CS Paper Radar

Exact Cut Complexity of Equal-Length Proportional Cake Cutting

Yasushi Kawase, Bodhayan Roy, Mohammad Azharuddin Sanpui

cs.MA cs.AIcs.DScs.GT ·submitted 2026-10-14 07:54 UTC · v1
publishedtheory

Abstract

We study proportional cake cutting under an equal-length constraint, where each of $n$ agents must receive a bundle of length exactly $1/n$ that is worth at least $1/n$ to that agent. Our main result determines the exact worst-case number of cuts needed to guarantee such an allocation, namely $2n-2$ for every $n$. This improves on the previously known quadratic upper bound. The proof combines the constrained necklace-splitting theorem with a recursive assignment argument based on Hall's theorem. The same bound extends to the stronger requirement of envy-freeness when $n$ is a prime power, and an $O(n^{1.525})$ upper bound holds for arbitrary $n$. We then ask whether such allocations can be computed. We first show that no deterministic protocol in the Robertson--Webb model terminates after finitely many queries on every instance and always returns an exact equal-length proportional allocation, even for two agents with identical valuations. For every $\varepsilon>0$, however, $O(n^2/\varepsilon)$ queries suffice to produce an allocation in which every agent receives a bundle of length exactly $1/n$ and value at least $1/n-\varepsilon$, again using at most $2n-2$ cuts. Finally, we augment the Robertson--Webb model with two-knife queries. We show that recursive balanced halving attains the optimal bound of $2n-2$ cuts when $n$ is a power of two. For arbitrary $n$, we give a procedure using $O(n\log n)$ cuts.

Comment
A preliminary version of this paper appeared in the proceedings of the 51st International Symposium on Mathematical Foundations of Computer Science (MFCS 2026)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Cutting Down the Tower: Single-Exponential Envy-Free Cake Cutting

cs.GT ·2026-09-04 ·Qilin Ye, Yannan Bai
theory similarity 0.82
Abstract

Envy-free cake cutting is a central problem in fair division with a striking divide between existence and computation. Classical topology guarantees that envy-free allocations exist, yet finding one efficiently (in the Robertson-Webb query model) has resisted decades of work. The seminal work by Aziz and Mackenzie established the existence of a bounded protocol for every $n$, but its query bound is $n^{n^{n^{n^{n^n}}}}$. Subsequently, Sokolov modified their protocol and sharpened its analysis, obtaining a bound of $n^{8n^2(1+o(1))}$ queries, the best deterministic upper bound known before this work. In contrast, the general lower bound, due to Procaccia, is merely $Ω(n^2)$. We close much of this gap with a deterministic protocol using $n^{O(1)}2^n$ queries, the first single-exponential bound for general valuations. Like Aziz and Mackenzie, we repeatedly allocate cake without envy until some agents can leave with their pieces, guaranteed not to envy anyone who stays, even if a staying agent receives all the remaining cake. To reach this state, Aziz and Mackenzie generate $n^{n^{n^n}}$ partial allocations so that enough of them can be redistributed without conflict. Instead, we show that only polynomially many partial allocations suffice. Our key idea is to ``prune'' scarce allocations upfront: if only a few allocations can help a certain pair of agents, we discard them and handle that pair another way, leaving plenty of allocations for every remaining pair so each gets a distinct one. As a result, we make only polynomially many calls to Aziz and Mackenzie's subroutines, and this gives us our $n^{O(1)}2^n$ bound.

