CS Paper Radar

When AI Advisors Agree: Distinguishing Forecast Risk from Forecast Reliability

Russlan Ramdowar

cs.MA ·submitted 2026-10-09 11:34 UTC · v2
code/data

Abstract

If seven AI advisors agree, what have we learned: that their forecast is reliable, or that the asset is easier to forecast? We examine 928 completed first-quarter outcomes for 232 assets across four historical iPulse AI batches. Ten Gemini configurations form seven equally weighted investment frameworks; no forecasts are regenerated. The council has mean absolute return error of 15.15 percentage points (pp), versus 14.99 for no change, with an unresolved paired difference of +0.16 pp. Error rises from 10.31 to 21.05 pp across disagreement quartiles, but the no-change baseline rises almost identically, from 9.89 to 21.15. In the pooled archive, selecting the lowest-volatility quarter produces lower error than selecting the least-disagreeing quarter: 7.97 versus 10.31 pp. Directional agreement introduces a second trap: its apparent value depends on the aggregation rule. When at least six of seven frameworks share a direction, the sign of their mean return is correct in 53.21% of cases, versus 44.11% with lower agreement. Scoring the modal direction instead changes the lower-agreement accuracy to 54.27%, removing that positive contrast. Recomputed-rank bootstraps, scale-aware losses, and period sensitivities qualify these descriptive results; four overlapping periods cannot establish future-regime performance. Agreement, visible asset risk, and aggregation-specific skill should be evaluated separately before consensus is presented as confidence.

Comment
Version 2: 24 pages, 11 figures, 12 tables. Expanded aggregation, dependence and reproducibility diagnostics; unchanged outcome cutoff and cohort. Artifacts: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23373782. Code: https://github.com/TheFutureEdge/research-when-ai-advisors-agree

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Forecast Accuracy Is Not Trading Profit: Evolving Small Recurrent Networks for Stock Return Prediction

cs.NE cs.CEcs.LG ·2026-10-06 ·Jonathan Chang, Zimeng Lyu
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Time series forecasting models are typically compared on pointwise error, which scores a prediction in isolation from the decision it is produced for, and a lower forecast error does not imply a better decision downstream. A parallel debate asks whether modern transformer architectures forecast better than recurrent and other lightweight models. We compare linear, fixed recurrent, transformer, and mixing based architectures against recurrent networks evolved by neuroevolutionary architecture search, evaluating each on forecast accuracy and on the net return of a daily long/short strategy. All models are fit on a pooled panel, one network trained across the whole universe. Across four mid-cap portfolios and three trading years, the evolved networks rank first on both forecast accuracy and net trading performance, while the second most accurate model loses money once positions are formed and costs are charged. The advantage tracks a horizon match, since rank IC for the evolved networks rises from a one-day to a ten-day scoring horizon while every model above 300 parameters declines. They are also the cheapest end to end: a CPU-only search of 16 minutes yields 66-weight networks that predict in 10.8~$μ$s on a Raspberry Pi Zero, against transformer baselines of up to 817,153 parameters that require GPU training.

0.26

Investor's Last Exam: Can AI Agents Do Equity Investment Without Seeing the Future?

cs.AI ·2026-10-28 ·Huangfei Jiang, Anning Hu, Kai Sheng, Yuchen Cai, Rui Ge +5 more
benchmark similarity 0.61
Abstract

Financial agents must form forecasts and investment judgments from decision-time evidence, with predictions evaluated against subsequent outcomes. Existing benchmarks assess financial knowledge, research workflows, or forecasting, but evaluating the full research process requires a strictly frozen information set and professional evaluation criteria. We introduce Investor's Last Exam (ILE), an equity-research benchmark led by experienced buy-side investors and fund managers. Its three components are a versioned financial database spanning 3.43 million document versions and nine source categories, supplemented by structured market data, with validated timestamps governing retrieval and computation; a task taxonomy organized around professional analyst deliverables; and an expert-led framework linking scoring criteria to sources, calculations, and assumptions through financial dependency graphs. Evaluation spans 86 assignments and jointly assesses research quality, forecast accuracy, and simulated investment performance. GPT-6 Astra and Claude Opus 5.5 lead overall at 68.1 and 66.9 out of 100, yet even Astra scores only 52.5 on Forecast & Model. Our results show that even state-of-the-art models fail to translate overall research capability into predictive performance. ILE shifts the evaluation unit from isolated capabilities to the evidence--assumption--judgment chain, allowing researchers to locate where analytical advantages fail to translate into forecasts and investment judgments, and providing a traceable, diagnostic foundation for training and evaluating financial agents.

