CS Paper Radar

Benchmarking Content-Defined Chunking Algorithms for Data Deduplication

Marcel Gregoriadis, Leonhard Balduf, Björn Scheuermann, Johan Pouwelse

cs.DB cs.DC ·submitted 2026-10-09 14:59 UTC · v1
top venuecode/data

Abstract

Data deduplication relies on content-defined chunking (CDC) algorithms to decide where data is split. We observe that most CDC algorithms are modular: a base chunking algorithm fixes the byte-level cut-point condition, while high-level techniques (size normalization, min/max thresholds, caching) layer on top. Existing benchmarks conflate the two, obscuring which design choices actually drive performance. We isolate and evaluate eight state-of-the-art base chunking algorithms across four realistic workloads and four metrics: throughput, deduplication ratio, mean chunk size, and chunk-size variance. Further, we derive new formulas relating algorithm parameters to expected chunk size for AE, RAM, and MII. In doing so, we uncover a longstanding error in the widely-used AE parameterization reproduced across multiple papers and evaluation tools that produces chunks 13-39% smaller than intended and inflates AE's reported deduplication. Across our evaluation, AE is the most balanced base chunking algorithm across all four metrics, RAM's similarity to AE does not carry over to low-entropy data, and MII and PCI show limited advantages over simpler alternatives in storage-oriented workloads. We release all implementations, datasets, and analysis scripts as open source.

Comment
Accepted at ICDE 2027

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Asymptotic Analysis of Data Deduplication Under a Constant Edit Model

cs.IT ·2026-11-06 ·Sarvin Motamen, Hao Lou, Farzad Farnoud
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Data deduplication has become increasingly important in large-scale storage systems, driven by the rapid growth of digital data. By identifying and removing repeats in the data stream, deduplication saves storage space more efficiently than traditional compression methods. In this paper, we study the performance of variable-length deduplication and multi-chunk deduplication algorithms from an information-theoretic perspective, focusing on data streams where repeats are approximate rather than exact. We consider two probabilistic source models in which source strings consist of repeated blocks that are modified by either a constant number of substitution edits or burst-insertion edits per block, the latter capturing the localized edit patterns commonly observed in real-world data. For both models, we show that variable-length deduplication achieves asymptotically arbitrarily large compression ratios, and that multi-chunk deduplication achieves compression within a constant factor of the source entropy under mild conditions.

0.16

The Price of Random Access: Measuring Block Granularity Across Four Compressed Formats

cs.DC cs.DS ·2026-09-15 ·Yakiv Shavidze
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 7 pages, 5 figures, 6 tables. Sixth paper in the ACEAPEX series (see arXiv:2606.04268, 2606.18900, 2606.24531, 2607.18541, 2608.10188). Code…

Random access into compressed data is normally bought with density. We measure the exchange rate. Across four formats and nine axes on a common corpus, the cost of cutting a 254 MB archive into independently addressable 16 KiB units is 1.632% of the archive for an absolute-offset format against 6.57% for seekable zstd, and the gap widens as the unit shrinks: at 4 KiB, 5.33% against 10.06%. Because the cost is small, several properties follow that are usually unavailable: splitting an archive is free and occasionally profitable (-0.28% on tiled input), append needs no format change, seek latency does not depend on position, and one archive is read by both a CPU and a GPU decoder. We give three structural results with proofs and bit-perfect verification - that the repeat-distance chain of an LZ77 parse forms a substitution monoid and is therefore prefix-scannable without touching the bitstream, that self-overlapping matches are periodic rather than chained, and that dependency depth admits an encoder-enforced bound - and we report each measured limit together with the mechanism that sets it. Seventeen rejected directions are listed with their numbers, including one that improved density by 26% and was declined. Every claim carries a level: reproducible by command, measured with a stated reason, or estimated. The measurement tool is released separately (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.22713364) with 435 provenanced records.

