CS Paper Radar

Settling PROPm and PROPavg in Graphical Resource Allocation

Bo Li, Ankang Sun, Ruijie Wang

cs.GT ·submitted 2026-10-07 16:17 UTC · v2
publishedtheory

Abstract

We study proportional fairness in graphical resource allocation, where agents are vertices, indivisible items are edges, and each item must be allocated to one of its two endpoints. It has been proved that PROP1 orientations always exist and PROPx orientations may not, but it has remained open whether the intermediate relaxations PROPm and PROPavg (both can be satisfied without graphical constraints) can always be satisfied. In this paper, we resolve this gap. We prove that PROPm orientations always exist for goods on multigraphs and can be computed efficiently. The guarantee extends to chores and a mixture of goods and chores. In sharp contrast, we show that PROPavg orientations need not exist, even for simple graphs with binary valuations, and that deciding their existence is NP-complete. We further quantify the efficiency loss of PROPm: for goods, the price of PROPm is exactly $2$, which is one of the few settings where a constant bound on the price of fairness can be obtained. We complement these results with hardness results for welfare optimization under PROPm and for the existence of orientations that are simultaneously PROPm and Pareto optimal.

Comment
Full version of a paper to appear in WINE 2026. V2 includes an extended related work section

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Polynomial Time Characterization For Strongly EFX Orientable Graphs

cs.GT ·2026-09-29 ·Jinghan A Zeng
similarity 0.74
Abstract · 16 pages, 9 figures

Discrete fair division is the problem of dividing a discrete set of goods among agents in a fair manner. In this setting, one of the most sought-after notions of fairness is envy-freeness up to any good (EFX). In 2023, Christodoulou, Fiat, Koutsoupias, and Sgouritsa introduced the idea of a graphical valuation, where the fair division problem is represented by a simple graph where vertices are the agents and the edges are the goods, and each vertex only values incident edges. They showed that an EFX allocation always exists, while determining the existence of an EFX orientation is NP-hard. They posed a open question of determining which graphs always admit an EFX orientation regardless of valuation. These graphs, called strongly EFX orientable graphs, were first studied by Zeng and Mehta in 2025, who demonstrated that all such graphs have chromatic number at most 3, and bipartite graphs always admit an EFX orientation regardless of valuation. In this manuscript, we finish resolving this question by giving a polynomial time characterization of strongly EFX orientable graphs. In particular, we show that a connected graph $G$ is strongly EFX orientable if and only if either of the following is true: (1) $G$ is bipartite, or (2) the block decomposition of $G$ contains exactly one nonbipartite block $B$, and there exists a vertex $v \in B$ such that the degree of $v$ within $B$ is 2 and $G-v$ is bipartite. This proof was discovered by AI, with human intervention to break the problem into the appropriate subproblems.

0.31

Fair, Efficient and Connected Allocations on Graphs

cs.GT ·2026-08-19 ·Susobhan Bandopadhyay, Anish Datta, Palash Dey, Ashlesha Hota, Abhishek Sahu
published similarity 0.70
Abstract · Accepted to Algorithmic Decision Theory (ADT) 2026, Paris, France

We study the classical and parameterized complexity of efficient connected allocation problems on graphs, where efficiency is measured by egalitarian and utilitarian welfare maximization. We first establish a sharp complexity dichotomy in the classical setting: both problems are NP-hard in general and remain hard even on very restricted graph classes such as paths, and consequently trees and cycles. In contrast, they are polynomial-time solvable on stars, but this tractability does not extend even to the case of two disjoint stars. Motivated by these boundaries, we move to the parameterized complexity framework, where we study the problem with respect to the number of agents. We obtain fixed-parameter tractability (FPT) on trees and, more generally, identify a robust phenomenon whereby tractability on a connected graph class extends to disjoint unions of graphs from that class. We further investigate the parameters treewidth and treedepth, showing that the utilitarian version is FPT for both, whereas the egalitarian version remains para-NP-hard even on graphs of treedepth two. Finally, we analyze the number of connected components and show that except for the collection of stars, the problems remain hard. For the collection of stars,while we obtain para-NP-hardness for the egalitarian case, the utilitarian case gives W[2]-hardness together with an XP algorithm.

0.25

Welfare in Envy-free Contracts: When Agents Have Sparse Interests

cs.GT ·2026-11-08 ·Junjie Chen, Cong Chen, Takuro Yamashita
similarity 0.70
Abstract

We study welfare maximization under envy-free contracts, where a principal assigns tasks and offers success-contingent payments to heterogeneous agents with hidden effort. For unit-demand agents, we establish a sharp complexity boundary: the problem is polynomial-time solvable when each agent is interested in at most two tasks, but NP-hard with at most three interests. Our algorithm analyzes tree-structured dependencies among forced assignments and reduces optimization to maximum-weight independent set in a perfect graph. When agents may receive multiple tasks, no polynomial-time constant-factor approximation exists unless $\mathrm{P}=\mathrm{NP}$. Finally, with homogeneous success probabilities and rewards, we establish a welfare- and revenue-preserving equivalence between unit-demand contract design and envy-free pricing. This yields polynomial-time welfare maximization without restricting interests, while revenue maximization remains NP-hard.

0.11

Non-Existence of PMMS Allocations and a $4/3$-PMMS Guarantee for Additive Chores

cs.GT ·2026-09-09 ·Xiaohui Bei, Zehan Lin, Shengxin Liu, Rong Luan, Biaoshuai Tao
theory similarity 0.68
Abstract · 23 pages, no figure

We study pairwise maximin share (PMMS) fairness for indivisible items with additive preferences. We give a polynomial-time reduction from chores to goods that preserves the existence of a PMMS allocation. Together with known nonexistence results for chores, this yields nonexistence for additive goods. In addition, we show that deciding if a given instance admits a PMMS allocation is NP-hard. We also give explicit instances whose PMMS factors are $226/227$ for goods and $1.102065$ for chores, certified by exact enumeration. Complementing these impossibility results, we prove that every additive-chore instance admits a $4/3$-PMMS allocation.

