CS Paper Radar

The Voter Model with Opinion Graph

Petra Berenbrink, Thorsten Götte, Martin Hoefer, Tim Koglin

cs.GT cs.DC ·submitted 2026-10-12 12:24 UTC · v1

Abstract

We study the \emph{voter model with opinion graph}, a generalization of the standard (pull) voter model that adds a notion of bounded confidence. In this process, we consider a finite set $A$ of $n$ agents. Each agent $u \in A$ has an opinion $x_u \in O$, where we model opinions as vertices in an undirected opinion graph $G = (O,E)$ with $|O|=q$. In each step, an agent $u$ interacts with another agent $v \in A$. In contrast to classical voting, $u$ adopts the opinion $x_v$ if and only if $x_v$ and $x_u$ are neighbors in $G$. The process is stable once all remaining opinions are an independent set in $G$. We analyze two variants of the process: the ordinary EdgeVOG process, which samples a pair of interacting agents uniformly at random from all possible pairs, and the productive EdgeVOG process, which samples only pairs with neighboring opinions in $G$. We show the following: - For every opinion graph and every initial configuration, ordinary EdgeVOG stabilizes within $O(n^2\log n)$ steps in expectation and with high probability. The expectation bound is asymptotically tight. For the productive EdgeVOG process, the expected stabilization time is exactly the initial number of compatible agent pairs, while $O(n^2\log n)$ steps suffice with high probability. - An opinion $i$ with initial support $s_i$ survives with probability at least $p_i:=s_i/(s_i+\sum_{j\in N(i)}s_j)$. Further, let $μ= \sum_{i \in O} p_i$, then we show the probability that less than $(1-δ)μ$ opinions survive is at most $\exp(-δ^2μ/(2(Δ^2+1)))$ for every $0\leqδ\leq1$. -If $G$ has maximum degree $Δ$ and every opinion initially has support at most $\hat{s}$, then no opinion ever acquires more than $\tilde{O}(\min\{n,Δ^6\hat{s}\})$ agents with high probability. This yields near-linear stabilization bounds for productive EdgeVOG for a large class of configurations.

Comment
Abstract shortened to comply Arxiv requirements

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Intransigence or compromise: concatenated opinion dynamics with voting feedback

eess.SY physics.soc-phecon.THnlin.AO ·2026-11-16 ·Lingfei Wang, Johan Swartling Sennhed, David Ohlin, Emma Tegling
similarity 0.69
Abstract

In this paper, we study opinion evolution in a sequence of Friedkin-Johnsen (FJ) models, concatenated so that the final opinions of each model serve as the initial opinions of the next. Each FJ model is followed by a vote, and each agent becomes partially or fully stubborn in the next model, depending on how close its opinion is to the voting result. With the state-dependent switching of stubbornness, the dynamics are not guaranteed to be contractive. We show that, over any fixed strongly connected network, the opinions always converge. A sufficient condition on the initial opinions is proposed, under which consensus is reached exponentially fast. For the complete graph, we further show that, if the agents' stubbornness levels do not differ too much, an agent that is partially stubborn in one FJ model can never become fully stubborn in a subsequent one: once it has started compromising, it keeps doing so.

0.26

Scaling Laws for Majority-based Opinion Dynamics in the Presence of Stubborn Agents

cs.MA math.PR ·2026-08-11 ·Luke Meredith, Arpan Mukhopadhyay
similarity 0.68
Abstract

In a multi-agent system, there are often stubborn followers of specific opinions or beliefs. Motivated by this observation, in this paper, we aim to understand how stubborn agents affect the distribution of opinions in a network where both stubborn and non-stubborn agents interact with each other. To do so, we assume that all agents have an opinion in the set $\{0,1\}$ and each non-stubborn agent updates its opinion according to the $2k$\textit{-choices rule}, where the agent samples $2k$ neighbours (including both stubborn and non-stubborn neighbours) uniformly at random and adopts the majority opinion among the sampled group of neighbours and itself. We assume that a proportion of agents, $γ_i$, are stubborn followers of opinion $i\in \{0,1\}$. It is natural to expect that the steady-state distribution of the opinions in the network will be dominated by the opinion with the larger proportion of stubborn followers. We show that while this is true, the time to reach steady-state depends heavily on the values of the parameters $γ_0$ and $γ_1$. When the individual values of these parameters, as well as their difference, are small, it can take an exponentially long time (in the network size) to reach the steady-state. In sharp contrast, when at least one of the parameters $γ_0$ and $γ_1$ is large, the network reaches the steady-state in a time that is only logarithmic in the network size. Hence, there exists a sharp phase transition in the network dynamics based on the proportions of stubborn agents. We also characterise the behaviour of the system when the parameters $γ_0$ and $γ_1$ lie on the boundary of the phase transition. In this boundary region, we show using Stein's method that the dynamics are driven by a diffusion process which takes polynomial time to mix.