0.32

Downside-Controlled Online Forecast Combination under Delayed and Revised Outcomes

cs.LG ·2026-09-24 ·Minkyoung Kim, Hyunjung Byun, Yohan Lee, Beakcheol Jang
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 8 figures, 8 tables; supplementary material (1 figure, 23 tables) appended

Post-hoc correction adjusts a forecaster that cannot be retrained, such as a foundation model, but a correction fitted where errors are stable can hurt where they shift. We aim for downside control: not much worse than the starting forecast. We combine the frozen forecaster, a static corrector and an online corrector on the simplex, using only losses that mature after the horizon. Across seven benchmarks and four base models, two of them foundation models, the worst deterioration over 28 pairs at the main horizon is 0.15% and gains reach 11.5%. On day-ahead load for seven European bidding zones it lowers mean MSE in all seven zones, while single correctors raise mean MSE by up to 102% where the published forecast is most accurate. Three empirical conditions on expert speed, stream length and outcome alignment, each fixed by a documented failure, delimit its scope. Learning from the provisional outcome improves four zones on the settled one; learning on the settled outcome restores all seven.

0.27

Evaluation Choices Decide the Forecasting Leaderboard: Evidence from a Production Marketplace Panel

cs.LG stat.APstat.ME ·2026-08-20 ·Md Rezwanul Islam, Wael Mohammed
benchmark similarity 0.59
Abstract · 18 pages, 8 tables, 1 figure. Evaluation protocol and audit scripts included as ancillary files

A forecasting benchmark reports which method won. We show that the answer is set by the evaluator's choices before any model is fitted. We benchmark 24 forecasting methods and one textbook reference, including six 2025-era time series foundation models, on a production marketplace panel of 1,887 business customers over 67 months. We hold the data, the horizon and the period fixed, and vary only the evaluation design. Three choices each reverse or dissolve a headline conclusion. Changing the unit of analysis from the market total to the individual customer moves our production baseline from second of nineteen, beaten by nothing, to twenty-third of twenty-five. Nineteen of its twenty-four challengers beat it there. Changing how much error is pooled decides whether a Diebold-Mariano test finds anything at all. Scoring prediction intervals rather than point forecasts reorders the field almost completely, with a rank correlation of 0.02 on intermittent demand. We then measure what the deployed system gets from this. Its selection rule captures 55% of the distance between doing nothing and choosing with hindsight. The reversal is not a quirk of our data. We ran the released protocol, unchanged, on the public M5 retail panel. The same baseline shape places first at the market total and last per series, beaten by everything, and a replayed selection rule closes 64.7% of the same floor-to-ceiling distance there. Adding five zero-shot foundation models to that roster changes who wins at the total, not the shape. The bands' blind spot travels too: conformal bands under-cover most on the spikiest items. Splitting our own panel into ever smaller groups turns the contrast into a curve: the baseline's rank worsens at every level of disaggregation. We release the evaluation protocol and report an error of our own that inverted a result before we caught it.

0.26

Target alignment, dilution and forecast selection when cross-sectional forecasts share a common target

cs.LG econ.EMq-fin.STstat.ME ·2026-09-22 ·Masoud Soleimani
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 35 pages, 5 figures, 13 tables

Forecasters often score the same units per date against one standardized realized outcome. We show that every standardized forecast splits exactly into a component aligned with this common target and a component uncorrelated with it. Three consequences follow: forecast-error correlation largely mirrors forecast correlation and is therefore a poor measure of diversity; an equally weighted combination beats a no-information forecast only when average alignment is large relative to the combination's dispersion; and the gain from adding a forecaster separates into genuine improvement and mere dilution, which equal-weight admission can mistakenly reward. We develop a cautious selection rule, study it in simulations, and apply it to language-model forecasts of US equity rankings and mechanical signals ranking exchange-traded funds. Selection removes most dilution losses, but no combination beats the no-information forecast.

