CS Paper Radar

Formally Certifying the Vertex Set of a Polyhedron Faster than Informal Enumeration

Xavier Allamigeon, Yazid Id-Sahra, Pierre-Yves Strub

cs.LO math.COmath.OC ·submitted 2026-10-08 13:11 UTC · v1

Abstract

The computation of the vertices of a polyhedron described by a system of linear inequalities is a central problem in polyhedral computation. It is a fundamental step in the conversion between H-representations, by linear inequalities, and V-representations, by vertices and extreme rays. This operation plays an important role both in the study of polyhedra and their combinatorics in mathematics and in applications to software and system verification. We present a certificate-based approach for formally verifying the computation of the vertices of a polyhedron. Given an informally computed list of vertices, our method allows to certify in the proof assistant Rocq that the list is complete, or even exact. The cornerstone of the method is a new completeness criterion based on an abstract simplicial complex that generalizes a triangulation of the normal fan of the polyhedron. A significant advantage over previous approaches is that the usually expensive numerical computations are essentially reduced to membership tests to the polyhedron, while the other steps are cheap combinatorial tests. We implement the certification method and prove its correctness in the proof assistant Rocq. We experiment with it on a variety of polyhedra, including Birkhoff polytopes, cross-polytopes, cubes, permutahedra, hypersimplices, and high-dimensional polytopes involved in the disproof of the Hirsch conjecture. Our experiments show that certification with the Rocq-to-OCaml extracted checker is typically 1.5x to over 5x faster than vertex enumeration by the state-of-the-art informal C implementation lrslib of the reverse search method.

Comment
20 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Approximate counting of vertices of 0/1 polytopes: a stronger hardness result

cs.CC math.CO ·2026-08-23 ·Heng Guo, Mark Jerrum
similarity 0.64
Abstract

We show that approximately counting the vertices of a bounded 0/1 polytope, presented as a system of rational linear inequalities, is, informally speaking, NP-hard. In particular, there is no FPRAS for this problem unless RP=NP. The proof is by a reduction from approximately counting homomorphisms from a given graph to a particular four-vertex graph. The main proof ideas were found using GPT-5.6 Sol Ultra.

0.45

0/1 integer programming over polytopes of Chvátal rank one is as hard as lattice problems

cs.CC math.OCcs.DM ·2026-10-07 ·Alberto Del Pia
similarity 0.63
Abstract

A rational polyhedron has Chvátal rank at most one if a single round of Chvátal-Gomory cuts yields its integer hull. In 1973, Chvátal asked whether 0/1 integer programs over polytopes of bounded Chvátal rank can be solved in polynomial time. For polyhedra of bounded Chvátal rank, integer feasibility is in NP $\cap$ coNP, so it is unlikely to be NP-hard. We answer Chvátal's question negatively already in its most restricted form: for Chvátal rank one, for integer feasibility, and even for the SAT polytopes of formulas whose clauses have at most three literals. Our answer holds under either of two standard assumptions from lattice-based cryptography. First, a polynomial-time algorithm for integer feasibility on such SAT polytopes of Chvátal rank one would solve bounded distance decoding with polynomial factors in deterministic polynomial time, contradicting the conjectured hardness of approximating lattice problems within polynomial factors. Second, assuming the hardness of learning with errors, an average-case analog of bounded distance decoding, the problem is also hard on average, for a polynomial-time samplable distribution of formulas. This also gives negative answers to related questions of Cornuéjols, Lee, and Li. We first prove these results for parallelepipeds, where they rest on an elementary sufficient condition: a polyhedron has Chvátal rank at most one if its width is less than one along every row of some unimodular matrix. For our parallelepipeds, such a matrix exists but is hard to find. For SAT polytopes, we represent candidate lattice vectors by their residues modulo small integers, and binary arithmetic on additional 0/1 variables checks that these vectors lie in the lattice.

