CS Paper Radar

The Symbol of the Surrogate: Measuring Numerical Provenance in Neural PDE Solvers

Ridham Patel

cs.LG math.APstat.ML ·submitted 2026-10-07 00:42 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Neural PDE surrogates are trained on numerical solver outputs that contain both physical evolution and solver-specific discretization errors. Because surrogates are also evaluated against held-out trajectories from the same solver, standard benchmarks cannot distinguish fidelity to the exact evolution from imitation of the numerical scheme. We introduce an empirical Fourier-symbol diagnostic that probes a trained surrogate's linearized one-step operator with individual Fourier modes and compares it with both exact-evolution and training-scheme references. To address architectural spectral bias, we train identical networks on schemes with orthogonal dissipative and dispersive signatures and compare their learned operators. In linear advection, the learned surrogates reproduce the training schemes' amplitude and phase errors, with the twin-scheme difference reaching more than 99.8\% of the analytically predicted full-imitation ceiling. The same behavior occurs for a non-local Fourier neural operator and at the operator level for nonlinear Burgers dynamics. These results show that agreement with solver-generated test data does not by itself establish fidelity to the exact evolution. Fourier-symbol measurements provide a direct diagnostic of numerical provenance.

Comment
Accepted at NeurIPS 2026 AI for Science Workshop

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From Numerical Simulators of PDEs to Neural Emulators and Back

cs.LG ·2026-08-25 ·Felix Koehler
similarity 0.74
Abstract

Simulation is central to modern engineering and science, but the cost of numerical solvers for partial differential equations (PDEs) remains a bottleneck whenever fast or many-query evaluations are required. Neural emulators trained on solver-generated data promise significant speedups, yet they are usually framed as opaque alternatives to the very methods that produce their training signal. This thesis argues the two paradigms are more alike than different: neural architectures mirror classical discretizations, their errors are amenable to the same spectral analysis, and insight flows profitably in both directions. We approach the relationship by disentangling the multiple roles a solver plays in the emulator learning pipeline. Mode-wise Fourier analysis then provides a common language in which solver errors, architectural inductive biases, and training objectives can all be read off simultaneously. Taken together, this allows synthesizing three contributions. (1) APEBench, a comprehensive benchmarking suite for autoregressive neural emulators of PDEs that uses fast differentiable pseudo-spectral solvers in JAX. (2) Progressively Refined Differentiable Physics, an investigation of the effect of unconverged solvers on surrogate training. (3) Neural Emulator Superiority, an analysis of the influence of numerical errors and architectural inductive biases.

0.23

Compute-optimal data scaling for neural surrogates via multi-fidelity training

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-10-12 ·Paul Setinek, Fabian Paischer, Nils Thuerey, Johannes Brandstetter, Felix Koehler
top venuecode/data similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted at NeurIPS 2026. Project page: https://psetinek.github.io/multi-fidelity-neural-surrogates/ Code: https://github.com/psetinek/multi…

Neural surrogates for Partial Differential Equations (PDEs) are usually trained on synthetic data from numerical simulators. As models grow and scaling laws demand larger datasets, the cost of data generation often outweighs the training cost and becomes the bottleneck in the scaling quest. Unlike data in other domains, however, each PDE sample has a tunable cost that depends on its numerical fidelity, with the resulting cost-accuracy trade-off governed by known convergence rates. We exploit this property by formalizing neural surrogate training as a function of both data quantity and fidelity under a fixed data generation compute budget, treating fidelity as a fine-grained discrete spectrum rather than a binary distinction. Building on this, we show that multi-fidelity training enables Pareto-optimal error scaling against data generation compute. By using simulations at lower fidelities as an additional training signal, training on the optimal fidelity mixture matches the accuracy of high-fidelity-only training, with up to $6.3\times$ less data generation compute across our settings. We validate these findings across six PDE problems spanning structured grids and unstructured meshes, two distinct error sources (discretization and iterative-solver error), and four surrogate architectures, totaling over 7,000 training runs.

