CS Paper Radar

Can Rényi Accountants Beat Lossless Accountants for DP-SGD?

Jinho Bok

cs.LG cs.CRcs.DScs.ITstat.ML ·submitted 2026-10-12 17:13 UTC · v1

Abstract

Recent frameworks in differential privacy (DP), such as privacy loss distributions and $f$-DP, provide lossless representations of the privacy leakage of mechanisms. These approaches are often considered to yield tighter $(\varepsilon, δ)$-DP guarantees than those obtained from relaxed notions such as Rényi DP. But is that always the case? We study this question for differentially private stochastic gradient descent (DP-SGD) with fixed-size batches under replace adjacency. Our key observation is that in this setting, privacy accounting based on Rényi DP can use a pair of worst-case distributions (i.e., a dominating pair) that differs from the one used in the lossless frameworks. In particular, we characterize the worst-case distributions as two-dimensional Gaussian mixtures and derive an improved Rényi DP bound for DP-SGD. Numerical and asymptotic comparisons show that across various hyperparameter settings, a Rényi DP accountant based on the new bound can yield better privacy guarantees than those obtained from the lossless frameworks.

Comment
41 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Gaussian Approximation for Composition and Subsampling of Differentially Private Algorithms

cs.LG ·2026-10-23 ·Vitaly Feldman, Moshe Shenfeld
similarity 0.77
Abstract

The privacy analysis of differentially private stochastic gradient descent (DP-SGD) relies on bounds for the composition of subsampled mechanisms. The privacy of such a composition is bounded by that of a pair of product distributions, whose privacy loss is a sum of independent terms and has been analyzed via a variety of notions and concentration results. Yet, existing closed-form bounds either lose a logarithmic factor or require restrictive conditions on the noise scale and delicate analysis of subsampling. Further, while it is well known that sums of independent random variables are approximately Gaussian, existing CLT-based techniques give an approximation with a large error in $δ$. We show that the privacy loss of this pair is approximately Gaussian as long as each step has a small privacy loss except with small probability. Specifically, its privacy loss distribution is close to a Gaussian with the same mean and variance, after truncating the rare large privacy losses. The closeness in both directions is up to a shift of $\varepsilon$ that grows only as $\ln(1/β)$ for an additive error $β$ in $δ$ and is a lower-order term in typical applications. In particular, the composition satisfies Gaussian differential privacy up to a lower-order shift of $\varepsilon$ and the additive error $β$. We also give a simple way to analyze the resulting variance-based bounds for subsampled mechanisms which relies on the $χ^2$ divergence of a single step. For the Gaussian mechanism at sampling rate $1/t$ and $t>\ln^{3}(1/δ)$, this gives the predicted rate for $σ\gtrsim\max\{1,\sqrt{\ln(1/δ)}/\ln(t)\}$, whereas the standard Rényi-divergence analyses need $σ\gtrsim\sqrt{t\ln(1/δ)}/\ln(t)$. We extend these results to random allocation (balls-and-bins sampling), and show that it explains the high accuracy of the connect-the-dots method.

0.41

Counting on Dummies: Privacy Amplification with Observable Counts and Truncated Batches

cs.LG cs.CR ·2026-10-30 ·Vitaly Feldman, Audra McMillan, Kunal Talwar
similarity 0.72
Abstract

In many practical deployments of Differentially Private Stochastic Gradient Descent (DP-SGD), the server processes data in batches. Randomly sampling these batches allows for better privacy bounds via privacy amplification results. Most sampling schemes with provable privacy amplification, including Poisson sampling and random allocation, result in variable batch sizes. The privacy guarantee of these schemes requires that the batch sizes are not revealed. In distributed settings, the server performing the aggregation or any party observing the communication traffic may learn these batch sizes. Furthermore, in both centralized and distributed settings, memory and computation constraints may require each batch to be of some maximum size $s$, necessitating truncation of the batch when it exceeds this limit. It is known that this truncation can result in a significant increase in privacy loss. In this work, we address both of these challenges via a simple mechanism that uses a random number of \emph{dummy points} to privatize the batch size and maintain the privacy guarantee even under truncation. We demonstrate that our mechanism is easy to implement in a distributed setting, and provide a general analysis of this mechanism for both Poisson sampling and random allocation. Our analysis is designed to support efficient and relatively tight privacy accounting. It also effectively amplifies the privacy of the count releases by subsampling, making the expected number of dummy points asymptotically smaller than what is needed to directly privatize the (sensitivity-one) batch sizes with non-negative noise. For Poisson sampling with truncated batches, we demonstrate empirically that our mechanism achieves better privacy--efficiency tradeoffs than the direct accounting for truncation recently given by (Ganesh, 2025).

