CS Paper Radar

Why Agentic Workflows Fail: A Taxonomy Derived from Literature and Empirical Data

Xin Li, Rami Bahsoon, Tao Chen

cs.SE cs.AI ·submitted 2026-10-12 21:32 UTC · v1

Abstract

Agentic workflows combine large language models with planning, memory, tools, execution environments, and iterative feedback. Their failures are difficult to diagnose because the same user-visible symptom may originate from model behavior, workflow orchestration, external tools, infrastructure, or their interaction. This paper presents a source-aware taxonomy of agentic workflow failures and applies it to evidence from academic literature and GitHub. The taxonomy combines source attribution with three empirical dimensions: a concrete failure-type dictionary, workflow-stage localization, and agent-capability localization. Its central structure is a two-axis localization matrix: workflow stages form the horizontal process axis and agent capabilities form the vertical functional axis. This design moves beyond taxonomies that mainly classify final failure manifestations by localizing intermediate process states inside agent operation. Our empirical comparison shows that literature-derived failures emphasize planning, reasoning, learning, perception, and knowledge-related mechanisms, whereas GitHub-derived failures concentrate on execution-stage, actuation-related, tool, API, and infrastructure failures. The dominant hotspot is iterative execution and actuation. These findings indicate that agentic workflow reliability should be treated as a systems problem rather than only a model-output problem. The taxonomy provides a basis for structured evaluation, root cause analysis, failure injection, and engineering triage.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Silent Failures in Agent-Tool Interaction: An Audit of ToolUniverse

cs.AI cs.SE ·2026-09-21 ·Devansh Singh, Shreya Gopalan, Sundaraparipurnan Narayanan
top venue similarity 0.72
Abstract · Accepted at the GenAI4Health and AgenticLS workshops at NeurIPS 2026

Agentic AI systems are increasingly adopting automated pipelines that integrate multiple tools. While prior research have studied task success and task completion of such agentic systems, research on agent to tool interaction chain via a wrapper and API, specifically in biological agentic workflows, remains limited. This study investigates specific failures in agent to tool interaction where a tool invocation appears successful but some or all of the information or functionality from the tool via its API / wrapper is incomplete or missing and there are no communications to the user or the agent regarding the missing information. We call these 'silent failures' because the user or the agents are not aware that such a failure has occurred. For the purpose of this study, we developed an audit mechanism to identify such silent failures in agent to tool interaction chains, by examining 15 scientific tools (and their associated API documentation and tool documentations) integrated within the ToolUniverse environment (ToolUniverse serves as our experimental environment rather than the object of the study itself). We structure our study around 7 failure locus, characterising where the failure occurs in the chain. We observed 91 failures (manually validated post LLM based candidate discovery and automated testing), most frequent of them being missing data or fields and inconsistencies in search, filtering or ranking criteria. Most of the 91 failures occurred in API layer (52) or wrapper layer (25), with a potential of silent failure amplification downstream. The results show that silent failures originate upstream of the event and propagate downstream into apparently valid scientific outputs. We propose a concept of contextual reliability to handle such failures and suggest mechanisms for testing, disclosing, monitoring, and measuring such failures across the agent-tool interaction pipeline.

0.53

A Phased Workflow for Operating LLM-Based Coding Agents

cs.SE ·2026-08-31 ·Ante Kapetanovic, Tomislav Duricic, Andro Mercep, Emanuel Lacic
top venue similarity 0.70
Abstract · 2 pages, industry paper, to appear in proceedings of the 35th ACM International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM '26…

LLM-based coding agents combine a foundation model with a harness that shapes agent behavior. For non-trivial tasks, how practitioners structure their work with the coding agents determines whether reliable results follow. We report on a phased workflow for operating coding agents developed by the AI research team at Infobip. The workflow structures agent-assisted development into four phases where human effort is front-loaded and delegation increases as artifacts mature. Context management is the central concern, addressed through four strategies applied at each phase to counter known failure modes. From practitioner experience, we observe that upstream errors in research and planning can compound across later phases, while correcting generated code can introduce bloat and fragility. This motivates front-loading human review. We identify two open problems: the absence of metrics for workflow effectiveness and the gap between formalized context management components and the workflow-level patterns that practitioners need.

