CS Paper Radar

Prompts versus Rules: Auditing and Controlling Speech Naturalness Behaviors in Voice User Simulators

Riqiang Wang, Elena Khasanova, Harsh Saini, Lex Konnelly, Parsa Kavehzadeh, Matthias Lee, Mohamed Attia

cs.CL ·submitted 2026-10-07 23:55 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

As voice agents gain more popularity commercially, the user simulators used to evaluate the deployed agents are also being developed to include more realistic, variable, and diverse speech naturalness behaviors -- disfluency, interruption and backchanneling. The quality of the user simulator directly affects the validity of agent evaluation results. However, we find that most studies so far have not examined in detail whether the intended configuration for these behaviors is realized in the simulation. In this study, we audit the realized naturalness behaviors of tau-Voice, our own LLM-based prompting approach across three models, and our rule-based injection algorithm for disfluency, interruption, and backchanneling. We find that prompting for these behaviors is unreliable and produces speech inconsistent with the instructions, placed and distributed less naturally than the instruction implies. In contrast, our rule-based, model-free algorithm produces controllable and diverse naturalness behaviors more aligned with natural speech. Our results suggest that LLMs not purpose-trained for user simulation are not sufficient on their own to represent authentic user behavior, and that linguistically informed deterministic approaches or specialized models are needed to close the gap; auditing and reporting realized naturalness behaviors, rather than configured settings, is what makes that gap visible.

Comment
Accepted to the UserSim @ NeurIPS 2026 workshop (non-archival)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Scalable Context Orchestration for Serving LLMs Over Voice

cs.SD cs.AIeess.AS ·2026-09-03 ·Linyi Jiang, Silvery D. Fu, Yifei Zhu
top venue similarity 0.67
Abstract · Accepted for publication in ACM SOSP 2026

Voice AI applications are gaining popularity as advances in large language models (LLMs) enable more natural and accessible spoken interactions. Serving these applications requires accounting not only for what users say, but also for how they speak (e.g., speaking rate) and the conditions under which their audio is captured and transmitted (e.g., background noise and packet loss). However, existing LLM systems represent conversation context as a flat, growing sequence of messages, leaving voice-specific context implicit in the audio. As a result, they can generate responses that are poorly aligned with user preferences, degrade interaction quality under adverse environmental conditions, and incur high costs over long voice sessions. We present llmovoice, a context-management middleware that explicitly models voice context and orchestrates its use. At each turn, llmovoice constructs a bounded voice context from the current user input, relevant interaction history, and explicit paralinguistic and environmental states. It then uses the serving LLM to reason over this context and generate runtime directives that guide how the system responds. We evaluate llmovoice on real-world voice applications and benchmarks. It reduces speaking-rate alignment error by 52.4%, lowers the false-interruption rate from 46.0% to 0.9% under packet loss, and reduces model usage cost by 79.2%. For long sessions, llmovoice reduces per-turn cost by up to 24.9 times while retaining up to 98.7% of baseline answer quality.

0.42

Towards User Simulators That Stay On Task And Still Sound Natural

cs.CL ·2026-10-22 ·Mustafa Omer Gul, Philippe Laban, Tanya Goyal, Jennifer Neville
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 30 pages, 16 figures, 6 tables. In submission

Users increasingly rely on AI systems for extended, multi-turn tasks, yet evidence indicates that LLM-based system performance degrades over prolonged interaction. To evaluate and improve AI assistants in such settings, we need user simulators that faithfully follow complex user intents while exhibiting realistic conversational behavior. Existing approaches manifest a trade-off: prompted assistants can follow complex user intents but lack behavioral fidelity, while specialized user simulators better approximate conversational behavior but struggle to remain faithful to complex intents. In this paper, we propose a reinforcement learning (RL) recipe that jointly rewards task intent adherence and behavioral naturalness. A crucial contribution of the method is operationalizing naturalness with a lightweight discriminator trained in an alternating, adversarial loop with the user simulator. We release the resulting model, UserLM-2.0, which produces valid simulated conversations (i.e., meeting both task-faithfulness and naturalness criteria) 46.2% of the time, over three times the rate of the strongest prior user simulator (14.1%).