0.22

Privacy Accounting for Empirical Denoisers

cs.LG cs.CRstat.ML ·2026-10-20 ·William Cheng, Dongjun Kim, Mijung Park
theoryhot direction similarity 0.72
Abstract · 31 pages, 7 figures

Diffusion models have emerged as the foundation of modern generative systems, yet their high memorization capacity raises privacy concerns. While differentially private (DP) training provides formal guarantees, it comes at a cost in sample quality. In this work, we study a complementary question: how much privacy loss is incurred during the sampling process itself? Directly analyzing modern neural denoisers is challenging because their sensitivity to a single training example is generally intractable. To overcome this challenge, we construct and analyze a clipped privacy-accountable empirical denoiser, a training-free estimator of the Bayes-optimal denoiser, whose per-step sensitivity can be computed explicitly, allowing each denoising step to be a Gaussian mechanism. This perspective enables privacy accounting under Gaussian DP when each training example contributes to each denoising step, and under $f$-DP trade-off functions when each generated sample uses a single randomly subsampled block of the training data. We report every $(\varepsilon, δ)$ guarantee as a certified upper bound from a privacy loss distribution accountant, and use a cumulant-based Edgeworth approximation as a fast diagnostic, characterizing where it is reliable and where it becomes anti-conservative. We also analyze the privacy loss along the denoising trajectory and show that it grows steeply near the critical window in which semantic content is formed. This observation motivates hybrid samplers that use the private empirical denoiser through the formative steps where it remains a faithful proxy for the neural denoiser, then switch to a public neural denoiser for the remaining refinement. Our results on CIFAR-10 and CelebA-64 show that the privacy of diffusion models depends not only on the training procedure, but also on sampling-time design choices such as subsampling, stopping time, and hybrid denoising.

0.25

Unifying Privacy Accounting: Information Equivalence and Information Loss

cs.CR cs.ITmath.ST ·2026-10-01 ·Buxin Su, Qiaoshi Yang, Yiding Su, Chendi Wang
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Differential privacy (DP) admits several notions, but the choice among them may affect both privacy analysis and utility. In this paper, we consider four mainstream curve-based privacy notions within a unified information-theoretic framework. For a fixed ordered pair of output distributions, we establish information equivalence among the two directional privacy profiles of $(\varepsilon,δ)$-DP, the pair of hypothesis-testing trade-off functions, and the extended privacy-loss distribution. The exact Rényi differential privacy (RDP) curve joins this equivalence class whenever it is finite at some order greater than one. Under this mild condition, choosing among these notions changes only their semantic interpretation and computational requirements. In contrast, taking the maximum of the directional privacy profiles or compressing the RDP curve into a single zero-concentrated differential privacy (zCDP) parameter can lose information. We quantify the information loss between the exact RDP curve and its zCDP bound for standard noise mechanisms. This gap is zero for Gaussian noise but generally positive for Gaussian-mixture, Laplace, discrete Gaussian, and Poisson-subsampled Gaussian mechanisms. Moreover, this gap grows linearly with the number of independently composed mechanisms. Our information-theoretic perspective has practical consequences. At the same certified privacy level, retaining the full RDP curve rather than using zCDP reduces the required noise variance by up to $45\%$ for Gaussian-mixture noise in workloads comparable in size to the American Community Survey. For DP-SGD on Fashion-MNIST under Poisson subsampling, an RDP-based privacy accountant improves test accuracy by up to $8.73$ percentage points compared to a zCDP-based accountant when both are calibrated to the same $(\varepsilon,δ)$ guarantee.

0.13

Efficient and Optimal Learning of Discrete Distributions with Person-Level Privacy

cs.LG cs.CRcs.DS ·2026-10-22 ·Gautam Kamath, Mahbod Majid, Ankur Moitra, Argyris Mouzakis, Jonathan Ullman
publishedtheory similarity 0.70
Abstract · Full version of the SODA 2027 paper

We study learning a discrete distribution under person-level differential privacy in the batched setting. Given $n$ users, each contributing $m$ i.i.d. samples from an unknown distribution $μ$ over $[k]$, we seek an estimate of $μ$ with total-variation error $α$. We give polynomial-time algorithms under both pure and approximate differential privacy. Under pure $(\varepsilon,0)$-DP, we achieve $n = \widetilde O(k/(α^2 m)+k/(α\sqrt{m}\varepsilon)+k/\varepsilon)$, the first polynomial-time pure-DP guarantee matching the information-theoretic optimum up to logarithmic factors. Under approximate $(\varepsilon,δ)$-DP, we achieve $n = \widetilde O(k/(α^2 m)+k/(α\sqrt{m}\varepsilon)+k+\log(1/δ)/\varepsilon)$. At $δ=2^{-Θ(k)}$, this is $\widetilde O(k)$ for fixed $α,\varepsilon,m$ and failure probability. Our algorithms use a new degree-6 sum-of-squares estimator for learning from untrusted batches. Its key ingredient is a trace-bounded diagonal majorizer for the difference between the empirical covariance of the repaired batch averages and the multinomial covariance predicted by their mean. We prove that clean data admit this certificate through semidefinite-programming duality and a new application of the stronger symmetric form of Grothendieck's inequality due to Friedland and Lim. The certificate preserves the mean-dependent variance of multinomial batch averages, yielding the near-optimal robust rate $O(η\sqrt{\log(1/η)/m})$ and providing the score required by the privacy reduction. We also prove a statistical query lower bound ruling out a uniformly smaller order of error under fixed polynomial SQ resource bounds.

