CS Paper Radar

Understanding Errors in LLM-Based Question Answering over Imperfect Tables

Baowen Zhang, Wei Fan, Ruman Wang, Hangting Ye

cs.CL ·submitted 2026-10-03 18:03 UTC · v2
code/data

Abstract

Answering questions over imperfect tables requires handling errors that can affect the answer. We investigate two challenges for large language models (LLMs): whether error discovery depends on where errors appear in a table, and whether providing their locations is sufficient for accurate question answering (QA). Using human-reviewed instances from RADAR-T, we conduct controlled studies across three LLMs by varying row order and comparing original, error-marked, and repaired tables. First, reordering rows changes error discovery even when the table contents and gold answer remain unchanged. During direct inspection, LLMs are more likely to discover all rows containing relevant errors when these rows appear later in the table or are grouped more closely together. Second, providing verified error locations alone is insufficient for accurate QA: with code execution, accuracy on repaired tables exceeds that on error-marked tables by 39.0-59.1 percentage points across the three LLMs. As a practical application of these findings, we combine error discovery across shuffled table views with explicit guidance for verifying and handling the reported errors in a simple workflow, Geometry-Balanced Discovery and Intervention (GBDI). On RADAR-T, GBDI improves QA accuracy by 3.8-18.5 percentage points over a code-agent baseline across five LLMs (paired 95% confidence intervals exclude zero for four), at the cost of additional inference. These results highlight the importance of both reliable error discovery and effective error handling in QA over imperfect tables. Code is available at https://github.com/645-t/GBDI-ICLR-2027.

Comment
41 pages, 7 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

TabScope: Question-Adaptive Scope Selection for Table Question Answering

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-09-03 ·Yuxiang Wang, Junhao Gan, Jianzhong Qi
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract · conference paper preprint

Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown strong performance on table question answering, yet their accuracy often degrades as table size increases. We find that this degradation is not uniform across question types. Localization-sensitive questions are particularly affected by irrelevant table content, while questions requiring broader evidence may still benefit from full-table reasoning. Based on this observation, we propose a question-adaptive framework that dynamically selects between localized and full-table reasoning. The framework constructs question-specific sub-tables through operation-aware table decomposition and uses the predicted question type to determine the appropriate reasoning mode. We further introduce silver reference sub-tables for evaluating evidence selection and construct SLQA, a benchmark based on real-world long tables. Experiments on WikiTQ and SLQA show that localization is particularly effective for lookup and local reasoning questions, while adaptive selection between localized and full-table reasoning achieves the best overall performance. These results highlight that long-table QA requires deciding not only how to localize, but also when to localize. Our code and datasets will be made available upon publication of the paper.

0.12

Automated Testing of LLM-Based Post Hoc Explainers Using Model Checking as an Oracle

cs.AI cs.LG ·2026-08-31 ·Dennis Gross, Helge Spieker
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are used as post hoc explainers of sequential decision-making policies, producing natural-language explanations of why an action was chosen. However, LLMs often generate plausible but incorrect statements, and no existing approach systematically tests whether such explanations are faithful to the underlying environment. Two classic software testing challenges stand in the way: there is no oracle for the correctness of an explanation, and the test inputs, natural language queries about a policy's behavior, lack the structure needed for systematic test case generation. We address both. Probabilistic model checking provides the test oracle, computing exact reference results against which LLM answers are graded automatically. A taxonomy of post hoc query categories structures the input space around the environment-level facts from which policy explanations are composed; test cases generated from it are prioritized by question-specific diagnostic difficulty scores. Across seven MDP environments, the testing separates three open-weight LLMs: a reasoning model passes 85% of test cases, a mid-size model 70%, and a 1B model falls below the random baseline, while prioritization surfaces significantly harder cases than random selection. Our results indicate how trustworthy LLM-generated explanations are in model-free settings, where the same LLMs are used but no oracle exists to verify them.

