CS Paper Radar

When Exposure Is Not Attention: Auditing the Preference-Exposure-Consumption Gap in Personalized News Recommenders

Woojin Park

cs.SI ·submitted 2026-10-07 14:46 UTC · v1

Abstract

Personalized news platforms are often evaluated as if stated preferences, logged recommendation exposure, and click consumption form a single coherent pipeline. Collapsing these layers can distort audit conclusions: a platform may appear more aligned or diverse than observed click consumption supports, which can misdirect diversity governance or algorithmic intervention. We introduce a reusable Preference-Exposure-Consumption (PEC) audit framework that separates stated preference, observed weighted profile state, logged recommendation exposure, app-surface pathways, and click consumption under explicit observability boundaries. Using six months of logs from a deployed mobile news application, we audit 1,583 user profiles, 95,143 logged recommendation items, and 17,512 click events. Each trace type contributes distinct information; none directly substitutes for another. Preference-consumption alignment exceeds chance-based null baselines but captures only part of users' top-consumed category set. Logged recommendation lists contain clicked articles more often than a date-matched candidate-pool baseline predicts (11.29% vs 9.13%; top-5 lift 1.47x), but many clicks arrive through other app surfaces. Raw exposure-consumption diversity gaps shrink under count matching, yet concentration mismatch persists in the audit-eligible cohort (HHI gap 0.082). Together, the results show that audit conclusions change depending on whether platforms measure stated preference, logged exposure, or click consumption.

Comment
16 pages, 5 figures, 14 tables. Submitted to ICWSM 2027

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Incremental Recommendation via Causal Models

cs.LG stat.MLstat.ME ·2026-08-27 ·Athanasios Vlontzos, David Gustafsson, Michael O'Riordan, Ciarán M. Gilligan-Lee
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · Accepted at the CONSEQUENCES Workshop @ RecSys'26

Recommendation impressions are a finite resource, hence delivering a recommendation to a user who would discover the content organically yields no incremental value and displaces other recommendations that could. We address this by extending an existing production recommendation model to a causal architecture using holdback data that is already collected as part of routine experimentation infrastructure, requiring no new data collection. A central challenge is that attribution windows differ between treated and holdback observations: treated users are attributed a stream within a short direct-response window, while holdback users are attributed organic streams over a multi-day window. This mismatch makes naive treatment-effect subtraction invalid. We resolve this with a dual-threshold targeting policy that delivers a recommendation only when the probability of a treated stream is high and the probability of organic stream is low. In a production-scale A/B test on millions of Spotify users, this policy reduces recommendation impressions by 7% with no statistically significant reduction in overall recommended content consumption. We further show that joint training with holdback data improves calibration of the treated head relative to the production baseline, and argue this can be taken as evidence that causal models learn more generalisable representations than models trained on observational data alone.

0.52

Why didn't more people see it? Recommendation: Transparency for providers

cs.IR ·2026-08-21 ·Meysam Varasteh, Robin Burke
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Transparency in recommender systems has been widely studied from the perspective of those receiving recommendations, yet the needs of item providers, the creators whose content is distributed through these platforms, remain largely unexplored. Providers often lack insight into how their items do or do not receive exposure in users' recommendation lists. In this work, we address this gap by proposing a surrogate modeling approach to explain item exposure at a system level. Rather than explaining individual user-item pairs, we train a proxy model to approximate the exposure distribution produced by a recommender. By quantifying the contribution of each feature, we seek to explain the factors driving the recommendation model's decisions across the entire user base. We evaluate our approach on two datasets and three recommendation models. Results show that the surrogate model captures the global behavior of all three recommenders with high fidelity and that the most influential factors vary meaningfully across models and domains.

0.55

Auditing Multi-Proxy Explanations of Web User Preferences: Identification Boundaries and Abstention

cs.LG cs.IR ·2026-11-03 ·Yu Zhang, Zhihan Wang, Yuhang Lu, Shuai Li
publishedbenchmarktheory similarity 0.60
Abstract · 11 pages, 1 figure. Accepted at WSDM 2027 (Main Track)