0.04

Trembling toward Duverger: Convergence and Cycles in Synchronous Plurality Dynamics

cs.GT ·2026-10-16 ·Maximilian Weigel, Damien Berriaud, Roger Wattenhofer
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 19 pages, 2 figures

Duverger's law states that plurality elections tend to concentrate support on two candidates. Pivotal-voter models typically derive this from aggregate uncertainty about votes, so that two-candidate competition emerges in the limit of large electorates. We instead propose a model for a fixed, finite population. A poll reveals the current support counts, and each voter best responds under trembling-hand beliefs, assuming that every other voter may deviate with a small probability. Starting from truthful votes, we show that a single update typically suffices for the dynamics to converge to a stable profile in which every voter supports her preferred candidate among the two poll leaders. For any number of candidates and any full-support tremble belief, a four-vote lead of the runner-up over all lower candidates suffices; for three candidates, a lead of two suffices. As a consequence, under random preferences, Duverger's law emerges after one update with probability $1-\mathcal O(N^{-1/2})$. While these results may suggest that the dynamics always settle, convergence can fail. Mild period-two cycles already arise, with a few voters swapping ballots around an otherwise stable profile. We show that substantially richer behavior is possible, even with three candidates. Period-three cycles arise with six voters changing their ballots, and no such cycle can involve fewer than four. Cycles can also alternate the plurality winner. Moreover, larger electorates support ever longer cycles: for every odd $\ell\geq3$, truthful voting can lead to a cycle whose vote counts repeat every $\ell$ rounds and whose full ballot profile repeats every $2\ell$ rounds.

0.29

DeGroot Dynamics on Multiplex Networks with Directed and Acyclic Interlayer Connectivities

cs.SI econ.THeess.SYmath.DS+1 ·2026-10-19 ·Mia Zender, Kye Shi, Abigail Hickok, Weiqi Chu, Mason A. Porter
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract · 44 pages, 9 figures

In models of opinion dynamics, researchers typically examine how an individual's opinion on one topic is influenced by the opinions of their neighbors in a network. However, people's opinions on a topic are also influenced by their opinions and their neighbors' opinions on related topics. In an election, for example, the opinions of a voter on a variety of issues inform their opinions of electoral candidates. To consider the influence between people's opinions on multiple distinct topics, we study a multiplex extension of the traditional DeGroot consensus model. In our multiplex DeGroot model, different network layers represent distinct topics and directed interlayer edges (which are not allowed to form cycles) encode relationships between distinct topics. In our model, an individual's opinion on one topic is influenced both by the opinions of their neighbors on that topic and by their own opinions on related topics. We prove under mild conditions that our multiplex DeGroot model converges to a limit state. We also prove that strong connectedness in ``source layers'' (which represent fundamental beliefs) eventually yields a consensus opinion in each layer. In particular, we show that consensus on source layers can lead to consensus on other layers even when those layers otherwise would be polarized. By numerically simulating our multiplex DeGroot model on a two-layer network, we examine the effects on opinion dynamics of (1) different network structures and (2) different types of initial opinion data.

0.30

Subgame-Perfect Nash Equilibria of Plurality Voting with Abstention: a PSPACE-Completeness Result for Restricted Ballots

cs.GT ·2026-09-21 ·Edith Elkind
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract

We consider sequential Plurality elections in which each voter may abstain or vote for a single candidate. Each voter assigns utilities to all candidates; for each voter, this induces a (weak) order over the candidates. Ties are resolved uniformly at random, and voting has a small positive cost, so that a voter prefers to abstain when their vote cannot change the election outcome. We consider a variant of this model where, for each voter, we additionally specify a prefix of her ranking, so that she is only allowed to vote for a candidate from that prefix (or abstain). We prove that for this variant of the model, deciding whether a designated candidate is among the election winners in a subgame-perfect equilibrium of the associated extensive-form game is PSPACE-complete. This partially resolves an open problem from the work of Desmedt and Elkind [2010].

