CS Paper Radar

Unconditional Separation between LL and CLL

Shubham Bhardwaj

cs.CC ·submitted 2026-10-11 11:55 UTC · v2
publishedtheory

Abstract

Catalytic computation involves the study of Turing machines that are provided an additional catalytic tape (with arbitrary content) that the machine may use while ensuring that the tape contents are restored at the end of the computation. Although it is known that catalytic log-space machines are at least as powerful as non-deterministic log-space (and more), we do not have unconditional asymptotic separations. In this work, we prove an unconditional separation between a deterministic space complexity class and its catalytic counterpart. More precisely, at the doubly logarithmic scale, we show that catalytic Turing machines can provably compute more languages than standard deterministic doubly-logarithmic space machines. The separation is witnessed by the unary language $\mathrm{POW2} = \{1^n : n \text{ is a power of two}\}$. We construct a catalytic Turing machine that uses $O(\log \log n)$ bits of space and $O(\log n)$ bits of catalytic tape to decide $\mathrm{POW2}$, whereas any standard deterministic Turing machine requires $Ω(\log n)$ space to decide it.

Comment
11 pages. v2: fixed an error in the upper bound concerning the endmarkers of the catalytic tape; thanks to András Salamon for pointing it out

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Catalytic space-efficient algorithms for Distance and Determinant

cs.CC cs.DS ·2026-10-30 ·Srijan Chakraborty, Samir Datta, Kushagra Shandilya
theory similarity 0.70
Abstract

Catalytic computation reuses potentially large but in-use space (or catalytic space) which must be restored to its initial contents while the clean space is small. This allows all problems in $\mathsf{NL}$ and even larger classes to be in catalytic logspace [Buhrman et al, STOC2014]. In [Chmel et al, CCC2026] the catalytic space for reachability was restricted to sublinear space (specifically, $n \big/ 2^{θ(\sqrt{\log n})}$ space) while remaining in polynomial time. This matches the non-catalytic bounds from [Barnes et al, SICOMP1998]. We extend the reachability bound to shortest distance, proving a simultaneous sublinear catalytic space and polynomial time bound (henceforth called, sublinear $\mathsf{CLP}$). This is the first simultaneous sublinear space and polynomial time bound for distance even without the catalytic discipline. Moreover, our bound works even for polynomially weighted graphs. Along the way we prove simultaneous near linear catalytic space ($\mathcal{O}(n\log^{O(1)}{n})$) and polynomial time bounds for the determinant. We also show some applications to planar matching problems. Our starting point was catalytic computation of reachability in directed graphs by [Cook-Pyne, ITCS2026]. [Edenhofer, arXiv:2602.21088] used it to give a tradeoff between catalytic and non-catalytic space, while [Chmel et al, CCC2026] compress the graph to a smaller graph preserving $s,t$-reachability to achieve a smaller space bound. All three can be modified to yield an algorithm for unweighted distance. Our contribution is to define an approximation to the walk polynomial in weighted graphs that allows us to infer weighted $s,t$-distance in sublinear $\mathsf{CLP}$. We do so by non-trivially combining elements from each of the above three papers.

0.17

Breaking the Space Barrier and its Application to Language Model Inference

cs.AI cs.CC ·2026-10-06 ·Arip Asadulaev
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract

Language models are more and more often asked for structured output: JSON that follows a schema, or a tool call with typed arguments. A small machine, an automaton, enforces the format by forbidding the tokens that would break it. We observe that this machine has a rare property: from any of its states, each token leads along exactly one path. Graphs in which only a few paths join any two points are a classical object of complexity theory, and our theoretical result settles an open question about them: one can decide whether such a graph connects two points while verifying that it really has few paths, with very little memory. Precisely, the problem lies in the classes ReachUL, LOGDCFL, C=L and SC2, and needs only O(log2 n/ log log n) space, below the classical O(log2 n) of Savitch's theorem. The constructions behind the proofs become an inference engine: text the format forces is written without running the model, the mask is recomputed on the GPU without any table, recursive formats use a small stack, every output stays valid under a token limit, and independent fields are decoded in parallel and verified. On one 16 GB Apple M2 Pro with Qwen3.5-2B and 4B, against MLX with llguidance, the standard setup for this hardware, schema-constrained extraction finishes 1.2- 1.3x sooner with the same answers, a grammar costs 3 MB instead of up to 1.5 GB, one server holds sixteen grammars where tables run out of memory, and sixteen tool-calling agents finish 2.5x sooner.

