It inserts few learnable soft prompts into each layer of the visual and textual encoders of a frozen retriever, utilizing a shallow-to-deep length schedule that is adaptive to the capacity in the model layers. These prompts are trained under a dynamic min-max scheme: an online multimodal attacker continually crafts hard adversarial documents against the current retriever, while the defender is updated to push such documents out of the top-k while preserving the ranking and diversity of benign evidence. Because the defended encoder can be pre-computed and indexed exactly as in standard dense retrieval, DSPrompt incurs no additional per-query optimization and introduces fewer than 1% additional parameters. Extensive experiments across four benchmarks and three representative poisoning attacks show that DSPrompt substantially reduces the attack success rate and poison retrieval rate while maintaining near-lossless retrieval utility and generation fidelity, consistently outperforming existing defense baselines at a fraction of their computational cost.

0.20

Consistency Is the Attack Surface: Detecting Coordinated Retrieval Poisoning with Embedding Geometry

cs.CR ·2026-10-17 ·Zeyan Li, Qirong Guo, Jianfeng Xu
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Consistency-based defenses for retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) rest on an assumption that a sparse adversary breaks: a poisoning campaign may modify a negligible fraction of the corpus, yet retrieval concentrates its passages into the reader's context. Across four Natural Questions retrieval seeds, at least one injection reaches the top-5 in 94.1% of targeted query--seed rows, and all three form a retrieved majority in 52.9%. Under our short-answer protocol, RobustRAG and ReliabilityRAG reach exposure-conditional attack success 0.512, against 0.576 for undefended RAG, while lowering clean accuracy from 0.328 to 0.216. Coordination, however, leaves a fingerprint: a dense, query-anchored component in the evidence embedding geometry. CoordGuard audits this structure from robustly normalized query-weighted affinities, without poison labels, correct answers, or reader gradients. Its always-filter mode suppresses the selected component whenever one forms; a benign-calibrated gate suppresses it only at unusually high scores and traces a robustness--utility frontier. Pooling four retrieval seeds, e5 always-filtering reduces $\mathrm{ASR}_{\mathrm{exp}}$ to 0.167 overall and 0.138 on parametrically unknown queries, at a 13.6-point clean cost, while a Contriever gate retains clean accuracy 0.315 at $\mathrm{ASR}_{\mathrm{exp}}=0.331$. The reduction transfers across two readers, three tasks, and multiple retriever--auditor pairs, and count-matched controls attribute it to component-targeted removal rather than deletion volume. These findings recast poison detection from judging truth to auditing the structure of retrieved evidence.

0.13

RAGLeak: Supply-Chain Privacy Backdoors in Retrieval-Augmented Generation

cs.CR ·2026-10-19 ·Yuchen Chen, Wei Cheng, Yuan Xiao, Junda He, Jieke Shi +5 more
code/data similarity 0.66
Abstract

Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) enables large language models to access external knowledge during inference, but its reliance on external knowledge bases also introduces new attack surfaces. Existing data extraction attacks against RAG systems rely on either prompt injection, which heavily depends on the generator's instruction-following capability, or backdoors that reproduce or paraphrase retrieved documents but struggle to balance extraction fidelity and stealthiness. In this paper, we propose RAGLeak, a supply-chain privacy backdoor attack that decouples information leakage from direct textual exposure. When triggered, the generator reversibly obfuscates retrieved private documents for high-fidelity recovery by an auxiliary LLM. Across three model families and three application domains, RAGLeak achieves up to $100\%$ ASR with limited impact on benign utility and at most a $10$-percentage-point ASR drop under representative detection-based defenses. The backdoor remains effective after clean fine-tuning and across model scales and versions, revealing an underexplored supply-chain privacy risk in RAG systems. The source code is available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/RAGLeak-4B67.

0.29

CIG-MIA: Context-Induced Information Gain Membership Inference Attacks against Retrieval-Augmented Generation

cs.CR ·2026-09-13 ·Tan Xue, Huo Chang, Wang Changhui, Yang Sanrui, Li Heng +2 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems ground large language models on external knowledge bases, enabling access to private, domain-specific, and up-to-date knowledge without retraining. However, the same retrieval interface can expose whether a candidate document is contained in the knowledge base. This paper studies knowledge base membership inference against RAG systems under both gray-box and text-only black-box access. Existing RAG membership inference attacks rely on signals such as direct membership prompts, response similarity, mask recovery, or query perturbation, which can be sensitive to prompt defenses, semantically related retrieved documents, and the generator's parametric knowledge. We introduce CIG-MIA, a membership inference attack based on context-induced information gain. The key insight is that explicit candidate-document injection affects members and non-members differently: if a document is already available through retrieval, injection provides little additional support for document-derived answers; if it is absent, injection introduces new evidence and yields a larger likelihood gain. In the gray-box setting, CIG-MIA computes this gain directly from token-level likelihoods. In the black-box setting, it estimates the same gain from generated text by scoring selected answer tokens with a lightweight surrogate-based estimator using semantic similarity and exact-match features. We evaluate CIG-MIA on Natural Questions, MS-MARCO, and HealthCareMagic against recent RAG membership inference baselines. On Natural Questions, CIG-MIA achieves an AUC of 0.99 in the gray-box setting and 0.93 in the black-box setting. We further analyze the information-gain signal, RAG configuration effects, ablations, and robustness to paraphrasing and generation randomness.

0.19

Coverage Is Not Containment: A Fundamental Limit of Admission-Time Defenses Against Coordinated Poisoning of Vector Retrieval

cs.CR cs.CLcs.IR ·2026-08-17 ·Prashant Kumar Pathak, Tarun Kumar Sharma
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract · 10 pages, 9 figures. Preprint; under submission

Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) answers a question by retrieving passages from a vector store and trusting them as context, so anyone who can add documents can try to steer the answer. A recent, appealing defense filters poisoning at ingestion, rejecting any document that behaves like a hub. We show it -- and every ingestion-time filter -- is defeated by a coordinated adversary that injects a handful of individually unremarkable documents which together surround one target query and seize its top-k (on BGE-large / BEIR, m=10 documents take 10/10; 9.9/10 on a live HNSW index). The attack is not theoretical. Realized as ordinary fluent text and run end-to-end through a BGE-large + HNSW + Qwen2.5-7B pipeline, it makes the generator emit the attacker's planted claim in 88% of targets, versus 0% without the injection. And no admission-time defense stops it: at ingestion an attack cone is geometrically identical to a legitimate niche upload, so -- measuring this directly -- the strongest trained classifier, given every feature and thousands of examples, separates the two no better than chance, catching 4.2% of attacks at a 1% false-positive rate. We prove this limit for the entire class of ingestion-time statistics (any decision from documents and reference queries alone), and it reproduces -- and worsens -- across two corpora and five encoders. The one signal that separates an attack from legitimate niche ingestion -- a query's demand -- is invisible before retrieval, which is also the escape: a retrieval-time detector that observes demand catches 100% of the attacks at the same 1% false-positive rate. Coverage of the query space by an admission gate is not containment of coordinated poisoning; robust defense must move past the front door, to demand.

0.48