0.59

Structure-preserving fidelity diagnostics for partial differential equations

cs.LG physics.comp-ph ·2026-10-12 ·Kyriakos Flouris
similarity 0.66
Abstract · Preprint

Machine learning surrogates of partial differential equations (PDEs) are commonly trained on data generated by numerical solvers. Therefore, the training data obey not the PDE but the modified equation of the numerical scheme, and the test loss, computed on data from the same solver, cannot distinguish a model that learned the physics from one that learned the discretization error. Here, we show that the difference is nevertheless visible in the trained model. We propose a suite of structure-preserving fidelity diagnostics, simple scores that measure whether a learned model respects one known property of the physics, such as a conserved quantity, a symmetry or a Hamiltonian structure, without access to the training data or the governing equation. Over five systems, the diagnostics track the error with respect to the true dynamics with a rank correlation of up to $0.94$, while the test loss is uncorrelated or anti-correlated with it. For the Burgers, Korteweg-de Vries and Navier-Stokes equations, the diagnostics separate numerical schemes that the test loss ranks as equivalent, including schemes of the same order. order.

0.16

Learning PDE Time-Stepping with Neural Cellular Automata

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-08-31 ·Esha Saha, Hao Wang
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract · 4 figures, 7 tables

Classical numerical solvers for partial differential equations (PDEs) are computationally expensive to solve repeatedly across varying initial conditions, motivating the need for learned surrogates. In this paper, we propose a trainable Neural Cellular Automata (NCA) based surrogate model for learning long time PDE dynamics. Rather than mapping an entire initial field to a full trajectory in one shot, our proposed model learns a small, local, homogeneous update rule that is applied identically and repeatedly at every grid cell, mirroring the locality of differential operators. We benchmark this framework against three baselines: PDE - Net, a modified physics-informed neural network (PINN), and a Fourier Neural Operator (FNO), on five canonical PDEs (heat, advection, Burgers, Allen - Cahn, and Fisher - KPP), evaluated at temporal domain two times beyond the training temporal domain. The proposed model achieves the lowest long-horizon relative errors on the majority of the experiments.

0.06

Operator-informed initialization for Fourier features physics-informed neural networks

cs.LG ·2026-10-02 ·Juan Molina, Paris Perdikaris, Mircea Petrache, Matías Courdurier, Francisco Sahli Costabal
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Physics-Informed Neural Networks (PINNs) typically exhibit spectral bias, where some frequencies of the target function converge more slowly than others. In this work, we analyze the training dynamics of Fourier Feature PINNs in the Neural Tangent Kernel regime to address this limitation. We derive an explicit evolution equation to estimate the residual error in the frequency domain, demonstrating that the convergence rate of specific frequencies is primarily governed by the product of the differential operator's symbol and the spectral density of the initialization weights. Leveraging this theoretical insight, we propose an informative initialization strategy that tailors the initial weight distribution to the specific PDE being solved. With this method, we can diminish the operator-induced spectral bias, balancing the convergence rates across the frequency spectrum and achieving better prediction accuracy. Numerical experiments on linear and nonlinear partial differential equations confirm that this initialization strategy improves learning dynamics and approximation accuracy across frequencies compared to standard initialization methods, with no additional training cost.

0.18

Cost-Accuracy Trade-offs: Neural Operator vs Classical Numerical Solver

cs.LG math.NA ·2026-09-21 ·Daniel Zhengyu Huang, Andrew M. Stuart
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract · 41 pages; 10 figures

Neural operators are data-driven models that learn mappings from inputs that parameterize partial differential equations, such as spatially varying coefficients, initial conditions, forcing terms, boundary conditions, or geometries, to solution fields or quantities of interest. Once trained, they can serve as surrogates for classical numerical solvers in many-query settings that require repeated evaluations for varying inputs. We address the question of when, and then why, neural operator surrogates outperform classical numerical solvers, in terms of cost for a given accuracy. We focus on the post-training, many-query limit, in which data-acquisition and training costs are treated as fixed and fully amortized. Even in this deliberately favorable regime for neural operators, there are regimes in which classical solvers outperform the surrogate models. We compare the cost-accuracy performance of neural operator surrogates and classical numerical solvers through a reproducible benchmark study comparing neural operators with problem-matched classical solvers on representative problems in computational science and engineering, focusing on prediction error, per-query floating-point cost, and wall-clock runtime. Neural operators are most competitive at low-to-moderate accuracy requirements. Their floating-point cost advantage depends strongly on the problem structure, arising when they avoid temporal or nonlinear iterations or predict a reduced quantity of interest rather than a full solution field. Additional wall-clock speedups result from dense tensor operations that are well suited to modern hardware. As the target accuracy is tightened, achieving the required accuracy with neural operators becomes increasingly challenging, and classical solvers outperform surrogates in this regime; thus classical solvers will remain important for verification and high-accuracy computation.