0.31

Computing faster with a full memory: Catalytic algorithms break time-space lower bounds

cs.DS cs.CC ·2026-10-17 ·Adelmo Morrison Orozco, Nathan Sheffield, Ryan Williams
similarity 0.64
Abstract

We show that adding "catalytic space" (which starts full and must have its original contents restored at the end of computation) provably speeds up time-and-space-bounded computation. In a natural output model, with $O(\log(n))$ free space and poly($n$) catalytic space, we give algorithms for sorting and the discrete Fourier transform running in time $n^{1+o(1)}$, and an algorithm for matrix multiplication running in time $n^{ω+ o(1)}$. In the same output model, without additional catalytic space, sorting and DFT are known to require time-space product $Ω(n^2)$, and matrix multiplication is known to require time-space product $Ω(n^3)$ [Borodin and Cook, 1982] [Beame, 1991] [Yesha, 1984] [Abrahamson, 1991]. This is the first unconditional demonstration that (uniform, non-relativized) catalytic logspace algorithms can outperform their (non-catalytic) logspace counterparts. We give several further results relevant to fast catalytic algorithm design. We observe that many applications of sorting, FFT, and fast matrix multiplication (e.g., kSUM, integer multiplication, and clique counting) can be performed catalytically, giving catalytic logspace algorithms matching (up to subpolynomial factors) the best known unbounded-space runtimes. Furthermore, we give a fast and simple catalytic algorithm for evaluating low-depth threshold circuits, improving the previously known runtime bound from $\widetilde O(|C|4^df)$ to $\widetilde O(|C|2^d)$, where $|C|$ is the total size (i.e. number of wires) of the circuit, $d$ is the depth, and $f$ is the maximum fan-in.

0.28

Accepting-Path Counting at the One-Tape $n\log n$ Threshold

cs.CC ·2026-09-26 ·Ondřej Kuželka
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract · 9 pages

We observe that the classical $n\log n$ time threshold for one-tape Turing machines is also a threshold for their accepting-path counts. Below it, every nondeterministic one-tape machine running in strong $o(n\log n)$ time has a rational ordinary generating function of accepting-path counts. At strong $O(n\log n)$ time, the situation changes completely: there is a fixed one-tape machine whose accepting-path function is complete for $\#\mathsf P_1$, the tally analogue of $\#\mathsf P$, under parsimonious polynomial-time tally reductions. A second construction within the same time bound gives positive accepting-path counts with a noncomputable exponential growth rate. The rationality result combines the one-tape time gap with the linear-time counting theorem of Tadaki, Yamakami and Lin. The completeness proof adapts the linear-time universal counting machine of Beame et al. to the one-tape setting.

0.32

Computational Work Extraction: The Complexity of Catalysts

cs.CC quant-ph ·2026-09-30 ·Atul Singh Arora, Shantanav Chakraborty, Alexandru Cojocaru, Sreyas Saminathan, Uttam Singh
theoryhot direction similarity 0.63
Abstract · 70 pages, 3 Figures; See https://atulsingharora.github.io/cat for updates

We prove maximal separations: $n$-qubit systems can have $Θ(n)$ ergotropy, while every efficient process extracts negligible work, even for Hamiltonians consisting of single-qubit terms. We establish an unconditional existential separation and give an explicit construction in the random oracle model. Assuming the existence of quantum-secure pseudorandom functions, this separation extends to the plain model. This work uncovers an important connection between ergotropy and the complexity of catalytic computation---computation where auxiliary qubits must be finally restored to their initial state. Relative to a random oracle, we establish relational and decision problems that: (i) can be solved efficiently with $λ$ catalysts; but (ii) cannot be solved by any algorithm with $cλ$ catalysts, for any $c<1$. We show this by proving query lower bounds for quantum-space bounded algorithms. As a consequence, for computational ergotropy, catalysts prove to be surprisingly powerful---there is a family of Hamiltonians and states for which catalysts enable efficient extraction of the full $Θ(n)$ ergotropy, while every efficient non-catalytic process extracts negligible work. Furthermore, catalysts also allow us to introduce and instantiate the notion of pseudoergotropy---analogous to pseudorandomness. On the other hand, we show catalysts do not change (information-theoretic) ergotropy. Finally, our work also sheds light on the classical aspect of the problem. First, most of our constructions rely on classical states and Hamiltonians and therefore imply analogous results for classical ergotropy. Second, we show that certain proof of quantumness protocols can be used to generically separate classical and quantum catalytic ergotropy.

