CS Paper Radar

How Inefficient Is Natural Gradient Descent? From Exact Optimality to Θ( \sqrt{ \log d } ) Divergence

Guni Sharon, Alan Kuhnle

cs.LG stat.ML ·submitted 2026-10-05 18:35 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

Natural gradient descent (NGD) underlies common methods in ML. For dually flat families, idealized NGD on the forward Kullback--Leibler objective follows the mixture geodesic which is often longer than the shortest Fisher--Rao path. We quantify this overhead by the inefficiency ratio \(R \ge 1\), the Fisher length of the mixture geodesic divided by the Fisher--Rao distance, and bound its supremum over endpoint pairs as a function of the parameter dimension \(d\). A tensor criterion identifies the regime (I) families, with \(R=1\) everywhere: exactly those with quadratic potential or dimension one, such as fixed-covariance Gaussians. For non-quadratic families, we prove two further regimes: (II) bounded third-order skewness plus finite Fisher--Rao diameter yields a dimension-independent bound; and (III) for products of scale families---including Gaussian covariances and Gamma rates---\(R\) grows as \(Θ(\sqrt{\log d})\), unbounded in \(d\). Under a per-step Fisher-chord budget, \(R\) translates to a practical computational cost: NGD requires asymptotically at least \(R\) times as many steps as an optimizer following the Fisher--Rao geodesic. Experiments confirm all three regimes: \(R=1\) to machine precision for quadratic-potential families (I), the categorical bound \(π/(2\sqrt{2})\) is approached but not attained (II), and sampled scale-product \(R\) grows with \(d\), reaching \(R \approx 1.5\) for long, high-dimensional moves (III).

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Preservation of Log-Concavity and Convergence of Wasserstein-Fisher-Rao Gradient Flows

cs.LG stat.MLmath.PR ·2026-09-16 ·Francesca Romana Crucinio, Sahani Pathiraja
similarity 0.65
Abstract

We study the convergence of Wasserstein-Fisher-Rao (WFR) gradient flows for sampling from probability distributions known up to a normalisation constant. By combining Wasserstein transport with Fisher-Rao birth-death dynamics, WFR flows balance exploration and selection. These flows have been recognised as a promising mechanism to accelerate convergence beyond Langevin dynamics. We show that for a class of strongly log-concave target distributions satisfying additional curvature conditions, WFR flows preserve strong log-concavity, in contrast to Wasserstein flows which enjoy this property only in the Gaussian setting. Exploiting this result, we derive explicit non-asymptotic convergence rates for the symmetrised Kullback-Leibler divergence, without requiring a warm-start as required in current estimates. In particular, we show that the convergence rate decomposes additively into Wasserstein and Fisher-Rao contributions, thereby confirming a recent conjecture within this setting. These results provide refined convergence guarantees and further develop the theoretical foundations of WFR gradient flows for sampling and Bayesian inference.

0.40

Loss-Parameterized Fisher Width Along Learning Trajectories

cs.LG math.ST ·2026-08-21 ·Vu Khac Ky
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 44 pages, 2 figures

Fisher width measures the Gaussian width of a probe set after deformation by the local Fisher geometry. We study its evolution along learning trajectories and ask when training loss can serve as an effective coordinate for this quantity. We first derive an exact trace--shape factorization and a deterministic stability bound for fixed compact probes. In a population Gaussian-teacher logistic model, the teacher-aligned state is extremal on every loss level below $\log 2$: it has minimal parameter norm and maximizes both Fisher trace and Euclidean-ball Fisher width. We then show that population gradient flow asymptotically selects this branch, with explicit rates for the aligned and orthogonal coordinates. This yields, for $d\geq2$, \[ \frac{w_F(B_2^d;θ(t))} {\sqrt{L(θ(t))}} \longrightarrow \frac{\sqrt6}π\mathbb E[χ_{d-1}]. \] Controlled full-Fisher experiments support the matched-loss branch and the population predictions. In a nonlinear MLP with a diagonal model-Fisher approximation, GD and SGD remain close at matched loss, whereas Adam follows a substantially displaced branch; the fixed probes tested retain highly similar temporal shapes. These results support a branchwise, rather than universal, loss parametrization of Fisher width.

