CS Paper Radar

An Improved Lower Bound for Separating Words by Permutation Automata

Chen Xu, Kenneth Regan

cs.FL ·submitted 2026-10-08 02:12 UTC · v1
theoryhot direction

Abstract

We prove that some pairs of binary words of every sufficiently large prescribed length $n$ require $Ω(\log n\log\log n)$ states to separate by a deterministic finite automaton whose letters act as permutations. We obtain this bound by constructing distinct equal-length positive binary words that form an identity of $\mathfrak{S}_k$ of length $\exp(O(k/\log k))$. This improves the previous lower bound $(3/2-o(1))\log n$ of Bulatov, Karpova, Shur, and Startsev (arXiv:1609.03199). The proof combines a positive-word construction with a cover of permutation orders. Consecutive segments of prime powers reduce the covering problem to enumerating sets of positive integers with bounded sum. The required estimates use the central binomial coefficient and the classical asymptotic formula for partitions into distinct parts. An appendix gives sharper constants and lower-order terms using a greedy cover and a quantitative prime number theorem.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

An Elementary Proof of the $\widetilde O(n^{1/3})$ Bound for Separating Words

cs.FL cs.CCmath.CO ·2026-09-08 ·Chen Xu
theory similarity 0.71
Abstract

For two distinct binary words of length $n$, the separating words problem asks for a small deterministic finite automaton that accepts exactly one of them. Chase proved a $\widetilde O(n^{1/3})$ upper bound using a complex-analytic estimate for sparse polynomials. We replace that estimate by a finite-difference argument and a second-order real recurrence cutoff. The resulting elementary proof gives an explicit bound of $O(n^{1/3}(\log n)^{7/3})$ states.

0.09

Protected tails and polynomial-time enumeration of permutations avoiding a direct sum of an increasing pattern and 231

cs.DM math.COcs.DScs.LO ·2026-09-14 ·Henning Arnór Skeggi Úlfarsson
code/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · 36 pages, 4 figures, 1 table. v2: revised and shortened exposition, corrected account of prior work, the first 151 terms tabulated, a proved…

We give an algorithm counting the permutations that avoid a fixed pattern of the following form: the direct sum of an increasing pattern and 231. The first members of the family are 1342 and 12453. For each member the algorithm uses polynomially many operations and stored integers, with degrees that grow linearly in the length of the pattern. It comes from a recurrence that reads a permutation from left to right and records the constraints that the letters read so far impose on those still unread. This recurrence has exponentially many states, but part of each state is protected: later steps carry it along unchanged and do not depend on it, and factoring the protected part out leaves a dynamic program of polynomial size. For 12453 a translation symmetry sharpens the bounds to degree seven for the operations and degree four for the storage. We also compute the number of 12453-avoiding permutations of every length up to 150. The previously published series, due to Biers-Ariel (2019), reached length 38. We also give a sampler of uniformly random avoiders. A floating-point implementation of it, proved to be within total variation distance $3.5\cdot10^{-5}$ of uniform for ideal random bits, draws the one million 12453-avoiding permutations of length 300 shown in a heatmap. The literal and kernel recurrences for 1342 and 12453 are verified in the Lean 4 proof assistant.

0.32

Further Remarks on Separating Words

cs.FL ·2026-08-31 ·John Nicol
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract · 7 pages, 2 figures

We revisit questions on separating words raised by Demaine, Eisenstat, Shallit, and Wilson, together with Ebrahimnejad's follow-up to their reversal problem. For length-$n$ pairs whose difference word has $d$ runs, we prove an $O(d\log n)$ bound, extending the Hamming-distance theorem of Demaine et al. For conjugate words, we give bounds controlled by the arithmetic of the shift. We resolve Demaine et al.'s Open Problem 2 by showing that the order of two words can change nondeterministic separation by an unbounded factor. Our reversal construction addresses Ebrahimnejad's follow-up to Open Problem 1: forward and reversed deterministic separation can differ by an unbounded factor. Since nondeterministic separation is invariant under reversal, the same construction also improves the lower bound in Open Problem 3.

0.18

Separating Words with Automata in the Half-adversarial Case

cs.FL ·2026-08-28 ·Gabriel Bathie
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract

We consider the problem of separating words with deterministic finite automata (DFA) (Goral{č}{í}k and Koubek, 1986). This problem asks: given two distinct words $u,v$ of length at most $n$, what is the size of the smallest DFA that accepts one and rejects the other? The best upper bound on the worst-case over all pairs of words of length at most $n$ is $\tilde{O}(n^{1/3})$ states (Chase, 2021), while the best lower bound is $Ω(\log n)$. In this work, we consider the half-random, half-adversarial case: we show that if $u$ is a uniformly random binary word of length $n$, then with high probability, for any word $v$ not equal to $u$, there is a DFA with $O(\log^{7/3} n \mathrm{poly}\log\log n)$ states that separates $u$ and $v$. Our results are based on a novel analysis that exploits the structural sparsity of random words: we show how to apply block-wise compaction with small deterministic transducers to reduce the separation problem to the case of words with short run-length encodings.