0.37

RITE: Evaluating End-to-End Resilience to Silent Tool Errors in E-Commerce Agentic Systems

cs.AI ·2026-10-20 ·Wenshuo Zhang, Yuquan Lin, Yushi Sun, Yishi Lin, Rui Sheng +4 more
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract

Tool-using LLM agents increasingly answer e-commerce queries through multi-step tool interactions. The expected output of a tool call can shift between agent development and execution, allowing a plausible but incorrect value to be returned without an explicit failure signal. These silent errors may propagate through subsequent decisions into final answers. To study agents' resilience across this end-to-end process, we formulate Silent-error Resilience Task, an interactive task that evaluates whether they complete the original query after a silent error corrupts an intermediate state. We introduce RITE, a benchmark built from human-authored industrial workflows and production-log-derived inputs. To enable controlled and reproducible evaluation, we use a semantic error taxonomy to inject errors into fixed workflow prefixes, freeze recorded tool behavior, and let agents continue freely. It contains 167 matched units across nine e-commerce workflows, yielding 501 silent-error, correct-value, and explicit-failure instances. Across 10 recent LLMs, silent errors roughly halve task success and are consistently harder than explicit failures. Recognition, use of an available verification path, and integration of the resulting evidence form successive bottlenecks. We also propose a light State Checker as an intervention to test whether resilience can be improved.

0.20

Benchmarking and Error Analysis of Deep Search and Deep Research LLM Agents

cs.LG ·2026-10-21 ·Zixuan Yu, Zhenheng Tang, Xiaowen Chu, Bo Han
published similarity 0.69
Abstract · Proceedings of the 1st ICML Workshop on Failure Modes in Agentic AI (FAGEN), Seoul, South Korea, 2026

As Large Language Models (LLMs) evolve into autonomous Deep Search and Deep Research Agents capable of executing long-horizon, multi-step tasks, evaluating their reliability becomes increasingly critical. However, existing evaluation paradigms predominantly focus on final task outcomes, leaving a significant gap in understanding the intermediate execution traces, where agents are highly susceptible to various errors. To address this critical gap, we introduce a comprehensive methodology and analytical framework designed specifically to diagnose errors in intermediate workflows. Building upon this framework, we establish a structured taxonomy that categorizes these vulnerabilities into two primary dimensions: System-Level Errors and Task-Level Errors. Through a systematic examination of step-by-step execution traces and agent-environment interactions, we reveal how these underlying errors affect overall performance. Finally, through empirical experiments and systematic analysis of the identified error types, we provide actionable design guidelines, aiming to enhance the robustness, reasoning capabilities, and reliability of Deep Search and Deep Research agents.

0.29

Specifying and Maintaining Agentic Workflows: An Empirical Study of GitHub Agentic Workflows

cs.SE ·2026-09-23 ·Jasem Khelifi, Issam Oukhay, Ali Ouni, Mohammed Sayagh, Mohamed Aymen Saied
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Agentic workflows shift software development from prompting AI agents for individual tasks to defining recurring work that agents execute automatically. GitHub Agentic Workflows (gh-aw) enables this approach through Markdown files that combine natural-language instructions with configuration and compile into executable GitHub Actions workflows. Unlike conventional workflows that primarily prescribe scripted operations, these files delegate tasks requiring interpretation to AI agents. They also couple agent instructions with execution triggers, making those instructions operational specifications for repeated repository activities. However, how developers structure and maintain these specifications, and which execution requirements and safeguards they express, remains insufficiently understood. In this paper, we examine the structure, evolution, and instruction content of gh-aw Markdown files to inform how practitioners define and maintain agent-run work. We analyze 1,248 files from 276 repositories, 20,841 commit-file events, and 288 resolved instruction-label sets from a sample of 294 files. Our results show that workflow instructions extend beyond short prompts, with a median of 556.5 words and code blocks in 62.1% of files. Among files with at least 120 days of observed activity, 78.2% still receive updates in month 4, while size-normalized churn decreases after the first month. Tasks, outputs, constraints, and process instructions each appear in over 93% of labeled workflows, yet only 9.4% explicitly address prompt-injection defense. LLM classification achieves an F1 score of 0.818 and Cohen's Kappa of 0.715 against the resolved human labels. These findings suggest that developers should account for the evolution of workflows copied or referenced across repositories and consider adding prompt-injection defenses, resource budgets, and evidencecredibility checks where applicable.