0.50

Chunk Recomputation under Real Document Revisions: Measuring Update Cost and Retrieval Quality of Fixed, Recursive, and Content-Defined Chunking

cs.CL cs.IR ·2026-10-22 ·Yuning Bian, Lele Xu, Yifan Yuan, Xinyu Yin, Chengyan Zhan
published similarity 0.64
Abstract · 6 pages, 3 figures, 3 tables. Accepted at AIBDCC 2026

Chunking strategies for retrieval-augmented generation are almost always evaluated on a static snapshot, yet the documents underlying a knowledge base continue to change. Because chunks are embedded independently, a boundary that moves after an edit forces unchanged text to be re-embedded. We measure this update cost on 120 pairs of adjacent Chinese and English Wikipedia revisions for three stateless chunkers (non-overlapping fixed-size, recursive paragraph-first, and content-defined chunking) under a strict byte-identical reuse rule and a frozen dense encoder. On the 116-article common-success pool, with frozen, length-calibrated parameters, fixed-size chunking recomputes 57-68% of its full new-version embedding-input workload, recursive chunking 38-56%, and content-defined chunking 43-54% (it failed on 4 of 62 Chinese articles), while at these parameters mean evidence recall under a fixed 2048-token retrieval budget differs by less than two percentage points within either language. A cost-only parameter grid shows that the ranking of the two content-aware chunkers changes with chunk-length settings, whereas non-overlapping fixed-size chunking has the highest recomputation cost in every length-matched condition. Controlled edits and a verbatim-presence diagnostic support boundary drift as one contributor to recomputation of text already present in the previous version. Update cost is therefore a substantial, parameter-sensitive dimension that static retrieval evaluations do not expose and that should be reported alongside retrieval quality.

0.22

Similarity-Aware Client-Side Reordering for Server-Side Storage Compression in Distributed File Systems

cs.DC ·2026-11-17 ·Yuanhong Huang, Zicong Chen, Yili Ma, Jinwu Yang, Yulong Chen +2 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract

As growing data volumes strain the capacity of distributed file systems, server-side storage compression transparently reduces disk usage, but its effectiveness is limited when similar blocks land in separate compression records and cannot share matches. We present a client-side reordering framework that transforms the physical block layout before persistence, so that related blocks are co-located within the same compression scope without replacing the existing storage-server compressor. It operates on bounded reordering windows, periodically selects among candidate layouts via lightweight compression of sampled data, and recovers the original logical order during reads with compact window-local metadata. We implement the framework in the SkyFS distributed file system, using the Zstandard (Zstd) compressor on the OpenZFS storage backend. Results on diverse datasets show that the framework reduces physical storage by up to 42.9% relative to logical-order writes, while achieving 94-108% of baseline sequential-read throughput and 91-99% of random-read IOPS. Client-side layout construction is the primary additional write cost, showing that adaptive similarity-aware reordering substantially improves storage efficiency with acceptable overhead.

0.20

Creating SquashFS Images to Support HPC and AI Datasets

cs.IR ·2026-10-14 ·Julie Mullen, Albert Reuther, LaToya Anderson, Michael Jones, William Arcand +16 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 8 pages, 5 figures, IEEE High Performance Extreme Computing (HPEC) Conference 2026

HPC users often download datasets on HPC systems for analysis and processing. When these datasets are comprised of hundreds of thousands (or more) of small files, accessing them in parallel can put a tremendous burden on the metadata servers of central parallel file systems. If the dataset is read-only, an effective solution is to compress the dataset into a SquashFS image. There are, however, a number of workflows that can be used to create such a dataset image, and we observed that some were more efficient than others. To provide more effective guidance for our userbase, we benchmarked eleven different workflows for creating SquashFS dataset image files of datasets with thousands to millions of very small files. We took into account whether the data arrived as tar.gz, zip, or files-and-directories downloads, whether the image creation was on the central file system or local compute node storage, and the number of SquashFS file compression threads used. This paper shares the results of these benchmarks and provides recommendations to HPC system users toward the best workflows to use for SquashFS image creation.