Web systems infer user preferences from behavior, ratings, text, and LLM-generated profiles, yet explaining a proxy may reveal its measurement process rather than the preference of interest. We develop an audit framework distinguishing point identification, partial identification, and abstention relative to an explicit reference distribution. Under feature-dependent, arbitrarily signed proxy bias, a strict majority of uncontaminated proxy attributions lets the coordinatewise median recover latent-attribution support and direction and, with externally justified positive scales, magnitude. We prove this threshold sharp using response-valid indistinguishable worlds, characterize sharp minimax error and exact compatible-target sets under approximate cleanliness and scale uncertainty, and propagate clean-proxy attribution error. A frozen known-truth benchmark spans two response families, four proxy counts, all contamination counts, three bias strengths, and eleven methods, with a focal comparison confirmed on twenty unseen seeds. Under correct budgets, a direct attribution-tensor audit achieved 100% coverage, 95.40%-97.05% active-driver sign decisions, and no false signs. In a temporally separated Amazon study, median aggregation reduced comparator-relative conditional sign error for all four targets; six of eight prespecified target-metric contrasts had Bonferroni intervals excluding zero. A controlled real-covariate perturbation favored the median on the prespecified focal metric for all four targets. Compatible sets showed that the current proxy configuration rarely licensed strict-sign conclusions. Weak comparator calibration limits the Amazon evidence to fitted-surface alignment rather than latent-preference recovery.

0.47

MARCO: Click-Intent Decomposition for Calibrated Ads Conversion Prediction

cs.LG ·2026-08-11 ·Shiwen Shen, Xiru Huang, Liang Luo, Jianbo Sun, He Lyu +30 more
theory similarity 0.58
Abstract

Not all clicks are equal. Industrial ads ranking decouples conversion probability into click-through rate (CTR) and post-click conversion rate (CVR), yet treats every click as the same event. In reality, users provide a free, self-generated signal of intent through their physical UI interactions. Different click types on the same ad exhibit a 4-fold difference in actual conversion rates. By conflating these signals, the standard CVR model under-predicts high-intent clicks and over-predicts low-intent ones, which is a bias masked by near-perfect aggregate calibration. We propose MARCO (Multi-intent Ads Ranking Composition Optimization), a framework that resolves this bias by decomposing each click by intent. Using the logged click type as a free behavioral label, MARCO trains per-intent CVR heads on homogeneous populations, and at serving time composes their per-intent CVR estimates under a predicted distribution over intents. Theoretically, we prove that decomposition never raises population risk, give the exact headroom under squared loss and non-negativity under the deployed loss, and show through a routing-efficiency dial how much of it reaches serving. Because the population-optimal score is unchanged, any gain is a finite-capacity estimation and calibration effect that we validated both offline and online. For deployment at scale, we further cast multi-impression, multi-click attribution as credit assignment with a bias-variance tradeoff analogous to RL return estimation, showing last-impression, first-click attribution is the low-bias, low-variance, deterministic choice under production constraints, and derive three consistency conditions enforced end-to-end at scale. Deployed at binary intent granularity, MARCO corrects per-intent calibration to approximately 100%, lifts conversions per click by +2.80%, and drives +0.98% cumulative improvement in topline metrics.

0.04

Reflection Is Not Always Worth It: Budgeted Reflection Allocation for Recommendation Agents

cs.IR ·2026-11-15 ·Jinfeng Xu, Zheyu Chen, Ziyue Peng, Jianheng Tang, Zheng Lin +4 more
published similarity 0.58
Abstract · Accepted by WSDM 2027

This work aims to make recommendation agents more efficient by reducing unnecessary LLM reflection while preserving full-catalog ranking and inference reranking. Since BRAVE changes only how training-time reflection is allocated, it does not introduce new user data requirements or additional LLM exposure beyond the base agent protocol. The main potential risk is that a poorly calibrated allocator may assign less reflection to users whose preferences are sparse, niche, or under-represented, which could weaken personalization for those users or indirectly affect item exposure. This risk can be mitigated through deployment-time auditing and conservative allocation design. In practice, reflection budgets should be evaluated not only by aggregate Recall or NDCG, but also across user-history lengths, item popularity groups, and application-relevant cohorts when such analysis is permitted. The allocator should rely on task-side ranking evidence rather than sensitive attributes, and fallback policies can reserve a small portion of the budget for random or fairness-aware coverage when subgroup robustness is important. Privacy risks can be controlled with the same protections required by the base recommendation agent: minimizing user text sent to the LLM controller, anonymizing user identifiers, retaining only necessary interaction evidence, and applying standard access-control and logging policies. Overall, BRAVE is designed as a cost-aware allocation layer, and its ethical deployment depends on validating that the saved computation does not come at the expense of vulnerable users or responsible exposure.