0.34

GH-AWTrace: A Large-Scale Dataset of GitHub Agentic Workflow Execution Logs

cs.SE ·2026-11-04 ·Jasem Khelifi, Hao Li, Ali Ouni, Mohammed Sayagh, Mohamed Aymen Saied
dataset similarity 0.68
Abstract

Agentic workflows enable AI agents to perform recurring repository tasks on schedules or in response to repository events. Existing studies examine workflow definitions and outputs, but provide limited evidence of what happens during execution. We present GH-AWTrace, a dataset linking 25,014 verified GitHub Agentic Workflows across 5,051 repositories to 4,112,526 run records and 562,877 nonempty execution log archives. The dataset preserves execution evidence subject to GitHub's log-retention limits and links it to repository metadata and generated workflow configurations. Illustrative cases show how the logs expose tool denials, provider failures, changes in an agent's approach, and delegation among agents. These observations enable research on execution failures, tool use, and the relationship between reported run outcomes and visible task progress. Coverage varies across workflows, and the logs provide partial observations rather than complete agent trajectories. Video: https://youtu.be/KIlfmZhHxtA

0.16

Evaluating Local Language Model Agents for Reproducible Data Engineering: An Empirical Software Engineering Study of Mobility Workflows

cs.SE cs.AIcs.DBcs.LG ·2026-10-08 ·Jorge García-Carrasco, Javier Sanchis, Alejandro Reina-Reina, Alejandro Maté, Juan Trujillo
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract · Preprint, under review. 26 pages, 5 figures, 5 tables. Dataset: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21397610

Context: Large language model (LLM) agents are increasingly used as software and data-engineering assistants, yet evidence about locally deployable open-weight agents remains limited. Existing evaluations often emphasize textual responses or isolated code generation rather than the validity of complete engineering artifacts. Objectives: We evaluate whether local LLM agents can produce correct and reproducible data-engineering artifacts, quantify the effect of a closed-loop workspace condition, and examine trade-offs in model scale, architecture, quantization, runtime, tool use, and failure. Methods: We introduce a benchmark of fifteen mobility-workflow tasks covering data discovery, connectors, transport-feed processing, semantic enrichment, feature engineering, validation, visualization, and reporting. Deterministic checkers assess generated scripts, tables, structured files, figures, and reports. Ten local configurations are evaluated in one-shot and closed-loop conditions, with five repetitions per model, mode, and task, yielding 1,500 scored attempts on a consumer-grade GPU. Results: Among models larger than two billion parameters, the workspace condition increases pass rates by 26.7-52.0 percentage points over one-shot generation. The strongest configuration reaches 85.3% artifact-level success, and a quantized 9-billion-parameter model reaches 69.3% with an approximately 6.5 GB memory footprint. Gains are largest when intermediate artifacts expose errors the agent can inspect and repair. Conclusion: Local open-weight agents can support a meaningful subset of software-intensive data-engineering work, but reliability depends on model capability, task verifiability, and deterministic validation. The benchmark provides a reproducible method for evaluating complete agent configurations before adoption in engineering workflows.

0.33

Natural-Language Workflows Are Not Software Yet: Artifact-Driven Compilation for Reliable Agent Execution

cs.SE ·2026-08-21 ·Xiangzhe Xu, Hanxi Guo, Guangyu Shen, Siyuan Cheng, Xiangyu Zhang
similarity 0.67
Abstract · The first two authors contributed equally

Natural-language workflows offer a software-like interface for agents: domain experts can write reusable procedures, and agents can execute them as instructions. This promise is not yet reliable. Workflow descriptions often leave data dependencies implicit, so the executor must infer which prior results a step should use; agents can also fail to follow long or branching instructions under context pressure. We propose Artic, an artifact-driven workflow compiler that transforms a natural-language workflow into an artifact-driven workflow in which each step declares the artifacts it reads and writes, constraints gate produced artifacts, and explicit control transfers route execution. This representation exposes the enforcement burden placed on agent execution, allowing the compiler to identify steps that depend on too much state or contain difficult control logic and refine them through constrained optimization. To validate the LLM-assisted transformation, Artic decomposes faithfulness checking into local obligations and uses scenario-based dry runs to test whether compiled workflow regions conform to the source workflow. We evaluate Artic on 488 problem instances from 11 real-world domain workflows; it improves task resolve rate by 28 percentage points over the original text workflow. We also show that workflows compiled by Artic are 32 and 56 percentage points more consistent in cross-model and repeated-execution setups, respectively.

0.35