0.25

Revisiting Index Performance under High Cache-Miss Penalties

cs.DB ·2026-11-16 ·Mathew M. Kim, Beomseok Nam
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Modern data-intensive applications often query very large datasets, making index performance critical. Recent index structures exploit the fine-grained access capabilities of emerging storage devices such as DCPMM and CXL. However, existing benchmarks typically evaluate indexes in isolation using saturated, closed-loop workloads that emphasize maximum throughput. Such workloads favor highly concurrent designs while overlooking the application work that follows an index lookup and competes for cache, memory bandwidth, and CPU resources. We present AuxBench - a microbenchmark that evaluates indexes as auxiliary access paths within larger application workloads. Using AuxBench, we evaluate four byte-addressable indexes under controlled post-lookup memory activity, concurrency, and request arrival patterns. Our experiments show that post-lookup memory activity can change the relative performance of competing indexes, that concurrency-oriented designs may lose their advantages when substantial application work is introduced, and that time-varying request arrivals can produce severe tail latency near saturation. These findings demonstrate why index-only benchmarks may not adequately predict performance in larger application workloads

0.20

FFSlim: An Efficient and Lightweight Format for Multi-modal Data Storage and Retrieval

cs.PF ·2026-08-28 ·Long Yang, Yu Mao, Yuchen Shao, Yumiao Zhao, Yaqi Li +7 more
similarity 0.60
Abstract

With the rapid expansion of large-scale media-text corpora, multi-modal datasets increasingly require efficient storage and retrieval. Existing formats such as Files, TDP, and FFRecord work adequately for uni-modal data but expose fundamental limitations in multi-modal settings, including storage redundancy, massive small-file overheads, cache-unfriendly layouts, and heavy index structures. These issues jointly inflate storage and memory usage and make I/O the dominant bottleneck in real training workloads. We present FFSlim, a lightweight format for storing and retrieving multi-modal data. FFSlim improves storage efficiency and loading throughput through three components: a unified file format that removes media duplication and avoids small-file proliferation; an adaptive retrieval mechanism that enables low-overhead pair-level access and accelerates repeated media loading; and a redundancy detection and aggregation module that converts existing datasets into the FFSlim layout. The experimental results demonstrate that FFSlim achieves 2.07x and 8.26x higher data loading and write throughput on average than the strongest baseline, with minimal storage and index overhead. Consequently, these underlying I/O accelerations enable FFSlim to reduce end-to-end training time by 5.36%-14.18% across seven diverse multi-modal models.

0.29

Direct-Operable SIMD Bit-Slicing: A Framework for Memory-Efficient Predicate Evaluation

cs.PF ·2026-08-26 ·Arunkumar Mathiyazhagan
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 25 pages, 8 figures, 12 tables

Traditional Java object models introduce significant memory overhead due to object headers and internal padding, often leading to performance bottlenecks in data-intensive distributed systems. This paper presents a novel framework that utilizes the Project Panama Vector API to perform predicate evaluation directly over bit-sliced, compressed data streams. By transposing standard row-oriented data into parallel bit-planes, we demonstrate a mechanism to evaluate complex filters using SIMD (Single Instruction, Multiple Data) instructions without requiring prior decompression. The framework supports integers, longs (timestamps), doubles (via IEEE 754 order-preserving transformation), and strings (via dictionary encoding). Our benchmarks indicate a reduction in memory footprint by up to 8x while maintaining or exceeding the throughput of uncompressed standard Java collections. End-to-end evaluation on TPCDS-modeled data at 50M rows demonstrates 2.4-10.8x speedup over scalar scans across five representative filter-heavy query patterns, with extended type benchmarks on TPCDS columns showing 1.5-43x speedups for timestamps, decimals, and dictionary-encoded strings.

0.31