0.27

Geometric Graph Representations via Compact SAT Encodings

cs.CG cs.DMcs.DScs.LO+1 ·2026-10-15 ·L. Sunil Chandran, Rishikesh Gajjala, Suraj Kumar Sahoo, Aatman Supkar
publishedtheory similarity 0.62
Abstract · To appear in ALENEX 2027

We present compact SAT encodings and certifying exact solvers for boxicity and cubicity. The boxicity of a graph is the minimum dimension in which it is the intersection graph of axis-aligned boxes; cubicity is defined analogously using unit cubes. Grid-based formulations face a geometric discretization bottleneck, growing rapidly with the target dimension. We avoid this bottleneck by encoding the total order of interval endpoints in each coordinate. For an $n$-vertex graph and target dimension $d$, our boxicity encoding uses $O(n^2d)$ variables and $O(n^3d)$ clauses, both linear in $d$. Requiring the left- and right-endpoint orders to agree yields a cubicity encoding of the same asymptotic size. Satisfying models are decoded into independently checked geometric representations, while unsatisfiable instances used as lower-bound evidence carry mechanically verified DRAT certificates. In a controlled evaluation with 186 trials per encoding on standard and structured graph families, the order encoding solves 96.8% of trials, compared with 71.0% for the known grid formulation, and reduces mean PAR-2 time from 178.21 to 21.70 seconds. The pipeline also certifies exact values for several named graphs. We turn one such value into a reusable obstruction by proving that every Kneser graph $K(n,k)$ with $k\ge3$ and $n\ge2k+1$ contains an induced Desargues graph. The resulting lower bound, together with an explicit three-dimensional representation of $K(7,3)$, establishes $\operatorname{boxicity}(K(7,3))=3$. This disproves the conjecture of Caoduro and Sebo that $\operatorname{boxicity}(K(n,k))=n-k$ for all $k\ge3$ and $n\ge2k+1$.

0.59

Separating comb inequalities is NP-hard

cs.CC ·2026-10-06 ·Yohan Finet, Victor Drouin-Touchette
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Comb inequalities are important cutting planes for the symmetric travelling salesman problem, yet the complexity of their exact separation has remained a longstanding question in polyhedral combinatorics. We present a reduction from 3-SAT proving that deciding whether a comb inequality is violated is NP-complete and that the corresponding separation problem is NP-hard. This result holds even when the input vector belongs to the subtour elimination polytope, every edge value is zero, one half or one and the support graph is nonplanar with maximum degree four. The reduction constructs a graph in which six-vertex ladder gadgets encode Boolean relations and cubic graphs enforce consistency among occurrences of each logical variable. For a propositional logic formula with $v$ variables and $m$ clauses, the constructed graph has $40v+70m+30$ vertices and a linear number of positive edges. The reduction also proves hardness when every permitted tooth has two or four vertices with half of the tooth in the handle. We discuss consequences for approximating the maximum comb violation, optimization over the comb relaxation and explain why hardness of separation does not automatically transfer to larger inequality families.

0.35

The canonical facets of multi-separator polytopes

cs.DM cs.LGmath.CO ·2026-08-17 ·Bjoern Andres, Silvia Di Gregorio, Jannik Irmai, Lucas Fabian Naumann, Shengxian Zhao
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 49 pages, 19 figures

We initiate a polyhedral study of the graph multi-separator problem proposed by Irmai et al. (2024) as an alternative to the lifted multicut problem for application to the task of image segmentation. Starting with an integer linear program (ILP) formulation and the multi-separator polytope spanned by its feasible solutions, we characterize in terms of efficiently-decidable, graph-theoretic conditions all facets induced by inequalities of the ILP. We proceed by strengthening these inequalities and describing additional facets of some multi-separator polytopes induced by the stronger inequalities. Specifically, we obtain a totally dual integral description of the multi-separator polytope for paths in the case where separation is considered for all vertex pairs. Finally, we relate the multi-separator polytope to the boolean quadric polytope, showing that facets induced by odd-cycle inequalities do not transfer generally, and to the lifted multicut polytope, showing that either polytope is a projection of a face of the other.