0.38

Simulating Space Bounded Read-$k$ PTMs with Space Bounded Read-Once PTMs

cs.CC ·2026-11-13 ·Kuan Cheng, Shengtang Huang, Ruiyang Wu
similarity 0.62
Abstract

We show that read-$k$ Probabilistic Turing Machines with bounded space $S$ and running time $T$ can be simulated by read-once Probabilistic Turing Machines with error $\varepsilon$, running in space $ O(k^2 (S + \log (n+ T)) + \log (1/ε))$ and time $\frac{1}{\varepsilon} \cdot 2^{O\left(k^2\left(S+\log(n+T) \right)\right)}$. As a direct consequence we show that read-$k$ $\mathsf{BPL}$ is equal to $\mathsf{BPL}$, for any constant $k$. Recently OpenAI announced that $\mathsf{BPL} = \mathsf{L}$. If this is true then our result immediately implies that read-$k$ $\mathsf{BPL}$ is equal to $\mathsf{L}$.

0.29

Descriptive Complexity in Lean: Completeness by First-Order Reductions

cs.LO cs.CC ·2026-09-16 ·Pierre Senellart, Anton Gnatenko
theorycode/data similarity 0.62
Abstract · 25 pages. Library available at https://github.com/PierreSenellart/descriptive-complexity

We show that descriptive complexity can serve as a foundation for formalizing computational complexity results in a proof assistant, by constructing a Lean library centered around the following concepts: decision problems are isomorphism-invariant predicates on finite structures; complexity classes are defined by their logical characterization; membership is shown by definability witnesses; hardness is shown by first-order reductions from a known hard problem. We also establish bridges to traditional machine models such as (non)deterministic Turing machines. The library proves 73 completeness results, on 68 problems or problem families, over 14 different classes; relations between the classes established inside the logic and not by machine simulation, among them NL = coNL and the Abiteboul-Vianu theorem; and unconditional lower bounds, among them $\mathrm{FO}(\leq) \subsetneq \mathrm{FO}(\leq, \mathrm{TC})$ and the failure of order-free FO(IFP) to capture PTIME.

0.47

The Complexity of Unpredictability

cs.CC ·2026-11-04 ·Aryan Agarwala, Dani Dorfman
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract

We initiate the study of middle-bit predictors: functions that take as input a string with one missing bit and try to predict that bit. These are closely related to next-bit predictors, a classical object in pseudorandomness. We study the deterministic complexity of computing an unpredictable distribution (UNPRED). Given a list of middle-bit predictors in circuit form and a parameter $ε>0$, output a multiset of strings such that each predictor succeeds with probability less than $1/2+ε$ on a uniformly sampled string from the multiset. We write $\mathsf{UNPRED}^{\mathsf{TC}^1}$ for the restriction to $\mathsf{TC}^1$ predictors. We show that UNPRED offers a unified route towards resolving several major open problems in catalytic computation, the biggest of which is whether deterministic polynomial time (P and FP) can simulate catalytic logspace (CL and SearchCL). It is believed that $\mathsf{SearchCL}\subseteq\mathsf{FP}$. We prove $$\mathsf{UNPRED}\in\mathsf{FP}\implies\mathsf{SearchCL}\subseteq\mathsf{FP}\implies\mathsf{UNPRED}^{\mathsf{TC}^1}\in\mathsf{FP}.$$ Thus, the questions of whether UNPRED is in FP and whether SearchCL is contained in FP are almost equivalent, up to the restriction to $\mathsf{TC}^1$ circuits. We also show that any deterministic polynomial-time algorithm for $\mathsf{UNPRED}^{\mathsf{TC}^1}$ must exploit properties of $\mathsf{TC}^1$ circuits, either in the algorithm itself or in its analysis. To our knowledge, this would also be the first algorithm to use the structure of $\mathsf{TC}^1$ circuits in this way to solve a natural problem, thus advancing our understanding of Boolean circuits. Together, our results provide strong evidence that middle-bit predictors could be the key to unlocking several major open problems in catalytic computation, pseudorandomness, and Boolean circuit complexity.

0.26