0.38

Online Fair Division under Eligibility Constraints

cs.GT ·2026-10-06 ·Joes Biburger, Nicole Megow, Golnoosh Shahkarami
theory similarity 0.68
Abstract

We study fair division of indivisible items under eligibility constraints: each item may be assigned only to a subset of eligible agents. This model coincides with restricted assignment in scheduling, with agents as machines and items as jobs, and captures settings where work or resources must be split among parties with different capabilities. Eligibility makes the usual fairness benchmarks inadequate, as agents should not be measured against items they could never receive. We therefore use eligibility-aware versions of proportionality and envy-freeness, where an agent's proportional share splits each item equally among its eligible agents, and envy comparisons discount items the agents are not eligible for. Our main finding is a sharp chore--goods separation for proportionality. We focus on identical valuations: under arbitrary valuations, no online algorithm can guarantee even an $o(m)$-approximation for chores. For chores, Prop1 is achievable offline, whereas exact proportionality and proportionality up to any item are not. For online chores, the optimal approximation factor for Prop1 for deterministic algorithms is $Θ(\sqrt m)$, with the lower bound holding even for unit-size jobs. For goods, Prop1 is again achievable offline, but the tight online bound drops to $Θ(\log m)$. For envy-based fairness, the picture is different. Goods and chores are equivalent under eligibility-aware envy notions, while the choice of notion is decisive. Strong EF1 may fail to exist even offline and cannot be approximated online. In contrast, weak EF1 can be maintained online, while weak EFX separates offline from online. Together, these results give a systematic study of online proportional and envy-based fairness in restricted assignment and show which fairness guarantees remain achievable under eligibility constraints.

0.36

Envy-free Allocations with Individual Payments

cs.GT cs.DS ·2026-10-07 ·Robert Bredereck, Eva Deltl, Tanmay Inamdar, Pallavi Jain, Pranjal Pandey
survey similarity 0.67
Abstract

When an envy-free allocation of indivisible goods does not exist, monetary transfers can restore envy-freeness. Existing work on fair division with subsidies, however, typically assumes that these payments are provided by an external source, an assumption that may be unrealistic in many applications. We address this limitation by allowing only monetary transfers between agents, with each agent's payments constrained by their individual budget. We show that while it is polynomial-time tractable to determine whether a given allocation can be made envy-free by payments under individual budgets, the general problem of computing such an allocation from scratch is NP-hard, even when agents have relatively large budgets. Motivated by this intractability, we conduct a parameterized complexity analysis, establishing fixed-parameter tractability with respect to the number of goods or to the joint parameter number of agents and good types, and we provide efficient algorithms in several special cases. For explicitly listed items, our type-based algorithm answers the envy-freeness part of an open question of T. T. Nguyen and J. Rothe, "Complexity Results and Exact Algorithms for Fair Division of Indivisible Items: A Survey."

0.15

Multilevel Fair Allocation under Additive Preferences

cs.GT cs.AIcs.MA ·2026-08-25 ·Maxime Lucet, Nawal Benabbou, Aurélie Beynier, Nicolas Maudet
publishedtheory similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted at the 9th International conference on Algorithmic Decision Theory

We study multilevel fair resource allocation with tree-structured hierarchical relations among agents. At each level, the problem can be viewed locally as allocating an agent's bundle to its children, the overall allocation being a trace of this process iterated down to the leaves. Assuming that internal nodes' utilities are the utilitarian welfare of their children, and the leaves have classical additive utilities over items, we first propose multilevel adaptations of usual envy-based fairness notions (e.g., WEF1). We present three adaptations and show that the choice among them is not neutral. We prove that, under identical preferences, the three adapted envy-based notions coincide, and that the Multilevel extension of Weighted Round Robin (Chakraborty et al., 2021) (MWRR) guarantees them. We then show that under general preferences, MWRR may guarantee some notions while failing others. Finally, through experiments, we show that MWRR may still perform well even for adaptations it does not formally guarantee.

0.26

Fair Division of Graphs: Beyond Traceability

cs.GT cs.DMmath.CO ·2026-08-30 ·Nicolas Bousquet, Frank Connor, Agnès Totschnig, Sébastien Zeitoun
similarity 0.67
Abstract

In this paper, we study fair division problems in which resources are structured as graphs and agents must receive connected bundles. This connectivity requirement fundamentally alters the problem, making it significantly more challenging than its classical counterpart. We focus on the fairness notion of $\mathrm{EF1}_{\mathrm{outer}}$, where envy can be eliminated by removing at most one vertex whose deletion does not disconnect the bundle -- a critical constraint for applications such as land division and network allocation. Our first result extends prior work by establishing the existence of $\mathrm{EF1}_{\mathrm{outer}}$ allocations for an infinite family of non-traceable graphs (that is, graphs that do not admit a Hamiltonian path), answering a central open question and generalizing Bilò et al.'s result for traceable graphs. We then make progress on a conjecture concerning the $\mathrm{EF1}_{\mathrm{outer}}$ spectrum of trees due to Chen and Zwicker. Finally, we complement our structural results with algorithmic insights, showing that deciding the existence of an $\mathrm{EF1}_{\mathrm{outer}}$ allocation is NP-complete even for binary additive valuations, thereby resolving an open complexity question. Taken together, our results deepen the connection between graph theory and fair division, and offer new tools for studying fairness in structured resource environments.

0.06