0.16

SleuthBench: Benchmarking Statistical LLM Evaluation Using Tabular Hidden Signals

cs.LG ·2026-09-28 ·Jingyun Jia, Antoine Remond-Tiedrez, Aaron Alvarez, Joshua Shunk, Rich Caruana +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract

Evaluating statistical discovery by large language model (LLM) agents requires verifiable analytical ground truth. Establishing such ground truth for real-world datasets is costly, and prior knowledge of public datasets can influence agent responses. We introduce SLEUTHBENCH, a benchmark that addresses both problems by injecting controlled data-quality problems and feature effects into public tabular datasets: the injected pattern determines the answer, so reference answers are computed automatically and memorized knowledge of the original table is insufficient, while the table keeps its background structure. The injected patterns are modeled on phenomena reported in real data analyses. The benchmark defines 17 question templates in two families: data-quality questions and feature-contribution questions. We evaluate six state-of-the-art LLMs that analyze the data using a Python coding tool, on data-science and business phrasings of 70 validated dataset-template combinations, yielding 1680 graded responses in total. The models detect data-quality problems reliably (83.8% accuracy) but recover feature contributions poorly (41.9%). Finding how features shape the target requires searching over both candidate variables and analytical procedures. To address this issue, we propose the Empirical Layer, a set of precomputed statistical artifacts comprising summaries, fitted feature and interaction effects, and dataset descriptions, which exposes candidate patterns for direct inspection. Access to these artifacts raises feature-contribution accuracy from 41.9% to 68.0%.

0.19

PARTAB: Partition-Aware Reasoning with Structured Evidence for Scalable Table Understanding

cs.CL cs.AIcs.IR ·2026-08-25 ·Md Mahadi Hasan Nahid, Davood Rafiei
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 21 pages, 13 figures

Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown strong capabilities in table reasoning, but their effectiveness degrades as tables grow in size and complexity due to irrelevant context and difficulty localizing the evidence required for reasoning. Existing approaches typically reason over either the full table or a single reduced view, which can still obscure important row-column relationships. We introducePARTAB (Partition-Aware Reasoning overTables), a framework that constructs a structured evidence interface between the LLM and the table. PARTAB represents query-relevant evidence as semantically coherent, row-linked table regions and performs hierarchical selection over column groups and row-level partitions before composing the selected evidence for answer generation. We evaluate PARTAB on multiple table reasoning benchmarks, covering question answering, fact verification, and numerical reasoning. PARTAB consistently improves over full-table prompting and several recent table reasoning methods, achieving strong performance on WikiTableQuestions and TabFact while remaining competitive on numerical reasoning. Additional analyses show that semantic partitioning and targeted evidence selection improve evidence localization, substantially reduce the reasoning context, and provide larger benefits on complex tables. These results demonstrate the value of structured, partition aware evidence construction for scalable table reasoning.

0.28

ACTS-SQL: Agentic and Critic-Oriented Tree-Structured SQL Correctness with Large Language Models

cs.AI ·2026-08-15 ·Xinmei Huang, Jie Song, Peng Li, Fuxin Jiang, Jing Zhang +8 more
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract

Large Language Models (LLMs) have been increasingly adopted in Text-to-SQL systems, yet SQL errors remain a major obstacle in real-world Text-to-SQL inference pipelines. Existing SQL correction approaches either rely on large-scale, high-quality training data with substantial overhead, or adopt single-path agentic workflows that are brittle to early mistakes and prone to error propagation. To develop a practical SQL correctness system for industrial scenarios, we present a training-free framework that formulates SQL correction as a plan-guided, tree-structured debugging process. By maintaining multiple correction strategies and enabling backtracking, the framework mitigates error accumulation during iterative refinement. We further integrate execution-based verification and clause-level diagnostic tools to support strategy pruning and precise error localization. We evaluate the system on the BIRD-Critic benchmark and observe consistent accuracy gains over strong LLM backbones and representative agent-based baselines, achieving a 9.42% improvement over the previous state-of-the-art method. The framework is also deployed in the Torch Log Service (TLS) of Volcano Engine to support an online Text-to-TLS API. In production, it improves execution accuracy from 36.77% to 53.61% on real user queries with a representative strong LLM backbone (GPT-5). These results demonstrate the effectiveness and stability of our approach in real-world deployments.