0.08

Talk2Agent: Benchmarking Voice Interfaces for Text Agents

cs.AI eess.AS ·2026-09-30 ·Terumi Chiba, Guangzhi Sun, Zheqi Yuan, Chao Zhang
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract

Large language model (LLM) computer-use agents are typically evaluated with clean written instructions, despite speech being an increasingly popular interface for interacting with such systems. Speech input introduces an additional failure point: transcription errors can alter task-critical entities, constraints, or targets before the agent begins reasoning, while conventional ASR metrics do not directly measure whether the information required for successful execution has been preserved. We introduce Talk2Agent, a benchmark for evaluating how effectively voice interfaces convey human-spoken instructions to LLM-based computer-use agents. Talk2Agent builds human-spoken versions of tasks from WildClawBench and OSWorld and evaluates a range of voice interfaces, including dedicated ASR models, audio-capable LLMs, contextual biasing, and LLM-based ontology repair. Because repeatedly executing long-horizon computer-use tasks is costly and stochastic, we further propose an execution-free, task-conditioned evaluation framework that projects the original task grader onto prompt-addressable intentions and measures how much task-relevant information is retained after the voice interface. On WildClawBench, Talk2Agent's execution-free native projection provides a practical, execution-grounded measure of voice-interface quality, correlating with downstream task completion and improving Pearson correlation by 0.246 over WER/CER on 32 hours of real human speech.

0.12

Joi-Bench-Task: Benchmarking Task Coordination in Full-duplex Voice Agents through Interactive Simulation

cs.AI ·2026-11-09 ·Xiangheng He, Mingjun Zhao, Zhehao Fan, Zhengjia Li, Xiaopeng Sun +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

Full-duplex voice agents enable natural, hands-free interaction, allowing users to refine requests, redirect ongoing work, and seek clarification while the agent is speaking. However, existing voice-agent benchmarks insufficiently isolate coordination between task execution and conversation. We introduce a benchmark that assesses this coordination by examining whether agents track what is being executed, what has been completed, what has been communicated, and what remains to be reported as the conversation evolves. We propose an interactive user simulator that introduces configurable interventions at designated timing in tool execution and spoken result delivery, supporting controllable and reproducible evaluation conditions. We evaluate five leading commercial voice agents along three dimensions: execution responsiveness, coordination under request changes, and coordination under interruptions. Agent evaluations reveal persistent coordination failures. Under request changes, the highest result completion rate is only 55%, indicating difficulty for current voice agents adapting to new requests while preserving earlier obligations. After user interruption, four of the five agents exhibit average information omission rates of at least 23%. These findings highlight task coordination as a central challenge for current voice agents in complex, evolving conversations.

0.16

Learning Natural Conversational Behavior in Tandem Speech-to-Speech Models with Randomized Guidance

cs.CL eess.AS ·2026-09-25 ·Manato Yaguchi, Yotaro Kubo, Hikaru Asano, So Kuroki
similarity 0.62
Abstract · Submitted to ICASSP 2027. 5 pages, 1 figure, 2 tables

Tandem speech-to-speech architectures couple a responsive speech frontend with an asynchronous text backend. In KAME, a large language model (LLM) serves as the backend, supplying candidate responses as guidance to the speech frontend while the user is still speaking. Ordinary conversation recordings capture the eventual response but not the guidance the backend would supply during the user's utterance. Generating the missing guidance with a simulator LLM adds substantial data-preparation overhead when training on real conversations. We propose randomized intermediate guidance, which derives guidance directly from the conversation corpus rather than simulating backend LLM behavior. During training, target responses provide informative guidance, while randomly sampled responses provide potentially irrelevant updates during the utterance. This combination aims to teach the frontend to use backend information selectively. On synthetic dialogues, KAME trained with this recipe achieves response quality comparable to that of the LLM-generated and similarity-based baselines. Training on 3.8k hours of real conversations improves smooth turn-taking and audio-judge naturalness over synthetic-data KAME while retaining a response-quality advantage over Moshi. These results show that randomized guidance offers a practical route to combining the response-quality benefits of tandem models with natural conversational behavior learned from real speech.

