CS Paper Radar

Execution-Time Opacity in (Controllable) Timed Automata is Hard

Sarah Dépernet, Engel Lefaucheux

cs.CC cs.FL ·submitted 2026-10-11 09:28 UTC · v1
publishedtheory

Abstract

Timing information leakage occurs whenever an attacker successfully deduces confidential internal information by observing some timed information such as the total duration of a run. Timed automata (TAs) are an extension of finite-state automata with a set of clocks evolving at the same rate and that can be tested or reset. Hence, this formalism is able to represent systems involving timing constraints reacting to the passage of time. Some of the transitions in a timed automaton may be controlled, i.e., enabled or disabled, to limit the runs that are allowed. Execution-time opacity (ET-opacity) aims at studying timing information leakage through the analysis of timed automata. More precisely, the ET-opacity problem consists in deciding whether an attacker can deduce whether some secret locations were visited by a run, solely from the run's duration. When control is allowed, the goal becomes to find a strategy that blocks the runs leaking information. This problem has been shown decidable for TAs, with and without control. However, these existing results only provide upper bounds on the complexity of the ET-opacity problem, sometimes largely above the tight bound. Our main contribution is to provide tight lower bounds for those two results. Moreover, for controllable TAs, two variants of ET-opacity (depending on whether detecting if a run did not visit a secret location represents an information leakage or not, and named full and weak ET-opacity respectively) had been separately studied; we prove here that these two notions are inter-reducible.

Comment
In Proceedings GandALF 2026, arXiv:2610.08898
Journal ref
EPTCS 454, 2026, pp. 84-100
DOI
10.4204/EPTCS.454.7

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Execution-Time Opacity Logic: A Logic for Ensuring ET-Opacity in Timed Systems

cs.FL ·2026-09-09 ·Jean Leneutre, Dylan Marinho, Vadim Malvone, James Ortiz
hot direction similarity 0.77
Abstract

Ensuring confidentiality in Cyber-Physical Systems is critical, especially when attackers exploit execution times to infer sensitiveinformation. Traditional opacity models are inadequate for timed systems, as verifying opacity in Timed Automata is undecidable. To address this challenge, we propose Execution-Time Opacity Logic (ETOL), a new formalism that specifies opacity by requiring that for every execution satisfying a secret formula, there exists another execution of the same duration that does not satisfy it. ETOL guarantees that timing observations cannot reveal confidential agent activities. We present a decidable and efficient verification framework based on zone-based model checking, supported by a dedicated algorithm that systematically identifies duration-equivalent executions. Our approach is validated through an ATM case study, showing that ETOL enables efficient verification of execution-time confidentiality under timing attacks. We also developed a prototype tool for the ETOL logic that supports symbolic model checking over timed systems. It allows users to verify ETOL formulas based on clock-constrained execution paths.

0.29

Existential Opacity for Discrete-Event Systems with State Observations

eess.SY ·2026-09-02 ·Zhiyuan Huang, Zhao Tong, Jiakai Li, Bingzhuo Zhong
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Opacity is a fundamental system property for confidentiality in discrete-event systems (DES). Classical opacity is typically defined under event-based observations, requiring that any secret system behavior remains indistinguishable from some non-secret behavior to an external intruder. However, in many applications such as path planning or opacity-preserving tasks, the intruder observes system states rather than events. Moreover, it often suffices that the system exhibits secret behaviors that can be exploited for opacity-preserving task execution, but such a system property cannot be fully captured by existing notions of state-observation-based opacity. Motivated by this limitation, we propose a relaxed notion of existing state-observation-based opacity, called existential opacity (EO), which only requires the existence of secret behaviors (instead of all secret behaviors) that are indistinguishable from a non-secret behavior under the state observations of the intruder. We show that the notion of EO is more expressive than existing state-observation-based opacity notions. In addition, a class of EO properties together with their corresponding verification approaches are developed, enabling the analysis of existential opacity in discrete-event systems and providing a new criterion for determining the feasibility of opacity-preserving problems.