0.41

Exact Envy-Free Cake Cutting with Polynomial Expected Queries

cs.GT cs.CC ·2026-10-20 ·Simon Mackenzie, Mashbat Suzuki
theory similarity 0.80
Abstract · 56 pages, 4 figures. Preliminary version

Envy-free cake cutting asks how to divide a resource so that no agent prefers another agent's share. Finding such a division with few queries about preferences has been a longstanding challenge. Aziz and Mackenzie gave the first query bound depending only on the number $n$ of agents: a tower of six $n$'s. Subsequent improvements culminated in Ye and Bai's single-exponential bound of $n^{O(1)}2^n$. A large gap remains between this deterministic upper bound and Procaccia's general lower bound of $Ω(n^2)$. Whether polynomially many queries suffice is a central open question in fair division. We show that a polynomial expected query bound is possible. Our randomised protocol uses only independent, uniformly sampled points from the cake as its source of randomness. For every profile of $n$ agents with nonnegative, additive, nonatomic valuations, the protocol has the following guarantees: (1) It terminates with probability one. (2) Every allocation it returns is complete and exactly envy-free. (3) Its expected number of Robertson-Webb queries is $\widetilde{O}(n^{30})$. The expectation is taken solely over the protocol's random choices, with no distributional assumptions on preferences.

0.32

Cutting a Cake For Human Consumption: An Elementary $n$-agent Cake Cutting Protocol

cs.GT ·2026-10-21 ·Alexandros Psomas
similarity 0.80
Abstract

We give a bounded envy-free cake-cutting protocol for any number $n$ of agents in the Robertson--Webb model, with a short, self-contained, and elementary correctness proof. The protocol uses $2^{O(n \log n)}$ queries. Most ingredients are already known and well understood in the fair division literature; our main contribution is a simpler organization of these ideas into a protocol whose complete description and proof fit in a few pages.

0.38

Nearly Settling the Complexity of Connected $\varepsilon$-Envy-Free Cake Cutting

cs.GT cs.CC ·2026-11-16 ·Simon Mackenzie, Mashbat Suzuki
similarity 0.79
Abstract · 66 pages, 2 figures. We corrected the attribution in the seven-agent hardness proof to make explicit its use of the theorem of Hollender, Ma…

Envy-free cake cutting has been one of the central problems in fair division. In cake cutting, agents' preferences over the cake are accessed through Robertson--Webb (RW) queries. For three or more agents, no algorithm that makes finitely many RW queries can always find a contiguous, exactly envy-free allocation. For contiguous $\varepsilon$-envy-free allocations, however, Hollender and Rubinstein~(JACM, 2025) showed that $\poly(\log(1/\varepsilon))$ RW queries suffice for four agents, leaving open whether such a bound is possible for five or more agents. In this paper, we establish a striking change in query complexity: $\poly(\log(1/\varepsilon))$ RW queries suffice for up to five agents, whereas $(1/\varepsilon)^{Ω(1)}$ queries are necessary for seven or more agents, even when valuations are additive. Thus, we resolve the five-agent case and, more broadly, determine whether polylogarithmic query complexity is possible for every number of agents except six. We also explore the computational complexity of finding contiguous $\varepsilon$-envy-free allocations. When monotone Lipschitz valuations are given by polynomial-time evaluation procedures (e.g., arithmetic circuits and efficiently computable Turing machines), we show that an $\varepsilon$-envy-free division can be computed in polynomial time for five agents. In contrast, even for additive valuations, finding an $\varepsilon$-envy-free division is UEOPL-hard for every fixed number of agents $n\ge7$ and PPAD-complete for every fixed $n\ge13$.

0.12

The Query Complexity of Envy-Free Division: Cake, Chores, and Mixed Resources

cs.GT ·2026-11-08 ·Alireza Farhadi, Mohammadtaghi Hajiaghayi
similarity 0.78
Abstract

We study the query complexity of envy-free division for cake, chores, and resources with both positive and negative values. For arbitrary nonnegative nonatomic chore costs, we give a deterministic exact protocol using $2^{n\log_2 n+O(n)}$ queries and cuts. For both cake and chores, a Las Vegas protocol uses $O(n^{12}\log(2n))$ expected queries and $O(n^{11}\log(2n))$ expected cuts. Conversely, every exact protocol with fixed positive success probability requires $Ω(n^2)$ expected queries in general, even with arbitrarily many output cuts at no query cost. For mixed cake and chores, no uniform finite expected-query bound exists even when every Cut returns the leftmost root or every Cut returns the rightmost root. This holds for any fixed positive multiplicative approximation factor and success probability, already when all net totals are one. An additive impossibility holds on the same normalized domain.