0.32

Privacy Amplification Without Independence: How Far Negative Dependence Carries the Guarantees of Poisson Subsampling

cs.CR ·2026-09-01 ·Xujun Che, Depeng Xu
theoryhot direction similarity 0.69
Abstract

Poisson subsampling is the default sampler in differentially private optimization because its independence makes privacy amplification tractable. Practical systems, however, are moving toward structured participation: random allocation (balls-in-bins), per-epoch allocation, random check-ins, schemes widely believed to be at least as private as Poisson subsampling at the matched rate. We isolate the probabilistic mechanism behind this belief and delimit it exactly, for Gaussian mechanisms up to correlated-noise matrix mechanisms. (1) If the participation indicator vector is negatively associated (NA), then at every integer Rényi order $α\ge2$, exactly at all finite parameters, its remove-direction Rényi divergence is dominated by that of the marginal-matched independent scheme. For fixed gradient sequences, this extends to the mechanism level whenever the noise strategy's Gram matrix is sign-balanced, an $O(t^2)$-checkable condition. (2) The integer-order restriction is essential. For random allocation with $k=1$, we prove a linear law for the Rényi-difference criterion: at large $t$, dominance reverses for every $α<3/2$, including KL divergence, while the crossing order tends to $3/2$ independently of $σ$. (3) We also localize the known failure of rate-matched Poisson domination exactly: below $(1-q)^t$, the hockey-stick ordering reverses, so substituting the Poisson pair into composition machinery is unsound. An upper-tail argument yields a finite crossover $γ_\star$, connecting this threshold picture to the Rényi boundary at $3/2$. Together, these results give a substitution map for privacy accounting: when Poisson-based computations remain sound for structured participation, where they fail, and what sound alternatives cost in deployment.

0.31

Revisiting the Provable-Auditable Privacy Gap of DP-SGD

cs.LG ·2026-08-28 ·Saloni Modi, Srivi Balaji, Yusong Zhu, Gautam Kamath, Kevin Tian
theorycode/data similarity 0.69
Abstract · The code for this paper can be found here: https://github.com/pineappleEnthusiast/empirical-privacy-defense

Differential privacy (DP) has traditionally been used to provide theoretical upper bounds on an algorithm's stability to changing its training data. In modern private machine learning applications, achieving strong tradeoffs between utility and theoretical privacy is challenging, and thus one may optimistically hope that existing theoretical privacy analyses are loose. Recent work on privacy auditing has adopted a dual viewpoint, instead lower bounding the true privacy of an algorithm by constructing empirical distinguishing events. The auditing literature has thus far yielded a pessimistic outlook on the looseness of theoretical privacy bounds for DP-SGD, the de facto private training method in modern ML, as nearly-matching empirical lower bounds have been achieved under various threat models [NHSBTJCT23, AC24, CBP25]. In this work, we propose the empirical privacy lower bound of an algorithm as a concrete metric to optimize for, complementary to the theoretical upper bound. We give a lightweight defense framework that generically augments optimization methods in the ML pipeline to have significantly-improved empirical privacy on standard benchmarks. Moreover, we show that our framework comes at no theoretical privacy cost when augmenting DP-SGD, unlike previously-proposed defenses against membership inference attacks. We evaluate our defense against a broad range of audit constructions, models, and datasets to demonstrate its flexibility.

0.25

Contraction and Statistical Inference under Privacy for Uniformly Bounded Distributions

cs.IT cs.CRmath.ST ·2026-09-23 ·Leonhard Grosse, Sara Saeidian, Tobias J. Oechtering, Mikael Skoglund
similarity 0.69
Abstract

We investigate $c$-interior pointwise maximal leakage (PML) as a tool for contraction analyses and disclosure control. Based on the strong adversarial threat models from maximal leakage, $c$-interior PML generalizes local differential privacy (LDP) to data-generating distributions with densities uniformly bounded away from zero by $c>0$. Viewing $c$-interior PML as an algebraic constraint on a kernel yields more flexible (and often tighter) contraction analyses than standard LDP. We provide tight bounds on the Dobrushin coefficient, and bound the contraction coefficient of the Hockeystick-divergence. We further derive strong data processing inequalities on $f$-divergences under $c$-interior PML constraints when the input distributions to the divergence are restricted to be in the $c$-interior. These results extend beyond the regime of pure LDP to cover a larger class of kernels, including, e.g., arbitrary stochastic matrices. We apply the results to minimax theory and provide asymptotically optimal strategies under $c$-interior PML constraints for binary hypothesis testing and mean estimation. The results show that disclosure control with PML allows analysts to reason about systems in a more differentiated manner: For example, it allows us to quantify the privacy leakage of deterministic systems, and can give precise adversarial guarantees with respect to arbitrary distributional assumptions. Interestingly, a recurring theme in the disclosure analyses is that if the privacy problem is relatively regular (if the density bound $c$ is large), private inference can be possible without incurring any additional cost in terms of sample complexity.

0.17