0.28

The Advective Fisher-Rao Geometry of Deterministic Measure Transport

cs.LG math.OCmath.DGmath.PR ·2026-08-12 ·Benjamin Gess, Johannes Müller
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 80 pages, 6 figures

A novel advective Fisher-Rao metric is introduced for optimization tasks on paths of probability measures governed by the continuity equation. This metric is shown to lead to optimal descent directions. It is then shown that this metric arises naturally from three different perspectives: As the rescaled zero-noise limit of the Fisher-Rao metric on path measures, as the expected value of the second variation of the Freidlin--Wentzell large deviation rate functional, and as the Hessian of the Benamou--Brenier action functional from dynamic optimal transport. We supplement this geometric construction with computational experiments. Here, we demonstrate empirically that the advective Fisher-Rao metric yields the desired optimal fitting of probability densities, whereas the Gauss--Newton method yields optimal fitting of velocity fields.

0.10

Acceleration and its Limits in Gaussian Variational Inference

cs.LG stat.MLmath.OC ·2026-10-14 ·Jaesung R. Park, Uijeong Jang, Yifan Chen
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 52 pages, 9 figures

We study whether the classical momentum-based acceleration that improves the condition-number dependence of gradient descent from $κ$ to $\sqrtκ$ for strongly convex, smooth objectives extends to Gaussian variational inference (GVI) for strongly log-concave, log-smooth target distributions. With exact Gaussian expectations, a convex composite formulation of GVI yields the classical accelerated $\sqrtκ$ convergence rate. However, when only pointwise derivatives are available, we construct a family of strongly log-concave targets for which any randomized algorithm requires $κ^{1-o(1)}$ queries to achieve a fixed objective accuracy, even when the initial objective gap is bounded independently of $κ$. Thus curvature bounds alone cannot guarantee uniform accelerated total-query complexity. We then ask which additional structure permits acceleration and give positive examples: under a Hessian-Lipschitz assumption, variance-reduced stochastic methods yield accelerated guarantees when the Hessian variation is sufficiently small. Finally, experiments on real datasets show substantial empirical speedups from acceleration across a broad range of methods.

0.18

Online Covariance Estimation for Averaged Stochastic Gradient Descent on Riemannian Manifolds

cs.IT stat.MLcs.LGmath.OC+1 ·2026-10-24 ·Jingrong Guan, Liwei Jiang, Sen Na
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 60 pqges, 7 figures, 2 tables

We study online inference for averaged Riemannian stochastic gradient descent (RSGD) when the unknown parameter lies on a manifold. Although the averaged RSGD iterate is asymptotically normal, practical inference requires estimating the unknown covariance operator in its limiting distribution. Existing online batch-means methods cannot be applied directly because a general Riemannian manifold lacks an addition operation, and the tangent space containing the Riemannian gradient varies across iterations. Through vector transport, we construct overlapping and non-overlapping covariance estimators that adaptively combine information from successive batches while accounting for the changing tangent spaces. The proposed estimators are online, require neither Riemannian Hessian computations nor a prespecified terminal sample size, and attain the same convergence rates as their Euclidean counterparts (Zhu et al., 2023). Together with asymptotic normality, these estimators enable online statistical inference for RSGD on manifolds. We illustrate the proposed framework through a detailed study of streaming principal component analysis on Grassmann manifolds.

