CS Paper Radar

Declared but Unaccountable: Measuring the Seller-Identity Gap in Advertising Supply-Chain Transparency

Tommaso Grotto, Alessandro Cantelli-Forti, Alessio Merlo

cs.CY cs.CRcs.NI ·submitted 2026-10-10 07:19 UTC · v2

Abstract

Public advertising transparency relies on a minimum accountability condition: an account authorized by a publisher in ads$.$txt or app-ads$.$txt should appear in the applicable sellers$.$json registry. When an available registry omits the declared seller ID, the authorization remains visible and machine-readable, but its public verification path breaks. We call this failure the seller-identity gap. We measure the gap using 233.4 million normalized advertising-transparency records and an absent-only, coverage-aware evidence rule. A declaration enters the numerator only when the applicable registry is available and omits its seller ID; unavailable, malformed, confidential, and other non-evaluable states remain separate. The resulting row-level floor is 24.25% in a high-popularity, low-removal reference population and 30.71% among publishers associated with at least 100 copyright-removal requests, a 6.45 percentage-point increase. The gap then remains near one third at stricter cumulative thresholds. Standardizing the populations to common weights over 1,469 shared ad systems reduces the primary contrast to 4.65 points: about 72% remains within systems, while 28% forms a composition-associated residual. We connect these population estimates to recurring seller-account coordinates, byte-identical declaration configurations, and provenance-bearing case packets. We frame this declaration-centered investigative use of public advertising records as Ad Transparency Intelligence: it reconstructs declared supply-chain relationships, identifies where public verification stops, and prioritizes evidence for corroboration without equating correlation with attribution. Advertising transparency supports accountability and investigation only when visible authorizations remain publicly verifiable.

Comment
21 pages, 4 figures, 12 tables. Preprint

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

The Source of Data Value: Consumer Disclosure, Access Design, and Platform Monetization

cs.GT econ.GNmath.OC ·2026-10-16 ·Hexiao Liu, Lijian Lu, Mingzheng Wang
benchmark similarity 0.59
Abstract

Digital marketplaces increasingly earn revenue from transaction commissions and seller-facing data services. Sellers may purchase data to increase revenue or avoid competing with an informed rival. We examine how consumer disclosure rights shape these motives and the platform's incentive to provide data. We develop a game-theoretic model of a commissioned platform, two differentiated sellers, and privacy-sensitive consumers. Data generates value through bilateral sales-revenue gains and competition threats arising from asymmetric access. Under mandatory collection, the platform can monetize defensive adoption, even when bilateral personalization reduces seller revenue. Under voluntary disclosure, anonymous purchasing and strictly positive privacy costs make unilateral disclosure unattractive in the baseline. Exclusive access thus yields no usable information, restores sellers' no-data rejection payoffs, and eliminates defensive fees. Profitable provision therefore requires nonnegative bilateral revenue gains. Under full fee extraction, sellers retain their no-data net profits. This revenue alignment does not guarantee welfare gains: additional transactions may benefit consumers, whereas segmentation in an already covered market can raise anonymous prices and reduce welfare. Capping anonymous offers at their no-data benchmark protects individual consumers and limits positive-mass provision to the transaction-creation region. Extensions consider access choice, heterogeneous privacy costs, imperfect identification, and limited contractual credibility. Platforms should evaluate data services based on both bilateral-use and seller-rejection outcomes, and sellers should distinguish revenue-enhancing from defensive investments. Regulators should distinguish equal-access rules from effective consumer control and monitor pricing in anonymous channels.

0.28

One String to Rule Them All: Measuring Consent Under the IAB Global Privacy Platform

cs.CR ·2026-11-01 ·Muhammad Abu Bakar Aziz, Christo Wilson
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 11 pages, 8 figures, 3 tables

Many privacy regulations, including the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), require websites to honor users' opt-out choices. To facilitate this process, industry has introduced technical standards such as the IAB Global Privacy Platform (GPP), which aims to standardize collection and transmission of user consent information across multiple jurisdictions. However, it remains unclear whether these standards consistently and correctly transmit user opt-out choices, or whether opt-out choices are respected by advertisers. In this study, we conduct an in-depth analysis of consent propagation under the GPP framework. We collect data from four web crawls across four experimental settings to analyze how widely the standard is adopted, the extent to which opt-out signals propagate from publishers to third parties, and whether these signals reach and alter third-party advertiser behavior. Our analysis reveals several inconsistencies in the implementation and adoption of the standard that result in user consent signals being lost and user opt-out choices not being respected by the advertisers.