0.19

Envy-free Allocations with Individual Payments

cs.GT cs.DS ·2026-10-07 ·Robert Bredereck, Eva Deltl, Tanmay Inamdar, Pallavi Jain, Pranjal Pandey
survey similarity 0.68
Abstract

When an envy-free allocation of indivisible goods does not exist, monetary transfers can restore envy-freeness. Existing work on fair division with subsidies, however, typically assumes that these payments are provided by an external source, an assumption that may be unrealistic in many applications. We address this limitation by allowing only monetary transfers between agents, with each agent's payments constrained by their individual budget. We show that while it is polynomial-time tractable to determine whether a given allocation can be made envy-free by payments under individual budgets, the general problem of computing such an allocation from scratch is NP-hard, even when agents have relatively large budgets. Motivated by this intractability, we conduct a parameterized complexity analysis, establishing fixed-parameter tractability with respect to the number of goods or to the joint parameter number of agents and good types, and we provide efficient algorithms in several special cases. For explicitly listed items, our type-based algorithm answers the envy-freeness part of an open question of T. T. Nguyen and J. Rothe, "Complexity Results and Exact Algorithms for Fair Division of Indivisible Items: A Survey."

0.15

Envy-Free Allocations for Random Non-Additive Valuations

cs.GT math.CO ·2026-10-25 ·Pasin Manurangsi
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Benade et al. (EC 2024) introduced a semi-random model for non-additive fair division in which each agent starts with an arbitrary base valuation over bundles of items and independently permutes the item names uniformly at random. While they proved that envy-free allocations exist with high probability as the number of items grows for $n = 2$ agents, they left open whether the same holds for $n > 2$ agents. We resolve this open question in the affirmative: for any fixed number of agents $n$ and any number of items $m$ divisible by $n$, an envy-free allocation exists with probability $1 - o(1)$ as $m \to \infty$. Our proof combines the second moment method with a connection to the (small-set) expansion of generalized Johnson graphs, which may be of independent interest.

0.07

Comparison-Based Fair Division of Indivisible Chores

cs.GT ·2026-09-08 ·Zehan Lin, Shengxin Liu, Biaoshuai Tao, Shengwei Zhou
similarity 0.67
Abstract

We investigate the query complexity of fairly allocating $m$ indivisible chores among $n$ agents with additive cost functions. We depart from the standard cardinal model and assume only comparison access: an algorithm may ask an agent which of two bundles is less costly, but never observes numerical costs. Our first results concern proportionality up to one item (PROP1). We design comparison-based algorithms that compute PROP1 allocations using $O(n^3\log m)$ comparison queries. When the chores are arranged in a fixed order and allocations are required to be contiguous, we compute a contiguous PROP1 allocation using $O(n^3 \log^2 m)$ comparison queries. Our main result concerns the maximin share (MMS) guarantee. We show that for any fixed number of agents $n$ and constant $\varepsilon>0$, a $\left(13/11 +\varepsilon\right)$-MMS allocation can be computed with a comparison complexity logarithmic in $m$. Remarkably, comparison access suffices to match the state-of-the-art $13/11$ cardinal-access guarantee of Huang and Segal-Halevi up to an arbitrarily small loss. Furthermore, our result implies that the MMS distortion of comparison access (i.e., the worst-case multiplicative loss in MMS fairness incurred by observing only comparisons rather than numerical costs) is at most $13/11$. Finally, we show that, for three agents, an allocation satisfying envy-freeness up to one item (EF1) can be computed using $O(\log m)$ comparison queries.

0.16