0.04

Experts Rise Where LLMs Disagree: Using Cross-Model Disagreement to Target Expert Effort in LLM Codebook Revision for Large-Scale Annotation

cs.CL cs.AIcs.HCcs.LG ·2026-09-22 ·Zeyu He, Zhuqian Zhou, Kirk Vanacore, Rene F. Kizilcec, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Large-scale text annotation brings expert insight to millions of documents, often through a codebook that AI annotators follow. Developing a robust codebook, however, takes months. Large language models (LLMs) could speed this process by applying an early codebook to the data, surfacing cases with strong LLM disagreement, and eliciting expert feedback to address them. We examined three ways experts can provide feedback for LLM codebook revision: (i) editing LLM-generated revisions driven by cross-LLM disagreement (Codebook Verifying), (ii) answering questions about LLM disagreements (Question Answering), and (iii) labeling disagreement cases with rationales (Rationale Labeling). Experiments on thousands of tutoring-session transcripts show that Rationale Labeling yielded the highest LLM-labeling accuracy (64.9%) against expert labels, outperforming the expert-revised codebook (57.8%). The best Question Answering setting also outperformed it (60.5%). Our work shows that LLMs can be used to strategically target expert attention, shortening months of codebook revision to days without sacrificing labeling performance.

0.43

Trace Integrity for LLM Data Agents: Auditing Structured-Data Computation Beyond Answer Accuracy in Real-World Systems

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-08-26 ·Srimonti Dutta, Akshata Kishore Moharir
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · Accepted at AAAI FSS Trustworthy Agentic Systems (TAS) 2026

Large language model (LLM) data agents answer structured-data questions by generating SQL, invoking tools, executing queries, and summarizing results. In operational settings, reliability depends on both reported answer and computation used to produce it, as errors may remain undetected when the resulting answer matches an expected value. We refer to the mismatch between natural-language intent and operator-level computation required to satisfy that intent as the Structure Gap, and define Trace Integrity as a reliability criterion for assessing whether the computation supporting an answer is explicit, executable, schema-valid, operator-faithful, replayable, answer-consistent, and auditable. We operationalize Trace Integrity through execution contracts that record the schema elements, operator plan, assumptions, executable query, verification status, and final-answer linkage associated with a request. We also define the Correct Answer / Invalid Trace (CAIT) Rate, which measures the proportion of correct answers whose recorded computations fail trace-integrity checks. These provide a way to evaluate whether answer-level success is supported by a valid and inspectable computation. We study this on 100 BIRD Mini-Dev text-to-SQL examples using three prompting conditions: Direct SQL, Operation Summary + SQL, and Contract-First SQL. The three conditions achieve answer accuracies 20.0%, 22.0%, and 24.0%, Trace Integrity Pass Rates 39.0%, 43.0%, and 40.0%, and CAIT Rates 55.0%, 59.1%, and 45.8%, respectively. The results show that answer accuracy, trace validity, and the frequency of correct answers supported by invalid traces capture different aspects of system behavior. Trace-level evaluation therefore complements conventional answer-based evaluation by providing evidence about the computational support, inspectability, and reproducibility of LLM data-agent outputs in real-world systems.

0.27

Why, Where, How: Taxonomy-guided Error Grounding for Code Repair in NL2SQL

cs.AI ·2026-10-04 ·Suchan Lee, Woomin Song, Hwanjo Yu, Sangwoo Mo
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 32 pages

SQL queries that large language models write from natural language questions can execute successfully yet produce incorrect results, so execution alone does not reveal what to fix. An error taxonomy says why the query is wrong, but not where to look or how to change it. Existing methods can guide SQL correction through feedback, error reports, or generated plans alongside an unmasked query. We introduce TEG(Taxonomy-guided Error Grounding), which turns a supplied diagnosis into a structured correction input for natural language-to-SQL (NL2SQL) correction. Type-specific rules map each error type to construct classes to reconsider and an edit operation to request. TEG masks the selected constructs in the query when applicable and states that operation in an edit instruction. TEG generates candidate corrections from this input, uses execution feedback to guide candidate selection, and repeats the process one annotation at a time for queries with several errors. On NL2SQL-BUGs, TEG reaches 47.3 single-error execution accuracy and 37.0 overall with Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct. Across the model sizes and thinking modes evaluated in the main comparison, TEG outperforms all evaluated baselines on single-error queries, even when the baselines receive the same error-type annotations. With predicted types, TEG stays above direct LLM correction and ErrorLLM on single-error queries.

0.19