0.28

Privacy-Friendly Cohort Determination: Sealed, CSP-Independent In-Browser ML Inference of Professional Segments for Identity-Less Advertising

cs.CR cs.LG ·2026-09-28 ·Om Shankar Tiwari, Navnit Shukla, Guanyu Wang, Akshay Jain
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 11 pages, 5 figures, 2 tables. Ancillary code, crawl data and full proofs are included

B2B advertising targets a viewer's professional attributes (employer size and industry, function, seniority) and has obtained them by matching identities across sites. Safari and Firefox block third-party cookies, Google retired the Privacy Sandbox cohort APIs in 2025, and reverse-IP firmographics decay under remote work. We present SIF (Sealed Inference Frame), which infers coarse professional cohorts on the device and emits only a locally differentially private, taxonomy-coded label into the OpenRTB bid stream, with no cross-site identifier. It rests on a property of the web platform we make precise: a navigated cross-origin iframe is the only way third-party code obtains a policy it controls, so inference runs in WebAssembly even where the publisher's CSP forbids it, and a nested worker served with default-src 'none' gives the model no network. Even a malicious model leaks at most about 5 bits per site per week. Labels pass through a memoised k-ary randomised response keyed to the publisher's first-party identifier, which gives $\varepsilon$-local differential privacy, defeats averaging, and links requests no better than the identifier already sent. An org-conditional k-anonymity rule suppresses cells, more strictly on corporate networks than at home. Cohorts ride OpenRTB user.data in a LinkedIn-aligned taxonomy, and attribution uses LinkedIn's click-scoped li_fat_id without bridging identities. We report a crawl of CSP deployment on 7,969 top sites and 431 B2B publishers, Heavy-Ad budgets, closed-form privacy-utility trade-offs, a re-identification simulation, and an assessment of which attributes are predictable at all: company type and size are, seniority largely is not. On-device is a design property, not a consent exemption.

0.26

Auditing Anonymous AI Models: A Four-Stage Protocol for Black-Box Identity Verification

cs.SE cs.AIcs.CR ·2026-08-31 ·Yisen Xi
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 35 pages, 4 figures

The 2025--2026 AI market has seen a wave of stealth releases: frontier models launched anonymously on developer platforms under codenames. For their users, identity determines data-handling terms, supply-chain risk, and capability expectations. No validated methodology exists for black-box identity verification of anonymous models: practitioner checklists lack accuracy evidence, and self-identification is untrustworthy by design. We propose a four-stage forensic audit protocol for API-served models. Stage 0 reconstructs launch-time configuration from archived platform snapshots (Internet Archive), exposing preview--production drift. Stage 1 fingerprints configuration (context, output ceiling, reasoning, modality) against the platform catalog. Stage 2 tests tokenizer identity with a cross-length differential that rejects short-prompt collisions. Stage 3 corroborates with behavioral probes. We test declaration consistency on 10 known-identity releases (7 exact, 2 precision-differences, 1 partial, 0 counter-directional), not end-to-end identification under anonymity. Identification is validated prospectively on a flagship case whose 2026-08-23 analysis pointed to the GLM-5.3 version line and whose official reveal confirmed those family and version-line inferences (deployment variant was not pre-asserted; Flash was consistent post-reveal), and on three Stage-0-only cases where the protocol produced a graded hypothesis or declined rather than guessed. A standard-library-only implementation is provided as supplementary material.

0.12

Bridging the Gap: A Longitudinal Analysis of Extended Identifiers in the Post-Cookie Era

cs.NI ·2026-09-02 ·Michael Smith, Riley Grossman, Krzysztof Franaszek, Antonio Torres-Agüero, Pritam Sen +2 more
similarity 0.54
Abstract · 10 pages

As third-party cookies fade because of browser restrictions, the online advertising ecosystem is turning to extended identifiers (EIDs) as an alternative. EIDs are persistent user identifiers, such as hashed email addresses, that are employed to link users across domains and devices. This paper presents a 41-month longitudinal study examining EID usage in over 145 million HTTP header bidding requests sent to six major supply-side platforms (SSPs) from 616,539 websites. Our findings show that EIDs are widely used and are becoming increasingly prevalent in the digital advertising ecosystem, reaching 83.76% of studied websites by May 2025. Our analysis of the 18 popular EID providers that account for 99.42% of all transmitted EIDs in our dataset raises concerns about the readiness of EIDs as an alternative to third-party cookie tracking. In terms of accuracy, only one identity provider consistently recognizes and identifies that the visitor is a self-identified bot crawler, and many providers regularly transmit multiple EIDs for the same visitor. We also identify privacy concerns with EIDs, as 12 of the providers create persistent EIDs that can identify the same user across visits, websites, devices, and months. Finally, we found that 16 providers transmit EIDs on EU websites without user consent.

