CS Paper Radar

Accuracy and Uncertainty in Machine Deception Detection (Research White Paper)

Heng-Sheng Chang

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CRstat.ML ·submitted 2026-10-11 03:38 UTC · v1
hot direction

Abstract

A deception detector is only as useful as the trust its alarms deserve. Like a polygraph, detectors that read a language model's internal activations can catch deceptive responses that look honest. Yet current detectors depend on which layers they read, weaken on broader tests, and do not state how certain their alarms are. This white paper proposes the Machine Deception Detector, which targets both detection accuracy and the uncertainty of detector scores. The detector reads every layer of the language model, learns which tokens carry evidence of deception using only response labels, and calibrates its alarm threshold so that its false--positive rate stays below a prescribed level. An ensemble of such detectors measures the uncertainty of each score and raises an alarm only when its members agree, with a confidence level that sets how certain each alarm must be. The proposed evaluation trains on instructed honest and deceptive statements, tests on five unseen deceptive tasks of Liars' Bench read by six Qwen3 models from 0.6B to 32B parameters, and is designed to also show which layers carry the deception feature and how this changes with model size.

Comment
18 pages, 2 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

DecepEval: A Benchmark for Evaluating Deception in LLM Agents

cs.LG ·2026-10-06 ·Yiming Xu, Hongyue Yu, Beihua Yang, Zihan Chen, Yixin Liu +6 more
benchmark similarity 0.75
Abstract

As large language model (LLM) agents become increasingly autonomous, they may pursue task performance through deception, raising concerns about their reliable deployment. Existing evaluations show that LLM agents can deceive, but often examine isolated scenarios or narrowly defined conditions, limiting systematic understanding of when deception becomes more likely. To address this gap, we introduce DecepEval, a benchmark comprising 1,532 instances across 3 task families and 28 professional scenarios. Drawing on classical fraud theories, we propose the LLM Deception Diamond framework, which characterizes four external conditions that may induce deception: pressure, incentive, opportunity, and conflict. DecepEval pairs neutral and induced versions of each instance to measure condition-dependent changes in deception rates, while explicit task facts and observable agent behavior help distinguish deception from capability-related errors. Evaluations of nine frontier LLMs show that inducements increase deception across models and task families, even among models with low baseline deception rates. DecepEval makes these vulnerabilities measurable, providing a shared benchmark for progress toward trustworthy artificial intelligence.

0.17

A persistent accuracy ceiling in automated verbal deception detection

cs.CL ·2026-10-08 ·Riccardo Loconte, Jonas Festor, Zane Fatjanova, Mariam Bolkvadze, Bennett Kleinberg
hot direction similarity 0.72
Abstract

Automated methods have been proposed to overcome the limitations of human verbal deception detection, but evidence remains fragmented across disciplines. We systematically reviewed 25 years of research (289 reports, 6,136 classification models) and meta-analyzed 3,653 models nested within 97 datasets. Pooled accuracy was 74.4% (95% CI: 71.2%-77.4%) with substantial heterogeneity. Accuracy was driven by methodological quality (ground truth, data source, class balance, evaluation procedure) more than by model complexity: the adoption of embeddings and large language models has not translated into improved predictive performance. Only 12.46% of reports used data with verifiable ground-truth, and only 23.96% of models were evaluated on independent data. The pooled accuracy aligns with meta-analyses of manual approaches, suggesting a ceiling of 70-75%, unlikely to be lifted by current research conventions.

