CS Paper Radar

Data Portability Revisited: Toward the Human-Centric, AI-Driven Data Ecosystems of Tomorrow

Mark Fenwick, Michael Fertik, Paulius Jurcys, Timo Minssen

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-10-11 10:10 UTC · v1

Abstract

This Article critically examines the contemporary regulatory framework and discourse surrounding data portability in the United States. Using recent regulatory developments in the European Union as an illustration, this Article suggests that although data access and portability are identified as vital issues in multiple policy instruments, in its current iteration, at least, legal conceptions of portability continue to reinforce the interests of service providers and data controller enterprises rather than individual end users. This Article argues that a paradigm shift toward a more human-centric data approach to data governance must occur, under which data would be recognized as fundamental to an individual's identity in a digital age. Therefore, it should be placed in the hands of individuals rather than service providers or data controller enterprises. This Article considers technical and market trends in the European Union that reveal and facilitate such a change. It suggests that regulatory frameworks should better align with these technological and market developments to encourage change-inducing trends among market actors. In short, this Article identifies a transformative approach to data portability that empowers individuals with the freedom and ability to aggregate their data in secure personal spaces under their control or dominion. Such a human-centric perspective on data portability is crucial in building Artificial Intelligence (AI)-powered applications for individual consumers that can pave the way for the human-centric, AI-driven data ecosystems of the future.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Usage Control in Public Data Exchange Infrastructures for Future Digital Governance

cs.SE ·2026-09-11 ·Oleksandr Kosenkov, Fathiyeh Faghih, Eric Jackson, Theo Dimitrakos
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Public data exchange infrastructures, such as X-Road, are essential to data-intensive digital public services and the EU digital economy. Their next generation requires advanced data usage control (DUC) mechanisms that address emerging requirements, including privacy by design, to mitigate privacy threats inherent in large-scale automated data exchange. Although research within the individual disciplines already addresses many of the emerging requirements, significant practical challenges arise at the intersection of the disciplines. This paper analytically examines the practical challenges and requirements of data usage control in public data exchange infrastructures. We examine the Estonian X-Road system and emerging use cases through an interdisciplinary lens that integrates formal verification and monitoring of usage control, requirements engineering, and digital governance research. We formulate key requirements and propose a conceptual vision for developing usage control in public data-exchange infrastructures to enable future digital-governance systems to comply with privacy requirements by design.

0.19

Data Patching

cs.HC ·2026-09-23 ·ATM Mizanur Rahman, Syed Ishtiaque Ahmed, Sharifa Sultana
similarity 0.62
Abstract

To provide data-driven quality services to their citizens, every institution determines the acceptability of the citizen data and datafied mechanisms through institutional protocols, including preset standards and policies. However, data meeting standards at one institution might fail to meet a different institution's standards in subsequent phases of the intended citizen services due to mismatched protocols, leading to data devaluation in the citizen service ecosystem. Terming this phenomenon cross-institutional data devaluation, we investigate its causes and workarounds through interviews with 41 Bangladeshi participants. We found that traditional data auditing mechanisms cannot solely address data devaluation; hence, we draw on our findings and theory of cross-institutional AI audits to propose the Citizen-centered Cross-institutional Data Audit (CCDA). We also discuss design and policy implications of CCDA in HCI and datafied citizen services.

0.35

From Voice to Leverage in Data Governance. Building Enforceable Social License for Data ReUse

cs.CY ·2026-09-04 ·Stefaan G. Verhulst, Adam Zable, Begona Gonzalez Otero, Jacqueline Lu
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 19 pages

Contemporary data governance has converged on participation. Citizens assemblies, deliberative polls, codesign workshops, and community advisory panels are now routinely suggested to build trust and secure a social license for the reuse of data. Yet this consensus rests on an unexamined assumption: that giving affected communities a voice will, on its own, change what data holders do. This paper argues that the field needs to complement voice with leverage: the capacity of individuals and communities to make their participation consequential by attaching credible legal, institutional, contractual, economic, or reputational costs to being ignored. Drawing on labor relations bargaining theory, the sociology of disputes, and James C. Scott's account of legibility, we develop leverage as an analytic category defined by three properties: it is counterfactual, enforceable, and durable. We further argue that leverage presupposes epistemic legibility affected publics can rarely impose costs on a system they cannot see, document, or contest; and that most existing transparency instruments equip regulators and procurers rather than the governed. We then map six sources from which communities and data subjects can derive leverage (legal and regulatory; institutional decision; contractual; economic; data access; and political and reputational), examine the intermediary structures that aggregate and sustain it, and propose a six dimension evaluative framework: obligation, enforceability, consequence, monitoring equipment, revocability, and institutional durability for auditing whether any social license process actually redistributes power. The paper's central claim is that a social license worth the name must share the properties of a legal license: conditions, a licensor, and enforceable remedies for breach.