0.28

Identity Amortization: Shared Resources and the Cost of Sybil Attacks

cs.CR ·2026-10-23 ·Homayoun Maleki, Nekane Sainz, Jon Legarda, Igor Santos-Grueiro
similarity 0.53
Abstract

Sybil defenses commonly price identities by requiring a resource for each one. When one resource can support several identities, an adversary can pay less per identity than the defense intends. We call this identity amortization: a strict reduction in the minimum cost of provisioning identities when resources may be shared, relative to provisioning each one independently. It is a second route to the gap that a Sybil attack exploits. When influence is assigned per identity, a defense calibrated to the nominal price can overestimate the cost of a Sybil threshold by up to the number of identities one resource supports. For any resource catalogue, we give exact tests for when identity amortization occurs, where it begins, and its largest error; a sharing cap below the onset removes it. Because the tests need only prices and capacities, they apply to any defense that admits identities against a shareable resource, telling designers whether the assumed per-identity cost is paid, how wrong it can be, and which intervention restores it most cheaply for honest participants. On published phone-verification prices, per-account estimates overstate provisioning cost 1.6 to 4.3 times; Tor's raised per-address relay limit cut modeled attack cost by 8 to 72%, depending on the address-to-relay price ratio.

0.51

Towards More Granular Reasoning: Mapping the DSA Transparency Database Taxonomy to Platform Terms and Conditions Using Large Language Models

cs.AI cs.CY ·2026-10-19 ·Alyson Ranucci, Eline Leijten, David Graus
publishedposition similarity 0.53
Abstract · Accepted to JURIX 2026

Article 24(5) of the Digital Services Act (DSA) requires providers of online platforms to submit every content moderation decision they make, with a corresponding Statement of Reasons (SoR), to the DSA Transparency Database (DSA-TDB). Such decisions are classified against seventeen high-level attribute categories that categorize the primary reason for the moderation decision. Because over 99.8% of statements cite a violation of the provider's own terms and conditions rather than a legal provision, the database is overwhelmingly a record of contractual enforcement using catch-all reporting; however, whether its categories actually describe those contractual rules well has not been examined. In this paper, we map the terms and conditions (T&C) of 31 designated online services against the DSA-TDB's high-level category taxonomy using a few-shot GPT-4.1 classifier over 447 policy documents. The analysis concerns how T&C rules are represented in the taxonomy, not how they are enforced. Two findings emerge. First, high-level category applicability varies sharply by service type: unsafe products account for 17.5% of e-commerce assignments and 0.2% of adult-platform assignments, and negative effects on civic discourse reaches 9.9% within the Meta family but is absent from adult platforms, Booking.com, and Wikipedia. Second, the categories have notable overlap among sub-category specifications, which makes assigning a single high-level category to a decision difficult. We argue that catch-all reporting is plausibly in part a consequence of the DSA-TDB's schema and attribute design, and recommend a schema that is differentiated by service type with more mandatory attributes derived inductively from platform governance language.

0.30

PrivAudit: A Dual-Lens Auditing Framework for Website Privacy Practices under the CCPA

cs.CR ·2026-09-09 ·Mohamed Moustafa Dawoud, Riya Aggarwal, Likith Rahul Krishnamurthy, Ram Sundara Raman
top venuecode/datahot direction similarity 0.52
Abstract · Extended version of a paper accepted to the 2026 ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security (CCS '26)

Five years after the enforcement of the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), understanding how website privacy practices evolve at scale in response to regulation remains a key challenge for both researchers and regulators. Prior work and regulatory efforts have focused on manual and case-specific enforcement, but there remain no scalable approaches to systematically audit two key user-facing facets of websites that are crucial signals for the CCPA: privacy disclosures and front-end user tracking behavior. In this paper, we present PrivAudit, an automated auditing framework that adopts a dual-lens approach to capture: (1) privacy disclosures through large language model-based analysis of privacy policies grounded in CCPA provisions, and (2) user-observable data collection behavior through automated browser measurements of cookie writes under diverse privacy configurations. We apply PrivAudit to 998 websites and report two broad findings. The law is associated with stronger privacy disclosures: CCPA-subject policies are more likely to disclose opt-out mechanisms, data-sharing practices, and user rights. On the other hand, cookie-based tracking remains pervasive, with both CCPA-subject and not-subject websites setting a total of 6,392 targeting cookies, 49% of which are third-party writes. Moreover, cookies show limited-to-moderate responsiveness to privacy signals and consent choices, even when websites claim to honor them in their disclosures. Our results highlight the need for multi-layered and scalable auditing approaches that combine policy analysis with behavioral evidence. PrivAudit can support these auditing workflows at scale by generating actionable signals and patterns for further manual review. We open-source PrivAudit and are engaging with regulators to support auditing in practice.

0.62