0.21

Opacity of Discrete Event Systems under Sensor Attacks

eess.SY ·2026-11-09 ·Shengbao Zheng, Yu Liu, Shaolong Shu, Feng Lin
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Many information control problems in discrete event systems can be addressed using strong opacity, weak opacity, and non-opacity. These opacities depend on observations. If cyber attackers can attack sensors (or observation channels), then opacities will change. An opaque system may become not opaque, or a not opaque system may become opaque. Therefore, it is important to investigate opacities under sensor attacks. In this paper, we consider opacities under sensor attacks for two settings. The first one is the user has prior knowledge of sensor attacks in which the opacities are called as W-CA-opacities. The second one is the user has no prior knowledge of sensor attacks, and opacities are called as N-CA-opacities. For the former, we construct an augmented automaton that integrates the information of sensor attacks and then converts W-CA-opacities into classical opacities to solve the verification problem. For the latter, we construct the observers for the given system without sensor attacks and with sensor attacks, respectively. We then do the parallel operation on these two observers to obtain a method of verifying N-CA opacities. Furthermore, by adopting the detector technique, we find polynomial algorithms for verifying weak opacity and non opacity for both settings.

0.14

Mining DTA with SMT by Exploiting Simple Elementary Language and Timed Augmented Prefix Acceptor

cs.FL ·2026-09-15 ·Ziran Wang, Jie An, Naijun Zhan
hot direction similarity 0.59
Abstract

Timed automata, which extend finite state automata by introducing clock variables, serve as a popular formalism for specifying and analyzing the timed behaviors of real-time systems. Extracting the timed behaviors of a black-box, safety-critical system is crucial for designing and analyzing its real-time requirements, yet it remains challenging. In this paper, we address this problem by generating a deterministic timed automaton (DTA) consistent with a given set of system behaviors, comprising both positive and negative examples. To this end, we adapt the formalism of simple elementary languages (sEL) and introduce the timed augmented prefix tree acceptor (tAPTA). Our approach proceeds as follows: First, we preprocess samples by translating them into sEL, which discards redundancy and detects conflicts; then, we rewrite the resulting sELs in an incremental form and construct a tAPTA to further simplify the samples; finally, we encode the search for a DTA that accepts the simplified tAPTA as an SMT formula. We evaluate our approach on randomly generated benchmarks and a scheduling case study. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of our simplification method in reducing the size of the encoded SMT formula and the efficiency of our approach in mining a DTA.

0.29

Approximating the Value of Time-Bounded Weighted Timed Games

cs.GT ·2026-10-15 ·Isa Vialard, Joël Ouaknine
theory similarity 0.58
Abstract

The Value Problem for weighted timed games, an extension of timed automata with weights and adversity, consists in determining, given a weighted timed game with a reachability objective and a rational threshold, whether or not the value of the game exceeds the threshold. This problem is known to be undecidable for weighted timed games, i.e., there is no algorithm that can compute the value exactly. A natural alternative is to approximate the value; however, the Approximation problem is also undecidable in general. In this paper, we prove that the Approximation problem is decidable in 4-ExpTime for weighted timed games whose executions are time-bounded.