0.49

Telling FIBS: Probes Effectively Detect Sabotage and Catch Unverbalized Deception

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-10-08 ·Oskar J. Hollinsworth, Alex F. Spies, Tigist Diriba, Adam Gleave, Chris Cundy
datasetcode/data similarity 0.72
Abstract · 10 pages main text, 119 pages total; 26 figures, 28 tables. Code and data: https://github.com/AlignmentResearch/fibs-probes

Recent incidents have highlighted the challenge of monitoring LLM agents and the danger of models deceiving people. We show that white-box deception detection via probes can be scaled up to frontier monitoring settings by collecting the largest deception dataset to date for training probes and introducing a novel probe architecture which can aggregate information across many layers and tokens. Our probes surpass black-box monitors on agentic coding benchmarks, achieving 98.3% AUROC in SHADE-Arena and 98.0% in BashArena (vs. 97.7%, 97.6% resp. for action-only text monitors), and show improved efficacy as the underlying model is scaled up. We further test probes on several cases where deception cannot be determined from the context alone; in these cases of introspective deception, the ground truth can only be determined through careful elicitation or knowledge of a model's training data. In one such evaluation, we show that probes can distinguish transcripts containing a model's true hidden goal from other goals with an AUROC of up to 99.7%. Our probes also detect deception on prominent open-weight models which lie about politically sensitive topics when put under pressure. We release our training dataset, dubbed FIBS, to help drive frontier deployment of effective probes, and encourage the community to expand upon it with further examples of deception and sabotage.

0.51

Adversarial Attacks Reveal Divergent Deception Competence in Humans and Generative Language Models

cs.CY ·2026-10-09 ·Lucca Pfründer, Riccardo Loconte, Bruno Verschuere, Bennett Kleinberg
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Machine learning models typically outperform humans in deception detection. A threat to machine learning models is their vulnerability to adversarial attacks: subtle yet targeted perturbations of input data that trick a model into misclassification. Yet, this also provides an opportunity: understanding how humans versus machines construct attacks offers new insights into second-order beliefs about deception. In a preregistered experiment (n = 501), we compare the effectiveness, efficiency, and nature of a paraphrasing attack by humans and generative language models on an automated deception classifier. We find that humans were more effective attackers when rewriting truthful statements to be deceptive, while the generative language model was more effective and efficient at making lies sound like truths. Computational text analysis suggests that this is because humans make targeted use of deception cues, while generative language models, instead, apply generic changes that signal truth. The failure to mimic deception is two-sided: while it exposes a blind spot in the machines increasingly used to detect lies, it also means that language models might facilitate successful lying.

0.18

A Lie Detector Test for Language Models: Reading Knowledge a Model Won't Reveal

cs.AI ·2026-09-18 ·Hiskias Dingeto
similarity 0.69
Abstract

Large language models can hold knowledge they do not report. A model may sandbag on a capability evaluation, or answer against what it internally knows, and its outputs alone cannot tell whether it is hiding an answer or simply does not have one. We borrow the Concealed Information Test, a forensic method that identifies guilty knowledge by presenting a suspect with the true detail among plausible decoys and measuring a stronger response to the item they recognize. Our method, Probe of Internal Recognition (PIR), does the same inside a model. It presents a question with its candidate answers and reads, from the model's internal states, which candidate the model recognizes as correct. PIR is reference-free, needing no honest reference model and no labeled truth corpus. Across eight models from five families (Gemma, Qwen, Llama, Mistral, and Phi), PIR recovers the recognized answer at 0.70 to 0.87 balanced accuracy, well above the 0.28 to 0.40 unknown-item baseline and the 0.25 chance rate. It stays readable across every form of concealment we test, from prompted deception and trained sandbagging to external password-locked and circuit-broken checkpoints, with recognition between 0.85 and 0.93. When the model hides a known answer, recognition stays high. When unlearning removes the knowledge, recognition drops to the level of a question the model never knew. PIR therefore separates a model that will not answer from one that cannot, which supports sandbagging audits and unlearning verification. The signal is causal, adds information beyond black-box behavioral cues, and extends from multiple-choice questions to free-form generation.