0.14

Statistical Rates for Entropic Optimal Transport in the Discrete to SubGaussian Regime

cs.LG math.ST ·2026-09-22 ·Tomas Gonzalez, Gonzalo Mena
theory similarity 0.58
Abstract

We study statistical rates in entropic optimal transport in the semi-discrete regime where one measure has finite support and the other is subGaussian. Our main result establishes parametric convergence rates for the empirical dual potentials to their population counterparts, with no dimension dependence in the leading term. Our result relies on tailored strong concavity analysis of the semi-dual objective, coupled with specialized bounds for the semi-discrete potentials. As a consequence, we obtain fast rates for downstream quantities derived from the optimal coupling. Chiefly, the empirical barycentric projection achieves a squared-error rate $n^{-1}$, matching the fully compact case and improving over the less favorable $n^{-1/2}$ rate known for fully subGaussian settings. Altogether, these results may indicate a lower complexity adaptation phenomenon whereby the statistical complexity of the barycentric projection is governed by the discrete measure. As an application, we analyze Sinkhorn-EM, an EM-type algorithm in which the E-step is replaced by an entropic optimal transport problem. In a well-specified and balanced two-component Gaussian mixture model, we prove $\sqrt{n}$-consistency of the empirical iterates to their population counterparts for any fixed number of iterations, matching classical EM rates up to a $\sqrt{\log n}$ factor. Simulations support the theory.

0.12

Generalised Score Matching on Convex Domains

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-09-10 ·Nishanth Shetty, Saisuchith Mahajan, Chandra Sekhar Seelamantula
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Score matching avoids computing the normalising constant that maximum-likelihood estimation requires. On constrained domains, its generalised variants weight the Fisher divergence so that boundary terms vanish. We derive generalised score matching on open convex subsets of $\mathbb{R}^{d}$ as the small-neighbourhood limit of minimum probability flow, in which the geometry of the neighbourhoods determines the weight. Every $C^{2}$ positive definite weight arises in this way, including those of classical score matching on $\mathbb{R}^{d}$ and of its variants for non-negative data on $\mathbb{R}_{+}^{d}$. For exponential families, we extend the standard convexity, consistency and asymptotic normality results to every such weight and show that the estimator converges to the true parameter under certain boundary conditions. For a truncated Gaussian on a polytope and a Dirichlet distribution on the simplex, proposed estimators attain the lowest median error of all methods compared, in at least 42 of 50 ground-truth configurations.

0.28

Sample-Optimal Estimation of the Fréchet Inception Distance

cs.LG cs.CVcs.DSmath.ST+1 ·2026-10-05 ·Ziyun Chen, Jerry Li, Kevin Tian, Yusong Zhu
code/datahot direction similarity 0.58
Abstract · Our code is available at https://github.com/zys996/sample-optimal-fid-estimation

The Fréchet Inception Distance (FID) is widely used to evaluate generative models, but its empirical plug-in estimator suffers from finite-sample bias [BSAG18, CF20]. We study the sample complexity $n$ of estimating FID to error $ε$ between $d$-dimensional Gaussians with bounded mean distance and covariances, when one distribution is known. Our contributions are threefold. (1) We establish tight finite-sample $Θ(\frac{d^2}{n})$ bias and $Θ(\frac{d}{n} + \frac {d^2} {n^2})$ variance bounds for the empirical plug-in estimator, establishing a $\gtrsim d^2$ sample complexity. (2) To debias the empirical plug-in estimator, we generalize the ${\rm FID}_\infty$ estimator of [CF20] to extrapolation methods of arbitrary order $k$. We further prove tight bias and variance bounds of $Θ(\frac{d^{k + 2}}{n^{k + 1}})$ and $Θ(\frac d n + \frac{d^2}{n^2})$ for any order-$k$ extrapolation under our framework. (3) We introduce Relative Taylor Debiasing (RTD), a new, computationally efficient FID estimation algorithm using debiasing techniques inspired by U-statistics. We show that RTD achieves an $O(\frac d {ε^2})$ sample complexity, and prove that this is optimal. We provide a complementary empirical evaluation of our new estimators. Our experiments on synthetic Gaussians validate the predicted residual bias and support the tightness of our bounds. On ImageNet with Inception embeddings, RTD achieves the lowest mean estimation error at the standard 50K sample budget, while our second-order variance-aware extrapolation estimator (VALE$_2$) uses only 10K samples to achieve accuracy comparable to FID$_\infty$ at 50K samples.

0.46