0.33

Data Colonisation and AI Governance in South Africa: Data Protection, Algorithmic Power, and the Struggle for Digital Sovereignty

cs.CY ·2026-10-03 ·Takudzwa Musekiwa, Kimon Kieslich
position similarity 0.62
Abstract

AI is not only a technological artefact; it is also a new site of political economy, legal struggle, and sovereignty contestation. AI systems depend on the continuous collection, storage, processing, and monetisation of large volumes of data. In South Africa, these datasets increasingly include behavioural, biometric, financial, consumer, health, and public-sector information. Our article uses data colonisation as a theoretical lens to analyse whether South Africa's existing legal and governance framework can regulate AI-specific risks. It argues that South Africa's current laws, including the Protection of Personal Information Act (POPIA), regulate personal information but do not adequately prevent data colonisation. POPIA remains important for privacy, lawful processing, automated decision-making, and cross-border transfers. However, data colonisation cannot solely be reduced to privacy protection. It concerns ownership, dependency, infrastructure, surveillance, regulatory power, value extraction, and the capacity of people and institutions to challenge algorithmic decisions. The article examines South African AI-related risks in various areas (e.g. cloud and digital infrastructure, biometric surveillance, and digital markets). This paper argues that South Africa's legal framework does not yet adequately regulate algorithmic opacity, externally controlled digital infrastructure, biometric surveillance, automated profiling, collective data harms, or the extraction of value from South African data. We argue for the need of a decolonial AI governance framework based on algorithmic impact assessments, public-sector AI registers, independent audits, biometric safeguards, competition-law remedies, public-interest data governance, stronger regulatory capacity, and democratic control to strengthen South Africa's digital future.

0.17

Rights by Architecture: A Human-Compatible Sociotechnical Layer for Digital Protection Across Regulatory Regimes

cs.CY cs.ET ·2026-09-02 ·Soheil Human
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Digital rights increasingly exist in law but remain difficult to exercise through the information systems that mediate them. Using disciplined conceptual synthesis and problematization, this critical-conceptual IS paper explains the gap through the interaction of legal heterogeneity, conflicting organizational and commercial incentives, fragmented architectures, and asymmetrical control over rights-relevant acts. It then theorizes a human-compatible rights layer: a governed sociotechnical capability for standardized, machine-readable, bidirectional, and jurisdictionally plural communication of requests, consent, refusal, withdrawal, objection, records, and support. Comparing California-style opt-out signals, the EU's mixed lawful-basis regime, and P3P, DNT, GPC, and ADPC, the paper derives seven normative requirements, develops rights by architecture as a bounded emancipatory policy argument, and treats a proposed GDPR provision on automated and machine-readable privacy management as a policy case for moving from banner-based compliance toward rights-supporting digital infrastructure.

0.18

Terms of Care: Designing for Participation in Data Governance by Disability Communities

cs.HC cs.AIcs.DL ·2026-11-11 ·Madiha Zahrah Choksi, Reeda Shimaz Huda, Rita Faia Marques, Anja Thieme, Cecily Morrison
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 26 pages, 3 figures, 3 tables, under review

Improving disability representation in AI-generated media requires community-specific datasets, yet openly sharing such data can expose communities to misuse, decontextualization, and exploitation. We examine how disability communities can participate in dataset governance through context-sensitive licensing. Working with three disability advocacy organizations, we conducted semi-structured interviews, an educational webinar and modular license activity to promote community participation in data stewardship. Our findings show that governance in these high-context communities relies on organizational memory (especially situated harms); both formal authority and informal relational practices; communication; and resulting trust. The modular license activity made organizational data choices more accessible and values-led, allowing communities to adapt Creative Commons clauses to express permitted uses, sector-specific restrictions, safeguarding requirements, and commitments to respectful representation. Yet, concerns remain about monitoring and enforcing appropriate data use. We contribute (1) an empirical account of governance tensions, (2) a practical modular approach, and (3) design implications for AI data platforms that support relational, context-sensitive governance beyond standardized, one-size-fits-all frameworks.

0.41

Towards a Platform for Mastering Personal Sovereignty

cs.CY cs.SE ·2026-09-23 ·Judith Michael, Bernhard Rumpe, Antonio Bucchiarone, Dominik Bork
position similarity 0.59
Abstract · 7 pages, 1 figure

The ongoing digital transformation of work, administration, health, mobility, and social interaction is profoundly reshaping everyday life, steadily shifting control from individuals to large platform providers. Although data is often labeled the "gold of the 21st century", its real value is realized through services that access, combine, and exploit it. Today, individuals have little sovereignty: life events (e.g., changing an address, insurance, job, or marital status) require fragmented, repetitive interactions across numerous systems, leaving users overwhelmed rather than empowered. We argue for a fundamental rethinking of this situation and propose a virtual, trustworthy platform, called "MyVirtualME" that acts on behalf of the human individual towards companies, administrations, and other actors. This platform centers services, data, permissions, and data usage around humans, not foreign actors, allowing genuine control and transparency. Our vision goes beyond a pure data focus: supported by trusted services ranging from basic notifications to intelligent assistants, MyVirtualME aims to reduce digital bureaucracy, improve and even automate interactions, and support informed oversight of an individual's health, financial, and administrative situation. We firmly believe that a human-centered MyVirtualME is essential for restoring personal sovereignty in our digital future.

0.21

Data Governance for Generative and Agentic AI : Technology, Law, Economics, and Security

cs.AI cs.CY ·2026-10-24 ·Narayana Darapaneni, Padmaja K, Gnana Chaithra D
similarity 0.56
Abstract

This book develops a unified governance framework for systems that retrieve, generate, infer, remember and act on information from large language models and retrieval augmented pipelines to autonomous multi agent systems. Eleven chapters and eight appendices integrate three disciplinary lenses-technology, law and economics-across the full lifecycle: data quality, lineage and provenance; global data protection law and intellectual property; the economics of data governance; digital trust, cybersecurity and zero-trust architecture; ethics and responsible AI; governing generative AI pipelines; governing agentic AI and multi-agent systems; data governance in elections and the public sphere; AI regulation across six jurisdictions; and the design of a governance control plane for 2030. Each chapter is anchored in Indian law and institutions while maintaining a comparative, cross jurisdictional perspective.

0.15