0.17

The Truth Was Never Gone: Perfect Aliasing in Compliant-Context Truth Probes

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-09-09 ·Dylan Jayabahu
code/data similarity 0.67
Abstract · 40 pages, 17 figures. v2: substantially revised and corrected. Code and aggregate results: https://github.com/dylanjayabahu/perfect-aliasing

Linear probes that decode the truth from a language model's activations have been proposed as deception monitors, and a truth probe scoring below chance on a model trained to deceive is naturally read as evidence that the model hid or stopped representing the truth. We show that a fitting-label ambiguity can produce the same readout. In a controlled game, a model should report a secret bit to an ally and its complement to a rival. On compliant (ally) contexts the true bit and the answer the task prescribes are identical labels, so a probe fitted there cannot tell which of the two it measures. We call this complete agreement perfect aliasing. The labels are complements on rival contexts, so one ally-fitted probe scored against each has rival AUROCs that sum to one. Mixed fitting, on ally and rival contexts together, makes the two labels differ; randomized output codebooks also decouple the prescribed answer from the output letter. For a reward-trained Gemma-2-9B policy that answers falsely on every evaluated rival trial, the ally-fitted probe scores $0.006 \pm 0.005$ AUROC at the final layer (mean $\pm$ sample SD over three RL training seeds), while mixed-fit probes score 1.000 on the same held-out activations. Mixed fitting also uses more examples and labelled rival data, so this shows the true bit remains linearly recoverable, not that separating the labels alone explains the gain. In instructed Llama-3.1-8B, a probe refitted on one prompt variant and one frozen from a reference variant both have held-out ally accuracy 1.000 but rival truth AUROCs of 0.080 and 0.986 on the same trials. Our main experiments use one single-token game that states the bit in the prompt, so the recovered direction may read a retained copy of it; where the model must infer the bit, no tested arm deceives reliably. We study what a probe measures, not whether the model uses that information.

0.30

The Deception Archive as a repository of standardized datasets for large-scale verbal deception detection research

cs.CL ·2026-11-09 ·Caterina Borgese, Riccardo Loconte, Lucca Pfründer, Bennett Kleinberg
survey similarity 0.67
Abstract

Computational advances in natural language processing and machine learning have substantially expanded the use of automated approaches in verbal deception research. However, existing verbal deception datasets remain fragmented across disciplines, as they are often difficult to identify, access, and reuse, limiting cross-study comparisons and the development of robust computational models. We present the Deception Archive, a curated and standardized repository of publicly available verbal deception datasets built upon a large-scale systematic review. Eligible datasets were retrieved, manually inspected, and standardized following a structured data curation workflow. The current repository comprises 41 publicly available datasets containing 387,995 truthful or deceptive statements. The archive represents a heterogeneous repository (e.g., in data size, topic of investigation, ground-truth, etc.) and a living resource for integrating newly available deception datasets over time. By providing centralized access to standardized datasets and accompanying metadata, the Deception Archive facilitates dataset discovery, cross-dataset validation, and reproducible evaluation of computational models.

0.14

Before Agent Tells The Lie: Has Deception Already Been Represented?

cs.CL ·2026-10-05 ·Xinling Li, Dadi Guo, Qingyu Liu, Qinghua Mao, Yi R. Fung +3 more
hot direction similarity 0.67
Abstract

Large language model (LLM)-based agents can exhibit deceptive behavior during task execution, including hiding failures, fabricating results, or falsely signaling task completion. Existing monitoring approaches mainly detect deception after it appears in observable actions or outputs. In this paper, we investigate whether deceptive behavior can be predicted from an agent's internal representations before it becomes externally visible. We frame deception monitoring as a trajectory-level representation analysis problem and align agent trajectories around key decision points. Using hidden states extracted before these points, we show that future honest and deceptive outcomes can be reliably distinguished, with predictive signals remaining detectable several model calls before the final decision. We further characterize the temporal evolution of these signals: deception-related representations are weak early in execution but become increasingly identifiable as trajectories progress, while transferable structure can emerge before the strongest decision-adjacent signals appear. Finally, we intervene on the identified honest-deceptive representation directions during inference and find that activation steering reduces downstream deceptive behavior, suggesting that these representations influence agent decisions. Our findings indicate that agent deception is an evolving internal process that can be detected and potentially mitigated before it is expressed externally.

0.25