CS Paper Radar

Realization Divergence in Multi-Provider Quantum Computing: A Pre-Registered Study of What Survives Measurement

Jouni Peltonen, Vlad Stirbu, Tommi Mikkonen

cs.SE quant-ph ·submitted 2026-10-15 11:33 UTC · v1

Abstract

Quantum programs pass through compilers, transpilers and vendor services before execution. However, the distance between what was written and what runs is rarely measured. We call this distance realization divergence: the observable difference in how an identical source circuit is realized and behaves across quantum software stacks. We report a hardware study across three vendors and four devices, combining pre-registered predictions with explicitly identified exploratory analyses and amendments. In a compilation experiment with assigned placement policies, embedding radius correlates with two-qubit overhead at Spearman 0.805, against 0.492 for circuit size. Under a fixed lowest-index policy, an eight-qubit Bernstein-Vazirani circuit exhibits greater execution divergence than a twelve-qubit circuit on IQM Emerald. The opposite ordering occurs on IQM Garnet. Both comparisons replicate across two repetitions with disjoint confidence intervals. These results support a placement-dependent explanation, without isolating individual hardware noise mechanisms. The same ordering inversion is absent on the all-to-all IonQ control. On Rigetti Cepheus, a follow-up using topology-aware native placement found no consistent advantage in correct-answer probability for either submission track, but did not establish equivalence between the tracks. Structural comparisons depend on metric weighting, placement and device generation. Provider interfaces also limit observability: Rigetti's supported-operation list remained unchanged across a device generation that replaced the native entangler. We classify silent interface failures in composed toolchains and identify checks at toolchain boundaries, connecting valid cross-provider comparisons with concrete software-quality practices.

Comment
36 pages. Submitted to Software Quality Journal. Replication package: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22471564

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

SeQUeNCe.DQC: Full-stack Simulation of Distributed Quantum Computing

cs.NI cs.DCquant-ph ·2026-10-29 ·Sanjay Suresh, Caitao Zhan, Joaquin Chung, Rajkumar Kettimuthu
benchmark similarity 0.71
Abstract · 6 pages, 6 pages

Distributed quantum computing (DQC) connects multiple quantum processing units to overcome the scale limits of monolithic hardware. We introduce SeQUeNCe$.$DQC a new top-level module within the SeQUeNCe package that compiles monolithic circuits into topology-aware execution plans and coordinates their execution using SeQUeNCe's existing quantum-network modules and protocols. We validate SeQUeNCe$.$DQC by reproducing a two-node trapped-ion Grover experiment in simulation and comparing success probabilities with the reported 71% benchmark. We then evaluate how compiler strategy, topology, and memory capacity jointly govern distributed circuit execution time and success rate. In these experiments, our hybrid compilers successfully identified mixed TeleGate/TeleData execution plans that outperformed pure gate-teleportation strategies. By capturing the physical overhead of distributed quantum primitives, SeQUeNCe$.$DQC provides a rigorous platform for co-designing DQC software and hardware architectures.

0.07

QROB: Quantifying Realization Overhead in Quantum Compilation via Reverse Construction

cs.AR quant-ph ·2026-09-07 ·Jintao Li, Kaiqi Li, Rui Wang, Yilun Zhao, Kaixuan Huang +5 more
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.70
Abstract · Accepted to the 59th IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO 2026)

Quantum compilation reconciles a program's idealized interaction topology with hardware locality constraints, yet evaluations at scale lack calibrated references for realization overhead. We present QROB, a scalable reverse-construction methodology that generates compilation instances backward from directly realizable configurations, retaining the inverse paths as feasible, compiler-independent references. QROB provides a common evaluation substrate for NISQ SWAP routing and fault-tolerant lattice-surgery scheduling, while extending its reference-preserving principle to capacity-constrained quantum memory-access scheduling. Across systems ranging from 9 to 156 qubits, evaluations highlight QROB's utility as both a diagnostic benchmark and a data source. First, for compiler characterization, QROB reveals substantial realization gaps in existing tools, with NISQ compilers incurring up to 24.1x the reference SWAP cost and fault-tolerant compilers requiring up to 7.0x the reference makespan. Second, as a supervision source for data-driven compilation, a router trained on QROB references outperforms Qiskit SABRE on 84.8% of real-world application circuits. Finally, on real hardware, QROB reference realizations achieve a median mirror-circuit survival rate 1.65x that of full Qiskit O3 compilations across three 156-qubit IBM Heron-r2 processors, demonstrating that closing algorithmic compilation gaps translates directly into physical fidelity gains.