0.25

Practical Runtime Enforcement of First-Order Temporal Requirements

cs.SE ·2026-10-03 ·François Hublet, David Basin, Srđan Krstić
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Runtime enforcers observe a system's behavior and exert control over it to ensure that the system always adheres to its requirements. Many natural requirements not only formulate restrictions on the system's present behavior, but also impose obligations on its future behavior; for instance, agentic security may require personal data collected during a run to be erased by some deadline. In an ever-growing compliance landscape, real-world systems may be subject to hundreds of such requirements. However, existing enforcement mechanisms supporting complex policies are often too slow for production software; instead, developers may resort to non-temporal access control mechanisms and ad-hoc instrumentation, but these scale poorly with requirement complexity. To address this problem, we introduce an efficient algorithm and tool for enforcing complex temporal requirements and demonstrate its performance. Specifically, we identify a fragment of Metric First-Order Temporal Logic (MFOTL) that can be enforced with low runtime complexity while supporting a rich family of practically relevant requirements, including obligations. We then design an enforcement algorithm for this fragment and implement it in EnfFlash, a novel tool that enforces requirements with latency up to 44x lower than EnfGuard, the previous state-of-the-art enforcer, on standard benchmarks, and up to three orders of magnitude lower on security policies for LLM agents. This performance is achieved by compiling requirements into imperative programs that we efficiently interpret. We evaluate EnfFlash both standalone, on existing benchmarks, and integrated in web applications as an enforcement backend. We demonstrate that it can enforce a substantial 400-line MFOTL formula specifying the GDPR on a social network while adding under 15 ms to each page view, which is sufficient for most interactive and real-time applications.

0.19

Symbolic Abstraction Refinement

cs.AI ·2026-11-17 ·Daniel Bryce, Robert P. Goldman, David J. Musliner, Jeremy Gottlieb, John Skovbekk
published similarity 0.57
Abstract · In Proceedings FMAS 2026, arXiv:2611.21375

Autonomous systems choose actions whose outcomes are uncertain and are subject to time constraints. Probabilistic timed automata (PTAs) model exactly this, and verifying one answers a question about the system's decision-making: the maximum probability of reaching a goal, or the minimum probability of reaching a hazard, that a controller can guarantee. Verification normally works over symbolic states, each pairing a discrete location with a region of clock values, and its difficulty is that the best behavior generally varies within such a region. The PRISM verifier's most capable PTA method responds by splitting regions until each is uniform, rebuilding the transitions that reach them and propagating the split backward through the state graph of a stochastic game, a cascade of graph reconstruction that partitions regions the property never depends on. We present SYMAR, which instead makes the value function symbolic: each symbolic state carries a function from sub-regions of its clock region to probability bounds, so refinement is the appearance of new sub-regions in that function, and previously generated states are never split nor their incoming transitions reconstructed. Both sources of PTA nondeterminism, the timing and the choice of actions, are captured implicitly by the preimage computation that produces those sub-regions. Heuristic forward search then bounds how much refinement is done at all, expanding an And-Or graph from the initial state along the most promising behaviors so that effort is confined to the property-relevant fragment, guided by bounds and preferred actions from a single unrefined run of the existing method; a partial-refinement backup keeps the otherwise combinatorial sub-region count lean, and every stored interval provably contains the true probability. On the PRISM PTA benchmarks, whose subproblems recur in autonomous systems (distributed agreement under contention, leader election, and self-configuration without central coordination), SYMAR is up to 108x faster, solves an instance on which the existing method exhausts the time limit, and is markedly less sensitive to the deadline constant, resolving one instance in a 37-node search graph, unchanged as the deadline triples, where the existing method needs 86,380 abstract states and 73 refinement rounds.

0.43

How Can Size, Ceiling, and Time Bounds Affect the Complexity of Nonuniform Automata Families?

cs.CC cs.FL ·2026-11-16 ·Tomoyuki Yamakami
similarity 0.57
Abstract · (A4 size, 10pt, 34 pages, 6 figures) This paper is a modified, extended version of arxiv.org/abs/2606.26685v1 (2026). This paper is an exten…

In the past literature, families of two-way finite automata and pushdown automata having limited resource-bounded complexity have been studied in direct connection to (mainstream) space-bounded complexity classes equipped with Karp-Lipton style advice of limited size when all inputs given to the automata have bounded length. We acknowledge three major factors--size, ceiling, and time--of such families, which have a significant impact on the computational/descriptional complexity of finite and pushdown automata families, where the "size" refers to the (stack-)state complexity, the "ceiling" refers to the maximum input length, and the "time" refers to the execution time of underlying automata. In this line of study, we further explore these effects caused by different sizes and ceilings. We exploit automata-based reducibility and translatability to space-bounded advised Turing machines and auxiliary automata.

0.45