0.24

Training User Simulators with Latent Intrinsic Feedback

cs.CL ·2026-10-09 ·Tarek Naous, Craig Boutilier, Wei Xu, Ofer Meshi
similarity 0.62
Abstract

User simulators are gaining attention as environments to train LLM assistants that can better cope with the nuances of multi-turn conversations with real users. Prior work on user simulation has emphasized generating realistic user utterances, leaving unexplored their potential as a source of direct feedback on the assistant's responses. Such evaluation signals may not be explicitly communicated in language, but can instead reside in the latent reasoning of users. In this work, we introduce user simulators with intrinsic feedback, namely, models equipped with latent evaluation states: internal thoughts, reactions, and scalar ratings that evaluate the assistant from a first-person user perspective at each conversation turn. We train LLM-based simulators using interaction logs between real users and assistants and demonstrate that intrinsic feedback improves simulation realism and critiquing behaviors versus prompted simulator baselines, while also providing turn-level evaluations that existing fine-tuned simulators lack. Further, evaluations generated by our trained simulators correlate better with human judgments than those of prompted simulators of the same size. Lastly, our experiments reveal that simulators with intrinsic feedback provide effective reward signals for multi-turn RL training, matching setups that rely on external judge LLMs for rewards while cutting RL compute by more than half.

0.13

Investigating Assistant Bias in LLM User Simulators Using a Role Vector

cs.CL cs.HC ·2026-09-01 ·Daeheon Jeong, Yoonjoo Lee, Eugene Choi, Sinie van der Ben, Juho Kim
top venue similarity 0.62
Abstract · 35 pages, EMNLP 2026 Findings

LLM-based user simulators are increasingly used to evaluate autonomous agents at scale, in place of costly human evaluations. Despite this promise, these simulators exhibit "assistant bias," a tendency to cooperate and pursue task goals. They rarely reproduce the frustration or disengagement that real users exhibit, compromising evaluation validity. Prior work outlines that this bias is baked in during model training, which role-playing prompts fail to override. We analyze this bias from model activations, extracting a user role vector by contrasting how the model represents user versus assistant perspectives on the same dialogue. We observe two findings: (i) the user direction is identifiable in activations, elicits user-like behaviors, and captures characteristics distinct from assistant traits; and (ii) although user-role activation associates with simulation realism and steering strengthens it, it can exaggerate user behaviors and override individual user profiles. Together, our findings provide a representation-level analysis of LLM user simulators, confirming that assistant bias is structurally identifiable and that user behavior can be directionally analyzed.

0.31

SURE-EVAL: A Systematic and Unified Agentic Framework for Reproducible Evaluation

eess.AS ·2026-09-30 ·Jing Peng, Junhao Du, Yixuan Wang, Bowen Wang, Hanqi Li +19 more
publishedcode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · This paper is accecpted to NCMMSC2026 as an oral presentation

Audio and speech models are released rapidly, but reported scores often conflate model capability with deployment and evaluation choices. The same checkpoint can produce different predictions under different runtimes, hardware, decoding settings, or fallback policies. Even fixed predictions can receive different scores under different normalization and metric implementations. Existing speech benchmarks standardize selected datasets or scoring procedures, but rarely connect heterogeneous model onboarding, controlled inference, and versioned scoring in one executable workflow. We introduce SURE-EVAL, a Systematic and Unified Agentic framework for Reproducible Evaluation of audio and speech systems. A Tool Agent Workflow converts model releases into isolated, verified callable tools. A Main Agent Workflow commits task-specific inference and scoring protocols, then delegates all score-bearing operations to versioned deterministic programs. Each result retains its runtime, protocol, pipeline nodes, predictions, and audit artifacts. Across 18 public releases covering automatic speech recognition, text-to-speech, voice conversion, speaker diarization, speaker-attributed recognition, and multi-task audio understanding, a Codex-only baseline completes 12 models in one shot, while the same agent with the SURE-EVAL Tool Agent Workflow completes all 18. We also conduct unified evaluations over seven ASR test conditions and two TTS subsets. A protocol analysis of three TTS systems finds absolute differences of 0.02-0.52 points between paper-reported and unified results, with the direction varying by model and language. These results show that reproducible evaluation requires controlling both model execution and output scoring.

0.30