0.37

Plateau-Constrained Selection: Exploiting Degeneracy for Lower-Depth Quantum Compilation

cs.ET quant-ph ·2026-08-27 ·Owen Friedewald, Ali Shiri Sichani, Chi-Ren Shyu
theory similarity 0.68
Abstract · 11 pages, 4 figures. Under review at IEEE Transactions on Quantum Engineering

Minimum-cost orders of commuting phase terms can produce substantially different routed circuits. On the same 36-term instances, three orders with identical support cost 74 yield mean routed depths of 228.6, 233.8, and 256.7. We exploit this degeneracy under fixed placement and maintained-parity lowering: Stage 1 attains the support optimum, and Stage 2 selects minimum routed depth among 24 equal-cost orders. For distinct pair supports, we characterize orders attaining the support lower bound through Hamiltonian paths of the support line graph and count optima exactly through 20 terms. On synthetic 16-qubit assignment-Ising instances, selection reduces depth by 12.83% under a different SABRE routing seed, with lower depth in all 20 instances. The selected orders lie a median 1.57 pool standard deviations below the pool mean, consistent with ordinary best-of-24 selection; the useful feature is that candidate rankings persist across routing seeds. Depth reductions extend to 48 terms and a random-MaxCut generator, whereas evaluation with BasicSwap reverses the gain. A 40-instance IBM Heron study measures a 0.59% error reduction on the executed stabilizer-probe panel, but the primary confidence interval across instances includes zero. Plateau selection therefore improves routed depth in the tested SABRE pipeline while preserving the logical support optimum.

0.49

SemQBench: Benchmarking Decomposition-Aware Runtime Policies for Quantum-HPC Search

cs.ET ·2026-10-16 ·Chandrachud Pati, Yogesh Simmhan
published similarity 0.68
Abstract · To Appear in the Proceedings of the 2nd International Workshop SFWM, co-located with SC26

Quantum processors are increasingly used as accelerators inside high-performance computing (HPC) workflows. A workflow runtime decides which quantum circuits to run, how to group them into provider jobs, and what to repeat after a failed attempt. Many search problems split into independent parts, but the runtime can use that structure only when the workflow exposes the parts and a validity check for each one. SemQBench measures what a runtime gains from this visibility. It compares seven execution policies for the same search problem, including two controls without amplitude amplification. The policies change one runtime choice at a time: whether to amplify, whether partial results may be combined across runs, whether the parts share one circuit, and what a retry keeps. We run them on the 20-qubit IQM Garnet processor using 106 distinct circuits in three jobs, and report circuit executions, active device time, and provider jobs separately before combining them in a cost model. Amplifying the problem as one whole circuit shows no statistically clear gain over random sampling and uses 6.7-104$\times$ more active device time. Exposing the parts and collecting valid partial results across a fixed batch of runs cuts the executions needed for 95% completion confidence by 2.20-4.00$\times$, and this policy is never worse than the other amplified policies in executions, device time, or jobs; it is selected in 99 of 108 overhead settings. Fewer executions do not always mean less device time: on one workload, executions fall from thirteen to four while active device time rises from 7.44 to 9.81 $μ$s. Exposing problem structure therefore gives the runtime a strong default policy and the measurements needed to decide when the simpler unamplified option is cheaper.

0.22

Architecting Instruction Execution for Scalable Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computing

cs.ET quant-ph ·2026-10-12 ·Dmitry Filippov, Justin Hogaboam, Mathias Soeken, Raghu Gatta, Prakash Murali +1 more
published similarity 0.68
Abstract · Published in IISWC 2026

Scaling fault-tolerant quantum computing (FTQC) requires orchestrating millions of operations continuously across a tightly coupled classical-quantum control stack. A critical challenge in this orchestration is determining the optimal hardware-software boundary, i.e., the Quantum Instruction Set Architecture (QISA). We focus on cryogenic, fixed-connectivity qubit platforms, such as superconducting and topological Majorana qubits. For these, existing QISA choices either operate at too low a level, violating cryogenic thermal budgets at scale, or at too high a level, imposing unrealizable complexity on the control engine. To reason about these tradeoffs, we introduce the ARIES instruction set hierarchy, which categorizes QISAs into distinct abstraction levels. To systematically evaluate these levels, we develop an end-to-end evaluation toolflow featuring a cycle-accurate classical driver and hardware engine simulator. Using eight quantum applications across superconducting and topological qubit platforms, we measure instruction bandwidth, transceiver power dissipation, and measurement processing overheads. We demonstrate that while physical-level abstractions exceed the thermal limits of dilution refrigerators by orders of magnitude, canonical-level abstractions significantly underestimate hardware routing congestion and execution runtimes. Our Level 4 QISA (local logical operations) offers an optimal architectural balance. As quantum hardware platforms scale toward FTQC in the coming years, our findings provide concrete architectural guidance for the design of their classical control stacks and instruction interfaces.