0.34

FinForesight: A Diagnostic Backtesting Benchmark for Deep Research Systems in Financial Forecasting

cs.CL cs.LG ·2026-11-01 ·Fengyuan Liu, Mukai Li, Jieshun You, Yilin Zheng, Chenjia Min +3 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.58
Abstract

Anticipating financial outcomes requires synthesizing evolving evidence and reasoning under uncertainty, making deep research systems promising tools for forecasting. Yet evaluating forecasting ability is challenging because historical backtests may reward memorized outcomes or information retrieved after the forecast date. Live forecasting avoids direct access to realized outcomes, but feedback arrives only after events resolve. To obtain timely feedback and assess historical scores, we introduce FinForesight, a diagnostic backtesting benchmark for financial deep research systems. Across the Chinese, U.S., and Hong Kong markets, the benchmark evaluates four forecasting tasks: valuation, return ranking, event direction, and future financial fundamentals. Two capability diagnostic tasks assess counterfactual reasoning and financial calculation, scored separately from forecasting performance. Our harness-compatible framework restricts retrieved evidence to information available at the forecast date. We compare pretraining-era, resolved post-cutoff, and live evaluations to test whether controlled backtests approximate future performance. Pretraining-era scores exceed post-cutoff scores in most temporal comparisons, and stronger retrieval controls narrow the gap between post-cutoff backtests and live results. Forecasting attribution and robustness analyses reveal how scores respond to retrieval policy and how predictions respond to prompt rewrites and numerical perturbations. The code and benchmark data are publicly available.

0.30

RehearsalBench: Can AI Predict What Happens When You Change a Company?

cs.AI ·2026-11-17 ·Mika Siddiqui, Tharaka Perera
benchmarktheory similarity 0.58
Abstract

Organizations increasingly ask AI systems what will happen if they change how they operate: which work to automate, which team to resize, what a voice agent will do to waiting times. We introduce RehearsalBench, a benchmark that measures whether AI models can diagnose an operation, choose an intervention, and forecast its consequences. Each model is placed in a simulated bank contact center fitted to real call-level records, sees only what a manager would see, and submits a plan and forecasts that are then played out across 200 seeded futures and three plausible versions of the organization. Decisions are scored in dollars at the stakeholders' stated valuations; forecasts are scored on the effect of each change relative to doing nothing. Ten models made 280 attempts across 14 organizations. The best model, GPT-6 Astra, improved on doing nothing by 6.8% of the no-change cost and made 77% less forecast error than a forecaster who always predicts no effect. On average, every model forecast the direction of every specified effect correctly, but models erred on the size of the same effects in the same direction, overstating a voice agent's effect on repeat contacts about five-fold. No model ever recommended holding off when doing nothing was the right choice. To test external validity, twelve models forecast 33 real organizational changes with known outcomes. Under verdict rules fixed in advance, the benchmark's forecast ranking agreed with the real-world ranking (Spearman $ρ= 0.92$, 95% lower bound 0.50). We report the result alongside an inconclusive first test, the analysis choices made after outcomes were seen, and evidence that part of the agreement reflects how well models size their uncertainty.

0.26

Governed Human-AI Prioritization Under Uncertainty: Adaptive Estimation and Dependency-Constrained Portfolio Selection

cs.SE ·2026-09-09 ·Azzeddine Ihsine, Sara Ihsine
similarity 0.58
Abstract · 18 pages, 7 figures. Substantially revised version following public PREreview feedback, with 30-seed robustness analysis, correlated estimat…

AI-native software engineering increasingly combines human judgment, historical analogy, parametric estimation, and AI-generated forecasts in the same prioritization decision. We study five quantitative operators used in the D-POAF decision practice and stress-test them under uncertainty, estimator dependence, drift, shared context error, dependencies, and limited capacity. Robustness extensions use 30 deterministic seeds. Moderate scoring changes preserve broad order while materially changing funded-set membership. Under independent estimator errors, inverse-MSE aggregation reaches MAE 0.615, a 42.2% reduction relative to the best individual estimator. The gain falls to 4.4% at error correlation rho = 0.6 and becomes negative at rho = 0.8, while calibration-set regression remains slightly better than the best individual and approaches a test-set oracle. Under estimator drift, four-Wave adaptive weighting reduces average RMSE by 4.64% (95% CI [4.50%, 4.78%]). Model-collective divergence achieves ROC-AUC 0.908 with independent channels and remains above 0.878 with shared noise up to 0.8. We separate budget-constrained portfolio selection from ODP's native dependency-aware sequencing role. When ODP distance is repurposed as a portfolio-selection heuristic, value-to-effort is stronger in the tested generator. For a fixed selected set, ascending ERS/BVS is optimal for an ERS-weighted completion objective without dependencies and reaches mean efficiency 0.982 versus the exact precedence-constrained optimum at dependency intensity lambda = 1.0. Scaling to 100 Feature Blocks, ODP has the highest mean early-value AUC among the transparent sequencing baselines, with a small margin over PVS ordering. These results characterize both the validity region of evidence-weighted human-AI prioritization and the boundary between selection and sequencing objectives.

0.52