0.33

Do Similarity Measures Measure Similarity? How User Activity Creates Phantom Correlation in Recommender Systems

cs.IR cs.AI ·2026-10-26 ·Marco Favier, Noah Daniëls, Jens Leysen, Sander Marinus, Bart Goethals
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.58
Abstract · 11 pages, 1 figure, 3 tables. Code: https://github.com/Mfavier91/Phantom-Correlation

Item-item similarity is one of the oldest and most foundational signals in recommender systems: two items are assumed to be similar when the same users consume them. Despite the sparsity and scale of interaction data, the implicit assumption across the field is that item co-occurrence reflects genuine shared preference, capturing what users like together. In this paper, we demonstrate that a substantial fraction of observed item-item similarity is an artifact of variance in user activity rather than shared taste. Even if every user consumed items completely independently, differing only in their total consumption volume, standard similarity measures still detect strong associations between items. We term this phenomenon phantom correlation: spurious item association that emerges strictly from heterogeneous user activity in the complete absence of preference structure. Starting from minimal formal assumptions, we show that independent consumption under varying activity is described by a Rasch model, and we derive how the resulting association depends on item popularity for each similarity measure. By comparing our theoretical baseline against real-world benchmark datasets, we reveal the extent to which popular similarity measures reflect phantom correlation, which bears on how item co-occurrence is interpreted and used in collaborative filtering.

0.44

Personal-Agent Mediated Recommendation with Cross-Platform User History

cs.AI cs.LG ·2026-10-06 ·Yu Xia, Jiangfan Zhang, Jun Xiao, Julian McAuley, Xiangjun Fan
benchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract

Modern recommendation is shifting from platform-centric personalization toward user-governed personalization, where a personal LLM agent can act on the user's behalf across services. We formalize this emerging paradigm as Personal-Agent Mediated Recommendation: a platform recommender ranks a candidate set using platform-local information, and a personal agent uses user-authorized cross-platform history to mediate the resulting ranking and produce the final top-K slate. Such mediation is nontrivial: the platform ranking can encode strong population evidence that the personal agent cannot observe, so effective mediation must therefore balance beneficial rescues against harmful overrides. To study this trade-off, we introduce MediateRec, a benchmark that includes scalable proxy cross-platform environments and a real cross-platform test under a controlled platform-agent information boundary. To train the agent to use cross-platform history effectively, we further propose Personal Attribution Mediation Optimization (PAMO), which counterfactually masks that history to estimate personal mediation support and reallocates rank-aware advantage mass under a platform-relative value floor. We theoretically prove that PAMO preserves cutoff-level advantage mass and is locally optimal among first-order reallocations that preserve this mass without lowering average platform-relative value. Experiments on MediateRec show that personal-agent mediation enables meaningful platform corrections, yet even strong proprietary LLMs introduce non-negligible harmful overrides. PAMO consistently improves over matched outcome-only RL across seen and unseen target platforms and on the real cross-platform test, while achieving a better rescue-harm balance.

0.16

PrivAudit: A Dual-Lens Auditing Framework for Website Privacy Practices under the CCPA

cs.CR ·2026-09-09 ·Mohamed Moustafa Dawoud, Riya Aggarwal, Likith Rahul Krishnamurthy, Ram Sundara Raman
top venuecode/datahot direction similarity 0.57
Abstract · Extended version of a paper accepted to the 2026 ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security (CCS '26)

Five years after the enforcement of the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), understanding how website privacy practices evolve at scale in response to regulation remains a key challenge for both researchers and regulators. Prior work and regulatory efforts have focused on manual and case-specific enforcement, but there remain no scalable approaches to systematically audit two key user-facing facets of websites that are crucial signals for the CCPA: privacy disclosures and front-end user tracking behavior. In this paper, we present PrivAudit, an automated auditing framework that adopts a dual-lens approach to capture: (1) privacy disclosures through large language model-based analysis of privacy policies grounded in CCPA provisions, and (2) user-observable data collection behavior through automated browser measurements of cookie writes under diverse privacy configurations. We apply PrivAudit to 998 websites and report two broad findings. The law is associated with stronger privacy disclosures: CCPA-subject policies are more likely to disclose opt-out mechanisms, data-sharing practices, and user rights. On the other hand, cookie-based tracking remains pervasive, with both CCPA-subject and not-subject websites setting a total of 6,392 targeting cookies, 49% of which are third-party writes. Moreover, cookies show limited-to-moderate responsiveness to privacy signals and consent choices, even when websites claim to honor them in their disclosures. Our results highlight the need for multi-layered and scalable auditing approaches that combine policy analysis with behavioral evidence. PrivAudit can support these auditing workflows at scale by generating actionable signals and patterns for further manual review. We open-source PrivAudit and are engaging with regulators to support auditing in practice.

0.62