0.21

Prime Accessible Deterministic Automata

cs.FL ·2026-10-09 ·Shen Zhao, Chenghe Xu
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 21 pages, 4 figures

We classify prime accessible deterministic automata over finite alphabets, both among finite automata and among automata with arbitrary state sets. Every one-state automaton is prime. Over a one-letter alphabet, a finite nontrivial automaton is prime exactly when it is a cycle of prime-power length or a finite chain ending in a fixed state. The unique infinite accessible unary automaton, up to isomorphism, is also prime. Every nontrivial automaton over an alphabet with at least two letters is not prime. Shen proved the finite case; we give a shorter proof. We also characterize a decomposition of the automaton whose states are all finite input words. The reachable product of the quotients by the least right congruences identifying the empty word with nonempty words $p$ and $q$, respectively, is isomorphic to this automaton exactly when $p^r\ne q^s$ for all positive integers $r,s$.

0.39

Enumeration Complexity of Permutation Classes

cs.CC math.CO ·2026-10-27 ·Manuel Bodirsky, Mohamed Elsheikh
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract

We study classes of permutations that are defined by avoidance of forbidden patterns. For each fixed finite set $B$ of forbidden patterns, we study the \emph{avoider enumeration problem}: given an integer $n$, output all $B$-avoiding permutations of length $n$. Avoider enumeration is output-polynomial for every fixed $B$. However, our main notion of efficiency is polynomial delay. We use the insert-maximum tree as a search tree, in which permutations are built by repeatedly inserting a new maximum while preserving pattern avoidance. This leads to the \emph{insert-maximum extension problem}, which asks if a given permutation has an avoiding descendant at a specified depth. An algorithm for this problem can prune branches that cannot reach the target length. Hence, if this problem is in P, we obtain polynomial-delay enumeration. To investigate this problem, we introduce and study \emph{pockets}, the maximal finite subtrees of the insert-maximum tree. For fixed $B$, if there is a polynomial $p$ such that every pocket rooted at $ρ$ has at most $p(|ρ|)$ nodes, then the extension problem is solvable in polynomial time and enumeration has polynomial delay. In particular, a bound on pocket depth depending only on $B$ suffices. We prove such a bound if the class is well-quasi-ordered, has a regular insertion encoding, or if $B$ omits one of the three maximum-position types: leftmost, interior, or rightmost. We also prove that extension is in NP for every fixed $B$, even with binary-encoded target depth. On the negative side, we construct a fixed set of $55$ forbidden patterns for which extension is NP-complete. Consequently, enumerating valid extensions from a given starting permutation cannot have polynomial delay unless P=NP. This also answers a question of Hanika by showing that the forbidden permutation constraint satisfaction problem can be NP-complete for a fixed forbidden set.

0.08

A Binary Search Tree with the Unified Bound

cs.DS ·2026-11-12 ·Yang Cao, Haoran Qi, Hanzhi Wang
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

We give a deterministic online binary search tree (BST) that satisfies the unified bound of Iacono [SODA 2001], which subsumes the working-set and dynamic-finger bounds: it serves every sequence $X$ of $m$ searches on $n$ keys at total cost $O(m+\mathrm{UB}(X))$, and every single search at cost $O(\log n)$. Previously, no BST was known to satisfy the unified bound, even offline. As a consequence, the dynamic optimality conjecture implies Iacono's conjecture that splay trees satisfy the unified bound. We also show that the unified bound is $O((m+n)(1+\log c_σ))$ on every sequence of searches that avoids a fixed permutation $σ$, where $c_σ$ is the Füredi-Hajnal limit of $σ$. Hence every BST that satisfies the unified bound, including ours, serves such sequences at this cost. For permutations this bound is tight, and it improves the previous upper bound $O(nc_σ^2)$ on the optimal cost, due to Berendsohn, Kozma and Opler [STOC 2024]. Finally, we extend the tree to support insertions and deletions: a sequence $X$ of $m$ operations, starting from $n_0$ keys, costs $O(n_0+m+\mathrm{UB}(X))$ in total, where $\mathrm{UB}$ is now the extension of the unified bound to insertions and deletions by Bădoiu, Cole, Demaine and Iacono [TCS 2007]. Hence, if splay trees are dynamically optimal for searches, insertions and deletions, then they serve every such sequence at this total cost as well.

0.25

Pumping Constants for Infinite Alphabets

cs.FL ·2026-10-05 ·Yoav Danieli
publishedtheoryhot direction similarity 0.61
Abstract · In Proceedings AFL 2026, arXiv:2608.23071

It is well known that the pumping lemma for regular languages over finite alphabets does not extend to infinite alphabets. Instead, the generalized version of the pumping lemma for infinite alphabets states that the pumped patterns need not be identical, but only equivalent up to a finite-order permutation of the alphabet. This generalized variant of the pumping lemma involves two parameters: the length of the pumped pattern and an upper bound on the order of the permutation. We improve the known permutation-order bounds from factorial to tight bounds governed by Landau's function. We also show that, if the pumping length is sufficiently large, then permutations of order at most two always suffice. Our main structural result concerns the one-register case: every one-register automaton satisfies the classical pumping lemma, with no alphabet permutation. We prove a quadratic upper bound on the pumping length and give a matching quadratic lower bound up to constant factors. The same classical pumping phenomenon is shown for hierarchical register automata. Finally, we prove that, in general, deciding whether a quasi-regular language is pumpable for given constants is undecidable, while the minimal classical pumping length is computable for non-guessing one-register automata.

0.68