0.24

QSimAdv: A Late-Bound, Vendor-Agnostic Architecture for High-Performance Quantum-Circuit Simulation

cs.DC quant-ph ·2026-08-11 ·Shusen Liu, Pascal Jahan Elahi, Wenyun Sun, Shenjin Lv, Xiaohan Shan +1 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 24 pages

Portability in high-performance quantum-circuit simulation need not begin at the kernel. We present QSimAdv, which makes late binding, rather than a common kernel, the basis of vendor independence. Representation, operator lowering, and data placement are bound only when their required inputs become available. Before full-state allocation, circuit, noise, and output inspection can route eligible generic sampled-count requests to a stabiliser tableau; explicitly requested representations remain fixed. For full-state execution, backend constraints shape fusion; an ordered fused operator binds to a native lowering only after its physical targets are known. A first-class logical-to-physical layout map records non-canonical order across local and rank-address bits, so the dispatcher moves nonlocal targets only on demand. GPU, CPU, and Message Passing Interface (MPI) backends share these semantics while retaining native execution paths. We realize this design on NVIDIA GH200 and AMD MI250X/EPYC systems across local and distributed execution. With matched complex 32-bit floating-point state storage, QSimAdv leads both Aer Hopper configurations at $N=32$ and Aer's HIP backend at four shared MI250X sizes from $N=24$ to 30. Strong scaling exposes platform dependence: on setonix, QSimAdv leads both GPU and CPU comparisons at every measured rank, achieving $3.4\times$ and $2.8\times$ speedups, respectively, from one to eight ranks; neither the GH200 path nor the CPU path speeds up at eight ranks. Weak scaling reaches 256 ranks with 2 TiB GPU and 1 TiB CPU states. Together, these results support that portability can reside above the kernel boundary while execution remains native and extends across distributed memory.

0.10

Quantum computers will not be that different: A blueprint for quantum computer architecture at scale

cs.AR quant-phcs.NIeess.SY ·2026-09-17 ·Torsten Hoefler, Matthias Troyer
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Quantum computers are technologically novel and unusual, but at system scale they should be engineered using many of the same principles that govern classical heterogeneous accelerators. This paper argues that utility-scale quantum architecture is primarily a cost-performance problem across a coupled quantum-classical system, leading to a blueprint for scalable quantum processing unit (QPU) design. Our architecture blueprint is organized around clean logical abstractions, hiding details and complexity of physical qubit modalities below the instruction set architecture (ISA) boundary, and specializes recurring functions aggressively to minimize the cost for utility scale quantum computations. Its low-level implementation through specialized local hardware for control, readout, and quantum error correction (QEC) closely resembles the architecture of high-performance network stacks. One of our main insights is that the design principles and the resulting architecture closely follow established practice from classical computing and networking.

0.37

Turning Quantum Compiler Configuration Selection Upside Down: A Top-Down Paradigm

cs.SE quant-ph ·2026-10-21 ·Ming Zhong, Xiangyu Ren, Kangyu Zheng, Zhi Zeng, Shenggen Zheng +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract · 16 pages, 9 figures, 9 tables

Selecting an effective quantum compiler configuration requires coordinated decisions over both hardware targets and compiler settings, with the ultimate goal of improving circuit execution fidelity. Existing SOTA approaches typically decompose this problem into two sequential stages: a device is chosen first, after which compiler options are tuned on that device through RL-based search. This bottom-up strategy can be fundamentally limited by its initial device decision, since a poorly matched backend may constrain the best fidelity achievable regardless of how effectively later compiler options are optimized. In contrast to classical compiler tuning, where the search space is often prohibitively large, the configuration space of quantum compilers remains manageable enough to support exhaustive search. Consequently, rather than repeatedly searching from candidate configurations, one can derive reusable configuration knowledge from offline oracle results and apply it directly to new circuits. In this paper, we introduce a top-down configuration-selection paradigm and build QuOPTBench, an exhaustively searched benchmark containing oracle configurations for 268 quantum circuits. We first study whether LLMs can directly infer suitable configurations and evaluate ten representative LLMs. The results reveal that vanilla LLMs remain far from the oracle. We then employ an LLM to extract transferable rules from sampled circuits governing configuration selection. Using these rules together with predictors trained on the enumerated configuration data of the sampled circuits, we design QuTOP, a rule-guided ML framework that performs fast configuration selection without iterative online search. Across our evaluation, the distilled rules consistently strengthen LLM-based selection, while QuTOP provides the strongest overall balance between solution quality and selection latency among the baselines.

0.10