0.45

AMOR: Adaptive Modal Operator Refinement for Operator Learning on Arbitrary Meshes and Irregular 3D Geometries

cs.CE math.NAphysics.comp-ph ·2026-10-27 ·David Voderholzer, Leonard Vetter, Thomas O'Leary-Roseberry
theorycode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 50 pages, 13 figures, 11 tables. Submitted to Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering. Code: https://github.com/leonardvetter/…

Parametric PDEs in science and engineering are often posed on irregular meshes with geometries that may contain holes or complex boundaries, yet popular operator-surrogate architectures such as the Fourier Neural Operator (FNO) rely on structured geometries for fast computational kernels. We introduce Adaptive Modal Operator Refinement (AMOR), which replaces FNO's Fourier-based spectral convolutions with reduced-basis blocks and supports both data-driven and prescribed input/output bases through a common encode/decode interface. AMOR thus applies unmodified to arbitrary meshes and, because its spectral parameterization has no tensor-product dependence on the spatial dimension, it scales favorably to three dimensions, where FNO's spectral weights grow as $m^3$ with the number of spectral modes $m$. We prove that AMOR is a universal approximator of continuous operators. On two-dimensional structured-grid benchmarks, AMOR is competitive with FNO overall and surpasses PCANet: it outperforms FNO on nonlinear diffusion and Helmholtz problems, while a static snapshot basis keeps it from matching FNO's accuracy on the time-dependent Kolmogorov flow problem. On three-dimensional problems it matches or exceeds FNO's accuracy at lower inference cost on linear elastostatics while trailing FNO on a turbulent lid-driven-cavity flow and scales favorably to problems demanding high capacity. On irregular meshes, where FNO is not directly applicable, AMOR reduces the relative $L^2$ error over the FNO extension Geo-FNO by $31\%$ (airfoil) and $42\%$ (elasticity). Finally, AMOR maintains strong performance across three physically distinct, experimentally motivated loading regimes on a topologically nontrivial three-dimensional aircraft-rib mesh, demonstrating its applicability to realistic engineering problems without modification.

0.23

Inductively Scalable, Single-Step Neural Surrogates for Wave-Scattering Inverse Problems

cs.AI physics.optics ·2026-08-18 ·Charles Dove, Laura Waller
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Neural network surrogates are an emerging alternative to traditional electromagnetic wave simulators like finite-difference time-domain (FDTD); their goal is to replace rigorous physical simulations with pre-trained neural networks that solve wave-scattering forward and inverse problems orders of magnitude faster. However, nonrecurrent, single-step surrogates have scaled only to a few tens of simulation variables. Here, we show that this barrier can be overcome by dynamically generating salient training examples during training, rather than randomly sampling the large space of possible examples. We introduce an algorithm that runs in parallel with surrogate training, using gradient ascent to search refractive-index and source configurations for cases where the surrogate disagrees with a full-wave ground-truth simulator. We also use source and ground-truth normalization with an evolving replay dataset to stabilize and accelerate learning. Using this approach, we train a fast, single-step surrogate for two-dimensional wave scattering with up to 41,772 controllable variables, including dense, freely configurable grids of refractive indices and complex-valued sources. The resulting neural surrogate is robustly accurate across diverse structured and unstructured examples and generalizes inductively to larger domains, reaching over 3 million controllable variables without retraining, a $73.8\times$ increase. We demonstrate the surrogate on large-scale forward simulations and inverse design of freeform beam splitters and gradient-index (GRIN) lenses up to 98 wavelengths wide, showing comparable or better performance than FDTD-based designs, with speedups from $1.29\times$ to $26.5\times$. These results demonstrate a practical path toward fast, robustly accurate, inductively scalable neural simulators for photonic inverse design and other wave-scattering inverse problems.

0.24