0.36

Approximate Polynomial Satisfiability and Integral Closure Membership in the Counting Hierarchy

cs.CC ·2026-10-30 ·Sanyam Agarwal, Archit Hari, Anurag Pandey, Himanshu Shukla
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract · Made some minor changes

Andrews, Garg, and Schost (FOCS~2026) recently, in a breakthrough result, placed Hilbert's Nullstellensatz (HN) in the Counting Hierarchy ($\CH$) using constant-depth circuits for multivariate resultants. While HN deals with exact polynomial satisfiability, Guo, Saxena, and Sinhababu (CCC~2018; Theory of Computing~2019) introduced approximate polynomial satisfiability (APS) as a natural approximative analogue of polynomial system satisfiability. They proved its $\mathsf{NP}$-hardness and a $\PSPACE$ upper bound, and used APS to construct hitting sets for $\overline{\mathsf{VP}}$ in polynomial space, substantially narrowing the GCT chasm in geometric complexity theory. We place APS in the Counting Hierarchy for rational polynomials given by arithmetic circuits. Our proof combines Noether normalization with a geometric restriction on how points in the image of a polynomial map approach the origin, reducing APS to a test on multivariate resultants which allows solvability in $\CH$. It complements the independent and concurrent proofs of Balaji, Shirmohammadi, Tavenas, and Worrell, and Andrews, Garg, Oliveira, and Schost. Moreover, we also place integral closure membership testing in the Counting Hierarchy. Here, the question is whether a given polynomial $f$ is integral over $\C[f_1,\ldots,f_m]$. Our approach uses a global annihilator criterion and an effective degree bound to reduce non-integrality to APS in polynomial time. In fact, we show that the reduction holds both ways, and Integral Closure Membership Testing is equivalent to APS under polynomial-time reductions.

0.17

A New Upper Bound for the Turán Density of the Tetrahedron

cs.DM math.COmath.OC ·2026-09-23 ·Gyeongwon Jeong, Seonghun Park, Seonghyuk Im, Joonkyung Lee, Hongseok Yang
theorycode/data similarity 0.60
Abstract · 28 pages, 5 figures, 8 tables. v2: Slightly improved upper bound and updated exact certificate following continuation of the search to conve…

We prove that the Turán density of the tetrahedron $K_4^{(3)}$ satisfies $π(K_4^{(3)}) \le 14993367693127837/26880000000000000 < 0.557789$, improving Baber's upper bound of $0.5615$ and closing about $62\%$ of the gap to the conjectured value $5/9$. The proof uses an exact seven-vertex flag-algebra certificate incorporating degree-stationarity from Razborov's differential method. To find the certificate, we combine the established techniques of cutting planes and column generation to optimize jointly over flag families whose types have at most five vertices. We give a complete formal proof of this Turán density bound in Lean 4.

0.63

Counting Square Tilings with a Fixed Set of Polyominoes Is #EXP-Complete

cs.CC ·2026-10-30 ·Qiuyu Chen, Baao Xie
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract

An important question in counting complexity is whether exact counting can remain hard under restrictions that make feasibility easy. Tilings of squares by a fixed family of polyominoes provide a stringent test of this question, since tileability is polynomial-time decidable and the only varying input is a binary-encoded side length. We prove that there exists a fixed finite family of connected polyominoes for which counting translation-only square tilings is #EXP-complete under polynomial-time metric reductions, while the counting function belongs to #E. The resulting separation reveals that solution multiplicities can retain computational information that feasibility alone cannot capture. The proof develops a two-stage numerical isolation technique that combines a boundary-amplified Wang system with a rigid geometric compiler to recover accepting-computation counts while controlling all noncanonical tilings.

0.22