0.10

Agent-based Modeling: Equilibrium, Echo Chambers, and Efficiency in Hybrid Coevolutionary Opinion Games

cs.GT cs.MAcs.SI ·2026-09-23 ·Ming-Zhi Jiang, An-Tzu Teng, Jun-En Liu, Po-An Chen, Yung-Ming Li
publishedtheory similarity 0.61
Abstract · 29 pages, 7 figures, 5 tables. A short version appears in the proceedings of CSoNet 2026

Online discussion of political and gender-related issues is often heated, and when opinions in a network draw closer, the convergence is readily taken as genuine consensus. Whether it carries a cost is a question existing methods cannot answer: coevolutionary opinion formation games measure the Price of Anarchy (PoA) of agents that update by numerical rules, while simulations with large language model (LLM) agents report only descriptive indices. We introduce the Hybrid Coevolutionary Opinion Game (H-COG), in which analytical and LLM-driven agents share one network, choose their neighbors by opinion similarity in every round, and hold stances drawn from real Reddit comments on gun control and abortion. To our knowledge, H-COG is the first framework to place Friedkin-Johnsen best-response agents and LLM agents in one coevolutionary game and to measure the social cost and PoA of LLM-driven populations. We prove that on any fixed network, given the LLM agents' opinions, the analytical agents' opinion stage has a unique equilibrium and the social optimum has a closed form, and that the convergence guarantee of Chen et al. for optimistic gradient ascent carries over to H-COG. All runs converge structurally. LLM-driven populations are less polarized yet have about five times the PoA of analytical ones; half of the gap comes from agents being pulled away from their own prior positions, a distance we prove must carry a cost whenever expressed opinions are more concentrated than intrinsic ones. Echo chambers form under every composition and grow out of the rewiring rule rather than the initial topology. Opinions in these populations draw closer largely because agents give up their own positions.

0.50

Behavior of Nonlinear Opinion Dynamics over Large Networks

eess.SY ·2026-09-12 ·Yu Xing, Anastasia Bizyaeva, Karl H. Johansson
hot direction similarity 0.60
Abstract

Opinion dynamics have been studied for decades across disciplines, with much of the theoretical literature focusing on behaviors such as consensus, polarization, and clustering. Although classic models can exhibit more complex opinion patterns in simulations, quantifying such distributions is not fully understood. To address this question, in this paper, we study the behavior of nonlinear opinion dynamics over large-scale networks using graphons, which capture the underlying network structure. In the model, agents update their opinions according to a nonlinear rule that includes saturation effects in interactions. The network is represented by random graphs generated from a graphon, and a corresponding nonlinear dynamical model is introduced over the graphon. We show that the graphon dynamics approximate the finite-dimensional system, when the network size is large. Leveraging spectral approximation results for random graphs, we further show that the equilibria of the nonlinear model can also be approximated by those of the continuum limit. This result enables a quantitative characterization of the opinion distribution based on the underlying graphon structure. The theoretical results are illustrated by numerical simulation.

0.26

Robust Action Clusters and Cascades in Opinion Dynamics with Heterogeneous Action Thresholds

eess.SY ·2026-11-16 ·Hassan Munif, Anthony Couthures, Vineeth Satheeskumar Varma, Samson Lasaulce, Irinel-Constantin Morarescu
similarity 0.60
Abstract

We study the preservation and propagation of public actions in networks whose agents hold continuous private opinions. Agents update their opinions from their neighbors' observed actions and express them through action rules whose thresholds differ across agents. We characterize groups of agents that preserve a given common action regardless of the outsiders' actions. We call such a group, paired with that action, a robust action cluster. We show that a group is a robust action cluster for that action if and only if each member places enough of its influence weight on the group, where the required influence depends on the member's own action rule. We further give a sufficient condition under which an agent outside the cluster permanently adopts the cluster's action, and we iterate it to obtain a cascade of agents that are guaranteed to adopt that action. Finally, numerical examples show that replacing heterogeneous thresholds by their mean can change both the propagation of an action and the presence of robust action clusters.

0.24